June 26, 2024

Totally Cool, Inc. Recalls All Ice Cream Products Because of Possible Health Risk

The products included in the recall is:

Brand Product Affected Lots

Friendly’s 60 fl oz Celebration Ice Cream All Dates Between:

Cake 05/20/2024 to 05/28/2025
40 fl oz Strawberry Krunch Ice
With Plant Code: 24-65, 24-
Cream Cake
0065, 2465, 240065

See Packaging, Example:

05/20/25 15:30 24-65

Abilyn’s Frozen Bakery Abilyn’s Frozen Bakery Vanilla All Best By Dates Between:
& Chocolate 30 fl oz 6” Ice 05/20/2024 to 05/28/2025
Cream Cake
With Plant Code: 24-0065
Abilyn’s Frozen Bakery Vanilla
& Chocolate 60 fl oz 8” Ice See Packaging, Example:
Cream Cake 15:30 24-0065
Abilyn’s Frozen Bakery “For Best By: 05/20/25
Love of Chocolate” Ice
Cream Cake

Abilyn’s Frozen Bakery

“Cookies & Cream” Ice
Cream Cake

Abilyn’s Frozen Bakery

“Cookie Dough” Ice Cream
Cake
Hershey’s Ice cream 38 fl oz vanilla and chocolate All Codes Between:
flavored ice cream cake
Cakes: 2305140 to 2405170
110 fl oz vanilla and
Cones: 3174 to 4047
chocolate flavored ice cream
cake Sandwiches: 2307187 to
2406163
4 fl oz Cookies & Cream Ice
Cream Cones See Packaging for Cakes and
4 fl oz Cookies & Cream Polar Sandwiches, Example:
Bear Ice Cream Sandwiches 2405140 11:42

Yelloh! 4 fl oz Vanilla Nut Ice Cream All Codes Between:

Sundae Cones
Cones: 6T3227 to 6T4157
4 fl oz Vanilla Fudge Ice
Sandwiches: 6T3115 to 6T4171
Cream Sundae Cones

4 fl oz Pecan Praline Ice See Packaging for Cones and

Cream Sundae Cones Sandwiches, Example:
6T4171 07:16
4 fl oz Chip & Mint Ice Cream
Sundae Cones

4 fl oz Cookies & Cream Ice

Cream Sandwiches

4 fl oz Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

Sandwiches

Jeni`s 3.5 fl oz Chocolate Silk Pie Ice Cream All Best by Dates: 07/24/25 to
Sandwiches
05/23/2026
3.5 fl oz Key Lime Pie Frozen
All Codes Between: 23205 to 24144
Dessert
With Plant Code: 2465
3.5 fl oz Mint Chocolate Truffle Pie
Ice Cream Sandwiches See Packaging, Example:
3.5 fl oz Triple Berry Tart Pie Ice Best By: 05/23/2026
Cream Sandwiches Lot 24144 07:03 2465
Cumberland Farms Cumberland Farms, Farmhouse All Best by Dates Between:
Premium Ice Cream Sandwich, Rich
11/30/25 to 12/04/25
Vanilla, 4 fl oz
With Plant Code: 2465
Cumberland Farms, Farmhouse
Premium Ice Cream Sandwich, See Packaging, Example:
Marvelous Mint, 4 fl oz Best By: 12/05/2025
07:17 2465

The Frozen Farmer 4 fl oz Elf On the Shelf Santa`s All Best by Dates Between:
Cookies Ice Cream
Sandwiches: 09/04/25 to
Sandwiches
12/07/25
16 fl oz Elf On the Shelf Santa`s
All Best by Dates Between:
Cookies
Pints: 09/05/25 to 07/30/26
16 fl oz Strawberry Sorbet Pints

16 fl oz Raspberry Sorbet Pints With Plant Code: 24-65

16 fl oz Orange Cream Frobert See Packaging, Example:

Pints Best By: 07/30/2026
16 fl oz Watermelon Sorbet 24-65 14:05
Pints
Marco 3.8 fl oz Dulce De Leche Ice Cream
Sandwiches Sandwiches:

3.8 fl oz Vanilla Chai Ice Cream All Best by Dates:

Sandwiches 11/28/25 to 11/29/25 with Codes
Between: 2405149 to 2405150
16 fl oz Dulce De Leche &
Cookies Ice Cream Pints Pints:
16 fl oz Turkish Mocha Ice Cream All Best by Dates:
Pints
06/07/24 to 12/11/25 with Codes
16 fl oz Vanilla Chai Ice Cream Between: 2312341 to 2406163
Pints
With Plant Code: 2465
16 fl oz Spicy Peanut Butter Caramel
and Peanut Butter See Packaging for Pints, Example:
Caramel Ice Cream Pints Best By: 12/11/2025
16 fl oz Moroccan Honey Nut Ice 14:11 24-65 2406163
Cream Pints
See Packaging for Sandwiches,
16 fl oz Green Tea White Example:
Chocolate Ice Cream Pints Best By: 12/11/2025
16 fl oz Aztec Chocolate Ice Cream Lot 2406163 07:09 2465
Pints
ChipWich 4 fl oz The Original Vanilla Chocolate
Chip Ice Cream Sandwich 10 Club All Best by Dates Between: Sandwiches:
Pack, 3 Best by dates: 02/23/25 to 12/21/25
Pack, 24 Pack

