BPP Business School

Coursework Cover Sheet

Please use this document as the cover sheet of for the 1st page of your assessment.

Please complete the below table – the grey columns

Module Name Executive Leadership and Governance

Student Reference
Number

(SRN)

Assessment Title Apple Leadership and Risk Management Report

Please complete the yellow sections in the below declaration:

Declaration of Original Work:

I hereby declare that I have read and understood BPP’s regulations on plagiarism and that
this is my original work, researched, undertaken, completed and submitted in accordance
with the requirements of BPP School of Business and Technology.

The word count, excluding contents table, bibliography and appendices, is __4907____
words.

Student Reference Number: __________ Date: ______

By submitting this coursework, you agree to all rules and regulations of BPP regarding
assessments and awards for programmes.

Please note that by submitting this assessment you are declaring that you are fit to sit this
assessment.

BPP University reserves the right to use all submitted work for educational purposes and may
request that work be published for a wider audience.
Contents
Part A: Board Review Report for new and existing Board Members........................................4

1. Organisational Culture and the Role of the Board.............................................................4

1.1. Leadership style and organisational culture at Apple..................................................4

1.2. The main duties of the board.......................................................................................4

2. Corporate Governance.......................................................................................................5

2.1. The Corporate Governance framework for Apple.......................................................5

2.2. Evaluation of the Remuneration Committee’s Role at Apple.....................................7

3. Regulatory Landscape and Management of Risk...............................................................7

3.1. Evaluate the Board’s responsibility for risk management...........................................7

3.2. The regulatory landscape for Apple and the impact regulators has on the company’s
success................................................................................................................................8

3.3. Analysis and evaluation the risks faced by Apple.......................................................8

3.4. Recommendation for the risk faced by Apple and the role of the board in managing
these risks...........................................................................................................................9

Part B: Leadership Report........................................................................................................10

1. Task 1 -Leadership and Management...............................................................................10

1.1 Analyse the Leadership and Management style at Apple...........................................10

1.2 Comparison of Apple’s Leadership Style with Samsung...........................................10

1.3 Apple’s ability to handle significant business challenges..........................................12

2. Task 2 – Leadership for Performance..............................................................................13

2.1. Balanced Scorecard for Apple...................................................................................13

2.2 Approaches to Achieve Objectives............................................................................14

2.3 Financial Statement....................................................................................................15

3. Task 3: Ethical Leadership...............................................................................................19

3.1 Ethical Issues in Apple...............................................................................................19

3.2. Recommendations.....................................................................................................20
Table of Figure

Figure 1: Corporate Governance Structure of Apple.................................................................6

Figure 2: Statement of Cash Flow............................................................................................16
Figure 3: Statement of Operations of Apple............................................................................17
Figure 4: Balance Sheet...........................................................................................................18
Part A: Board Review Report for new and existing Board Members

1. Organisational Culture and the Role of the Board

1.1. Leadership style and organisational culture at Apple

Under the course of Tim Cook and Steve Jobs, Apple's organizational culture and leadership
style have encountered a significant change that mirrors their different yet attractive strategies
for empowering success and innovation (Beheshti, 2018). Steve Jobs established the early
tone of Apple with his visionary and autocratic management style. Jobs' commitment to
excellence and his ability to motivate staff members to push boundaries resulted in ground-
breaking products and unparalleled success. Yet, his autocratic approach also empowered an
atmosphere of intimidation and fear. Which restricted free exchange of ideas and silenced
criticism inside the company. Despite this, Jobs' inspiring leadership made Apple's innovative
and creative culture and shaped the company's reputation as a leader in the tech industry.

According to Ian (2024), Tim Cook, on the other hand, has taken democratic leadership style
that is characterized by collaboration, transparency, and trust. Cook's emphasis on open
communication and cooperation has made an inclusive and engaged atmosphere, where
individuals feel free to share their ideas and abilities. This strategy has boosted worker
resolve and made a more joyful work environment, which has stimulated creativity and long-
term development (Bajarin, 2021). Furthermore, Cook's devotion to moral leadership and
openness has improved Apple's standing and fortified its bonds with stakeholders.

Tim Cook's cooperative leadership style and Steve Jobs' imaginative drive are combined to
make Apple's organizational culture. According to Bajarin (2021), Cook's democratic
leadership has fostered diversity and sustainability. Establishing the groundwork for sustained
success in a sector that is always showing signs of change. Whereas Jobs' dictatorial style
supported innovation and fast expansion. Together, these two leadership philosophies have
formed Apple's culture to emphasize moral way of behaving and moral business practices
alongside innovation, creativity, and excellence.

1.2. The main duties of the board

Apple Inc.'s Board of Directors plays a critical job in coordinating the company's direction
and guarding its interests. They have to make sure that the company is growing and behaving
ethically. Their numerous responsibilities incorporate managing and directing Apple's
direction, sticking to a strict code of ethics and excellence. Led by Arthur D. Levinson, the
Board examines and approves Apple's plans, goals, and initiatives (Apple, 2024 a). He
ensures alignment with long-term objectives and stakeholder interests by closely
communicating with CEO Tim Cook.

