Chipotle Valuation
Chipotle Valuation
Environment
Business Analysis
Company Overview
Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc. also known as Chipotle is one of the leaders in its industry, the fast
and casual dining segment. It was established around 30 years ago. Where it specializes in
Mexican dishes that are made to suit the segment of the industry it is targeting. The company
has also focused on giving clients what they want by offering them various
customized options. In recent years, and accommodation to the world trend, the company has
focused its process on both sustainability and ethical sources to maintain the brand loyalty it
has worked hard to develop. In 30 years of business, Chipotle now runs 3200 branches globally
with the main concentration being in the United States. This averages out to more than 100
new restaurants per year. Unlike other fast-casual chains, Chipotle runs its operations across all
branches to ensure consistent standards of quality are applied, and to maintain the Chipotle
experience anywhere in the world (Chipotle Mexican Grill, 2023).
As part of being in line with the global trend, Chipotle has ensured its online market presence
as the world shifts to a more digital approach to consumerism. Focusing and enhancing their
dynamic digital system which generates increasing sales year over year over the past few years.
As of 2023, this revenue share of digital sales accounted for almost 45% of their overall revenue
of the year. Furthermore, their company app includes around 30 million unique clients which
was a determining part of their growth in recent years (Chipotle Mexican Grill, 2023). On top of
their online sales, Chipotle has customized its drive-thru experience and refers to it as
"Chipotlane" which enhances the experience of their consumers and serves them in the outlet
that conveniences them best.
Analysis
Compared to its peers, Chipotle has the highest reinvestment rate. It currently stands at 38%
which is actually significantly higher than any of these 5 peers and their average. This highlights
the focus that Chipotle has on developing its current operations and its presence. This can allow
us to use a higher growth rate in the valuation as it is a function of the reinvestment rate and
return on capital.
While in terms of its debt-to-equity ratio, we can quickly notice how heavily are the peer list
structured on debt. Where the average for the peers quickly indicates that these companies
have more debt than equity. Which is a risky tendency for the competitors. On the other side,
Chipotle has a market debt-to-equity ratio of 6.3%. In terms of book value, this drops to less
than 1%. Chipotle has no long-term debt or bonds issued in its books. Rather all its debt is
actually of operating leases, thus implying they are only for operation purposes and
commitments. This low debt-to-equity ratio will aid in lowering the cost of capital for Chipotle
compared to its peers.
Risk Assessment
Risks
There are 3 main risks to affect the valuation and operations of Chipotle. The first is inflation
and rising costs. The second is the intense competition. Lastly, regulatory challenges. To avoid
repetition, we will skip the first point as it was already discussed earlier in the analysis. In terms
of competition, their industry is fast-moving and ever-growing. Some client behavior is
susceptible to changes in taste and trying new things. Also, consumers are very sensitive to the
prices of their products and meals. This forces Chipotle and its peers to always adapt and
expand their offering and price range in order not to lose their edge and competitive advantage
against their peers.
Regulatory challenge is a broad topic that can include labor laws, health laws, and compliance
costs. For example, the rising minimum wage can seriously affect the costs of Chipotle and
could require them to quickly adjust their budgets to accommodate. Health laws are one of the
core controllers of the food industry and consumers' evolving needs. Therefore, Chipotle is
always exposed to risks arising from regulatory changes. Lack of cooperation from Chipotle's
side can cause serious reputational challenges that they cannot afford.
Mitigation Strategies
There are many strategies that can lessen the exposure to such risks. One of the main ones that
is currently trending is automation and the increasing dependency on AI technology and tools.
This allows them to lower the number of employees needed and at the same time enhance
efficiency in their delivery of services whether it is in their catering, in-restaurant, or digital
sales.
Part 2: Discount Rate Estimation
Regression Beta
Calculation and Analysis
For the calculation of the regression beta, we used Chipotle's monthly closing price and the
monthly closing price of the S&P 500 index over the past years from 2019 until 2023. We
calculated the returns of each, the stock, and the index. Then we employed two methods to
calculate the regression beta.
The first method is the slope method. This required more data points to be extracted. As for the
first slope calculation, we needed to include the last 60 data points which are the closing prices
of the stock and index from 2014 until 2019, and their returns. Each month moving forward, we
included the 60 most recent slopes until we reach the last data point of December 2023. Lastly,
we averaged the 60 computed slopes to get a regression beta of 1.15202.
