2ndedition 26 34
2ndedition 26 34
net/publication/383212917
CITATIONS READS
0 422
3 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mercy Ehidiamen Ikponmwosa on 18 August 2024.
1
Mercy Ehidiamen Ikponmwosa, 2Prof. Stephen. M. Omodia & 3Harriet Omokiniovo Efanodor-
Obeten, Ph.D.
1, 2 & 3
Department of Political Science and Public Administration, Edo State University Uzairue
Edo State, Nigeria.
KEYWORDS ABSTRACT
political The study examines the use of quantitative method in political science research and probes into the extent to which
science; researchers apply quantitative methods in political science research. It also identifies the possible factors limiting the use
positivism; of quantitative method in political science research. The study adopts descriptive quantitative research design using
quantitative; primary and secondary sources of data. It applies content analysis technique, using a self-constructed checklist containing
qualitative different aspects and attributes of quantitative research was adopted for data collection. Analysis of the data was carried
method; out using percentage analysis, graphs and charts from articles on SCOPUS database, with the aid of the Statistical
research Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) 27.0 software. The study finds that the usage of quantitative method in political
science research is low across the articles examined. The study recommends collaboration and a multidisciplinary focused
research, so as to incorporate varieties of methodologies in political science research.
18
EDSU Journal of Politics and Administrative Studies (EJPAS) | Volume 1 Issue 2 | ISSN: 1597-8850 | July, 2024
Quantitative research is not new in the field of political science as web scraping. The qualitative papers are frequently so big that they
researchers like Young and Soroka (2012); Cassese et al. (2014) can no longer be termed qualitative data and need advanced
have applied quantitative method in investigating various political quantitative analysis methods like topic modeling or machine
inquiries. Some have resorted to combining the quantitative and learning. In a similar vein, surveys are frequently seen as a
qualitative methods (Wesley, et al., 2020). Although researchers like quantitative research methodology. Interviews and surveys are
Creswell and Plano Clark (2007); and Tzagkaraki and Kritas (2023), comparable, but surveys are typically more structured and used on a
a suitable blend of quantitative and qualitative methodologies bigger sample (Wesley et al., 2020). Qualitative data from surveys
contributes to a deeper comprehension of study issues. Despite the are usually converted to quantitative data through coding, which
usage of the quantitative research approach, it is unclear to what involves assigning numerical values to qualitative responses. Data
extent it is used in political science research because there is a dearth obtained from web scrapping and surveys are usually expressed in
of empirical data to support this claim. The study therefore charts and graphs and/or analysed statistically to produce a summary
investigates the depth of usage of quantitative method in political (descriptive statistics), deduce relationships (correlation) or make
science research among academics and researchers. inferences (regression).
Specifically, it: Johnson and Christensen (2012) list the following characteristics of
quantitative research: "the confirmatory stage of the study cycle is
probes into the extent to which researchers apply quantitative stressed; Behavior is seen to be consistent and predictable; Instead
methods in political science research; and of focusing on particular groups in particular settings, the researcher
is interested in discovering general laws that apply to entire
identifies the possible factors limiting the use of quantitative method
populations; To isolate the effects of individual variables, behavior
in political science research.
is being studied under controlled circumstances; It is use an
The scope of the study covers articles in political science published objective strategy, which calls for a range of observers to be able to
in Journals indexed in the Scopus data base during the period 2018 agree on what is being seen; Data are based on precise measurement
to 2023, to capture the recency and the state of research in political using organized and approved data collection equipment. Data
science discipline. One of the biggest databases of top-notch analysis attempts to look at statistical linkages.
research publications is Scopus. Compared to other
multidisciplinary databases, Scopus contains twice as many titles Empirical Studies
and over 50% more publishers listed, in addition to a large number In their 2018 paper, Pellicer and Wegner argued in favor of using
of peer-reviewed journals. Scopus is regarded as one of the biggest quantitative methods to investigate the Middle East and North
multidisciplinary databases of specialized scientific publications as Africa. They acknowledge the challenges in gathering high-quality
a result. and trustworthy data, but they use instances of recent
methodological advancements to explain how these challenges
Review of Literature might be lessened. They also emphasize the need for in-depth
qualitative expertise to interpret raw data because quantitative
The quantitative approach to study gathers numerical data; data
methods by themselves cannot adequately capture the political and
analysis is generally statistical in nature in order to explain, forecast,
social complexity of the area.