Likewise, the Board assesses the executive team's performance, including determining
compensation plans. This obligation is overseen by Andrea Jung and Alex Gorsky. By doing
this, incentives are guaranteed to be suitably coordinated with Apple's general strategy and
performance indicators. The Board is accountable for risk management and internal controls.
Monica Lozano and Ronald D. Sugar hold significant positions on the Audit and Finance
Committee (Apple, 2024 a). They supervise the establishment of resilient systems to decrease
risks and preserve the integrity of the business' activities productively.

Another vital duty of the Board is approving important investments, acquisitions, and
divestitures to safeguard Apple's financial standing and future growth opportunities. Susan L.
Wagner makes a substantial commitment to this part of the Board's duties by using her
knowledge of corporate governance. They each contribute to maintain the trust and
confidence placed in them and guide Apple towards success in ever changing sector through
ethical monitoring and moral leadership.

2. Corporate Governance

2.1. The Corporate Governance framework for Apple

According to Mahmood (2023), Apple's operational philosophy is established by its

Corporate Governance structure. It upholds the values of responsibility, openness, and
stakeholder involvement. The framework's primary objective is to maximize shareholder
wealth. However, it also acknowledges that it has more extensive obligations to its customers,
workers, the climate, and the communities. One of the core principles of Apple's governance
idea is transparency (Ahmed, 2023). The corporation upholds freely accessible records. These
records emphasize its devotion with complying to labour rules, natural statutes, and other
administrative statutes overseeing its overall supply chain. This devotion to openness
promotes confidence among interested parties and guarantees adherence to ethical standards.

According to Mahmood (2023), another significant pillar of Apple's governance structure is

accountability. The Board of Directors, chaired by Arthur D. Levinson, is principally in
charge for determining the company's strategic direction and protecting the interests of its
shareholders. To ensure consistency with long-term objectives, they inspect and endorse
monetary targets, operational strategies, and strategic plans. Also, the board authorizes
significant investments, acquisitions, and divestitures as well as checking management
execution and assessing CEO remuneration. This proactive strategy guarantees Apple's
resilience to short-term setbacks while advancing in long-term, sustainable development and
value generation.

Figure 1: Corporate Governance Structure of Apple

Source: Apple, 2024 a

Apple's management team, led by President Tim Cook, carries out strategic choices and
supervises everyday operations while ensuring compliance, controlling risk, and empowering
innovation. Risk management and financial integrity are ensured by specialized committees
such as the Audit and Finance Committee, which is led by Ronald D. Sugar. Andrea Jung,
committee’s chair, determines chief compensation as per organizational objectives (Apple,
2024 a). Susan L. Wagner, as chair of the Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee,
makes sure that governance guidelines are observed and the board operates actually. These
independent chief committees focus on significant topics and work on Apple's presentation
and governance structure by offering various skills.

2.2. Evaluation of the Remuneration Committee’s Role at Apple

Ensuring impartial and competitive remuneration for its executives is an important role of
Apple's Compensation Council. The council makes sure Apple stays competitive in bringing
and keeping best individuals in the innovation industry by performing in-depth market
analysis. Likewise, the board creates a compensation scale that matches executive salary to
the presentation and strategic objectives of the business (Apple, 2024 B). The council
incentivizes decisions that make long-term value creation for Apple and its shareholders by
connecting compensation to standards including income development, item innovation, and
stock execution.

Responsibility and transparency are two other important areas that the committee monitors. It
makes sure that data on CEO compensation is obviously disclosed in Apple's yearly
intermediary statement. Which promotes responsibility and certainty among shareholders.
Keeping up with sound corporate governance processes and addressing developing concerns
about executive compensation rely upon this transparency (Apple, 2024 B). The
Remuneration Panel's essential membership of independent directors serves to lessen the
possibility of conflicts of interest. This guarantees that choices on compensation are made
unbiasedly.

3. Regulatory Landscape and Management of Risk

3.1. Evaluating the Board’s responsibility for risk management

The board of Apple plays an essential job in guiding the association's way to deal with risk
management. They cover operational, legal, financial, reputational, and data security issues as
a component of their comprehensive oversight (Kipkoech, 2019). For instance, the board
must ensure the company takes strong precautions to safeguard customer data and intellectual
property in the radiance of developing cybersecurity threats. One of the board's specialized
committees, the Audit Committee, is essential to risk management. This committee closely
examines the management's mitigation efforts and keeps a close eye on any serious risks. For
instance, the Audit Committee needs to assess Apple's operational disruption minimization
strategies and resistance to supply chain interruptions.