16 fl oz Vanilla Chocolate Chip Ice • Club pack (10 units):

Cream Pint Lot# 23298-24172 •
Single Serve:
16 fl oz Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Lot# 23298-24164 •
Cream Pint 3 packs:
Lot# 23298-24136

Pints: 07/25/2024 to 01/27/2025

With Plant Code: 24-65, 24-

0065

See Packaging for 10 Club Pack and

Retail 3 Pack Sandwiches Example:
Best By: 12/21/2025
24-65 14:17 24173

See Packaging for Single Serve

Sandwiches Example:
BB: 12/14/25 24166
13:04 24-0065

See Packaging for Pints Example:

Best By: 01/27/2025
14:21 24-65

AMAFruits 3 gal Acai Sorbet Tubs All Best by dates and Codes:
3/28/24,3/29/24
3 gal Dragon Fruit Sorbet Tubs
3/30/24,05/01/25,05/02/2
5,
05/03/25,05/04/25,
6/24/25,6/28/25,6/29/25,
6/
30/25,6/01/25,7/28/25,8/
28
 /25,8/31/25,09/05/25,
231132
4

2311325 2311326 2311331

2311332 2311333 2311334
2401031 2401032 2401033
2401036 2401037 2401038
2401039 2401040 2402043
2402044 2402057 2402058 402059
2403085 2403086
2403087 2403088 2404120
2404121 2405142 2406158
2406159

See Packaging Example:

Best By: 07/28/25 2307209

Taharka 16 fl oz Honey Graham Ice Cream Best By date: 10/01/25

Pints With Plant Code: 24-65

16 fl oz Key Lime Pie Ice Cream See Packaging Example:

Pints Best By: 10/01/2025
24-65 17:02
Dolcezza Gelato 16 fl oz Mascarpone & Berries All Best By Dates Between:
Ice Cream Pints
05/20/24 to 06/20/25
16 fl oz Roasted Strawberry Ice
With Plant Code: 24-65
Cream Pints

16 fl oz Vanilla Bean Ice Cream See Packaging Example:

Pints Best By: 06/12/2025
14:34 24-65
16 fl oz Peanut Butter Mash
and Peanut Butter Cup Ice
Cream Pints

16 fl oz Dulce de Leche & Cookies

Ice Cream Pints

16 fl oz Stracciatella Ice
Cream Pints

16 fl oz Peanut Stracciatella Ice

Cream Pints

16 fl oz Swiss Chocolate Ice

Cream Pints

16 fl oz Coffee & Cookies Ice

Cream Pints

16 fl oz Hot Cocoa Ice Cream

Pints

16 fl oz Sugar Cookie Dough

Ice Cream Pints

16 fl oz Dark Chocolate Ice

Cream Pints

16 fl oz Dark Chocolate Fudge

Ice Cream Pints

LaSalle 16 fl oz Chocolate Ice Cream All Best By Dates Between:

Pints
11/18/24 to 10/25/25
16 fl oz Vanilla Ice Cream
Pints
With Plant Code: 24-65
16 fl oz Cherry Vanilla Ice
Cream Pints
See Packaging Example:
16 fl oz Vanilla Mango Ice
Best By: 10/25/2025
Cream Pints
24-65 17:05

16 fl oz Vanilla Raspberry Ice

Cream Pints

16 fl oz Vanilla Fudge Ice

Cream Pints

16 fl oz Dulce De Leche Ice

Cream Pints

16 fl oz Cookies & Cream Ice

Cream Pints

16 fl oz Butter Pecan Ice

Cream Pints
 Example Photographs

Friendly’s Products

Abilyn’s Frozen Bakery Products

r,nonfat milk, guar gum, sunflower lecithin, xanthan gum), vanilla ice cream (milk, cream,
---
,oco\ate cookies lcane sugar, non-hydrogenated shortening fpalm o,IJ pea ~tarch, potato
ru\l, ~• prote·,n, salt, canola 01\, pea fiber, natural flavor, sunflower /ec1th1n, ,nulm), vanilla
less than 2% of: natural f1avor, chickpea, xanthan gum, sodium caseinate, locust bean gum,
rar, \lalm l<.emel and palm oil, corn starch, sunflower lecithin, co/ors [vegetable juice, annatto
'auba wax, cellulose gum). Contains: milk. Manufactured on equipment that also processes
Hershey’s Products
 I
I

\\
I
\ \ I
I I
y ' \ \
\ \
I
I I

__________ ( ' I

Cumberland Products
Taharka Products
AMAFruits Products

ruit
ROIi/i THE AMAZOfl

~~ON FRlJ/1
~ ... .
~ . .

