Com Res 11046
Com Res 11046
COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS
                                         Inkamuros, Manila
PETITION                                         FOR
DISQUALIFICATION IN
CONNECTION WITH THE 2025
NATIONAL AND LOCAL
ELECTIONS INCLUDING THE
BANGSAMORO
AUTONOMOUS REGION IN
MUSLIM     MINDANAO
PARLIAMENTARY
ELECTIONS.
Y-----------------                           --______x        Promulgated:               August 28, 2024
          In the Matter of the Guidelines in the Conduct   of Preliminary Conlerence Prcceedings, Clarifying Resolutiorls
No. 9523 and 10673, 06 October 2021
2             tlre Matter of SPecial Action Cases Motu Proprio filed Against Nuisance presidential, vice-presidential
          -In                                                                                                           and
Senatorial Candidates, Further Clarifying Resotutions No. 9523, 10 673: and"IO7D.,12 OctoLlet 2021.
1          In the Matter of the Amendment to Rules 23, 24 and 25 of the COMELEC Rules of Ilocedure for purposes
                                                                                                                      of the
13 May 2m3 National, l-ocal and ARMM Elections and Subsequent Elections, 25 September
{                                                                                           2m2
           In Re: Guidelines on ElecEonic Filin& Conduct of Hearings/ lnvestigations/ Inquiries ol-,,1 Video Conference and
Seryice, 25 June 2020.
s         In the Matter of the Amendment of the Marrrer and Schedule of liting of pleatlings pursuant to CoMELEC
Resolution No. 1062i Entided: Guidelines on Electronic Filin& Conduct of Hearings/ Investigitions/
                                                                                                   Inquiries uin Video
Conference and Service,20 December 2OZ.
                                                                                                                   Page 2 of 74
Section L. Grounds.
            1.   The COC has been filed to put the election process in mockery
                 or disrepute;
5           SrcnON    s. The Commission on Elections may sit r,r barrc or     in two divisions, and shall promulgate its rules of
Procedure   in order to exPedite disPosition of election   cases,   includitrg pre-prc.lamation .olkoversies. All such election
cases shall be heard and decided in division, Provided that motions for ieconsideration of decisions
                                                                                                     shall be decided by the
Commission e, I,nnc. (Emphasis Supplied.)
7           Bahs Pambansa Blg. E81, approved on m December 1985.
               Act lntroducing Additional_ Reforms in the Rectoral System and for other pur.poses, also known          ,,The
:.       . -An
Electoral Reforms l,aw of 1982, approved on 05lanuary 19gg.
                                                                                                                    as
                                                                                                                     Page 3 of 14
              The fine shall be Paid within thirty (30) days from receipt of notice of such failuJe; otherwise,             it   shall be
enlorceable by a    writ of execution issued by the commission against the properties of the oflender.
                   shal be the duty of every city or municipal election regishar to advise in ta'ritin& by personal delivery or
    .        -lt
registered mail, within five (5) days from the date of election all candidates residing in his jurisaiction
                                                                                                            io comply wittr         irelr
obligation to file theil statements of contributions and expenditures.
          For the commission of a second or subsequent offens€ under this sectioo the administrative fine shal be from
Two thousand pesos (P2,000.00) to Sixty thousand pesos (P60,0m.00), in the discretion of the Commission. In addition,
                                                                                                                      the
offender shall be subiect to perpetual disqualifi.ation to hotd pubtic offrce. (Emphasis Supplied,)
                                                                                                                      Page 4 of 14
;          ;;r.-t*"r"*"*,                  and driflks. - It shall be unlawful for any candidahe, political party,
or any person to give or accept, free oI charg€, diectry or indirectry,                                             orga'ization.
the five hours befoie and after a public meJting, or, tfre_auy pruceii.g
                                                                        transportation, food or a""r..   *,r,-g. irr ,"ir"    J;i
                                                                           ttrl'"f".ti"o    o^ tfr"   a.y;;;
or contribute, directly or indtectly, money o, tlrirrgs of rralrre fo,                   ^a                      ""d;;;;;;:
                                                                       suat prapo"".