Moreover, risk exposure is significantly affected by the board's strategic advice. Contemplate
Apple's strategic decision to extend its product line past equipment and incorporate services
like Apple TV+ and Apple Music. This increases revenue streams, yet it also brings with it
new dangers, similar to content licensing contracts and competition from deeply grounded
firms like Netflix and Spotify (Han et al. 2023). The board of Apple is a major impact on the
company's approach to risk management. According to El Khatib et al. (2023), through strict
monitoring, the creation of specialized committees, the board works to protect Apple's
interests and guarantee its long-term sustainability notwithstanding a fast-paced and
constantly-changing business environment.

3.2. The regulatory landscape for Apple and the impact regulators has on the company’s
success

Apple's operations are based on its adherence to regulatory standards, especially those
pertaining to privacy and the environment. Apple has started to lead the pack in ensuring that
its privacy policies conform to strict requirements, such as the General Data Protection
Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union (Phelan, 2018). App Tracking Transparency
(ATT), is a feature that Apple launched to give customers more control over their data
privacy. This move is in line with GDPR principles and has been praised by privacy activists.

Furthermore, Apple has made a reason behind featuring its dedication to environmental
sustainability. The business has set elevated requirements for itself, such as becoming carbon
neutral throughout its supply chain by 2030 (Johnson, 2023). To do this, Apple has set up a
number of efforts. Such as encouraging its suppliers to follow after accordingly and switching
to renewable energy sources for its facilities. Apple's commitment to observing
environmental guidelines is evident in its Environmental Responsibility Report. Which offers
transparent insights into the company's activities and success around here.

Misjudging the importance of regulatory compliance for Apple's international growth and
market penetration is impossible. According to Coulter et al. (2024), Apple's adherence to
privacy and environmental rules guarantees legal compliance as well as improves customer
trust and brand reputation. Failure to consent might incur significant legal fees and harm
Apple's reputation.
3.3. Analysis and evaluation the risks faced by Apple

A thorough assessment of Apple's risks finds a number of significant obstacles that could
meaningfully affect the business' operations and competitive standing.

Creativity Challenges: Innovative creativity is clearly associated with a high level of risk.
Apple has high expectations for innovation and needs to outperform its customers
continuously (Echowook, 2023). Be that as it may, being creative at this level is extremely
difficult, particularly in a field where consumer tastes are shifting and technology is
developing rapidly.

Supply Chain Risks: Given the worldwide scope of Apple's activities, supply chain
interruption poses a genuine concern. Any interruption could cause delays in the supply of
products, which would bring down sales and lower consumer satisfaction (Culpan et al.
2023). As the landscape of the supply chain gets more intricate, continuity and resilience
must be ensured.

Competitive Pressures: Apple's market supremacy is continuously undermined by

competitors. With so numerous businesses competing for market share as the tech industry
develops, Apple finds it difficult to stand out from the competition and preserve its
competitive advantage as per Savov (2024).

Tech Sector Evolution: The possibility of falling behind in Silicon Valley highlights how the
tech sector is evolving. Despite the fact that Apple has long been a mainstay in Silicon Valley,
new tech clusters are a threat to innovation and the retention of talent (Gurman, 2021).
Decentralization from Silicon Valley might increase this risk significantly more, requiring
determined choices to arrange the shifting terrain successfully.

3.4. Recommendation for the risk faced by Apple and the role of the board in managing
these risks

Apple can establish several strategic measures to address the threats that have been
distinguished.

 Innovation Cultivation: Apple needs to put more emphasis in developing its creative
teams and empowering a continuous innovation culture to address the issue of
creative innovation. This might involve making investments in the training of future
leaders, empowering teamwork, and offering resources for brainstorming and
 experimenting (Peng et al. 2020). Apple can sustain its reputation for leading products
and stay in front of changing consumer needs by engaging its creative teams.
 Supply Chain Strengthening: Apple should focus on further developing supply
chain resilience to lessen interruptions. To relieve possible interruptions, it very well
might be necessary to diversify suppliers, assign resources towards digital supply
chain technologies to upgrade transparency and adaptability, and establish risk
management procedures (Taylor, 2023). By constructing a robust supply chain, Apple
can lessen the effects of disruptions and assurance that its products will be accessible
to consumers.
 Talent Diversification: Apple should contemplate widening its search for talent
outside of Silicon Valley and entering exceptional tech hotspots across the globe to
moderate the risk of losing position there. According to Li and Qiao, (2023), this can
ensure access to a changed pool of highly qualified workers and lessen the
opportunity of talent drain.
 Board Oversight: The Board plays a vital job in controlling these risks. The Board is
responsible for determining the company's strategic direction and supervising risk
management initiatives. They must to effectively team up with management to grasp
the possible consequences of these risks and deal direction on suitable measures to
take.

