CPD Unit-7 Design Solution
CPD Unit-7 Design Solution
UNIT 7:
Design Solutions
by
University
Services
COPYRIGHT DECLARATION
This Study Material is designed, developed and published by Illumine Knowledge Resources Pvt. Ltd.
Booklet printed from and licensed to Career Knowledge Resources Pvt. Ltd, the promoters of I-Become. All rights are
reserved. No part of this Study Material may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted
in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise by any
person or organization (including program participants) without the prior permission of Illumine
Knowledge Resources Pvt. Ltd.
UNIT 7:
Design Solutions
Contributors approach the various situations in their life and
work place with a unique mindset. This mindset we call, the
‘Contributor Mindset’.
Concept Exploration
EXPLORATION 1:
Non-contributors are often “rigid” about Contributors are focused on goals and
the procedure or their own way of doing find appropriate methods to achieve
things instead of focusing on the goal them within the framework of the
system
REFLECTIONS
Q1. A term that is gaining popularity in the business world is the word “jugaad”. Think of examples of
how “jugaad” has been used positively in the real world. Write about these.
2 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
EXPLORATION 2:
There are only two ways. We Can we look for a third way that
must choose one of these. combines the best of both choices?
? ?
REFLECTIONS
Q1. Generating new possibilities1 is the first step in creating innovations. Do you agree? Why?
MEANINGS:
1
Possibilities: New ways or alternative approaches or other options to make the goal possible
© NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET 3 OF 22
UNIT 7: DESIGN SOLUTIONS
EXPLORATION 3:
REFLECTIONS
Q1. Have you met individuals with the “can-do” attitude? Why are such people so valued in the workplace?
4 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
EXPLORATION 4:
Failure will
become a
I will lose This experience
What will stepping stone
confidence will help us improve
happen to my to success the project/
image? product
Whether there is
I can’t even success or failure, I
imagine the will become stronger
consequences and wiser through the
experiment
REFLECTIONS
Q1. When you overcome your “fear of failure”, your willingness to try out new things increases. Share
some experiences from your own life.
© NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET 5 OF 22
UNIT 7: DESIGN SOLUTIONS
Concept Application
6 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
REFLECTIONS
Dr. Spencer did not fear failure. Thus he was willing to keep presenting his failed discovery
in different forums. His persistence eventually resulted in him connecting with Art Fry in one
of these forums. Art Fry, on his part, wanted an answer to his own problem. He redefined the
utility of the entire discovery and came out with an alternate use of the weak glue.
Q1. What was the benefit that each received from his own different approach?
(i) benefit for Dr. Spencer
Q2. Think of an example where you or someone you know were able to find a solution to
the problem by persistently trying different approaches to arrive at a solution until you
succeeded. Write about this.
[Hints: Write about –
– what was the situation?
– what were the obstacles and failures faced?
– what was the response to these failures?
– what was the final outcome?]
APPLICATION QUESTIONS
Q.3 Think of some difficult project you would like to take up, where many people have said
chances for success are low.
As a contributor, what are some of the actions or choices you could take so as to improve
your team’s chances of success? Discuss to answer.
[Hints: Think of how you can first experiment in a low-risk environment.]
© NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET 7 OF 22
UNIT 7: DESIGN SOLUTIONS
To get started, Nikhil passed the word around in the This is terrible! Nothing
village, calling for a meeting of all farmers. However… can be done here! I am
better off back in my
corporate job!
Nikhil regrouped energies and readied himself for a long struggle. He began meeting
farmers regularly – individually and in groups. He also met some of the middlemen and
shared with them ways in which they could benefit from and support this effort. Seeing his
persistence, more villagers joined in. They ran a pilot with 10 farmers using the technology
to get connected to the mandi [market place]. These 10 farmers then became advocates to
other farmers in the village. The movement caught on… more and more people got involved...
Three years later, not only were most of the farmers in that village using this technology,
but neighboring villages had also begun replicating this.
8 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
REFLECTIONS
Q1. Nikhil took responsibility for finding a solution to the situation. He believed that solutions
can be found, thus even though he faced many difficulties, he struggled with the solution
until he found answers – one step at a time. What were the benefits of this approach?
[Hints: Consider the
– benefits to the community
– benefits to Nikhil]
APPLICATION QUESTIONS
Q2. In the workplace, often we are faced with challenges with no easy solutions. As a
Contributor, what are some strategies / tips you can learn from Nikhil’s approach, so as
to find your own answers when faced with these tough situations? Discuss to answer.
© NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET 9 OF 22
UNIT 7: DESIGN SOLUTIONS
One more
accident death
3
I don’t think we have an
Dr. Venkat studied the factors affecting answer to this situation in
the severity of accidents, to diagnose the the hospital.
causes.