r1        sec 95' Prohibited contributions. - No contribution for purposes of partisan
                                                                                                political activity shall be made
dLectly or indtectly by any of the following:
    a' Public or Private financial instifutions: Provided, however, that nothinq herein shall Drevent the makino 6f
                                                                                                                   ffi;r#JJ ^n-
          loan.to a candidare m potiticaj parry by any su.t prltic o, pri.,,urc
                                                                                finur,'ciJ ;il;i;;g"X;;
          lending honey, and that *re loan is mide in accord"ncu *iih lu-s
                                                                                unJreg,lations a.d in"the'ordt"",y.;-*;             ;;
           business;
      b    Natual and iuridical Persons oPerating a public utility or in possession
                                                                                    of or exploiting any nafural iesour.ces of
           ihe natior!
      c   Natural and- jwidical Persons who hold contracts or sub{onhacts
                                                                                  to supply the goverrunent or anv of 1<
          divisions, subdivisions, or inskumenralities, with goods or services
                                                                               or ; ;if;;;;il;il;;;"il":i.;"
     d Nafural and iuridical persons who have been graited franchir"., ir,."nur"t                       allocations or similar
          privileges or concessions by the govemment oiany of its divisions,             "ru-ptions,
          govemment_owned or conkolled coiporations;
                                                                               subdi"i"io*,   oi;;;;;hlj;;;,        ilrd;;
     e Nahtal and iuridical persons who, within one year prior to the date of the electiorL have been
                                                                                                             granted loans or
          other acconmodations in excess of pI00,000 by ih" go.ru..,-ur,t
                                                                                 or any of its divjsionj, subdivisiorls or
          inshumenratities hduding govemment-owned oicontroilled corpolations;
     l.. Educational institutions whi.h luve rec€ived grars of pubtc fu-na amounting to no less ihan p100,000.00;
     g. Officials or employees in the Civil Service, o. ir"-ber" of th" A.m"d Forces of *re philippines; and
     h. ForeigneB and foreign corporations.
Tt shal be unlawfl for any person to solicit or receiv€ any
                                                             contribution from any of the persons or entities enumerated
herein.
11         sec 9T Prohibited raising of funds. - lt shar be ur awld for any person to hold
                                                                                           dances, lotteries, cockfights,
8ames, boxing bouts, bingo, beauty contests, entertainments, or cinematogripinc, $eauicar o,
                                                                                          o*r"r'p".ro. *."" roi tiJ
plrpose of raGing funds for an election camPaign or (or the support of"any
                                                                           candidate {iom the commencement of the
election.period up
                to and induding election diy;-or for any p"rron o, o.g*iltion, whether
                                                                                       civic or relisious, directlv or
morrecuy, to souot and/or accept fTom any candidate for pubtic office,
                                                                          or ftom his ar_prlgr,                 .i.ugua             o,
rePresentative, or any Person acEn8 in their behaff, any gifL      f;d,                                         "g"ni
                                                                     transportatiorL conhibutionor"donation"in caih or              in
Krno rorn tie coD'lmencement of the elertion period up to and including
                                                                        election day; Provided, That normal and          customarv
religious stipends, tithes, or collectioi* on-sundayi andlor other
                                                                           i*lg""t"a .';U*ti".;;;;;;ffi;';;';i
prohibition.
r5        se.. 80. Election dmPaign or Parti6an polifi.al activity outside campaign period. - It shall be unlawfuI for any
persor; whether or not a voter or candidate, or. for any party, or association of persons, to engage in
                                                                                                        an election campaigi-r
oi partisan political activity o(cept during the campaign period: provided, that poJiticai p:arties may hota poiitiJat
conventions or meetings ho nominate their official candidates within thtty days beforjthe commencementLf
                                                                                                                 the campaign
period and forty-five days for Presidential and Vice-presidential eletion.