The second method applied to determine the regression beta is the covariance beta. Which
includes calculating the covariance between the stock and the index returns and then dividing it
by the variance of the index returns. This gave us a regression beta of 1.33121.
The final regression beta that we decided to proceed with is the average of both these
methods. This gave a final regression beta of 1.24. The aim of these regression betas is to
reflect how sensitive is Chipotle to changes in the index based on historical exposure. The value
of the beta tells us that this exposure has a moderate exposure to the market.
Limitations of Regression Beta
One of the main limitations of using regression beta is the assumption that the company risk
profile maintains consistency over time. This is not true, especially for a company like Chipotle
which experienced high growth over time. During the period of valuation we are undertaking,
we can notice how rapid the growth of Chipotle has been. Their digital evolution and
operational investments are changing the way the company is to an extent that historical data
might not be the best reflector of reality.
Another argument to support the limitation of the model is by viewing the graph of the slopes
that aided in the computation of beta. Over the period, we can notice a jump in the beta
computed where the data starts close to 0.6 till it reaches above 1 and attempts to stabilize
itself. Further highlighting the change in the risk profile of the company.
This allows us to understate the risk of the business by removing the effects of each company's
financial leverage. After calculating all the unlevered betas, we average them using a simple
average and consider it the peer benchmark beta. We then accommodate this peer benchmark
beta to the specific risk of Chipotle by leveraging it using Chipotle's debt-to-equity ratio and its
own tax rate. This gives a final bottom-up beta for Chipotle of 0.77.
Market Value of Debt and Equity
Average Benchmark Unlevered Beta 0.73
Total Debt 3,976,437,637
62,722,164,96
Total Equity 0
WACC Tax Rate, (%) 21.6%
Debt to Equity 6.3%
(1-t) 78.4%
1+[(D/E)*(1-t)) 1.05
Beta 0.77
WACC
There are two necessary rates for the computation of the WACC. The cost of debt and the cost
of equity. As shown earlier the cost of debt for Chipotle is 5.1%. For the cost of equity, we need
to retrieve the risk-free rate, Beta which was already computed, and the expected return of the
market. For the risk-free rate, we got the rate of a US 10-year treasury bond and retrieved a
rate of 4.3%. We also extracted the expected return of the S&P index from Refinitiv and got a
value of 7.4%.
Using the CAPM formula, we can compute the cost of equity. We calculated 3 costs of equity,
one by using the regression beta, the bottom-up beta, and finally the average of both. As can be
seen in the tables below.
Debt to Equity (Market Value) 6.3%
Marginal Tax 21.8%
Risk-free rate: 4.3%
Average Beta 1.01
E(Rm) 7.4%
Equity Premium 3.0%
Cost of Equity 7.41%
Cost of Debt 5.1%
WACC 7.2%
WACC 7.9%
WACC 6.5%
There are two necessary rates for the computation of the WACC. The cost of debt and the cost
of equity. As shown earlier the cost of debt for Chipotle is 5.1%. For the cost of equity, we need
to retrieve the risk-free rate, Beta which was already computed, and the expected return of the
market. For the risk-free rate, we got the rate of a US 10-year treasury bond and retrieved a
rate of 4.3%. We also extracted the expected return of the S&P index from Refinitiv and got a
value of 7.4%.
Beta 1.19
Cost of Equity 9.38%
Cost of Debt 5.09%
Reinvestment Rate 34.51%
Non-cash Working Capital/Sales 3.57%
For the growth rate used in each year, we computed growth as a function of reinvestment rate
and ROIC in each. Providing us with a smooth transition of the growth of the company to where
it would grow perpetually at the US 10-year government bond rate.
Model Base Year 1 2 3 4 5 Terminal
Revenue Growth Rate 6.98% 7.00% 6.98% 6.94% 6.86% 4.35%
Total Capital Invested 7,113,310,000 8,983,962,336 11,469,535,230 14,799,788,058 19,299,589,611 25,431,717,900 33,860,354,341
Reinvestment Rate 26.30% 27.67% 29.04% 30.40% 31.77% 33.14% 34.51%
Return on Invested Capital 26.37% 25.24% 24.10% 22.96% 21.83% 20.69% 19.56%
Non-cash Working
Capital/Sales 0.2% 0.80% 1.35% 1.91% 2.46% 3.02% 3.6%
Scenario-Based Cash Flow Forecasting
We considered the first model above as the base scenario and the basis of our other scenarios.