and/or regulate phenomena of interest. Quantitative research is
conducted "by numbers," as has been rightly stated (Sodaro, 2008). Using information from 67,000 papers that were published in 100
The term "quantitative" refers to the generation of quantitative data high-impact journals between 2000 and 2019 and other sources,
that may be subjected to rigorous quantitative analysis in a formal Carammia (2022) conducted a bibliometric analysis of the academic
and structured manner. (Peter, 2018). The quantitative research output of European political science communities in relation to other
method primarily examines social phenomena that may fluctuate in scholarly communities around the world. The bulk of scientists who
quantifiable levels or amounts. (Sodaro, 2008). contribute to the global scientific output, according to studies, are
concentrated in just a few countries, with the US and UK alone
The field of information sought, the researcher's orientation,
contributing more than half of the articles that are published in high-
interest, background, and other factors, among others, determine the
impact journals. However, there is a trend toward more regional
choice of an approach to political and social inquiry, claims Peter
variety in the base of the global scientific production, with European
(2018). Many political scientists feel uncomfortable using the
nations playing a key role in this transition. The enhanced scientific
quantitative technique to conduct research despite its accuracy and
output of academics based in Europe has been significantly boosted
empirical emphasis. They believe it to be riskier because of the
by their contributions to worldwide joint publications. This was a
political scientist's worries about these concerns. Many more people
widespread global trend that was particularly stunning for several
are uncomfortable with numbers, which accounts for their
national intellectual communities. Three clusters have consolidated
preference for the qualitative approach to conducting political
within an expanding and denser network, according to the network
science research.
analysis of international cooperation. The US is at the center of a
Apart from the use of financial data, statistical data and numeric global cluster of collaborations, followed by the UK. A larger,
demographic data, the web scrapping and survey techniques are also increasing cluster and a smaller, even more integrated, highly
useful quantitative approaches. Setting up a computer script to productive, and connected cluster of academics based on seven
download a collection of documents from the internet is known as northern European states make up the bulk of the countries in
19
EDSU Journal of Politics and Administrative Studies (EJPAS) | Volume 1 Issue 2 | ISSN: 1597-8850 | July, 2024
Europe. All bibliometric indexes consistently point to a broad technique, which is often more concerned with articulating
growth in output and a globalization of the scholarly contribution experiences, stressing significance, and investigating the substance
offered by the European political science community. of an issue (Coolican, 2013). According to Kumar (2014), the
quantitative methodological approach is a structured method in
Arel-Bundock et al (2022) assessed the influence of political science which all components of the research process are decided before
research by gathering more than 16,000 hypothesis tests from data collection begins.
around 2,000 papers. According to their generous assumptions, the
median analysis has about 10% power, and only about 1 in 10 tests
METHOD
have at least 80% power to identify the consensus effects asserted in
the literature. The study also shows that there is a big difference in The study adopts descriptive quantitative research design using
the power of tests across research domains, with some having high primary and secondary sources of data. The population of the study
power but others having relatively low power. To analyze the results, consist of open access Journals and conference proceedings (2018-
the study polled political methodologists about how they view 2023) for subject area political science, as obtained in scopus data
power systems. The bulk of methodologists, they conclude, vastly base as at 20th March, 2023. The total population is 6,421 articles
overstate the statistical significance of political science research. from 90 Journals in political science and International relations as
found in SCOPUS database.
From the above, there are limited studies in recent times that carried Using the Taro Yamani formulae for sample size determination, a
out a bibliometric or content analysis of political science research sample size of 377 was derived using 0.05 degree of error expected
using a globally recognized and renowned data base like Scopus. (Yamani, 1967). The articles were selected using stratified random
sampling techniques from the Scopus data base, ensuring that a
maximum of 5 and a minimum of 4 articles were randomly picked
Theoretical Framework
from each of the 90 journals, to arrive at the sample of 377 while
This study is based on the positivism theory. The paradigm that gave ensuring that all of the 90 journals are adequately captured and
rise to positivism was physical science. It carries out research equitably represented. Using content analysis, a self-constructed
methodically and scientifically. Hughes (2010) asserts that the checklist containing different aspects and attributes of quantitative
positivist paradigm claims that through understanding these research formed the basis for appraising the sampled articles.
constant, universal laws, everything that occurs in our world can be
understood. It is vital to systematically watch and record the events Analyses of the data obtained via content analysis was carried out
and phenomena that take place around us in order to understand using percentage analysis, graphs and charts, using the Statistical
these universal laws. The next step is to identify the fundamental Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) 27.0 software.
idea that "caused" the event to occur. The tale of Sir Isaac Newton
and the apple serves as an illustration of this procedure in action.
DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS
Isaac Newton allegedly witnessed an apple fall directly to the
ground when he was strolling through an apple orchard. He began This section involves the presentation of data using pie chart and
to formulate his theory of gravity as he began to ponder how high histogram as well as percentage analysis presented in tables. This is
above the Earth the force of gravity was effective. In this illustration, followed by an analysis of data extracted via content analysis.
the observable event was an apple falling, and gravity represented
the underlying universal law (Keesing, 2008).