10 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
REFLECTIONS
Q1. Dr. Venkat’s functional goal as a doctor was to cure patients. What do you think were the
goals that he saw at a human level, that motivated him to take the effort to find the cause
and find a ‘non-medical’ solution to the challenge?
Q2. Write down 2 experiences from your life where a challenge was faced –
1. Where you saw a person focused on the process and the same old way of doing things.
2. Where the person found a new way of solving the challenge.
Compare the results of both these approaches.
APPLICATION QUESTIONS
Q3. In the workplace, suppose you are asked to join a team which has to complete a task
in a short time, as a contributor, which of the following would be your choice in the
situation?
You work sincerely and even do over-time
© NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET 11 OF 22
UNIT 7: DESIGN SOLUTIONS
CASE STORY
A surgeon typically performs 150 cataract surgeries every week, six times the number
common among Western specialists. To further lower costs, Aravind has created a sister
organization to manufacture lenses, drugs etc. locally at prices one-fiftieth of U.S. prices.
All these measures have greatly helped reduce costs. In addition, it has made cross-
subsidization an integral part of its business model.
Thus, despite the constraints of poverty, Aravind has built a systemic solution to a complex
social and medical problem.
12 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
REFLECTIONS
Aravind Hospitals wanted to make affordable eye care accessible to the rural population
of the country. To achieve this, they continuously found ways to reduce costs and improve
efficiencies in the way eye care is done.
– To Aravind Hospitals
APPLICATION QUESTIONS
Q2. Write down an example of any organization/individual who wanted to achieve a clearly
defined goal. How did the goal-oriented approach influence the choices that the
organization/individual made?
[Hints:
– what was the goal?
– what were some of the difficult choices that had to be made?
– what factors were considered while making these choices?]
© NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET 13 OF 22
UNIT 7: DESIGN SOLUTIONS
The rural branch team of a large public sector bank shares its experience…
But then the team got together and thought — why can’t we do something such that we
are able to give them loans AND enable them to repay their loans? Why can’t we find a
way to increase their income?
Now, not only are they repaying their loans on time, moving out of our
NPAs list, but many have also approached us for new loans for dairy
equipment, thus increasing our business!
14 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
REFLECTIONS
To find a solution, this team first defined the end-state or outcome they sought (i.e. genuinely
help this farmer community + protect interests of the bank). Then they went all out to find
solutions. Their answer was simple: “find a way to increase their income”. The entire team
then got energized to reach this goal! Through this solution approach all the issues they faced
regarding the NPA status of this community disappeared.
Q1. What is the value of sharing the vision of the goals (amongst all bank team members)?
Discuss to answer.
[Hints: Consider impact on
– team energy
– quality and creativity of alternate solution ideas
– closing the gap between “ideas” and “action”
– interests of the bank
– interests of the community]
Q2. This case is also an example of Imaginative Sympathy (topic of Unit 11) where the bank
officials appreciated the necessity of finding a solution that would genuinely help the
farmers. Do you know of any other case where a solution was found at a deeper level
because of genuine concern for the people involved? Write about this case.
© NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET 15 OF 22
UNIT 7: DESIGN SOLUTIONS
CASE STORY
The Gold Corp Challenge
In 1983, Rob McEwen took over an old under-performing Gold Mine in Red Lake district
of Ontario. This Mine had very high operating costs and production was very low.
McEwen attended a Linux conference. Here he got to know of the idea of “open
innovation”, which triggered the idea of the GoldCorp Challenge.
Within weeks of launching of Gold Corp Challenge, submissions of 1200 people from 50
countries came flooding. Geologists, mathematicians, consultants all got involved.
16 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
REFLECTIONS
By re-defining his challenge as “how to bring in more experts to identify gold-yielding sites”,
McEwen made the problem into one where he “knew what to do about it”. McEwen was
also able to identify an approach being used by software developers and adapt it to solve a
problem in his own field of work (Mining).
Q1. What choices does one need to make, to open one’s mind to solutions from other fields
that could be adapted to one’s own context? Discuss to answer.
Q2. McEwen’s firm belief that ‘he could find a solution’ to his problem, made him explore new
ways of thinking. Write down about one person you know who overcame a challenge
because of his/her ‘I can do’ approach.
APPLICATION QUESTIONS
To find solutions to complex problems, many organizations use ‘brainstorming’. These are
idea generation sessions in which people from diverse backgrounds from within or outside
the organization come together to discuss the problem.
Q3. What do you think are the benefits of such sessions? Discuss to answer.
© NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET 17 OF 22
UNIT 7: DESIGN SOLUTIONS
How many of us can dare to tackle one of the world’s toughest problems? Jerry Sternin, a
visiting scholar at Tufts University in USA, and his wife Monique had the courage to try…
In 1990, as staff
members of Save the
We call conventional wisdom about
Children, the Sternins
malnutrition ‘true but useless,’ or
were invited by the
tbu… it’s all about poor sanitation,
Vietnamese government
ignorance, poverty, etc. Millions
to help fight the problem
of kids can’t wait for those issues
of malnutrition in 10,000
to be addressed. Nothing has
villages in the country.
changed with outsider solutions.
But once there, an
This wouldn’t work - not in the
impossible demand was
6 months we had to make a
placed before them: They
difference.
had six months to produce
results. That’s it!
By the end of the program’s first year, 80 percent of the 1,000 children enrolled in the program
were adequately nourished. In addition, the effort was replicated within 14 villages across
Vietnam. The groundbreaking work that Sternin did in Vietnam has served as a model for
rehabilitating tens of thousands of children in 20 countries.
18 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
APPLICATION QUESTIONS
Sternin patiently studied the practices of the community. He then amplified / increased their
positive effects by spreading this across the community. Through this they brought a huge
change in the community’s malnutrition which had seemed like an unsolvable challenge. This
solutioning approach called “positive deviance” originally proposed by Zeitlin in the 1980s
has been formalized over time. (You can do an internet search to find out more about this.)
Similarly, many organizations have formalized ‘best practices sharing’ to address many
recurring challenges. However, it is found that most employees don’t put in the effort to
document and share.
Q1. What are the consequences of not sharing possible solutions and practices across the
community? Discuss to answer –
– Immediate and long-term consequences for the team and organization?
© NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET 19 OF 22
UNIT 7: DESIGN SOLUTIONS
PROJECT 1:
Project Goal: To identify how people (contributors) have found solutions to challenges they have faced,
and how they practiced “designing solutions”.
STEP 1: Identify any one “contributor” case where there was a challenge and the people involved designed
solutions to face and address the challenge. This case could be about -
l An incident or project you or someone you know has been a part of.
l A public case or incident that you may have read / heard about (in newspapers / public
knowledge).
STEP 3: Do a research study to collect data (video, photographs, data, etc.) for your project presentation.
Your research can include –
• Primary research done by interviewing the people involved / beneficiaries in this case.
• Secondary research done by using the internet, going through newspapers and magazines, talking
to experienced people who know this case well.
20 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA CONTRIBUTOR PERSONALITY PROGRAM
“
engaging the profound thought of the modern civilised
We want that education by which
world, but it was solved in our country thousands
character is formed, strength of
of years ago. The education which does not help the
mind is increased, the intellect is
common mass of people to equip themselves for the
expanded and by which one can
struggle for life, which does not bring out strength of
stand on one’s own feet. Physical
character, a spirit of philanthropy, and the courage of
weakness is the cause of at least
a lion – is it worth the name? Real education is that
one-third of our miseries. We are
which enables one to stand on one’s own legs. The
lazy; we cannot combine. We
education that you are receiving now in schools and
speak of many things parrot-like
colleges is only making you a race of dyspeptics. You
but never do them. Speaking and
are working like machines merely, and living a jelly-fish
not doing has become a habit with
existence.
us. What is the cause? Physical
weakness. This sort of weak brain
“
A nation is advanced in proportion
as education and intelligence
spread among the masses. The chief
cause of India’s ruin has been the
monopolizing of the whole education
and intelligence of the land, by dint
of pride and royal authority, among a
handful of men. If we are to rise again,
we shall have to do it in the same way,
i.e. by spreading education among the
masses. All the wealth of the world
cannot help one little Indian village
if the people are not taught to help
themselves.
In Junagadh, sometime in 1892, Swami Vivekananda
“
also came in contact with Chhaganlal H. Pandya
(b.1859, d.1936) of Nadiad, a great scholar,
Within man is all knowledge, and it
educationist and well known in Gujarat’s literary world
requires only an awakening, and that as translator of Sanskrit classics like Kadambari.
Source: The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda Source: Shri Ramakrishna Ashrama, Rajkot,
(Published by Advaita Ashrama, 5 Dehi Entally Road, website (www.rkmrajkot.org)
Kolkata 14, India)
22 0F 22 © NOVEMBER 2011; ALL COPYRIGHTS ARE OWNED BY ILLUMINE KNOWLEDGE RESOURCES PVT. LTD. | STUDY BOOKLET
The material in this booklet is meant to be studied
along with the material available at gtu.ibecome.in