Design of 1-7 GHZ High Gain Wideband Filter Lna For Wireless Applications
Design of 1-7 GHZ High Gain Wideband Filter Lna For Wireless Applications
                                                                                                                                                                    Sandeep Kumar
                                                                                                                                                                          ECE
                                                                                                                                                                        CRSSIET
                                                                                                                                                                      Jhajjar, India
                                                                                                                                                            Abstract—The paper proposes a 3-stage wideband LNA
                                                                                                                                                        based on 3rd order Chebyshev band pass filter with cascode
                                                                                                                                                        MOS configuration and an output matching stage. MOS1
2022 IEEE 3rd Global Conference for Advancement in Technology (GCAT) | 978-1-6654-6855-8/22/$31.00 ©2022 IEEE | DOI: 10.1109/GCAT55367.2022.9971914
                                                                                                                                                                                  I. INTRODUCTION
                                                                                                                                                            The microwave and Radio Frequency (RF) technology
                                                                                                                                                        have a huge effect and is an important striking research area.                                      Fig. 1.Block diagram of basic LNA [14].
                                                                                                                                                        Interest in Ultra-Wideband (UWB) (i.e. 3.1-10.6 GHz, which
                                                                                                                                                        is divided into 3.1-5 GHz and 6-10.6 GHz) system has                               LNAs are discussed in literature which resonate at
                                                                                                                                                        increased as it is used in imaging systems, wireless personal                      frequencies by varying the components. But it requires
                                                                                                                                                        area networks and ground penetration radars. In                                    reactive components, each resonating at a particular
                                                                                                                                                        communication system, at the receiver side, the first stage is                     frequency. So, instead of using multi-band operation,
                                                                                                                                                        Low Noise Amplifier (LNA) and the critical one. LNA                                wideband LNAs are mainly designed. Various techniques are
                                                                                                                                                        amplifies the small signals received from the antenna and is                       discussed in literature for designing wideband LNAs. These
                                                                                                                                                        responsible for good Signal-to-Noise ratio (SNR). Low                              are [2]: a) Common Source (CS) stage with resistive
                                                                                                                                                        Noise Amplifier (LNA) consists of an input matching                                termination, b) using feedback techniques, c) Common Gate
                                                                                                                                                        network, a transistor amplifier (mainly CMOS), an output                           (CG) stage [13], d) distributed LNA, and e) filter LNA. Due
                                                                                                                                                        matching network, and load (as in Fig. 1). For maximum                             to resistive termination in (a), the design has high NF. Using
                                                                                                                                                        transfer of power from the antenna to LNA, the LNA’s input                         feedback requires several reactive components which leads
                                                                                                                                                        impedance should be matched with the resistance of antenna                         to large chip area. CG LNAs provides wideband matching,
                                                                                                                                                        [1]. The main characteristics required from LNA are high                           but it has low linearity and parasitic components degrade the
                                                                                                                                                        power gain, low Noise Figure (NF), good input and output                           overall performance. Distributed LNA requires more active
                                                                                                                                                        impedance matching and low power dissipation over the                              devices, so, it has high power consumption and occupies
                                                                                                                                                        entire range of frequency of interest. CMOS is mainly used                         large chip area. Moreover, it has low gain and poor NF.
                                                                                                                                                        for designing LNA, as CMOS serves the range well due to                            Filter LNAs seeks the input impedance of the circuit in the
                                                                                                                                                        low cost, ease of bulk fabrication, high level of integration                      reactive network. The band pass filter at the input section,
                                                                                                                                                        and low power consumption.                                                         resonates over the range of frequencies, providing flat gain
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           over a large bandwidth. This paper proposes a high gain, low
                                                                                                                                                            An LNA can be narrowband or wideband. A narrowband                             NF wideband filter LNA with an input band pass filter. The
                                                                                                                                                        LNA results in high cost, high power consumption, if it is                         active device (CMOS) is used in CS stage with source
                                                                                                                                                        used for each standard separately. So, instead of designing                        degeneration inductor for providing high gain and an input
                                                                                                                                                        narrowband LNAs for individual applications, focus has                             band pass filter for wideband operation.
