Transport
Plan
               Plan  de     Systems
                     de Formación
                        Formación (40h)
                                   (40h)
                 Lecture 2. Trajectories
                                 Learning
• Learning goals: Competences to estimate, describe and characterize how
  vehicles, people and goods overcome distance; competence to infer kinematic
  variables of one or multiple vehicles from a space-time diagram; to plan
  transport services in linear infrastructures to maximize the service efficiency or
  to guarantee safety conditions; competence to rebuild traffic crashes.
• Previous knowledge: Time and space means of a solid (Continuum
  mechanics), vehicular flow and density concepts in roadways (Roadways and
  Railways)
• Exercises and cases: Shared trips among different travellers,
  acceleration lanes, percentage of heavy vehicles based on aerial photography,
  design of sidetracks in single-track railways, management of airport runways,
  linear infrastructure capacity.
                                                                                           1
               Trajectories (s-t) + queues (N-t)
Transport operations:
  • Trajectories (in motion –
    overcome the distance)
       – Speed, acceleration, etc.
                                       s
  • Queues (waiting – overcome
    the time)
       ̶   Waiting time, maximum
           queue and average, etc.
  • Dual analysis of motion
   N
                      Q
                                                                           t
                                t                                              3
                              Definition
 • Determination of the position of a vehicle (x) in relation to a
   reference point during the time (t).
 • Geometrical place of the vehicle position (space) respect to
   the time: function x(t). Graphic representation of x(t) in the
   plane (t, x) is a curve named trajectory.
 • Applications:
    – Minimum travel time between stations in a railway line for a
      maximum speed.
    – Determine the initial speed of a car from the braking marks on its
      tires.
    – Length of runways and location of exits.
    – Length of acceleration / deceleration lanes.
    – Etc.
                                                                                   2
                                                  Diagrams s-t
    x
                                                                  TRAJECTORY
                                                                    Instantaneous speed
                                                                       v(t) = dx(t)/dt
            1
                                                                    Instantaneous acceleration
            2                                                          a(t) = dv(t)/dt = d2x(t)/dt2
            3
                                 *                           t
         (*) does not represent a real physical trajectory
In case uniform motion, v(t) = v(constant) and a(t) = 0(constant):
In case uniformly accelerated motion, a(t) = a(constant):
                                     Interpretation of trajectories (1/2)
s       t                                  Acceleration
                                           (recovering
    Deceleration                           speed)
    (intersection,
    pedestrian
    crossing, bump)
        Free
        speed
                                                                 Vehicle running at a
                                                                 lower speed and with
                                                                 a longer spacing than
                                                                 the previous vehicles
                                                                                                      3
                    Interpretation of trajectories (2/2)
¿If we record a video
in a section of a road,
what do we see?
                 Construction of Trajectories
A) by recording times of vehicle passing through fixed sections (elevators,
pedestrians, automobiles, etc.).
B) by photographs in sequenced areas in time or by time ranges in systems
operated by scheduled in a circuit (buses with navigation systems).
C) by recording of the overtaking time of vehicles to an observer in motion at a
constant speed.
D) by continuous “tracking” with GPS (in vehicles such as cars, trucks, urban
buses via SAE or private smart phones) or bluetooth (roads).
                                                                                       4
Diagrams (s,t) in traffic
                    Real trajectories in
                        a highway
Traffic jams in highways
                                           10
                                                5
                             Comparison of PT modes
                                                                       11
                                  Bus bunching
                             TRAJECTORIES D'AUTOBUSOS
               4500,00                                         bus 1
               4000,00                                         bus 2
               3500,00                                         bus 3
TEMPS (seg.)
