Toyota Final
Toyota Final
Name
Course
Instructor
Date
2
Table of Contents
Introduction....................................................................................................................................................2
Opportunities and threats posed by social, economic, and institutional environment...................................3
PESTEL analysis.......................................................................................................................................4
Political factors......................................................................................................................................4
Economic...............................................................................................................................................4
Sociological............................................................................................................................................4
Ecological factors...................................................................................................................................5
Legal issues............................................................................................................................................5
Institutional theory.........................................................................................................................................5
Threats to Toyotas International Strategy in India.........................................................................................6
Institutional voids..........................................................................................................................................6
Toyota's Internationalization Strategy in India..............................................................................................7
Internationalization theory.............................................................................................................................7
Monopolistic advantage analysis...................................................................................................................8
Recommendations for emerging market......................................................................................................10
Conclusion...................................................................................................................................................11
References....................................................................................................................................................12
3
Introduction
Toyota is one of the most successful auto brands in the world. The company was founded
in 1937 by Kiichiro Toyoda and has grown steadily since its founding (Loyd, 2020). Today,
Toyota operates in 170 countries across the globe. The company's headquarters are in Toyota
City, Aichi, Japan (Qu & Wu, 2022). Toyota is the world's leading automaker based on the
company's sales. In 2022, the company sold 8.9 million units of cars and made sales worth
$276.57 billion. Toyota employs a total of 364,445 employees across the globe.
One of the dominant philosophies of the company is to make cars for all people. Through
this philosophy, Toyota focused on serving the middle-income and affluent class since they are
huge on making purchases (Loyd, 2020). Consequently, Toyota's growth has been driven by its
ability to serve the middle class and the affluent class type of customers. For the wealthy classes,
Toyota has focused on its famous brand of vehicles. The markets where Toyota has employed
these strategies are Brazil, China, and India. One of the problems Toyota has faced is its inability
to cater to the needs of local consumers. Many of Toyota's competitors deeply understand the
markets they serve. This challenge can be amplified because Toyota is lagging in electric
vehicles. Toyota was the first car manufacturer to start on the journey in electric vehicles (Yu et
al., 2011). Toyota built a hybrid car in 2002 that could use petrol and electric power. However,
Toyota never pursued the electric car ambitions further than this. Instead, Toyota settled on its
traditional car modeling method. In 2022, Toyota failed to feature among the world's top 5
electric car manufacturers, showing how far behind Toyota is in catching up with the
hybrid/electric car technology. This disadvantages the car brand since it is not the first mover in
electric cars.
Toyota must find new pathways to grow into the future (Hatani, 2009). One frontier for
growth should be found in the new and emerging markets (Uchil & Yazdanifard, 2014). In this
4
regard, this research analyzes Toyota's international strategy for India, given that India is one of
the emerging markets. In particular, the study seeks to understand Toyota's threats and
opportunities in the emerging market. Further, the research aims to determine what strategies
Toyota faces threats and opportunities as it seeks to expand into India (Voeten et al.,
2017). Toyota has a footing in India but has been seeking to increase its market capitalization in
India. However, Toyota's expansion ambitions have been inhibited mainly by differing
challenges inherent in the Indian market (James & Jones, 2013). The conceptual frameworks
analyzed reveal Toyota's challenges and opportunities as it seeks to expand its market
capitalization in India.
PESTEL analysis
that are critical for its success (Çitilci & Akbalık, 2020). Through pestel analysis, it becomes
competitive advantage. Further, PESTEL analysis highlights the elements for a specific business
success. The PESTEL analysis is an acronym for Political, economic, social, technological,
Political factors
Toyota operates in areas with differing political orientations and inclinations, so its
operations in India are cordial (James & Jones, 2013). Toyota has a global outlook and
Toyota has a free trade agreement with the Indian government, which makes working in India
simple.
Economic
There is a high competition rate in the Indian automotive industry today (James &
Jones, 2013). This is due to the entry of other companies in the automotive industry, such as
Suzuki, Mahindra & Mahindra, Hyundai, Volkswagen, and Tata Motors (Meena et al., 2020). As
such, operating in Indian market is challenge for Toyota due to the high rate of competition.