Part B: Leadership Report

1. Task 1 -Leadership and Management

1.1 Analyse the Leadership and Management style at Apple

Famous for combining an assortment of leadership philosophies. These fit the six leadership
styles recognized by Daniel Goleman. Each style adds something to Apple's success. At
Apple, visionary leadership has been significant (Stier, 2023). It encourages workers to be
innovative and exceptional. Steve Jobs' progressive style served to act as an illustration of
this. What he would consider user-friendly technology transformed entire sectors. Tim Cook
carried on this practice by prioritizing environmental responsibility and ethical
manufacturing. According to Leswing (2023), Apple's sales skyrocketed to $383.29 billion in
2023 under his direction.

According to Ian, (2024), Tim Cook employs democratic leadership as he consistently asks
workers for their opinions on a scope of topics. This aesthetic encourages creative thinking
and a welcoming environment. Apple's strategy fosters a feeling of dedication and
community. Apple's high standards are indicative of its pacesetting leadership. Workers are
tested to attain greatness. Apple's constant technological improvements are driven by this
style (Lewis, 2022). In any case, it can also result in stress at work and excessive pressure.
Albeit less obvious, it is just as essential to mentor leadership. Apple has a significant training
and development budget. For instance, leadership and decisive thinking are instructed at
Apple University (Baron, 2023). This human capital investment fosters innovation and
improves problem-solving abilities. Within Apple, affiliative leadership improves
relationships amongst coworkers.

1.2 Comparison of Apple’s Leadership Style with Samsung

Apple's management approach is totally different from Samsung's. Apple as often as possible
takes a visionary stance. Strong brand loyalty and innovation are supported by this. Then
again, Samsung tends to be more autocratic (Radić, 2021). Efficiency and hierarchical
decision-making are focused on in this style. Apple's strategy places a high need on user
experience and design. All of its product offerings demonstrate this. Samsung, then again,
prioritizes market variety and response. Under Tim Cook, Apple has focused on ethical
production in its approach. Cook has made Apple's supply chain more transparent.
These variations don't influence the companies' continued high profitability. In 2023, Apple
kept $383.29 billion in revenue (Leswing, 2023). In 2023, Samsung proclaimed revenues of
KRW 279.6 trillion. Apple has issues in the future because of its dependence on innovation.
Two significant dangers are technological disruption and market saturation. Retaining market
share and production efficiency is Samsung's issue. Sustainable environmental practices are a
constant issue for the two businesses. The two brands are affected by elevated scrutiny about
corporate responsibility.

Key Challenges for Apple’s Future Development:

1. Innovation Saturation: It gets more diligently to think of new ideas for weighty
innovation as long as Apple remains at the highest point of the tech industry. To
maintain consideration and market share, the business must continue to give
distinctive items. For instance, even while sales of iPhones continue to be a
significant source of income, the development of the global smartphone industry has
slowed (O'Mahony, 2024). This suggests that Apple might have to adopt a more
aggressive strategy to exploring new product categories.
 2. Supply Chain Vulnerability: Due to its extensive global supply network, Apple is
defenceless against trade conflicts and geopolitical unrest. Tensions over trade
between the United States and China stand out to the hazards. Because of its
dependence on Chinese manufacturers, where most of its goods are made, Apple is
exposed to a lot of risk from possible tariffs and supply interruptions (Choudhary,
2021). These risks might be diminished by diversifying suppliers and manufacturing
sites.

3. Environmental Impact and Sustainability: Apple's environmental policies and

practices are going under more scrutiny as environmental issues become more
pervasive in society. All by 2030, the company wants to have decreased its carbon
footprint and accomplished net-zero climate effect across its goods (Johnson, 2023). A
significant obstacle stands in the approach to accomplishing these objectives while
keeping up with high production quantities of electronic items.

4. Regulatory and Legal Challenges: Authorities from one side of the planet to the
other are scrutinizing Apple to an ever-increasing extent, raising concerns about its
business practices, especially those connected with the App Store. According to
Stolton and Bodoni (2024), the Digital Markets Act of the European Union and
tantamount laws in different jurisdictions urge Apple to profoundly alter the manner
in which it runs its online marketplaces, which affect its business strategy.

1.3 Apple’s ability to handle significant business challenges

1. Driving Innovation Beyond Saturation: For Apple to keep growing, it will be

essential that it can improve consistently. Regardless of whether the global
smartphone industry is saturated, Apple has continuously shown that driving how in
developing new product categories and technology is capable. Two of its best
examples of innovation are the introduction of the Apple Watch and AirPods. These
goods enhanced Apple's ecosystem and brought in additional sources of income. The
company's devotion to innovation is shown in its $29 billion investment in research
and development in 2023 (MARTINS 2023). Apple is ready to investigate state of the
art technologies like augmented reality and artificial intelligence thanks to its
continuous R&D spending.

2. Strengthening Supply Chain Resilience: In spite of the fact that Apple's vast supply
chain is essential to its business success, it also carries a number of significant
 dangers. Apple has started to diversify its supply chain in an effort to reduce these
risks. This entails considering other Southeast Asian nations well as growing
industrial plants in India. Apple can relieve the impact of any interruptions resulting
from international trade disputes or tariffs by decreasing its dependence on Chinese
manufacturing (Taylor, 2023). Apple also keeps spending cash on new manufacturing
technology and supply chain automation. Which increase productivity and lessen
reliance on labour-intensive procedures.