               3000,00                                         bus 4
               2500,00                                         bus 5
               2000,00                                         bus 6
               1500,00                                         bus 7
               1000,00                                         bus 8
                500,00                                         bus 9
                  0,00                                         bus 10
                         0    2    4      6      8   10   12   bus 11
                                       PARADES                 bus 12
                                                                       12
                                                                            6
                          Bus bunching
                                AUTOBUSES PAREADOS
               2000
               1800
               1600
               1400
               1200
Tiem po (s )
               1000
               800
               600
               400
               200
                 0
                      0   5    10                    15   20   25
                                         Paradas
                                                                    13
                          Bus bunching
                                AUTOBUSES PAREADOS
               2000
               1800
               1600
               1400
               1200
Tiem po (s )
               1000
               800
               600
               400
               200
                 0
                      0   5    10                    15   20   25
                                         Paradas
                                                                    14
                                                                         7
                          Bus bunching
                                AUTOBUSES PAREADOS
               2000
               1800
               1600
               1400
               1200
Tiem po (s )
               1000
               800
               600
               400
               200
                 0
                      0   5    10                    15   20   25
                                         Paradas
                                                                    15
                          Bus bunching
                                AUTOBUSES PAREADOS
               2000
               1800
               1600
               1400
               1200
Tiem po (s )
               1000
               800
               600
               400
               200
                 0
                      0   5    10                    15   20   25
                                         Paradas
                                                                    16
                                                                         8
                          Bus bunching
                                AUTOBUSES PAREADOS
               2000
               1800
               1600
               1400
               1200
Tiem po (s )
               1000
               800
               600
               400
               200
                 0
                      0   5    10                    15   20   25
                                         Paradas
                                                                    17
                          Bus bunching
                                AUTOBUSES PAREADOS
               2000
               1800
               1600
               1400
               1200
Tiem po (s )
               1000
               800
               600
               400
               200
                 0
                      0   5    10                    15   20   25
                                         Paradas
                                                                    18
                                                                         9
                                                                Bus bunching
                                                                                     AUTOBUSES PAREADOS
                                      2000
                                      1800
                                      1600
                                      1400
                                      1200
                       Tiem po (s )
                                      1000
                                       800
                                       600
                                       400
                                       200
                                            0
                                                0               5                   10                          15                   20              25
                                                                                                Paradas
                                                                                                                                                          19
                                                          Trajectories PV and PT
                                                                            Trajectòries
          4.000
          3.800
          3.600
          3.400
                                                                                TRAJECTORIES                                                     B
                      TRAJECTORY PV                                               OF BUSES
          3.200
                                                                                                                                                 H
          3.000
          2.800
                                                                                                                                                 A
          2.600                                                                                                                                  E
          2.400
                                                                                                                                                 G
Posició
          2.200
          2.000                                                                                                                                  C
          1.800                                                                                                                                  I
          1.600
                                                                                                                                                 H2
          1.400
          1.200                                                                                                                                  A2
          1.000
                                                                                                                                                 J
           800
           600
                                                                                                                                                 B2
           400
           200
             0
                  0                   100           200   300   400   500     600         700             800    900   1000   1100        1200
                                                                            Temps
                                                                                                                                                          20
                                                                                                                                                               10
           Trajectories PV and PT
                      TRAJECTORIES
TRAJECTORY PV           OF BUSES
                                        21
    Micro and Macro traffic variables
                   Micro: h, headway
                   Macro: q, flow
                               i=1
                   Micro: s, spacing
                   Macro: k, density
                               j=1
                                        22
                                             11
                         Time and Space means
                                                 Time-mean speed
                                                         vi : instantaneous speed at a
                                                         specific location during a time T
                                                 Space-mean speed
                                                           vj : instantaneous speed at a
                                                           specific time along a length L
One stationary observer sees two fast vehicles
per one slow vehicle, but a picture shows two
     slow vehicles and one fast vehicle!!
     Wardrop relationship
                                                                                        23
            Average speed of a group of vehicles
  Example 1. Three family of vehicles crossing a highway section with
  the same flow and speeds v1 = 30 km/h, v2 = 60 km/h and v3 = 60
  km/h.
  Example 2. Circular highway of length 2 km with 3 vehicles running
  at speeds 100, 120 and 140 km/h respectively.
