COVID-19 Impact on Kids' Health
COVID-19 Impact on Kids' Health
Dietitian Professional Study Program, Department of Nutrition, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universitas
2
ABSTRACT
This is an open access article under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License
(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/)
J. Gizi Pangan,Volume 17, Number 3, November 2022 			                                                                 139
Nugroho et al.
children decreased their physical activities due          topics. Therefore, 2,075 articles were excluded. In
to social restrictions during the pandemic (Zheng         the next stage,the abstracts of 44 selected articles
et al. 2020). This fact is against school-age             were examined by considering the inclusion
children’s natural characteristics, such as playing,      and exclusion criteria; this examination resulted
moving, interacting in groups (Chusna & Utami             in 28 articles. The next step was examining
2020), and more actively exploring many things            the full texts of the 28 remained articles. This
(Rachmawati et al. 2021). Another study has               examination resulted in seven articles for review.
reported that the Body Mass Index (BMI) of                The seven articles consisted of six cohort studies
children aged 2‒19 years and obesity prevalence           and one cross-sectional study. The whole process
have increased by 16.1% during the COVID-19               of the article selection is presented in Figure 1.
pandemic (Lange et al. 2021). Children’s limited
mobility during the pandemic could lead to a lack                 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
of physical activities, a sedentary lifestyle, and
changes in the nutritional status (Zheng et al. 2020).          Seven selected articles were reviewed
       Exploring the effects of the COVID-19              and presented descriptively. The impacts of the
pandemic on school-age children’s physical                COVID-19 pandemic on children are grouped
activities, sedentary lifestyle levels, screen time,      into physical activities, sedentary activities,
and changes in nutritional status are pivotal and         screen time, and nutritional status
relevant to current conditions. This review aims
to review the latest research results on decreased        Physical activities of children during the
physical activities, sedentary lifestyle levels,          COVID-19 pandemic
screen time, and changes in nutritional status                   The effects of COVID-19 on children’s
of school-age children during the pandemic.               physical activities are reported by five of the
The results of this study are expected to bring           seven articles reviewed. These five articles
important information to create a strategic               mention that children’s physical activities have
solution and combat the effects of COVID-19 on            significantly decreased during the pandemic; all
the obesity in school-age children.                       p values are <0.01 with a negative association
                                                          direction (Table 1).
                   METHODS
       A cohort study in Czech children in 2021        the girls, the greater the decline (Treuth et al.
has found children’s activities more severely          2009). During the pandemic, another study cites
decrease during the pandemic than before               children could not fulfil their basic physical
(Stverakova et al. 2021). The study reported           activities due to social restrictions (Moore et al.
that the children experienced a decline not only       2020). Moore et al. (2020) explain that genders
in total physical activities but also in spare time,   showed differences in physical activities; boys
before–school-activities, sports class activities,     are physically more active than girls. The data
and rest activities (Stverakova et al. 2021).          on age denote that older children experienced a
Another study in the Netherlands compared data         bigger impact of changes in their activity patterns
from two cohorts and report non-converging             than younger children do (Moore et al. 2020).
results (Ten Velde et al. 2021). One of the cohort
results mentioned that children’s total physical       Sedentary activities of children during the
activities (p<0.01) decrease. However, this            COVID-19 pandemic
result disagrees with another cohort study (Ten                The sedentary lifestyle was reviewed from
Velde et al. 2021). Children’s decreased physical      three selected articles (Table 1). An increased
activities have also been recorded by a previous       sedentary lifestyle was reported by Ten Velde
study which reveals a p-value of 0.002 (Alonso-        et al. (2021) from two cohort results. Moreover,
Martinez et al. 2021). This result was supported       they report that the children’s physical activities
by another study although it was not significant       have lightly, moderately, and vigorously
(Cachon-Zagalaz et al. 2021).                          increased during the pandemic (p<0.01). The
       Children’s physical activities decrease         same result was reported by Alonso-Martinez
because they do not have alternative substitute        et al. (2021) with a p-value of 0.006. Whereas
activities during the pandemic (Stverakova             a study has found two types of significant
et al. 2021). Children’s organized indoor and          sedentary lifestyles in children: playing computer
outdoor activities decline; organized physical         or video games by boys and talking on the
activities in distance learning encounter various      phone or texting by girls (Dunton et al. 2020).
challenges so that decreased physical activities of            Keeping children from experiencing a
children cannot be optimally prevented (Vilchez        sedentary lifestyle during the pandemic was proven
et al. 2021; Gobbi et al. 2020). Another study         to protect children’s mental well-being (Gilbert et
also reported that returning children’s physical       al. 2021). Children were the age group who are
activity levels to the same level as before the        affected the most by the pandemic (Runacres et
pandemic was probably difficult due to lack of         al. 2021). Runacres et al. (2021) stated that the
parental support, amount of sleep time, lower          increased sedentary lifestyle negatively impacts
energy, and lower time (Moore et al. 2020).            children’s mental health, depression, anxiety, and
       This review notes that several selected         quality of life. These problems are influenced by
studies analyse age and gender with mixed              several factors, such as socioeconomic (the main
results. A recent study states that neither age        factor), education levels of parents, overweight
nor gender was significantly associated with           or obese parents, and parents’ high anxiety about
decreased physical activities during the pandemic      COVID-19 (Runacres et al. 2021). Runacres et al.