20
EDSU Journal of Politics and Administrative Studies (EJPAS) | Volume 1 Issue 2 | ISSN: 1597-8850 | July, 2024
Figure 1: Distribution of Articles by Year of Publication
EDSU Journal of Politics and Administrative Studies (EJPAS) | Volume 1 Issue 2 | ISSN: 1597-8850 | July, 2024
Figure 2 depicts the distribution of sampled articles by the region of In carrying out content analysis of sampled articles, we investigated
researchers (corresponding authors). It reveals an even distribution the presence or otherwise of selected elements of quantitative
of articles across various regions of the world, with Europe, North methods. These elements are descriptive statistics, analysis using
America and Asia having the highest number of articles in the interview, graphs and charts, applied coding for questionnaires,
sample. Article of Africa extraction was also well represented, ahead inferential statistics, analyses of secondary data and hypotheses
of South America and Asia. testing. The results are presented in tables as follows.
22
EDSU Journal of Politics and Administrative Studies (EJPAS) | Volume 1 Issue 2 | ISSN: 1597-8850 | July, 2024
As shown in table 4, only less than 4 percent of sampled articles coding. By implication, analyzing questionnaires quantitatively is
converted qualitative attributes to quantitative properties through still poorly practiced in political science research.
23
EDSU Journal of Politics and Administrative Studies (EJPAS) | Volume 1 Issue 2 | ISSN: 1597-8850 | July, 2024
What are the possible factors limiting the use of The usage of quantitative method in political science research is low,
quantitative method in political science research? across the quantitative properties examined.
Conducting quantitative research is a challenging topic in political Although articles come from many nations, they all share the same
science due to a number of difficulties. Some of these problems worries about heavily relying on qualitative methods and
include: methodologies. implying that no unique variation based on location
was found by the study.
Many political scientists lack rudimentary understanding of
quantitative research. This represents a significant obstacle to its
potential use in conducting political science research. Modern Recommendations
political scientists, who are more accustomed to qualitative research From the findings made, the study makes the following
methods, won't be able to teach quantitative knowledge to pupils. recommendations.
The conclusion of this is that the qualitative method will continue to
dominate political science research forever (Peter, 2018). 1. The study recommends better collaboration and
multidisciplinary focused researches, so as to
The research's conclusions could also be invalidated by potential incorporate non-traditional methodologies in political
data fabrication and/or omission. This is related to how honest and science research.
ethical the individuals managing the data were. The people who
collect, analyze, and interpret data are extremely capable of 2. Researchers should be dynamic, to vary research choices
falsifying the truth occasionally, despite the widespread belief that so as to bring new methodologies to bear.
numbers do not lie (Osorio, 2014). The natural conclusion is that if
these individuals are required to employ quantitative techniques, 3. Institutionally, journal editors, peer reviewers, and
they may need to enlist the assistance of statisticians and computer promotion committees should do more to incentivize
scientists. Interpretation and generalization will undoubtedly be researchers to conduct quantitative based research and
dubious since the outside aid providers are not familiar with political subject theories, hypotheses or assertions to testing.
reality. There are numerous opportunities for human error to
4. Future studies could expand the sample size of this study
influence a quantitative method from conception to execution.
to improve on generalization. Similarly, other databases
The challenges of selecting the right quantitative or statistical tool(s) outside Scopus could be explored.
to use are another challenge. Only instances of mono-causality,
which are uncommon in the social sciences, can be handled using Conclusion
quantitative methods. In the field of political science, it is frequently
The investigation of Scopus indexed Open Access papers shows a
challenging to attribute a given action or behavior to a single source.
diversity of approaches, however, a significant portion of sampled
When dealing with multi-causality problems, this research
articles were based on qualitative method and techniques. Despite
methodology frequently falls short (Babbie, 2010). The use of
coming from different nations, the articles' themes are the same.
instruments by researchers to gather and analyze numerical data,
However, the study found no particular geographic variance, which
such as surveys, computer software, or statistical packages, presents
brings us to the conclusion that political science approaches should
a barrier to many political scientists who likely have little to no
be examined from a global viewpoint rather than a country-based
experience with those techniques.
one.