3. Commitment to Environmental Sustainability: Apple has established aggressive

environmental goals, one of which is to become carbon neutral for the entire company
by 2030. With more than 110 suppliers pledging to use just renewable energy for
Apple production, the business is investing in renewable energy solutions (Johnson,
2023). With this program, Apple lessens its carbon footprint as well as establishes
itself as a pioneer in environmental corporate responsibility. Furthermore, Apple is
constantly improving its product recycling capabilities and introducing new
technologies for recovering materials, such as the "Daisy" robot that can disassemble
iPhones to recover important materials (O'Brien,2022). Incorporating sustainability
into its business strategy helps Apple solve environmental issues.

2. Task 2 – Leadership for Performance

2.1. Balanced Scorecard for Apple

Perspective Objectives Key Targets Initiatives

Performance
Indicators
(KPIs)

Financials Increase in Revenue 5% annual Expand product lines

revenue growth rate growth and enter new markets

Improving Net profit Maintain at Cost reduction through

profit margins margin least 20% supply chain
optimization
 Customers Enhancing Customer Score > 90 Improve customer
customer satisfaction service and support
satisfaction index

Increasing Market share Gain 2% Marketing campaigns

market share in key market share and partnerships
segment annually

Internal Optimizing Efficiency Improve Lean management

Process operational ratio efficiency by practices
efficiency 10%

Enhancing Product Less than Advanced quality

quality control defect rate 0.5% assurance systems

Innovation Leading in Number of File 200 R&D investments and

technological new patents patents collaborations
innovation filed annually

Developing Revenue 30% of total Launch new product

groundbreaking from new revenue from categories
products products new products

Employee Improving Employee Achieve a Enhance work

employee satisfaction score of 85 out environment and
satisfaction score of 100 benefits

Enhancing Employee Retain 90% of Competitive

talent retention retention rate key personnel compensation and
career development
programs

2.2 Approaches to Achieve Objectives

Apple's leadership approach to performance improvement may be extraordinarily upgraded

by integrating Herzberg's Two Factor Theory into the association's strategic goals, as stated in
the Balanced Scorecard. The strategic goals referenced in the Balanced Scorecard can be
considerably exceptional at Apple by executing "Leadership for Performance" initiatives
(Amin and Munsi, 2020). These strategies focus on further developing leadership
philosophies to boost customer satisfaction, innovation and staff involvement. To accomplish
Apple's goals, these ideas can be purposefully consolidated as follows:

Hygiene Factors:

 Financial Perspective: Diminishing employee unhappiness requires competitive

salary and job security, the two of which Apple's effective leadership achieves.
Financial results can be improved by diminishing dissatisfaction, increasing
efficiency, and boosting transparency in financial transactions (Zhong et al. 2021).

 Internal Processes: Simplified processes and clear disclosure of job duties can
further develop morale (Zhong et al. 2021). This lucidity reduces misunderstandings,
boosts productivity, and creates a positive work atmosphere where everybody knows
their responsibilities.

Motivators:

 Customer Perspective: Superior customer service is bound to be given by staff

members who feel esteemed (Al-Saqri et al, 2023). This increases client loyalty and
happiness. Apple's objectives of developing its market share and further developing
customer relations are in accordance with compensating staff for extraordinary client
interactions.

 Innovation and Employee Growth: Support of professional growth can enormously

increase employee motivation. Apple's leadership methods, which incorporate
empowering creativity, setting up training programs, and perceiving unique
contributions, should mirror the company's commitment to innovation.

 Employee Perspective: Recognizing successes in collaboration, creativity, and

project completion can further develop morale at work (Amin and Munsi, 2020).
Celebrating in these victories fosters a positive work atmosphere that increases output.

In detail, leadership for performance at Apple could be implemented as follows:

 Ensuring Leadership Alignment with Financial Goals: Apple executives must

facilitate their activities with the company's financial goals (Zhong et al. 2021).
Managers, for instance, can get training to assist them with better grasping what their
 choices mean for financial indicators such as profit margins and revenue growth and
to fittingly act.

 Fostering a Culture of Innovation: Apple's executives should support a culture that

values creativity and views setbacks as educating moments. Innovation challenges
and incessant brainstorming sessions could assist with this (Al-Saqri et al, 2023).

 Developing Talent and Leadership: Employee skill enhancement and talent

retention can be accomplished through the execution of continuous development
programs. Drives that give open doors to continuous learning, similar to career
development courses, skills seminars, and mentoring programs, ought to be given
main concern by Apple chiefs. By supporting the professional development of its
staff, Apple can foster a lively and knowledgeable labour force, ensuring that they
have the mastery expected to prod innovation and keep a competitive edge in the fast-
paced tech sector.