Sociological
Customers are more conscious about their consumption than they were before. As such,
companies are taking greater responsibility for their production (Gagan Deep, 2023). Recently,
Toyota has had to recall cars due to faulty fuel pumps after an uproar from the public. The
automaker recalled over 700,000 vehicles, which was an expensive recall (Ahmed, 2020). The
company stated that the fuel pumps could fail, leading to engine failures. In India, Toyota made a
recall of 11,56 cars (Team BHP, 2021). The recall of the cars in India gives negative publicity to
the company. This gave a wrong perception of Toyota brand in the Indian market.
Ecological factors
The market is moving towards production that is focused on lowering the carbon
footprint (Sheth et al., 2020). The eco-friendly car market in India is growing at a rate of 35%
(Economic Times, 2024). Toyota produces cars that majorly use gasoline. The failure to optimize
eco-friendly cars is making Toyota lag in its carbon footprint reduction. Further, it makes Toyota
Legal issues
Legal issues are damaging to the company's image and revenue. When Toyota recalled
cars with faulty fuel valves, the company was hit with lawsuits from disgruntled customers
6
(Bebeteidoh & Takim, 2016). This led to heavy financial losses. In 2020, Toyota recalled 11,556
(Team BHP, 2021). Some of the law suits which Toyota faced were from India, damaging its
Institutional theory
practices to increase their legitimacy in particular markets (Lammers & Garcia, 2017). In every
market that a business operates in, there are the set of values and the rules that govern this
society. Based on institutional theory, companies strive to conform to the set regulations and the
values of society to attract customers to their companies (Berthod, 2018). Research highlights
that market forces, such as customer demand, influence corporate direction. Achieving
sustainable development is one example of a value driven by the need for legitimacy. Companies
need help to achieve a zero carbon footprint in their operations. These efforts have seen
Toyota has been following the pathway of institutional theory (Meena et al., 2020). In
particular, Toyota has been seeking to learn the legitimacy of the Indian population, where it is
advancing its internationalization strategy. One of the ways Toyota has been committed to
sustainable social development is through the use of Corporate Social responsibility activities in
the Indian market. In India, companies must use 2% of their net profits in corporate social
responsibility activities. However, Toyota has exceeded this threshold and continuously
committed 5% of its net revenues to Corporate Social responsibility activities (Toyota, 2021).
Toyota invests in CSR activities and projects in India. Then, it turns over the management of
these activities to the local communities and administrations where the CRS projects have been
administered.
7
of the beneficiaries of the Indo-Thai free trade agreement (Briefing, 2014). This trade agreement
will give Toyota access to the Indian market and other Indo-Pacific countries. The trade
agreement allows Toyota to make cars in India duty-free. Toyota's other opportunity is to partner
with Indian car manufacturers. Toyota has bought a stake in the Suzuki car manufacturer to
increase its market share in the Indian economic market. (2018). India is one of the fastest-
growing car markets in the world, and Toyota can benefit from expanding its operations there.
India is moving towards the development of clean energy. Toyota can also take advantage of the
green energy shift in India. According to the International Trade Administration (2024), India is
making policy directives to promote the country's development and use of green energy. Toyota
is a leader in the manufacture of hybrid cars. The company can promote itself as a first mover in
developing electric cars in India. Toyota has a lot of experience in hybrid cars and can leverage
The other opportunity that Toyota has is to decentralize its production. Toyota has heavily
relied on its factories in Japan to service its Global Supply Chain (Asah, 2023). However, the
company does have factories in some countries, such as the US, China, and India. The
production costs in Japan are rising, making cars unable to compete well with other vehicles
produced at a lower market price (Reuters, 2022). Japan needs to expand its global supply chain
Further, Toyota needs to have more suppliers in their supply chain. Currently, Toyota
depends on one or two suppliers for many of its components in the Global Supply chain. This is
risky since the company may need to stop its operations if one supplier fails. In 2023, Toyota had
8
to shut down all its factories in Japan after a problem with the supplier supplying the company
with coils (Asah, 2023). Toyota uses a production model called Just-in-time. This model dictates
that only the needed parts are produced at any given time. The shutdown lasted ten days before
the supplier could operate again (Asah, 2023). Thousands of cars were made behind schedule,
which cost the company money. If the company had other suppliers, it would not have gone into
a shutdown.
Market for Toyota. One of the disciplinary regulatory practices is the high taxation of
automobiles in India. According to Brunner Upton (2020), India has imposed a tax of 28% on all
automobiles, motorcycles and SUVs. However, the electric ones are excluded from this high
taxation (Fortune, 2024). The exclusion of electric cars from this high taxation does not help
Toyota since the company has yet to invest in the development of electric vehicles in India.
