Internation Relations
Internation Relations
INDIA
Q. What was the Indus Basin Treaty? 4)
Q2. Why did relations between India and Pakistan bad from 1947 to
1950? 7)
The canal water dispute began when India stopped the flow of water from
three eastern tributaries of the Indus River—Ravi, Sutlej, and Beas—since
their headworks were in Indian Punjab. This caused significant damage to
Pakistan’s agriculture, as the Indus plains are vital to the country's
economy.
The 1948 Kashmir war started when Indian forces entered Kashmir, taking
control of most of the region. Pakistan believed Kashmir belonged to it, and
along with local Kashmiris, it fought back. This conflict made Kashmir a
major point of tension between India and Pakistan.
Successes:
Failures:
Kargil Conflict:
In 1999, a war broke out between India and Pakistan over the Kargil
Heights in Kashmir. India and the international community accused
Pakistan of aggression, leading to calls for Pakistan’s forces to withdraw.
This event damaged relations between the two countries, especially after
the Lahore Declaration, where both sides had agreed to pursue peaceful
negotiations just months before.
Opinion:
In my view, relations between India and Pakistan have always been tense
because both countries struggle to resolve their main issues. Political
leaders in both countries often use these issues for political gain, which has
prevented meaningful peace efforts and kept relations hostile.
USA
Q1.Describe Anti-communist Pacts? 4)
Q2. Why did Pakistan join the USA as an Ally after independence? 7)
SUCCESS:
ANTI-COMMUNIST PACTS-1955
AFGHAN MIRACLE-1979
In 1979, the Soviet Union sent 80,000 tanks into Afghanistan to support a
pro-Soviet government. In response, the United States, through Pakistan,
intervened to help fight against the USSR. Pakistan played a key role as a
proxy for the U.S. in this conflict. The Soviet Union got stuck in a long and
costly war, leading to huge economic losses. Eventually, the USSR was
forced to sign a peace treaty in 1986, and this conflict contributed to the
disintegration of the Soviet Union in 1991. As a result, Pakistan’s relations
with the U.S. improved quickly, and Pakistan received economic aid.
Additionally, the U.S. helped train and develop Pakistan's military.
FAILURES:
INDO-CHINA WAR-1962
The Indo-China War of 1962 was fought over a boundary in the northern
region, particularly in Kashmir and Ladakh. During the war, India was
defeated by China. The United States provided unconditional military
support to India but did not consult Pakistan, which caused tension
between the two countries. As a result, Pakistan began to turn towards
China and the USSR for support, leading to growing mistrust between
Pakistan and the U.S. This shift in alliances marked a change in Pakistan's
foreign policy.
1965-71 WARS
The wars of 1965 and 1971 had a major impact on Pakistan. The 1965 war
was fought over Kashmir, and the 1971 war was a civil conflict within
Pakistan. During both wars, the United States imposed a weapons
embargo on both Pakistan and India, which left Pakistan struggling since it
had relied on U.S. support. Neither SEATO nor CENTO helped during
these times. As a result, Pakistan's relations with the U.S. became strained,
and in response, Pakistan decided to leave SEATO.
ZAB POLICIES
Zulfikar Ali Bhutto’s policies caused tension between Pakistan and the
United States. He dropped Pakistan's membership in SEATO and visited
the USSR, where he signed agreements, including one to build a steel mill
in Pakistan. Bhutto also implemented nationalization policies, taking control
of key industries, and started Pakistan's nuclear program. These actions
were seen by the U.S. as a potential threat, which led to strained relations
between the two countries.
NUCLEAR TESTS
AFGHANISTAN
Afghanistan was offered the chance to join the RCD (Regional Cooperation
for Development), an economic group formed by Iran, Turkey, and
Pakistan, but it refused because of Pakistan's membership. During the
1965 war between Pakistan and India, the Afghan government did not offer
official support to Pakistan, even though the public in Afghanistan
sympathized with Pakistan.
Success:
ACCOMODATION OF REFUGESS:
Pakistan faced a large influx of refugees, with around 3 million people
entering the country. These refugees lived in Pakistan for 30 to 40 years,
placing a huge burden on the country's economy. Despite the challenges,
Pakistan's role in accommodating these refugees was recognized and
appreciated internationally.
CHINA
Q. How successful were Pakistan's relations with China from 1949 to
1999? 14)
Failures:
TREATY WITH INDIA
One of the significant diplomatic setbacks was India's early recognition of
China and its role in bringing China to the United Nations. Additionally,
India signed a Treaty of Peace and Perpetual Friendship with China,
strengthening ties between the two nations. These moves were seen as
diplomatic failures for Pakistan, as they left Pakistan isolated in its regional
diplomacy.