Dolcezza Products

---:~~i ~;
i ~' .···.: _. .
~~~:
,...,.,....._..,:-.•.
~~.c~

'.~- _;;=-
.... ...v...
lt
,.-,.,,...,,...c--• • •--• C.!;w,ro {
 The Frozen Farmer Products

FARM CRAFTED FARM CRAFTED

w~ Shawb
SORBET SOR
DAIR~ GLUTEN DAIR~ GLUTEN
& FAT FREE &. FAT FREE
ONE PINT 1473m0
--
ONE PINT 1473m0

I ,~frozen
. - ~

FARM CRAFTED
0~ C'U!.afn
ROBERT
~l bAIRT Dl:SSERT

MORE DECADENCE
LESS CALORIES
ONE PINT i473m0

Marco Products
 Dllll/l/1/11 ··~~,..
-~~r

s~
DIIIIU/i11/16 .......

-'~ 9C.~~- .; 9(~~-

~,".",.:;;:._~

-:;.-
AZTEC CHOCOLATE

···~:•.."-:"'.''- ' __,_

I':.""-

rs·..:... ,7::.'--'
::
_ ... --~ .......
PEANUT BUTTER CARAMEL
_,,_.,

,..,_,...... _,,.' "'"" ..,- _,,....'

,
- - -~~~ ---:,,,....:::.~ -~ ~ ...

Rllll/1//11 ...,,,.

DULCIDl-
•oo-­
-.:-~-=-=-
 Jeni`s Products

int Chocolo t• Tru le

~=:=~ .!. iUUIIIII. Q
- ~{= ----
Key L,,., p,,
......, .... ~
·--
...,,...,_...,_,_
t-UR._.!IUllJ • .
1U11tf!IUll)lll 1--- - - - - - / 1;1 iaillll'

· - I~ . ~

--
--
=-=
==-
=­
==-
 - ,@••!-, ~=1~
- ·-- · -·
r1,1nu·1n""""""'-
~~--;
<Y
~
, --s
.l..lnWfW

,lili1ll111" ---.....:.."';:..':: ~

·111111111·
0 0 0 0
1-1

80 NDAE CONE:ll
~•nlla lco c,-1wirl..iwttll 1'1dge
and to 1,1 pe<ll'ritti , h~•tl chi~1 in 11
chac olat ey l ine-d u. g ■l'" cone

,~
'IJ IL Ol. !l .◄ 11J

-------.
----·----
.-it.,., _..,__
- ---~=-:
..
J..&n'fM
~
.,
~.,,......,,,.
•11r1111111111 •
·-=.::=-::=..
'"". ..,. , ..,.__
----=-..~'"':
I~~:
"""~
~ ,11rr1r111 •
0 0 0 0

SU NDA E CONES
SUND AE CON es
Mint tee cream 1w1t' ed with
Var.ilia ice crum 1wirie,c wit h cu~111el
r1tdge af'd topped with.c"10col:n:11i ch'c:1
and topped v,ith prar..ne prtt:•m~ in Iii
in I c"ocolcitoy l•Md 1u;:1r cono
'"~c-col1t:cy lined :111511· ca,i,u
,,1 11 11 n w •'4fl01 (I '71)

Yelloh! Products
 ITi1!1 \ Cookies& Cream
_ _ ea Cream sandwiches

__... ___
:..-=---
I·---· -
-
c:oolde9acr.a•
lcoCrea111
sandwiches

Cookies le cream
Ice cream
•370
cookie•• C ream
Ice Cream
Sa ndwlch e l

Sandwiches
.■.
W]!il!JI• " . !e Chip COOkle sandwich - - K371
C hoco late Chip Ch~toChip
Cookie sandwich Cookie ... ndwtch

W lr" IA. ILUtlCl'Cll ll' l l'-1

.IIJII.
Vanilla ice en_am betw.entwu bomeatyla
c Mco lctcchipcookics

2A..OZ./?O?nt.l

\ I

ChipWich Products
 CH<P
<Cl-tlll l ..t•l~
CH . . :-,, .
 LaSalle Products

LaSalle Aavors LaSalle Fhl\lors

~--· ~
.......................
. , . . . .. . . .._. . . . _..-;Ulilll

---
~---.-.---

ll
LaSalle Aavors LaSaHe· Fl wrs
,.,.... ..... .....:w. ....
~ ..... lll'mRI~

---
... ~ .... ca- ....
1L~~­
g,,..ir...,,..._-.

IJtSalleflavors LaSalle Fta\i'Ol"S Nu hU l,ail Faic;h

...........-
,....._.... ___
~---­
......
r--,-.........---

LaSalle Ravo.r s l aSalle Ravo,s

 lit'
., '> ;
..
L

-----