                                                                                                                                                        shifted from narrowband to wideband. Wideband LNAs uses
                                                                                                                                                        less area with low cost for accommodating multi-band                                  The rest of the paper is as follows: Section II shows the
                                                                                                                                                        operation. In wideband LNA design, CMOS have parasitic                             ways of attaining wide bandwidth using filters along with
                                                                                                                                                        and at high frequencies capacitive loading of output stage                         Common Source (CS), Common Gate (CG), or cascode
                                                                                                                                                        impacts the overall gain of the system. Multi-band                                 topology by various researchers. Based on literature review,
                                                                                                                                                        Authorized licensed use limited to: Mississippi State University Libraries. Downloaded on February 17,2023 at 19:26:28 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Section III elaborates the design factors and provides the                         dB and input return loss of –17.5 dB is designed. The NF of
specifications targeted for the design. Section IV explains the                    the designed LNA is 4.56 dB.
proposed filter LNA for wide bandwidth. Section V gives the
simulation results and compares the parameters. Section VI                              In [7], a CG stage is used for wideband matching with a
concludes the design.                                                              cascode stage for providing power gain and a shunt peaking
                                                                                   inductor for high 3-dB cut-off frequency. An active notch
                      II. LITERATURE REVIEW                                        filter of 3rd order between the cascode is used to remove the
                                                                                   interferers. The maximum power gain is 14.7 dB with a NF
     Wideband Low Noise Amplifiers provide a wide                                  of 5.3 dB consuming a power of 16 mW with a TSMC 180
bandwidth with a flat gain over the frequencies of interest.                       nm PTM node.
There are many ways cited in literature which are used to
provide wideband matching. These include Common gate                                    In [8], a CG, CS single to dual converter wideband LNA
LNA having wide input matching, or Common source LNA                               is designed. Common gate first stage is used for wide input
with resistive termination or filter LNA consisting of                             matching and dual converter output is used by 2nd order bi-
Common Source amplifier topology with an input filter                              quad Butterworth filters followed by mixer stage.
section. Distributed amplifiers are also sometimes used, but                       Butterworth filter provides maximally flat gain over the
they occupy large chip area and more power dissipation. So,                        frequency of interest. CS stage gives noise cancellation
they are rarely used in LNA design. This paper focuses on                          coming from the CG stage. In [9], a two-stage narrowband
filter LNA and thus a detailed review of various techniques                        LNA in the frequency range of 1.8-2.3 GHz consisting of CS
to achieve wideband matching using such LNA as                                     first stage followed by a buffer stage is designed. By using a
considered by various researchers is evaluated.                                    capacitor in parallel with source degeneration inductor, a
                                                                                   notch filter is formed which helps in reducing the third
    In [3], a wideband LNA in 180 nm TSMC CMOS                                     harmonic components. Harmonics are filtered out before
technology is designed using a cascode CMOS amplifier and                          reaching the mixer and hence strong blockers are
a high pass filter (HPF) at the input section. A T-type high                       desensitized. Due to the passive nature of the notch filter,
pass filter is designed which uses less inductor and hence                         current consumption is also not increased. Buffer stage
reduces the chip area. A Chebyshev 3rd section is used for                         provides the output matching. A NF of 3.1 dB and gain of 11
high attenuation. HPF provides the lower 3-dB cut-off                              dB is attained by using a PTM node of 40 nm. [10] Designed
frequency while the resonance of RL and CL at drain of                             a receiver front end at 0.47-0.86 GHz for interoperability
MOSFET M2 gives the high 3-dB cut-off frequency. This in-                          between TV tuner receiver and GSM. An LNA with notch
turn provides wideband matching. Output impedance                                  filter is designed where parallel resonance is bypassed for
matching is done using a buffer stage. Input return loss is –                      DVB and series notch is used. For GSM, parallel resonance
27 dB, while NF is 3.3 dB with a maximum power gain of 10                          circuit is used. A high gain of 28 dB along with NF of 3 dB
dB and a power consumption of 7 mW from a 2 V supply.                              is obtained using a PTM node of 130 nm.