(Stverakova et al. 2021). Another study by Ten         (2021) have found that gender was not related to
Velde et al. (2021) agrees that children’s age was     an increasingly sedentary lifestyle; however, girls
not associated with decreased physical activities,     were consistently reported to be more sedentary
but data on gender show that girls’ physical           than boys.
activities decrease more significantly than boys’.
The next cohort study reported that physical           Screen time of children during the COVID-19
activities decrease along with the increasing age;     pandemic
moreover, the study has found that girls’ leisure              This review has found two articles reporting
time greatly increases (Dunton et al. 2020). A         changes in screen time of children during the
weaker cross-sectional study by Cachon-Zagalaz         COVID-19 pandemic (Table 1). Ten Velde et al.
et al. (2021) reported that children’s daily           (2021) report several results of screen time. They
activities increased as they got older.                investigated two cohorts and have found that
       A longitudinal study has found that girls’      screen time for school purposes has significantly
physical activities have decreased; the older          increased on weekdays and weekends (Ten Velde
                                                       et al. 2021).
Table 1. Extraction results of articles on the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on physical activity,
        sedentary lifestyle, screen time, and changes in nutritional status in school-age children
     Title                Country       Type of                                                        Association
                                                    Variable           Result
 (Author; Year)         (Participant)    study                                          Significancy       Type        Direction
Physical activity
The impact          Czech Republic      Cohort    Pre COVID     The mean PAQ-C           Significant     Decreased        (-)
of COVID-19         (Children aged                vs during     (physical activity)      (p<0.001)
on physical          8‒12 years                   COVID         total score
activity of         (n=98) during                               Spare time               Significant     Decreased        (-)
Czech               lockdown                                    (activities during       (p=0.001)
children            and (n=206)                                 leisure time)
(Stverakova         pre-COVID)
                                                                Activities before        Significant     Decreased        (-)
 et al. 2021)
                                                                school                   (p=0.003)
                                                                Activities during        Significant     Decreased        (-)
                                                                sports learning          (p<0.001)
Physicalactivity     Spain (Children      Cross-    Screen time        Screen time         Significant      Increased          (+)
and Daily            aged 0‒12 years      sectional during                                 (p=0.013)       (boys>girls)
Routine among        (n=837), 50.2%                 COVID-19
Children Aged        boys (n=420)                   Screen time        Daily screen        Significant        Increased        (+)
0‒12 during          and 49.8%                      during             time                (p=0.000)      (older>younger)
the COVID-19         girls (n=417))                 COVID-19
Pandemic in                                         by age
Spain (Cachon-                                      Screen time        The highest         Significant          n/a            n/a
Zagalaz et al.                                      during             screen time was     (p=0.043)
2021)                                               COVID-19 by        in children with
                                                    family type        single parents
                                                                       compared to
                                                                       other children
                                                    Screen time        The more active     Significant      Decreased           (-)
                                                    during             children, the       (p=0.018)
                                                    COVID-19 by        screen time will
                                                    children’s level   decrease
                                                    of active
Nutritional status
Paediatric BMI       United State of      Cohort    BMI changes        Children aged       Significant       Increased      Potentially
changes during       America (Children              (∆BMI) vs age      6‒9 years           (p=0.002)                           (+)
COVID-19             aged 6‒17 years                group
pandemic: An         (n=191,846) with
electronic health    details taken from
                                                                       Children aged       Significant       Increased      Potentially
record-based         the results of the
                                                                       10‒13 years         (p=0.003)                           (+)
retrospective        WCC U.S
cohort study         Electronic Health
(Brooks et al.       Record (EHR)
                                                                       Children aged          Not               n/a            n/a
2021)                data from
                                                                       14‒17 years         significant
                     Optum 2017‒2019
                     (n=144,714)
                     and 2020 data
                     (n=47,132)
Projecting the       United State of      Cohort    BMI and            BMI in girls in     Significant       Increased         (+)
impact of the        America (Children              Childhood          the group of         (p<0.05)
coronavirus          who come from                  Obesity            children with
disease              various                        Prevalence         COVID-19
(continue)           (continue)                                        compared to the
                                                                       control
Physical              Spain (Children      Cohort    Children           Sedentary time      Significant      Increased        (+)
activity,             aged 4 to 6 years              experience                             (p=0.006)
sedentary             from 3 (three)                 during lockdown
behaviour,            different schools
sleep, and sleep-     (n=268). The data
regulation in         comes from the
Spanish               initial assessment
pre-schoolers         (September‒
during the            December 2019)
COVID-19              and the second
lockdown              evaluation in
(Alonso-              March‒April
Martinez et al.       2020)
2021)
Physicalactivity     Spain (Children Cross-         Screen time        Screen time         Significant      Increased          (+)
and Daily            aged 0‒12 years sectional      during                                 (p=0.013)       (boys>girls)
Routine among        (n=837), 50.2%                 COVID-19
Children Aged        boys (n=420)                   Screen time        Daily screen        Significant        Increased        (+)
0‒12 during          and 49.8%                      during             time                (p=0.000)      (older>younger)
the COVID-19         girls (n=417))                 COVID-19
Pandemic in                                         by age
Spain (Cachon-
                                                    Screen time        The highest         Significant          n/a            n/a
Zagalaz et al.