We want to explore the effects of different growth structures on the cash flows, reinvestment
rate, and return on invested capital. For this, we kept the computation as is but only changed
the growth rate. Then we calculated the ROIC by dividing EBIT(1-T) by the invested capital
calculation. We then used the growth function to estimate the reinvestment rate.
For the high growth scenario, we assumed that the high growth will keep on increasing till it
reaches the peak of 25% in two years. Thereafter, it decreases by five percent a year. Under this
growth structure, we noticed that the reinvestment rate for a period of time will exceed 200%
in a single year. For Chipotle to be able to sustain such growth it will have to reshape its capital
structure and become heavily invested in debt.
In the low growth scenario, we assumed that the company would only grow 3-4 in each of the
years. The reinvestment rate in this scenario was reasonable and realistic. This makes sense as
this is a function of growth itself. However, this approach undermines the capacity of Chipotle
to generate returns which is not true based on historical analysis.
When comparing these scenarios to whether they are a realistic approach to how the company
might behave in perpetuity, we find that the base scenario remains the most realistic approach.
The high growth scenario seems unsustainable, especially with the required reinvestment rate.
One of the key elements is that the reinvestment rate for the terminal year is above 100%
which implies that Chipotle must maintain that in perpetuity which is far from reality.
The Valuation
PV of FCFF = 3,271,762,741
PV of Terminal Value = 8,520,182,612
Value of Firm = 11,791,945,353
- Value of Outstanding Debt = 3,976,437,637
Value of Equity = 7,815,507,716
Outstanding Shares 1,371,300,000
Value of Equity per share = 5.70
The per-share value computed is much lower than the closing price of Chipotle during 2023.
This highlights that the stock is currently overvalued and the market sentiment on the future of
the company is pushing the price up. Market sentiment is in support of the growth the
company has done in the past few years and indicates their expectation of company
profitability. Given this big difference, our recommendation would be to Sell Chipotle's stock.
Even though the fundamental performance of the company is great, the a difference between
the intrinsic value and the market price.
Sensitivity Analysis
Methodology
For the sensitivity analysis of the financial model, we wanted to explore the variations of the
valuation based on changes in growth and discount rates. For the changes in discount rate, we
chose to test two scenarios, a high WACC and a low WACC. For the high WACC, we increased
the rate for each year by 2% while for the low WACC, we decreased the rate from the base year
by 2%. For changes in growth rate, we took both the high and low scenarios previously
discussed and used them in parallel with the changes in the discount rate.
Results
When combining changes in both variables we can see how changes in these rates affect the
valuation. The best case scenario occurs when we have high growth and a low discount rate
where the company value shows the highest result of 22 billion USD equating to a value per
share of 13.24 USD. The Worst Case Scenario occurs when we combine a high discount rate
accompanied by low growth which totals a firm value of 9.15 billion USD and a value per share
of 3.78 USD.
Growth
Value of Firm
Low Base High
Growth
Value per Share
Low Base High
Cost of Capital
Base 7.19% 7.39% 7.56% 7.70% 7.82% 7.92% 7.99%
High 9.19% 9.39% 9.56% 9.70% 9.82% 9.92% 9.99%
Low 4.19% 4.39% 4.56% 4.70% 4.82% 4.92% 4.99%
Growth
Base 6.98% 7.00% 6.98% 6.94% 6.86% 4.35%
High 20.00% 25.00% 20.00% 15.00% 10.00% 4.35%
Low 4.00% 3.00% 4.00% 3.00% 4.00% 4.35%
Based on this analysis we can see that the valuation range for Chipotle's stock is between 3.78
USD and 13.24 USD depending on how the scenario plays out in reality. This big difference in
the price highlights the impact of both these rates on the valuation and their importance.
Therefore, for any valuation to be successful, the basis of it will be dependent on how these
two rates were calculated.
References
Chipotle Mexican Grill, Inc. 2023 Annual Report.
IBISWorld. Industry Report: Chain Restaurants in the U.S.
Morningstar. Chipotle Mexican Grill Analyst Report, 2023.
Statista. Digital Ordering Trends in Restaurants, 2023.