                    Any radio or television stations, including that owned or conholled by the Government, shall give free
          of charge equal time and plominence to an accredited politi.al party or its candidates iI it gives free of darge air
          time to an acoedited political party or its candidates for political purposes.
                       In all iistances, the Commission shall supervise the use and employment of press, radio and television
          facilities so as to give candidates equal opportunities under equal circumstances to mal<e known tlleir
          qualifications and theh stand on Public jssues within the limits set forth in this Code on election spending.
                    Rules and regdations Promulgated by the Commission under and by authority of this section shall
          take effect on the seventh day after thet publication in at least two daily newspapers of genelal circulation. prior
          to the effectivity of said rules and regulations, no political advertisemerrt or propugi.ra" fo. or against any
          candidate or political party shall be published or broadcast through the mass media.
                     Violation of the nrles and rcgulations of the Commission issued to impledent this section shall be an
          election offense punishable unde! Section 264 hereof.
          Sec. 261.   Prchibited Acts. - The Iollowing shall be guilty oI an election offense:
                d.     Coercion of subordinates.
                            1.  Any public of{icer, or any officer of any public or private corporation or ass(xiation, or any
                                head" superior, or administrator of any religious organization, or any employer or hnd_
                                owrier who coerces or intimidates or compels, or in any manner influence, directly or
                                indirectly, any of his subordinates or members or par.ishioners or employees or house
                                                                                                 Page 6 of 14
                 helpers, tenants, overseers, hrm helpers, tillers, or lease holders to aiq campaign
                                                                                                     or vote for
                 or against any candidate or any aspirant for the nomination or selection of ian&dates.
            Z    Any ?ublic officer or a:ry officer of any codmercial, indirstrial, agriculturat, economic ot
                 social enterprise or public or private corporation or associatiory oi any head, superior
                                                                                                             or
                 adminisEator oJ any religious organization, or any employer or landowner who dismisses
                 or thJeatens to dismiss, prmishes oI tlueatens to'puniih ie reducing his salary, wage or
                 compmsatiory or by demotion, transfe, suspension, separatiorl excommunication,
                 ejechtslt or causing him armoyance in_ the performance oI his
                                                                                iob or in his membership, any
                 subordinate member ol affiliate, par.ishioner, employee or house helpeD tenant, overseer,
                 farm helper, tiller, or lease holder, for disobeying or not complying'with any o( the
                                                                                                           acts
                 ordered by the former to aid, campaign or vote tor or against aIry can"aidate, or any
                                                                                                       aspirant
                 for the nomination ot selec[on of candidates.
                              No payment shall be made witiin five days before the date of election to laborers
                 who have rendeled services in prcjects or works except those falling under subparagraphs
                 (a), (b), (c), and (d), of this para$aph.
                           This prohibition shall not apply to ongoing public works projects cornmenced
                         _
                 F.6*    h:  .-.ptq- geriod or similar    proiects unaer ioieign agree-enS. Fo, p.,.po*s of
                 this provision, it shall be the duty
                                                   of the government oflicialior agencies concerned to.ep,rt
                 to the Commission the [st of a]I such projects being undertaken i'y them.
          2.     The Ministry of Social Services and Development and any other office in other ministries of
                 the govemment per(orming functions similat to said ministry, except for salaries of
                 Personnel, and for such other routine and normal expenses, and ftr suctrother expenses as
                 the Commission rllay authorize after due notice and hearing. Should a calamity or disaster
                 occur, all releases norrully or usually coursed through the said ministries and offices of
                 other ministies shall be tumed over to, and administered and disbursed by, tlrc philippine
                 National Red Cross, subject to the supervision of the Commission             ;n   Audit or its
                 representatives, and no candidate or his or het spouse or member of his fardly witiin the
                 sson! c1wil d:fee ol affinity or consanguiniry shall participate, directly or indtectly, in rhe
                 distribution of any relief o. other goods to the victims of the calamity oi disaster; and
          3.     The Ministry of Human Settlements and any other office m any other minisEy of the
                 govemnent pedorming functions stnilar to said ministry, except for salaries of personnel
                 and for such other necessaty administrative or other expense; as the Commission may
                 authodze afte! due notice and heaing.