Additionally, charges are imposed on cars depending on the length of the car and the
horsepower of the vehicle. An SUV with an engine capacity of more than 1500 CC attracts a tax
of 50% (Fortune, 2024). This heavy taxation of cars in India frustrates Toyota's philosophy of
making cars for everyone. Due to the heavy taxation, car ownership in India is restricted to the
Institutional voids
Another obstacle Toyota faces is institutional voids in its ambitions to expand in the
Indian market. Institutional voids were first exposed in the book Winning in Emerging Markets.
Institutional voids refer to a state where no intermediaries in the market are involved in
intermediary tasks (Singapore Management University, 2013). These intermediary tasks include
9
research and development, financing systems, market research, and credit card systems
(Dieleman et al., 2022). Most companies have been stuck with the traditional system of doing
things since innovations have yet to drive the next frontier in their industries. Entry into new
markets requires organizations to have strategies tailored for these new markets. According to
HBR, many globalized companies need help-seeking strategies to infiltrate emerging markets.
Sinha et al. (2015) identify that the absence of investment in research, regulatory framework, and
In India, Toyota faces a myriad of institutional voids that inhibit its growth and
development ambitions. One of the institutional voids identified in India is the absence of an
innovation policy (Voeten et al., (2017). The other void is more technical support for the
research and development work. India also lacks safety nets for innovative hubs and personnel,
leading to evasiveness in research development and investment (Dieleman et al., 2022). The
financing landscape in the country could be better, and this is an institutional void that frustrates
research and development (Voeten et al., 2017). Institutional support is also flimsy in the
innovative sector, leaving a void for companies seeking to develop new product offerings.
Internationalization theory
The internationalization strategy is the process through which companies seek and
expand into other countries apart from their home countries (Whitelock, 2002). The primary goal
of internationalization is to gain a more significant market share and increase corporate revenue.
integrating states, economies, and organizations across different countries and regions (Maqbool-
ur-Rahman, 2015). For a company to internationalize, it must adapt to be accepted in the country
10
it seeks to expand into. Companies must adapt to the countries in which they are seeking to
expand. It may require that the company adjust to the local culture of the people to become
accepted. Further, a company needs to adapt to the standards set in terms of technology and way
of doing business.
objective is to circumvent the punitive taxation by the Indian government on imported cars. In
the past, Toyota relied on selling vehicles in India manufactured from their factories in Japan and
other countries where their production costs were relatively low. However, the Indian
government, in a move aimed at bolstering the local industry, instituted punitive taxes on car
imports (Reuters, 2023). The effect of these vast taxes is that most manufacturers' production
costs have gone high. The internationalization strategy Toyota has employed is localizing the
production of cars in India. Localizing production helps eliminate import tariffs; therefore,
Toyota can sell its vehicles more cheaply in the Indian market. The second internationalization
strategy is to manufacture low-cost hybrid cars. For years, Toyota has flourished in mixed car
manufacturing (Yu et al., 2011). However, its hybrid vehicles, including Toyota Prius and Camry
Hybrid, are expensive and unable to penetrate the Indian car market. Toyota is planning to
manufacture low-cost hybrid cars in India and hence be able to sell low-cost vehicles in the
Indian market.
advantages concerning resources to gain competitive advantages in the market (Akter et al.,
2022). Through the monopolistic advantage, it is possible to explain why foreign companies
enter other countries and seek to gain a market edge over home-based companies. The
11
monopolistic advantage can be achieved by direct investment, or it can also be acquired through
portfolio investment. By making either of these two investments in another country, a company
can directly control the industry by investing in the country. The direct control a firm gains is a
particular financial asset (Kievskaya, 2018). In the case of Toyota in India, the company has a
direct market but also expands through acquisition. Through acquisitions, Toyota is increasing its
Toyota has been seeking comparative advantages in the Indian market to gain
competitive advantage. Toyota has gained a competitive advantage through mergers and
acquisitions. Toyota has for example acquired a stake in Suzuki Maruti. Suzuki Maruti is India's
bestselling automaker. Suzuki controls over 50% of the Indian auto market (Ghosh, 2019).
Toyota stands to gain from this acquisition of Suzuki through cross-badging. Cross-badging is
where one car maker sells a car under a different name but the same car (Economic Times,
2018). Minor alterations are made to the vehicle to make it seem like a unique car, but the
changes are usually on the surface only. The automaker is only selling the same car under a
different name. Toyota can sell premium hatchback cars under the Suzuki Maruti brand in the
cross-badging arrangement. This is because Toyota does not have a premium hatchback segment,
and now they can sell them under the Suzuki brand name, even though the cars will be Toyota
model cars.