  Generalization for the calculation of speed means:
                                                                                        24
                                                                                             12
                      Fundamental Traffic Equation
x
                                                Stationary:
                                                - Constant speed
                                                - Constant headway
L                          n, # vehicles        - Constant spacing
                                                     Identical values of variables at any point of
                                                     the diagram (x,t)
                               t
            T
Stationary traffic:
                                               Fundamental equation:
                                                                                                     25
                      Group of vehicles
                                    2 families of vehicles
                                    Ex: Highway with one lane for light vehicles and one lane
                                    for heavy vheicles
                                    Assumption: Uniform headway and constant spacing
                                    between vehicles of the same family (stationary traffic)
                                           hl vl  sl l  1,2
                                                                             Additive magnitudes
                                         ql  kl vl l  1,2
                                           q   ql ;          k   kl l  1,2
                                                 l                   l
    Fundamental Traffic Equation:          q  k  vl (kl /k )  vs k l  1,2
                                                      l
                                                          ql kl
                                                               l  1,2
                                                          q k
                                                                                                     26
                                                                                                          13
                                        Railway station capacity
• Capacity of railway stations with high frequency:
                                                                                       ht  t g  t s  t a  t d
                                                                                                                          1
                                                                                                           C
                                                                                                                          ht
                                                                                                  Maximum time admitted between
                                                                                            tg    front and back between two
                                                                                                  consecutive trains
                                                                                            ts        Time of getting on / off
                                                                                                      passengers
                                                                                       ta td          Times of acceleration and
                                                                                                      deceleration
                                                                                                                                                  27
                                            Train line capacity (1)
  Critical factors:                            - Line length
                                               - Running speed
                                               - Number and location of sidetracks
                                               - Maintenance time
                                               - Modelo de explotación adoptado
                               Mantenimiento
 Figueres
                     120
                     110
                     100
                     90
                     80
     Recorrido, km
                                                                                                                                    Apartaderos
                     70
                     60
                     50
                     40
                     30
                     20
                     10
   Mollet              0
                           4    5   6   7      8   9   10   11     12   13   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   23   24
                                                                 Horario, horas                                                                   28
                                                                                                                                                       14
                                   Train line capacity (2)
                                    Figueres
- L= 122km,
  v=80 km/h,
                                                                       4 trenes
                                          Recorrido
  Hmin=9min                                                          consecutivos
                                         Mollet
                                                           Horario
•Figueres
    •Recorrido
                                              14 trenes
                                            consecutivos
 Mollet
                              •Horario                                              29
                             Airport runway capacity (1)
                         6-10 nm
                 50 nm
                                                                                    30
                                                                                         15
                         Airport runway capacity (2)
     Type of       Max. take-off                  Num. of        Approaching                        Classification
     aircraft   weight, MTOW (kgs)                engines        speed (Kts)                     according to capacity
        A                                         Mono
                      <7000                                         100                               Light (L)
        B                                         Multi
        C         7000-136000                     Multi             120                              Medium (M)
        D           >136000                       Multi             140                               Heavy (P)
                                                                                                                             31
                         Airport runway capacity (3)
1.      Minimum distance between two consecutive take-offs:
                 SPAIN                                                                                  USA
                                                                                                 Aircraft follower
T>1 min if routes diverge more than 45º
                                                                               Aircraft leader
T>2 min if routes are parallel but vi –v i+1>70 kt                                                      L      M         P
                                                                                                 L     90s    60s    60s
T>3 min other cases
                                                                                                 M    120s    60s    60s
                                                                                                 P    120s    60s    60s
2.      Minimum separation between two consecutive landings:
                                                            USA
                                                       Aircraft follower
                                Aircraft leader
                                                            L       M          P
                                                  L       102s     77s     77s
                                                  M       150s     90s     90s
                                                  P       210s     144s    108s
                                                                                                                             32
                                                                                                                                  16
                              Airport runway capacity (4)
3. Minimum distance between take-off and landing:
     • Standard occupancy time of a runway with fast exit is 1 min (50 sec)
     • For a take-off preceding a landing: Dda=2 nm
                                                                                                   33
                              Airport runway capacity (5)
4.       Development of analytic solutions:
     –       Case i: vi≤vj
                                                               
                                                       tij 
                                                               vj
     –       Case ii: vi≥vj
                                                        1 1
                                         tij           
                                                 vj     v v 
                                                         j i 
     – CAPACITY
             1
                             PIJ   Fraction of events that an aircraft of characteristics j is
            PIJ TIJ                 preceded by other of characteristics i
            I ,J              TIJ    Time between events characterized for the succession ij
                                                                                                   34
                                                                                                        17
Connection btw trajectories and cumulative diagrams
                                                      35
                                                           18