                                                                                                      PageT of     '1.4
      vii. Violated any of Secrion +0 (a), (b), and (c) of the Local
             Govemment Code (LGC) of                          1991;zo sy
viii.Violated all other grounds under the LGC and the OEC.
             In
             case of substitution of candidate by reason of death or
   incapacity, the Petition must be filed within five (5) days from the
   time the substitute candidate filed his COC.
   For cases under Section 1.c.2, the Petition shall be filed at any time
   during office hours.
       In case the petition is filed personaly, the party shall submit four (4)
hard copies of the petition with compiete u.,rr"*ur, a portable Document
Format (PDF) thereof saved in a read-only flash drive, and proof of payment
of the fees.
       Petitions filed not in accordance with these rules shall not be docketed
or may be outrightly dismissed. However, the petitioner may re-file the
petition in accordance with these Rures before the lapse of reglementary
period provided for filing of the petition.
6. Upon receipt of the Petitiory and the official receipt for the payment
   of filing fees of PhP 10,000.00 and legal research fee of php
   100.00,the case shall be docketed accordingly and be prefixed as
   sPA (DC).
     111   The Petition was filed beyond the period prescribed by the
           rules;
     iv.   The filing fee and legal research fee were not paid within
           the reglementary period;
 8. If the Petition is not summarily dismissed, the oCoC shall issue the
    corresponding Summons directly to the respondent or through the
    Office of the Election Officer (OEO) having jurisdiction over the
    party, oia E-mail. Provided that iJ the Summons is served
    electronically to the field office, the concerned oEo shall personally
    serve a copy of the Summons, petition, and Annexes to the
    respondent.
      The failure of the respondent to file his or her verified Answer czrz
      Memorandum within the reglementary period shall bar the
      respondent from submitting controverting evidence.
10. The case shall be deemed submitted for resolution upon the receipt
    of the respondent's Answer czre Memorandum or upon the
    expiration of the period to do so, whichever comes first.
                                                                                                    Page 11 of 14
n        In the Matter of Amending Rule 3 S€ctions 4 6, and 8; Rule 18 Sections 1 and 5; and Rule 38 Sertion 8 with
Additional Sections of the 1993 COMELEC Rules of Procedue and tnserting a New Rule on precedence and protocol,
promulgated on 16Ianuary 2007.
                                                                   Page 12 of 14
         Failure of the movant to pay the required filing fee and/ or research
fee   , or furnish the adverse party with a copy of the motion for
reconsideration prior to the filing of the same, shall be a ground for the
dismissal of the motion for reconsideration, after elevation to the
Commission (EnBanc).
Section 9. Finalifu -
        In cases where two or more candidates have the same names as the
nuisance candidate, the votes cast shall be considered as stray votes and
shall not be credited to anv candidate.
        In case the nuisance candidate does not have the same name as any
candidate for the same position, the votes cast for the nuisance candidate
shall be considered as strav votes.
        ln   case of a
                    multi-slot office, if the ballot contains one vote for the
nuisance candidate and no vote for the bona fide candidate, the vote will be
counted in the latter's favor. However, if the nuisance candidate and the
bona fde candidate each gets one vote, only one vote will be counted in the
latter's favor.
        In case the rules of succession shall not apply, a vacancy shall exist
for such position.
SO ORDERED.
CERTIFICATION
                                             C             oB. IOLA
                                                    Director IV
                                       Office of the Commission Secretary
This Resolution can be verified at this number (02) 8SZ7 2987; e-mail address
comsec@comelec. gov.ph