    In [4], a wideband amplifier in the low frequency range                            In [11], an inductor-less wideband LNA at 3.1-4.8 GHz
of 3-5 GHz is designed using 180 nm CMOS technology                                range is proposed which reduces noise and distortions. Three
node. A narrowband cascode amplifier with a feedback                               notch filters are used at the last stage of LNA in series
resistance Rf is employed from the output of cascode stage to                      resonance and three sub-bands are associated with each
the input of Common source first stage to obtain a flat gain                       tunable notch filter to remove out-of-band interferers. A
over the desired bandwidth. The feedback Rf lowers the Q-                          voltage gain of 13.4-14 dB with a NF of 3.9 dB is achieved.
factor which in turn increases the bandwidth. In this design                       Due to the addition of additional parasitic capacitances, the
also, input impedance matching is done using LS, to achieve                        gain of the overall system decreases. In [12], a notch filter is
maximum power gain. The main drawback of this design is                            employed at the input of a cascode amplifier to work in dual
the use of Rf which is a source of noise and hence NF is                           band. A mutual induction matching circuit at the output is
increased. The design provides a NF of 2.3 dB, maximum                             used to reduce NF. Current mirror circuit is used as a biasing
gain of 9.8 dB and input return loss greater than 9 dB. [5]                        circuit and to reduce power consumption. At the first band of
Describes a 3-8 GHz wideband LNA using a CS Cascode                                1.66 GHz, the LNA provides a gain of 12.5 dB and NF 1.91
stage with an input mutually coupled symmetric center tap                          dB. At the second band (3.26 GHz), gain of 9.02 dB and NF
inductor. The symmetric center tap inductor acts as a 5th                          of 3.25 dB is attained. 180 nm PTM node is used to design
order band pass filter and is used to remove out of band                           the concurrent LNA.
interferers. For wideband matching, a feedback resistor is
used which affects the input impedance. Rf diminishes the Q-                                 III. DESIGN FACTORS AND SPECIFICATIONS
factor and hence increases the bandwidth. But at the same
time, it increases the NF. To overcome it, a MOS with high                             The designing of a wide bandwidth LNA is a complex
unity gain bandwidth can be used. By using triple resonance                        task. It is very difficult to attain high gain over a wide range
at the load of cascode stage, the high frequency bandwidth is                      of frequencies. A CG topology with its easy input impedance
increased significantly.                                                           matching over a wide range provides moderate gain.
                                                                                   According to maximum power transfer theorem, maximum
    In [6], a CS stage followed by a series shunt peaking                          gain is obtained if input and output section of the LNA is
second MOS stage and a feedback resistor is used to design a                       matched in impedance. The lower frequency pole is provided
wideband LNA. A source degeneration inductor is used in                            by input matching circuit and higher frequency pole is
first CS stage for narrowband matching and maximum power                           provided by output matching circuit. Lumped components
gain followed by increase in bandwidth using series shunt                          cannot be scaled down to the same extent, as the length of
peaking and Rf. By using 180 nm PTM node, a wideband                               MOS device decreases. If a lumped component like inductor
3.1-10.6 GHz LNA having maximum power gain of 17.92                                or capacitor is also scaled down as per PTM node, the
                                                                                   amount of energy dissipation will be more, and this leads to
Authorized licensed use limited to: Mississippi State University Libraries. Downloaded on February 17,2023 at 19:26:28 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
more power dissipation. As the PTM node decreases, the                             optimum impedance (ܼ௧ ) and return loss is minimized. The
available voltage level also decreases. The limited speed of                       topology provides amplifier stability and linearity. The MOS
operation of the MOS device and the resistance of the                              is configured with PTM node of 90 nm. The cascode stage is
channel considerations also poses challenges while designing                       used to isolate the gate to drain capacitance of the output
an LNA.                                                                            with the input section of the amplifier. This improves NF
    For hand-held mobile devices or portable gadgets, the                          performance of the proposed design. For output matching, a
power consumed should be as minimum as possible. MOS                               combination of inductor (L3) and a capacitance (C3) along
geometry (Width of channel) affects a large number of                              with the gate to drain capacitance is used to match with the
parameters. The channel resistance of MOS decreases with                           output termination impedance of 50 Ω.