Pakistan was member of Anti Communist block
The War of 1962, fought between India and China over their northern
boundary, presented an opportunity for Pakistan to improve its diplomatic
relations with China. Despite the United States supporting India against
China, Pakistan managed to settle its own border issue with China
amicably. As a result, China extended a $60 million interest-free loan to
Pakistan and pledged to support the country in any future war with India.
Additionally, Pakistan supported China's entry into the United Nations, and
Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) began flights to China, marking a new
chapter in bilateral relations.
1965 WAR
During the 1965 war between India and Pakistan, China provided military
aid to Pakistan and applied diplomatic pressure on India to ease the
conflict. However, when the 1971 war broke out, China was unable to offer
the same support due to the Soviet Union's involvement, which shifted the
balance of international alliances and limited China's capacity to intervene
on Pakistan's behalf.
In 1972, U.S. President Richard Nixon visited China for a six-day trip, with
Pakistan playing a key role in facilitating the visit. This diplomatic
breakthrough led to a significant improvement in relations between the
United States and China, while also undermining the influence of the Soviet
Union. Pakistan was seen as a key country in improving relations between
the U.S. and China.
During Zulfikar Ali Bhutto's visit to China, Pakistan's previous loans from
China were converted into grants. The two countries also agreed on the
supply of military aircraft and tanks. In 1978, the Karakoram Highway,
which had been under construction since 1966, was completed as the first
major road built between the two countries. Largely financed by China, the
project was led by Chinese engineers, and tragically, one construction
worker lost their life for every kilometer of road built. The highway replaced
the old Silk Route and became a vital link between Pakistan and China.
Zia ul-Haq chose China as the destination for his first state visit. During this
visit, he signed a nuclear cooperation treaty between the two countries. As
a result, Pakistan and China enjoyed excellent relations, strengthening their
diplomatic and strategic ties.
USSR
Q. How successful were Pakistan's relations with USSR from 1947 to
1999? 14)
Success
INDO CHINA WAR-1962
During the Indo-China War of 1962, the United States supported India,
which led Pakistan to turn towards China and the USSR in response. The
Soviet Union extended financial assistance to Pakistan by providing a loan
of £11 million and offered support for oil exploration. In 1964, Pakistani
President Ayub Khan visited the USSR, resulting in the establishment of an
oil refinery in Pakistan. The Soviet Union also provided military support to
Pakistan, marking the beginning of a period of strong bilateral relations
between the two countries.
TASHKANT TALKS-1966
In 1966, the Soviet Union invited both India and Pakistan to Tashkent to
engage in talks aimed at resolving their disputes. The result was the
signing of the Tashkent Declaration, which marked a significant effort by
the USSR to mediate peace between the two nations. This initiative not
only increased Soviet influence in South Asia but was also seen by
Pakistan as a positive gesture of goodwill from the USSR. The Soviet
Union played a crucial role in promoting peace in the region through these
talks.
ZAB VISITED USSR-1972
In 1972, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto visited Moscow, where an agreement was
reached to establish a steel mill in Pakistan. Additionally, the USSR began
supplying Pakistan with military aircraft and tanks, marking a positive step
towards stronger relations between the two countries. This development
introduced a new dimension to Pakistan's foreign policy, as it deepened its
ties with the Soviet Union.
Failures:
LIAQAT ALI KHAN VISITED USA-1950
Between 1947 and 1950, the United States showed little interest in
establishing ties with Pakistan. In 1950, the USSR extended an invitation to
Pakistan, but the United States quickly followed with its own invitation.
Pakistan chose to visit the United States, which resulted in a diplomatic
snub to the Soviet Union. This decision led to a deterioration in Pakistan's
relations with the USSR, which subsequently supported India on the
Kashmir issue.
USSR OFFICIALLY SUPPORTED INDIA OVER KASHMIR-1955
In 1955, Soviet leaders visited India and made a significant visit to Kashmir,
where they officially declared their support for Kashmir's integration into
India. Additionally, the USSR backed Afghanistan on the Pakhtoonistan
issue, aligning itself against Pakistan. This stance was largely in reaction to
Pakistan's decision to join anti-communist military pacts, which strained its
relations with the Soviet Union.