The process of operationalization involves turning variables into
Searching for institutional, methodological, and theoretical
quantifiable components. It is necessary for the execution of all
solutions should be motivated by the issue of the limited use of
scientific research. The data source is directed by an operationalized
quantitative research methods in political science. The institution
idea. It has to deal with the ideas in the empirical indicators of the
should do more to encourage scholars to do quantitative based
phenomenon under examination. The underlying thesis is that
research and put ideas, hypotheses, or statements to the test. This
quantitative research techniques have limited ability to probe
includes encouraging journal editors, peer reviewers, and promotion
solutions. It becomes difficult to define concepts effectively because
committees. By utilizing cutting-edge methodologies, study
everything is reduced to statistics and numbers (Peter, 2018)
designs, and measurement approaches, researchers should aim to
boost their quantitativeness. The study should be interpreted with
Findings caution as some aspects of quantitative method may have been
The investigation of Scopus indexed Open Access papers shows a omitted from the content analysis conducted. Also, Scopus indexed
diversity of approaches, however, a significant portion of sampled articles that are not open accessed were excluded from the study.
articles were based on qualitative method and techniques. Similarly, the study did not capture published articles outside the
Scopus database.
24
EDSU Journal of Politics and Administrative Studies (EJPAS) | Volume 1 Issue 2 | ISSN: 1597-8850 | July, 2024
REFERENCES Hammersley, M. (2014). MRes programme: Module A core reading:
An Introduction to Social
Arel-Bundock,V., Briggs, R.C., Doucouliagos, H., Mendoza A. M.,
& Stanley, T. D. (2022). Research. England: The Open University.
Quantitative Political Science Research is Greatly Underpowered. Hughes, P. (2010).‘Paradigms, Methods and knowledge’, in G.
I4R Discussion Paper Series, No. 6, Institute for Replication (I4R). MacNaughton, S. Rolfe and I. Siraj- Blatchford (eds), Doing Early
1-27. http://hdl.handle.net/10419/265531 Childhood Research: International Perspectives on Theory and
Practice, 2nd edition. Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Babbie, E. R. (2010). The practice of Social Research. Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth Cengage. 1-23. Johnson, B., & Christensen, L. (2012). Educational Research (4th
ed.). Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
Carammia, M. (2022). A bibliometric analysis of the
internationalization of political science in 34.
Europe. European Political Science 21 (1), 564–595. Kaplan, R. M., Chambers, D. A. & Glasgow, R. E. (2014). Big data
and large sample size: a
https://doi.org/10.1057/s41304-022-00367-9
cautionary note on the potential for bias. Clinical Translational
Cassese, E. C., Bos, A. L., & Schneider, M. C. (2014). Whose Science 7 (4), 342–346.
American government? A quantitative analysis of gender and
authorship in American politics texts. Journal of Political Science https://www.doi: 10.1111/cts.12178.
Education, 10 (3), 253-272.
Kumar, R. (2014) Research Methodology: A Step-by-Step Guide for
Ceswell, J.W., & Plano Clark, V.L. (2007). Designing and Beginners. 4th Edition, SAGE Publications Ltd., London
conducting mixed method research.
Marlow. C. (1998). Research Methods for Generalist Social Work.
Sage, Thousand Oaks Brooks/Cole publishing
Coolican, H. (2013). Research Methods and Statistics in Muijs, D. (2004). Doing quantitative research in education with
Psychology, 5th edition. Abingdon: Routledge. SPSS. London: Sage.
Farrant, B. M. & Zubrick, S. R. (2013). Parent–child book reading Mukherji, P. & Albon, D. (2014). Research Methods in Early
across early childhood and child vocabulary in the early school Childhood: An introductory guide
years: Findings from the longitudinal study of Australian children.
First Language 33 (3), 280-293. Los Angeles: Sage. Ch-01_Part 1.indd 9
Guba, E. G., & Lincoln, Y. S. (1994). Competing paradigms in Peter, A. M. (2018). Between the perils and the opportunities:
qualitative research. In N. K. exploring the strategies for overcoming the challenges of
quantitative technique in political science research. Endarch:
Denzin & Y.S. Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research Journal of Black Political Research 2. 1-18. Available at:
(pp.105-117). London: Sage. http://digitalcommons.auctr.edu/enda/vol2018/iss2/5
Hammersley, M. (2007). Educational research and evidence-based Sodaro, J. M. (2008). Comparative politics: A global introduction.
practice. London: Sage New York: McGraw-Hill. 60-80.
Publications.
Steinmetz, J. (nd.). Politics, Power, and Purpose: An Orientation to
Political Science. Kamsas-
25
EDSU Journal of Politics and Administrative Studies (EJPAS) | Volume 1 Issue 2 | ISSN: 1597-8850 | July, 2024
America: Fort Hays State University press. 218-225. Available at
https://fhsu.pressbooks.pub/orientatisonpolisci/chapter/chapter-10-
Wesley, W., Tracey, B., Hank, J. S., Joseph R. Gary, C., Matthew,
N., Tyler, H., Aaron, F. &
26
EDSU Journal of Politics and Administrative Studies (EJPAS) | Volume 1 Issue 2 | ISSN: 1597-8850 | July, 2024