increase in fingers for the width. It also results in high
capacitance between gate and source which degrades the                                                      ͳ
                                                                                              ܸ ൌ ܫ          ሺܫ  ݃ ܸ௦ ሻܵܮଶ                       (1)
input matching of the circuit. MOS is used in LNA which                                                    ܵܥ௦
acts as a non-linear device, so techniques should be used to
provide a linear output [14]. Stability of the designed LNA is                                   ͳ                ܫ
another important design factor. As discussed above,                                    ൌ ܫ         ቆܫ  ݃      ቇ ܵܮଶ ൌ  ܫ ܼ                    (2)
                                                                                                ܵܥ௦             ܵܥ௦
different ways are present for wideband operation such as
feedback, CS, CG or distributed amplifiers. Also, CG
topology LNA provides moderate gain and in applications                                                                ͳ     ݃ ܮଶ
                                                                                                  ܼ ൌ ܵሺܮଶ ሻ                                           (3)
that need high gain CS topology must be used.                                                                         ܵܥ௦    ܥ௦
    Based on the parameters discussed, an LNA is proposed                             ܼݎܨ ൌ ܴ௦ ǡ ݃݉ܫሺܼ ሻ ൌ Ͳܴܽ݊݀݁ሺܼ ሻ ൌ ܴ௦                         (4)
for wide bandwidth having high gain, good reverse isolation,
low NF, low power consumption, and stable design. The
specifications are as in Table I.                                                                            ͳ             ݃ ܮଶ
                                                                                                ݓଶ ൌ             ܴܽ݊݀௦ ൌ                              (5)
                         TABLE I. SPECIFICATIONS
                                                                                                          ሺܮଶ ሻܥ௦          ܥ௦
             Frequency                                 1-7 GHz
                                                                                      In the proposed circuit, one CS cascode stage is taken
              Gain (S21)                               > 13 dB
                                                                                   and width of MOSFET2 is changed to obtain high power
                  NF                                   < 3.5 dB
                                                                                   gain.
        Input return loss (S11)                        < -12 dB
         Stability Factor (K)                             >1
Authorized licensed use limited to: Mississippi State University Libraries. Downloaded on February 17,2023 at 19:26:28 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
hence minimizes the NF. Increasing the supply voltage                              off between the device capacitances and the bias current,
increases the NF slightly. Increasing the bias voltage                             which leads to changes in NF and gain. So, instead of
decreases the NF. As shown in Fig. 4, the NF decreases at                          transconductance, the increased output impedance causes the
low frequencies and minimum NF of 1.115 dB is achieved at                          overall gain to increase. As shown in Fig. 5, maximum gain
a frequency of 3.3 GHz. This occurs with the degeneration of                       of 17.951 dB is achieved at 2.7 GHz and a good reverse
noise source of MOSFET2 by the output impedance of                                 isolation of -22.8 dB is achieved 3.1 GHz.