Further, Suzuki does not have a sedan car in the Indian market. Suzuki seeks to get the
models from Toyota and sell them as its premium sedan cars in the Indian market and the rest of
the world (Economic Times, 2018). Toyota will get additional sales of sedans under the brand
12
name Suzuki. Suzuki needs to develop its electric car market segment better. However, Toyota
has over 20 years of experience in building hybrid cars. Suzuki could use the money to create the
electric vehicle in terms of research and development (Ghosh, 2019). However, the company can
quickly develop a new car model and technology. Suzuki can use the hybrid car technology used
by Toyota to build its electric car segment. By using Toyota's technology, Toyota will gain
revenue and market share in the electric and hybrid car markets. By being able to sell its cars in
India under the Suzuki brand name, Toyota is increasing its market share in the Indian market.
Consequently, Toyota's competitive advantage also increases the proportion of its share in the
Indian market.
Toyota needs to penetrate the upcoming markets to have a growth impetus for the
future. Some of these upcoming markets that Toyota needs to penetrate include Africa, Asian
markets, and South America. One of the notable problems identified in the research is the
presence of institutional voids. The institutional voids were identified as inhibitors to research
and development and posed operating obstacles to investment (Voeten et al., 2017). Owing to
this shortcoming, Toyota needs to invest more in research and development for the emerging
markets it seeks to expand into. It was highlighted that in the process of internationalization,
companies need to integrate into the local culture, customs, and traditions to win the hearts of the
locals. As such, Toyota needs to invest more in research and development in the countries and
regions where it seeks to expand. Research and development will give Toyota novel products
Sustainability is becoming critical in many global markets (Sheth & Parvatiyar, 2020).
Consumers are becoming more conscious of what they purchase and its environmental impact.
Toyota needs to rethink how it will enhance its sustainability in the market. In particular, Toyota
needs to invest more in electric car manufacturing since it is currently the driver of sustainable
marketing. Toyota Company will achieve this goal through more research and development.
and other mobility forms (Althubaiti, 2022). Toyota must invest more in research and
development to gain a first-mover advantage in the market. This will avoid getting overridden by
companies such as Tesla. Toyota also needs to diversify its product offering in the market.
Different markets have different market needs. This is especially true for emerging markets. This
can be seen from the strategy which Toyota has employed in India. Toyota did not have products
tailored for the Indian market and it therefore had to acquire Suzuki to gain a more significant
Conclusion
Toyota is one of the most profitable companies in the world in terms of the revenue that
the company generates every year. For the company to remain as good as it is, it must keep
developing and innovating. In particular, Toyota needs to keep improving its organizational
strategy. India is one of the emerging global markets with massive potential for Toyota. This
research has examined the internationalization of Toyota in India. The study has found that
Toyota has some inherent competitive advantages in India, which are part of its strength as it
seeks to expand in this market. Some of them include its portfolio investment in the Indian auto
industry and the technological advantage it possesses. Toyota also faces some threats in the
Indian market, such as the high tariffs instituted by the Indian government and institutional
voids.
