Scoring Computation
Uploaded by
PraveenaScoring Computation
Uploaded by
PraveenaComparative Analysis:
Criteria
Experience
Project Scope Fit
Technical Expertise
Local Presence
Track Record with Major
Clients
International
Partnerships
Financial Strength
Compliance and
Certification
Lee Engineering (Nigeria)
32 years of experience in Nigeria’s Oil &
Gas and Power industries. Mostly small to
medium-scale projects.
Familiar with oil & gas operations but lacks
direct experience with large-scale O&M
services, specifically in refineries.
Experience in oil & gas processes, but
minimal involvement in Fluid Catalytic
Cracking and large-scale Conversion units.
Indigenous company with a strong local
presence and knowledge of Nigerian
regulatory landscape.
Clients include NPDC and SPDC, but no
major projects in the refinery O&M domain.
Established some international
partnerships, though limited in scope
compared to global O&M leaders.
Moderate financial capacity, but no
indication of handling multi-billion-dollar
projects.
Local expertise may aid in easier
compliance with Nigerian regulations, but
certifications for global standards may be
limited.
PCCS (China)
25+ years of international and local
experience, including large-scale O&M
projects.
Proven track record in O&M services for
major refinery projects, including post-
commissioning and turnaround operations.
Strong expertise in Fluid Catalytic Cracking
and Conversion units, with experience in
commissioning and start-up operations.
Foreign firm with a local subsidiary (PCCN)
that has an established presence in Nigeria.
Extensive experience with high-profile
international projects, including Edo Refinery
and Petrochemical Co., AIPCC Energy Co.,
Green Energy E&P Co., and First Modular
Gas Service Co.
Strong international network and
partnerships, with a history of successful
joint ventures in refinery O&M.
High financial capacity, with an annual
turnover exceeding $2 billion, making them
a financially stable partner.
Complies with international standards and
certifications, well-suited for global-scale
refinery O&M projects.
Scoring Computation
Criteria Weight
Experience 20%
Project Scope Fit 25%
Technical Expertise 20%
Local Presence 10%
Track Record with Major Clients 10%
International Partnerships 5%
Financial Strength 5%
Compliance and Certification 5%
TOTAL
Lee Engineering PCCS
LEE PCCS (China)
(Nigeria) Score (1- Weighted
Weighted Score Score (1-10)
10) Score
6 1.2 9 1.8
5 1.25 9 2.25
5 1 10 2
9 0.9 7 0.7
6 0.6 9 0.9
5 0.25 10 0.5
5 0.25 10 0.5
6 0.3 9 0.45
5.75 9.1