MOSFET1. At higher frequencies, NF degrades due to
parasitic admittance at source (MOSFET2)-drain                                     C. Stability Factor
(MOSFET1) common node. Also, the source degeneration                                   An effective low noise amplifier should have a low
inductor (L2) makes optimum noise and power points closer                          output reflection coefficient (S22), input reflection coefficient
together. The overall NF in the range of 1.7-6.1 GHz is less                       (S11), reverse transmission coefficient (S12), and high gain
than 2.2 dB which shows good NF.                                                   (S21) [14]. The stability of the proposed circuit is analyzed
                                                                                   using S-parameters. The necessary condition for stability is:
                                                                                                    െ ȁࡿ ȁ െ ȁࡿ ȁ  ȁࢤȁ
                                                                                           ࡷ ൌ                                 ͳ                        (8)
                                                                                                            כȁࡿ ࡿ ȁ
                                                                                                        ߂ ൌ ܵଵଵ ܵଶଶ െ ܵଵଶ ܵଶଵ                             (9)
B. Gain and Reverse Isolation Analysis                                                Stability factor for the proposed circuit is given in Fig. 6
   The magnitude of voltage gain (Av) of a cascode LNA                             and the value is greater than 1 over the complete frequency
neglecting the impact of body bias is given by:                                    range. Hence the circuit is stable.
             ȁܣ௩ ȁ ൌ  ݃ଵ ݎ כଵ ሺͳ  ݃ଶ ݎ כଶሻ                        (6)
                                                                                   D. Comparison
    Here gm1, ro1, gm2, and ro2 gives the transconductance of                          A comparison of the proposed filter LNA circuit is
MOSFET1, output resistance of channel of MOSFET1,                                  compared with some latest research on filter LNA. The Table
transconductance of MOSFET2 and output resistance of                               2 shows that the circuit is providing a comparable gain over
channel of MOSFET2 respectively. The cascode structure                             the frequency range with very good NF. The reflection
has high output impedance and CS stage as a degeneration                           coefficient is in accordance with the technical specifications
resistance (ro1) by MOSFET2 of CG stage. Thus, the output                          mentioned in Table 1 and is also better in comparison to [9],
impedance of cascode stage is given by:                                            [10], and [12]. The power consumption of the proposed
           ܴ௨௧ ൌ  ݎଶ  ሺͳ   ݃ଶ ݎ כଶ ሻݎଵ                      (7)           circuit is 18 mW with power supply of 0.8 V.
   MOSFET2 improves the output impedance of MOSFET1                                           TABLE II. COMPARISON WITH EXISTING FILTER LNAS
by a factor of gm2 ro2. As the overall gain of the cascode stage
                                                                                                                                           PTM       Power
depends on the transconductance and the output resistance of                                 Frequency       Gain      NF       S11
                                                                                                                                           node   Consumption
both stages, the increase in output resistance due to cascode                                  (GHz)         (dB)     (dB)     (dB)
                                                                                                                                           (nm)      (mW)
CG stage, increases the gain. Transconductance has a trade-
                                                                                    This
                                                                                                 1-7         17.9     1.11    -22.8         90           18
                                                                                    work
                                                                                                                              < -
                                                                                    [10]      0.47-0.86       28       3                   130           14
                                                                                                                              10
                                                                                                                              < -
                                                                                     [9]       1.8-2.3        11      3.1                   40           19
                                                                                                                              10
                                                                                    [12]      1.66-3.26      12.5     3.25    -7.11        180          20.5
Authorized licensed use limited to: Mississippi State University Libraries. Downloaded on February 17,2023 at 19:26:28 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
                          VI. CONCLUSION                                                  Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 58, no. 2,
                                                                                          pp. 287-296, February 2010.
     A three stage 1-7 GHz wideband LNA is designed which                          [7]    Jui-Yi Lin, Hwann-Kaeo Chiou, “Power Constrained Third-Order
consists of BPF, cascode amplifier stage and an output                                    Active Notch Filter applied in IR-LNA for UWB Standards”, IEEE
matching stage. Cascode stage provides narrow band                                        Transactions on Circuits and Systems-II: Express Briefs, vol. 58, no.
matching by using source degeneration inductor. Band pass                                 1, pp. 11-15, 11 January 2011.. Young, The Technical Writer’s
                                                                                          Handbook. Mill Valley, CA: University Science, 1989.