 Customer-Centric Leadership: Leaders should get training on focusing on customer

demands and instilling this disposition in their teams (Amin and Munsi, 2020). For all
pertinent personnel, this entails designating customer satisfaction as a key
performance metric.

2.3 Financial Statement

Apple has released financial statements for the quarter that finished on July 1, 2023. Which
offer comprehensive information about the company's operating dynamics and financial
standing. To distinguish areas that require strategic improvements, the company's cash flow,
operational KPIs, and balance sheet information have all been closely inspected.

Figure 2: Statement of Cash Flow

 Source: Apple (2023c)

Apple's operating cash flow decreased to $88.945 billion in the detailed quarter from $98.024
billion in the earlier year. This drop implies a drop in EBITDA, suggesting that albeit the
business is still strong. Apple has demonstrated its smart financial management amidst
monetary concerns by its cautious way to deal with investment securities. Nonetheless, the
drop in net income from $79.082 billion to $74.039 billion suggests that there can be
difficulties in clutching profit margins while the economy is struggling (Apple, 2023).
Simultaneously, Apple continues to demonstrate its commitment to innovation with its
increased spending of $7.442 billion on research and development.

Figure 3: Statement of Operations of Apple

 Source: Apple, (2023c)

Apple's financial results from a revenue and operations standpoint were steady yet slowly
falling. Contrasted with the same period last year, when revenues were $82.959 billion, they
were somewhat lower at $81.797 billion. Despite figuring out how to slightly improve its
profit margin from $35.885 billion to $36.413 billion, the enterprise faces difficulties as
confirmed by a decrease in earnings per share from $1.26 to $1.20 (Apple, 2023 c). This can
be observed decrease in net income or by purposeful stock repurchases.

Figure 4: Balance Sheet

 Source: Apple, (2023c)

The balance sheet gave Apple's asset management and financial strategy additional
background information. The total assets dropped from $352.755 billion to $335.038 billion,
which could be the result of proceeding with asset depreciation or resource reallocation. Yet,
a huge drop in generally liabilities — from $302.083 billion to $274.764 billion — worked
on Apple's financial leverage and would increase its ability to get cash (Apple, 2023c). A solid
financial establishment that can make value for its owners is demonstrated by the decrease in
current liabilities from $153.982 billion to $124.963 billion and the increase in shareholder
equity from $50.672 billion to $60.274 billion.

The company is exploring through economic upheavals with a strong foundation in

profitability and strategic insight, according to the financials for the quarter. Apple's emphasis
on debt reduction and stockholder equity growth creates a solid foundation for financial
stability. Furthermore, its constant R&D expenditures might assist with offsetting some short-
term cost effects and drive future expansion. With a strategic focus on careful cost control
and progressing innovation, Apple is strategically situated to keep up with its market-leading
position even despite economic unpredictability. To keep up with Apple's market dominance
and financial stability, this analysis emphasizes the intricacies of the company's financial
environment and the need for proactive management and strategic adaptability.

3. Task 3: Ethical Leadership

3.1 Ethical Issues in Apple

As a leader in the world of innovation, Apple has a number of moral dilemmas that influence
its business practices and brand. Because of their importance and wide-ranging effects on
stakeholders and the environment, two of these challenges stand out.

Net Zero Commitment- Apple’s pledge to become carbon neutrality by 2030 poses a
significant moral dilemma. This goal calls for every Apple product sold to have a net zero
climate impact, covering every stage of the process from customer use and recycling to
manufacture (Johnson, 2023). The possible discrepancy between statements made out in the
open and real actions here presents a moral dilemma. For instance, a ton of energy is used
during the creation of Apple products, especially during the extraction and processing of raw
materials. Apple has an ethical obligation to guarantee openness and genuine advancement
towards its objectives.

Privacy and Data Issues - Apple is faced with moral conundrums pertaining to data security
and consumer privacy. The business has experienced harsh criticism for its murky customer
data handling procedures and its consistence with surveillance orders from the government
(Cooke, 2020). For instance, Apple has gained consideration for refusing to open iPhones for
policing, contrast to instances in which it agreed with requests from governments in non-
democratic nations. Keeping up with user privacy while supporting security measures is a
sensitive and morally complex balance. Apple's global operations put its privacy stance under
serious scrutiny as it has to oversee differing legal and ethical requirements regarding user
data.

3.2. Recommendations

To effectively manage the identified ethical issues, Apple can adopt several strategic actions:

1. Enhance Transparency in Environmental Goals: To keep up with credibility while

dealing with its net zero pledge, Apple needs to be more open about its environmental
initiatives. Emissions, energy consumption, and advancements made toward
sustainable objectives should all be regularly and completely reported. Verifications
and audits by third parties should also be remembered for these reports (Pastrana et
al., 2022). For instance, disclosing the carbon footprint associated with every class of
item could make it easier for stakeholders to follow Apple's turn of events. This level
of openness will support stakeholder confidence and corporate accountability by
ensuring that Apple's actions are consistent with its stated promises.