U2 INCIDENT
The U-2 incident occurred when a U.S. spy plane, flown from a military
airbase in Budhber, near Peshawar, Pakistan, was captured by the Soviet
Union while flying over its territory. Although Pakistan had provided military
airbases to the U.S., it denied any involvement in this mission. However,
the USSR did not accept Pakistan's denial and accused it of involvement in
the act. This incident led to a significant deterioration in relations between
Pakistan and the Soviet Union.
1971- PAKISTAN CIVIL WAR.
During the 1971 Pakistan Civil War, the USSR signed a Treaty of Peace,
Friendship, and Cooperation with India, solidifying their alliance. The Soviet
Union encouraged India to intervene in the conflict, which eventually led to
the division of Pakistan and the creation of Bangladesh. Additionally, the
USSR warned China against aiding Pakistan, threatening retaliation if it did.
This left Pakistan at a significant disadvantage, as it received no support
from either the United States or China during the conflict.
AFGHAN MIRACLE
BANGLADESH
Q. How successful were Pakistan's relations with Bangladesh from
1947 to 1999? 14)
Failures
BRITAIN
Q. How successful were Pakistan's relations with Britain and the
commonwealth from 1947 to 1999? 14)
Relations in 1980s
During the Afghan crisis, Britain showed strong support for Pakistan, with
Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher visiting the country. In contrast to its
neutral stance during the Bangladesh crisis, Britain provided significant aid
to Afghan refugees, offering £30 million, along with an additional £16
million for refugees in Baluchistan and NWFP. By 1986, trade between the
two countries had grown significantly, reaching an estimated value of £376
million.
ROLE IN COMMONWEALTH
SUCCESS WITH CW:
GOT ECONOMIC SUPPORT FROM CW
Pakistan received significant economic support from the Commonwealth
through various initiatives. Under the Colombo Plan in 1950, £1 million was
provided for the Sui Gas project in Pakistan. Additionally, Canada
contributed $40 million to help develop Pakistan's railway infrastructure.
These contributions through the Commonwealth platform played a key role
in improving Pakistan's infrastructure and supporting its economic
development.
IRAN
Q. How successful were Pakistan's relations with Iran from 1947 to
1999? 14)
Success
CENTO/ BAGHDAD PACT
In 1955, the Baghdad Pact was established by Turkey and Iraq, and later
Pakistan and Iran joined, with the UK also becoming a member. The pact
was renamed CENTO (Central Treaty Organization). Although the pact
didn't create a structure for raising permanent forces for mutual defense, it
helped bring Pakistan and Iran together as neighbors and allies of the USA.
As both countries were Muslim, it was natural for them to develop good
relations, which further strengthened their ties.
RCD
On July 21, 1964, Pakistan, Iran, and Turkey formed the Regional
Cooperation for Development (RCD) with Pakistan's efforts. The initiative
aimed to strengthen trade links and establish industrial projects, such as
mills and factories. Later, in 1985, Zia-ul-Haq transformed RCD into the
Economic Cooperation Organization (ECO). The partnership fostered
economic ties between the neighboring countries, with new railway and
road links connecting them. This helped bring the two Muslim countries
closer together.
1965 War
During the 1965 war, Iran asked other countries to help Pakistan, but that
support didn't materialize. However, Iran did assist Pakistan by fueling its
fighter jets during the conflict, showing its support for Pakistan in the war.
Balochistan Crisis
In 1973, during Zulfikar Ali Bhutto's era, law and order in Balochistan
became a major issue. Guns were exposed at the Iraqi embassy in
Islamabad, which led the government to launch a military operation in the
region. Iran stepped in to help control the situation by providing 50 Cobra
helicopters and $200 million in aid to support the Pakistani government’s
efforts.
Failures:
Islamic revolution in Iran
In 1979, the Shah of Iran was overthrown, and Pakistan was the first
country to recognize the new regime. However, there were reasons for
mistrust between the two countries. Pakistan had been a close ally of the
Shah, so the new government in Iran viewed Pakistan with suspicion.
Additionally, while Pakistan supported the USA during the Afghan conflict,
Iran’s new government was strongly anti-USA, which further strained
relations.
FAILURE OF UNO
(a) Why did Pakistan support the Palestinian cause between 1947 and
1999? [7]
Why was Benazir Bhutto dismissed from office a second time in 1996? [7]
(a)Why were there so many governments between 1951 and 1958? [7]
(a) Why did Pakistan distrust India so much between 1971 and 1988? [7]
(b) Why did being a nuclear power create difficulties for Pakistan in the
1980s and 1990s? [7]
(a)Why did many Pakistanis migrate between 1947 and 1999? [7]
(a)Why was India successful in the 1965 and 1971 wars against Pakistan?
[7]