filter adds the input impedance of the circuit and provide flat
gain over wide bandwidth. The proposed circuit with good                           [8]    Baktash Behmanesh, Seyed Mojtaba Atarodi, “Active Eight-Path
                                                                                          Filter and LNA with Wide Channel Bandwidth and Center Frequency
output matching stage provides a gain of 17.95 dB, 1.115 dB                               Tunability”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave theory and
NF, and a good reverse isolation of -22.8 dB and a stable                                 Techniques, vol. 65, no. 11, pp. 4715-4723, November 2017.
design.                                                                            [9]    Raymond Gyaang, Dong-Ho Lee, Jusung Kim, “Analysis and Design
                                                                                          of Harmonic Rejection Low Noise Amplifier with an Embedded
                              REFERENCES                                                  Notch Filter”, MDPI Electronics, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 1-10, March 2020.
[1]   T. H. Lee, “The Design of CMOS Radio Frequency Integrated                    [10]   Yangji Jeon, Sung Wook Yoon, Changyeol Kim, Hyunwon Moon,
      Circuits”, 2nd ed., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U. K.,                   Iiku Nam, “A Wideband Digital TV Receiver front-end with On-chip
      1998.                                                                               Notch Filter”, International Conference on Electronics, Information
[2]   S. Arshad, F. Zafar, R. Ramzan, Q. Wahab, “Wideband and                             and Communication (ICEIC), Auckland, pp. 415-418, 2019.
      multiband CMOS LNAs: State-of-the-art and future prospects”,                 [11]   Paria Sepidband, Kamran Entesari, “A CMOS Wideband Receiver
      Microelectronics Journal, vol. 44, no. 9, pp. 774-786, September                    resilient to out-of-band interferers using blocker detection and
      2013.                                                                               rejection”, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques,
[3]   Mun-Sook Jung, et Al., “A 2.7 to 9.3 GHz CMOS Wideband                              vol. 66, no. 5, pp. 2340-2355, 2018.
      Amplifier Combined with High pass Filter for UWB system”, The 7 th           [12]   Yuito Sawayama, Takayuki Morishita, Kiyotaka Komoku, Nobuyuki
      International Conference on Advanced Communication Technology                       Itoh, “Dual Band Concurrent Low Noise LNA”, IEEE International
      (ICACT 2005), Phoenix Park, Korea (South), pp. 57-60, 21-23                         Symposium on Radio-Frequency Integration Technology (RFIT),
      February 2005.                                                                      Hiroshima, pp. 160-162, September 2020.
[4]   Chang-Wan Kim, et al., “An Ultra-Wideband CMOS Low Noise                     [13]   Vikram Singh, Sandeep Kumar Arya, Manoj Kumar, “A Common-
      Amplifier for 3-5 GHz UWB system”, IEEE Journal of Solid-State                      Gate Current-Reuse UWB LNA for Wireless Applications in 90 nm
      Circuits, vol. 40, no. 2, pp. 544-547, February 2005.                               CMOS”, Wireless Personal Communications (Springer), February
[5]   Ali Meaamar, et al., “A 3-8 GHz Low Noise CMOS Amplifier”, IEEE                     2021.
      Microwave and Wireless Component Letters, vol. 19, no. 4, pp. 245-           [14]   Rohit Goel, Anil Kumar, Mahesh Kumar, Sandeep Kumar, “Design of
      247, April 2009.                                                                    High Gain 2-11 GHz Wideband Common Gate LNA using Shunt
[6]   Yo-Sheng Lin, et al., “Analysis and Design of a CMOS UWB LNA                        Series Peaking Technique for Wireless Applications”, International
      with Dual-RLC-Branch Wideband Input Matching Network”, IEEE                         conference on Advances in Computing, Communication, and Control
                                                                                          (ICAC3), Mumbai, December 2021.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Mississippi State University Libraries. Downloaded on February 17,2023 at 19:26:28 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.