2. Strengthen Supply Chain Oversight: To ensure that ethical and environmental

norms are consistently maintained, Apple should upgrade its monitoring of its supply
chain, especially in nations with careless rules. The whole supply chain can be pushed
toward greener practices by ordering stronger compliance audits and more stringent
requirements for supplier operations. All apple wants its suppliers to use 100 percent
renewable energy by 2025; investments and technology sharing will be essential to
implementing and facilitating this transformation (ESG News, 2023).

3. Commit to Data Privacy Globally: Keeping up with strict standards for user privacy
and data security across all markets is necessary to address privacy issues. By
carrying out the same data protection policies all over the place, Apple might bolster
its position on privacy autonomous of local government regulations or pressure
(Cooke, 2020). By keeping privacy rules consistent, moral conundrums can be stayed
away from and user confidence can be increased. Apple may, for instance, decline to
store user data in nations where local laws don't ensure privacy.

4. Engage Stakeholders Regularly: Incessant connection with stakeholders, including

as clients, environmental organizations, and government agencies, can yield various
viewpoints and comments on Apple's tactics. Apple may, for instance, organize yearly
forums with environmental specialists to analyze its sustainability procedures and
adjust its plans in response to guidance from the experts (Pastrana et al., 2022).
Similarly, Apple may all the more successfully adjust its policies to consumer
expectations by using customer feedback forums specifically focused on privacy
concerns.
References

Ahmed, B., (2023) Apple: Global Ethics and Transformational Leadership. Journal of Global
Awareness, 4(2), pp.1-12.

Al-Saqri, Z.T.A.H. and Vida, V., (2023) Motivation among employees in multinational
corporations. Applied Studies in Agribusiness and Commerce, 17(1).

Amin, M.R. and Munsi, M., (2020) Motivational Techniques for Business Organization–A
Case Study of Apple Inc.

Apple (2023 c) Consolidated Financial Statements. [Online] Available at:

https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/fy2023-q3/FY23_Q3_Consolidated_Financial_State
ments.pdf [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Apple, (2024 A) Leadership and Governance. [Online] Available at:

https://investor.apple.com/leadership-and-governance/default.aspx#:~:text=Apple's%20Board
%20of%20Directors%20oversees,of%20shareholders%20are%20being%20served.
[Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Apple, (2024 B) Compensation Committee Charter [Online] Available at:

https://s2.q4cdn.com/470004039/files/doc_downloads/2020/20200819-Compensation-
Committee-Charter.pdf [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Bajarin. T (2021) What Is Tim Cook's Greatest Contribution To Apple Since He Became
CEO?. [Online] Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/timbajarin/2021/12/15/what-is-
tim-cooks-greatest-contribution-to-apple-since-he-became-ceo/?sh=3b1284e62bdc [Accessed
on: 4 May 2024]

Baron. Z (2023) Tim Cook on shaping the future of Apple [Online] Available at:
https://www.gq-magazine.co.uk/culture/article/tim-cook-apple-interview-2023 [Accessed on:
4 May 2024]

Beheshti. N, (2018) Remembering Steve Jobs: A Visionary Leader Who Changed The World.
[Online] Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/nazbeheshti/2018/10/05/remembering-
steve-jobs-a-visionary-leader-who-changed-the-world/?sh=3130cce9ced7 [Accessed on: 4
May 2024]
Choudhary, N.A., Ramkumar, M., Schoenherr, T. and Rana, N.P., (2021) Assessing supply
chain resilience during the pandemic using network analysis. IEEE Transactions on
Engineering Management.

Cooke, T.N., (2020) Metadata, jailbreaking, and the cybernetic governmentality of ios: or, the
need to distinguish digital privacy from digital privacy. Surveillance & Society, 18(1), pp.90-
103.

Coulter M, Chee. Y. F and Mukherjee. S (2024) Exclusive: Apple faces 'strong action' if App
Store changes fall short, EU's Breton says [Online] Available at:
https://www.reuters.com/technology/apple-faces-strong-action-if-app-store-changes-fall-
short-eus-breton-says-2024-01-26/ [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Culpan. T, Fickling. D and He. E (2023) Apple’s Supply Chain Is on a Collision Course With
Climate Change [Online] Available at: https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2023-opinion-
apple-supply-chain-climate-change/ [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Echowook (2023) A Glimpse into the Future of Apple: Innovations and Expectations.
Medium [Online] Available at: https://medium.com/@thanulathanula24/a-glimpse-into-the-
future-of-apple-innovations-and-expectations-91529555e558 [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

El Khatib, M., Al Shehhi, H. and Al Nuaimi, M., (2023) How Big Data and Big Data
Analytics Mediate Organizational Risk Management. Journal of Financial Risk
Management, 12(1), pp.1-14.