14
will help the company circumvent the punitive taxation that the government imposes on foreign
companies that sell products in the Chinese market. The second recommendation is that Toyota
should focus on producing low-cost cars. This is because of the high competition in India with
other car manufacturers such as Suzuki, Mahindra & Mahindra, Hyundai, Volkswagen, and Tata
Motors. Toyota also needs to focus on the manufacture of hybrid cars in India. The Indian
market is under-exploited in terms of electric vehicles; therefore, there is a lot of market potential
that Toyota can exploit. The other recommendation for Toyota is that the company needs to
invest in research and development in India and the other emerging markets that the company is
seeking to expand into. Investing in research and development will help to overcome the
institutional voids that plague India and the other emerging markets Toyota can invest in, such as
References
Ahmed, F. G. (2020, January 15). Toyota is recalling nearly 700,000 vehicles because of issues with the
pump-recall-trnd/index.html
Akter, K., Mieszkowska, N., Kadalie, R., Barsade, S. G., Sheridan, S., Sarker, A. R.,
competition. https://doi.org/10.22541/au.165158300.01964919/v1
(CICN). https://doi.org/10.1109/cicn56167.2022.10008358
16
Asahi S. (2023, August 30). Toyota’s reliance on 1 supplier drags out long shutdown | The
Asahi Shimbun: Breaking news, Japan news and analysis. The Asahi
Shimbun. https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/15040092
Bebeteidoh, O. L., & Takim, S. A. (2016). Toyota’s slow response to manufacturing defects
3-319-20928-9_63
Briefing, I. (2014, January 8). Toyota looks to benefit from Indo-Thai FTA. India Briefing
News. https://www.india-briefing.com/news/toyota-benefit-indothai-fta-902.html/
Çitilci, T., & Akbalık, M. (2020). The importance of PESTEL analysis for environmental
Dieleman, M., Markus, S., Rajwani, T., & White, G. O. (2022). Revisiting institutional voids:
Economic times. (2018, August 9). Toyota, Suzuki to make cars for each other. The Economic
Times. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/auto/cars-uvs/toyota-suzuki-to-make-
cars-for-each-other/what-is-cross-badging/slideshow/65339677.cms?from=mdr
Economic Times. (2024, January 5). EV sales in India likely to grow at CAGR of 35%; annual
Times. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/renewables/ev-sales-in-india-
17
likely-to-grow-at-cagr-of-35-annual-volumes-may-cross-27-million-by-2032-says-
report/articleshow/106578432.cms?from=mdr
Fortune. (2024, February 9). The great Indian SUV confusion. Fortune India: Business News,
great-indian-suv-confusion/115747
077. https://doi.org/10.30574/msarr.2023.9.2.0162
Ghosh, M. (2019, August 28). Toyota, Suzuki forge deeper ties by buying stakes in each other.
mint. https://www.livemint.com/auto-news/toyota-and-suzuki-announce-capital-alliance-
1566982470668.html
Hatani, F. (2009). Pre-clusterization in emerging markets: The Toyota group's entry process in
387. https://doi.org/10.1080/13602380802667353
renewable-energy
James, R., & Jones, R. (2013). Transferring the Toyota lean cultural paradigm into India: Implications
Kievskaya, E. (2018). Analysis of modern approaches to the formation of the portfolio investor
9. https://doi.org/10.15587/2312-8372.2018.145730
18
Lammers, J. C., & Garcia, M. A. (2017). Institutional theory approaches. The International
10. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118955567.wbieoc113
Loyd, N. (2020). Empirical study of Toyota Motor Corporation relative to the good to great
15. https://doi.org/10.5296/jmr.v8i3.9374
204. https://doi.org/10.20547/jms.2014.021/1501103
Meena, A., Dhir, S., & Sushil. (2020). An analysis of growth-accelerating factors for the Indian
0047
Qu, Y., & Wu, Y. (2022). Research on the corporate value of Toyota based on multiple
250. https://doi.org/10.54691/bcpbm.v31i.2588
Reuters. (2022). Focus: As yen tumbles, Japan's automakers take cost burden off their suppliers.
reuters.com. https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/yen-tumbles-japans-
automakers-take-cost-burden-off-their-suppliers-2022-06-15/
Reuters. (2023, February 1). India raises tax on imported cars, motorbikes, including
EVs. https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/india-raises-tax-imported-
cars-motorbikes-including-evs-2023-02-01/
19
Sheth, J. N., & Parvatiyar, A. (2020). Sustainable marketing: Market-driving, not market-
165. https://doi.org/10.1177/0276146720961836
Opportunities? https://ink.library.smu.edu.sg/pers/21.
Sinha J., Palepu G., & Khanna T. (2015, June 1). Strategies that fit emerging markets. Harvard
Team BHP. (2021, March 17). 1-crore fine for vehicle recalls in India. Team-
BHP.com. https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/indian-car-scene/234558-1-crore-fine-
vehicle-recalls-india.html
Activities. https://global.toyota/pages/global_toyota/sustainability/esg/social-
contribution/social_cont_all_en_p.pdf
Uchil, S. A., & Yazdanifard, R. (2014). The growth of the automobile industry : Toyota’s dominance in
265. https://doi.org/10.17722/jorm.v3i2.86
Voeten J., Saiyed J., & Dutta, K. (2017). Emerging Economies, Institutional Voids, and
University.
347. https://doi.org/10.1108/02651330210435654
20
Yu O., Silva C., & Ch L. (2011). Electric vehicles: Struggles in creating a market Conference:
PICMET '11:.
Yusoof, S., Iylia, F., Zuber, F., MNSR, H., Zamziba, N., & Toriry, S. (2016). Relationship