ESG News (2023) Apple Advances Supplier Clean Energy Commitments [Online] Available
at: https://esgnews.com/apple-advances-supplier-clean-energy-commitments/ [Accessed on: 4
May 2024]

Gurman. M (2021) Apple Decentralizes From Silicon Valley, but Workers Just Want to Be
Remote Bloomberg [Online] Available at:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2021-07-04/apple-hq-is-no-longer-the-center-
of-the-company-s-universe-kqpi2879 [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Han. Y, Zhang. J and Dong. H (2023) The Successful Marketing Strategy of Apple [Online]
Available at:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/375551855_The_Successful_Marketing_Strategy_o
f_Apple [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]
Ian, (2024) Time Cook’s leadership style: Insights into Apple CEO Pressfarm. [Online]
Available at: https://press.farm/tim-cook-leadership-style-apples-ceo/#:~:text=Tim%20Cook
%20is%20known%20for,encouraging%20open%20communication%20and
%20collaboration. [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Johnson, L (2023) Apple makes strides towards reaching 2030 carbon neutrality goal in Q4
[Online] Available at: https://www.esgdive.com/news/apple-2030-product-supply-chain-
carbon-neutrality-progress-tim-cook-2023-q4/699002/ [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Kipkoech. A (2019) Apple company Risk management [Online] Available at:

https://www.academia.edu/39607461/Apple_company_Risk_management [Accessed on: 4
May 2024]

Leswing. K (2023) Apple stock dips after weak outlook for December quarter revenue
[Online] Available at: https://www.cnbc.com/2023/11/02/apple-aapl-earnings-report-q4-
2023.html [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Lewis, S., (2022) An Apple for teacher (education)? Reconstituting teacher professional
learning and expertise via the Apple Teacher digital platform. International Journal of
Educational Research, 115, p.102034.

Li, Y. and Qiao, H., (2023) September. Equality, Diversification, and Inclusion Problems in
Daily Management of Apple Organisation. In 2023 International Conference on Management
Innovation and Economy Development (MIED 2023) (pp. 619-624). Atlantis Press.

Mahmood. A (2023) CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND ETHICS A CASE STUDY OF

APPLE INC [Online] Available at:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/368629983_CORPORATE_GOVERNANCE_AND
_ETHICS_A_CASE_STUDY_OF_APPLE_INC [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

MARTINS. D (2023) Apple Invests More In Research And Development Today Than Eve
[Online] Available at: https://www.thestreet.com/apple/news/apple-invests-more-in-research-
and-development-today-than-ever [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

O'Brien. C, (2022) Meet Daisy, Apple’s recycling robot [Online] Available at:
https://www.irishtimes.com/technology/big-tech/2022/06/02/apples-recycling-robots-and-the-
race-for-net-zero/ [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]
O'Mahony. P (2024) Apple shares look pricey as growth slows [Online] Available at:
https://www.irishtimes.com/your-money/2024/02/13/apple-shares-look-pricey-as-growth-
slows/ [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Pastrana, F.J., Dargusch, P. and Hill, G., (2022) How is environmental sustainability a key to
innovation?. Advances in Environmental and Engineering Research, 3(2), p.016.

Peng, B., Zheng, C., Wei, G. and Elahi, E., (2020) The cultivation mechanism of green
technology innovation in manufacturing industry: From the perspective of ecological
niche. Journal of Cleaner Production, 252, p.119711.

Phelan. D (2018) Apple Promotes Powerful Privacy Tools For iPhone, iPad, Mac Users In
GDPR Response [Online] Available at:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidphelan/2018/05/26/apple-demonstrates-privacy-by-
design-to-benefit-iphone-ipad-and-mac-users-worldwide/?sh=572fa4d4739c [Accessed on: 4
May 2024]

Radić, M., (2021) Business strategy and management method on the example of
Samsung. International Journal of Contemporary Business and Entrepreneurship, 2(2),
pp.33-49.

Savov. V (2024) Apple Faces Worst iPhone Slump Since Covid as Rivals Rise Bloomberg
[Online] Available at: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-04-15/apple-s-iphone-
shipments-plunge-10-as-android-rivals-rise [Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Stier, B.G., (2023) Applying Steve Jobs's Insights on Innovation, Leadership, and Technology
Toward an Apple-Inspired Law School. Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics and Public
Policy, Forthcoming (non-final version).

Stolton. S and Bodoni. S (2024) Apple on track to collide with EU as new Digital Markets
Act kicks in [Online] Available at: https://www.business-standard.com/world-news/apple-on-
track-to-collide-with-eu-as-new-digital-markets-act-kicks-in-124030501043_1.html
[Accessed on: 4 May 2024]

Taylor, M., (2023) EU endeavors to secure and strengthen its supply chain.

Zhong, B., Wang, X. and Yang, F., (2021) More than an apple: better lunch enhances bus
drivers’ work performance and well-being. International Journal of Occupational Safety and
Ergonomics, 27(3), pp.874-883.