                                                    during             screen time was     (p=0.043)
2021)
                                                    COVID-19 by        in children with
                                                    family type        single parents
                                                                       compared to
                                                                       other children
                                                    Screen time        The more active     Significant      Decreased           (-)
                                                    during             children, the       (p=0.018)
                                                    COVID-19 by        screen time will
                                                    children’s level   decrease
                                                    of active
Nutritional status
Paediatric BMI       United State of      Cohort    BMI changes        Children aged       Significant       Increased      Potentially
changes during       America (Children              (∆BMI) vs age      6‒9 years           (p=0.002)                           (+)
COVID-19             aged 6‒17 years                group
pandemic: An         (n=191,846) with
electronic health    details taken from
                                                                       Children aged       Significant       Increased      Potentially
record-based         the results of the
                                                                       10‒13 years         (p=0.003)                           (+)
retrospective        WCC U.S
cohort study         Electronic Health
(Brooks et al.       Record (EHR)
                                                                       Children aged          Not               n/a            n/a
2021)                data from
                                                                       14‒17 years         significant
                     Optum 2017‒2019
                     (n=144,714)
                     and 2020 data
                     (n=47,132)
Projecting the       United State of      Cohort    BMI and            BMI in girls in     Significant       Increased         (+)
impact of the        America (Children              Childhood          the group of         (p<0.05)
coronavirus          who come from                  Obesity            children with
disease              various                        Prevalence         COVID-19
(continue)           (continue)                                        compared to the
                                                                       control.
        Another cross-sectional study by Cachon-              have experienced an increase in BMI during the
Zagalaz et al. (2021) noted several results. They             COVID-19 pandemic. Both studies also reported
reported that screen time significantly increases             that obesity prevalence has inclined in girls and
in boys and girls. However, boys experienced a                boys.
higher increase in screen time than girls do. An                      Lange et al. (2021) have found increase in
identical condition has also been found in older              children’s BMI values. The BMI of children aged
children compared to younger ones (Cachon-                    2-19 years has doubled during the COVID-19
Zagalaz et al. 2021). Children with a single                  pandemic (Lange et al. 2021). Children who were
parent have more screen time than other children              initially overweight or obese before the pandemic
do although the difference was not significant                experienced a higher average BMI increase than
(p=0.043). Meanwhile, active children have                    children with a normal weight do (Lange et al.
shown less screen time than physically not active             2021). The increased BMI is triggered by an
children with a p-value of 0.018 (Cachon-Zagalaz              online or hybrid environment which reduces
et al. 2021).                                                 children’s opportunities to do physical activities
        According to Musa et al. (2021), screen use           or obtain healthy food as provided at school
was necessary during the COVID-19 pandemic.                   (Lange et al. 2021).
Parents are strongly advised to have vigilance of                     Another study has revealed a change in the
screen-time sedentary behaviour as a precursor of             Z-score of children during the pandemic (Weaver
NCDs (Musa et al. 2022). Another study deploys                et al. 2021). Weaver et al. (2021) also state that
that increasing screen time in children during the            girls have a higher increment of the z-score than
pandemic is unavoidable, but screen time not for              boys do. They argue that this change was caused
school purposes or learning activities should be              by children’s difficulty to access scheduled
limited (Olive et al. 2021). Olive et al. (2021)              regular activities, compulsory physical activities,
mentioned that an increase in screen time can                 and physical education at school (Weaver et al.
usually be accompanied by sleep disturbances,                 2021). Children also experienced food insecurity
mental health problems, and physical activity                 since they cannot access healthy food usually
issue that strongly urge all families to significantly        provided by the school as well as experience
deal with this issue (Olive et al. 2021).                     changes in sleeping time; both were factors
                                                              triggering overweight and obesity (Weaver et al.
Nutritional status of children during the                     2021).
COVID-19 pandemic
        Two studies reported a significant increase                                 CONCLUSION
in children’s BMI as presented in Table 1. Brooks
et al. (2021) report that children aged 6‒9 years                    This review has generally shown the
and 10‒13 years significantly increased their                 advanced risk of overweight and obesity in
BMI; this condition did not occur among children              childhood during the pandemic. The results of
aged 14‒17 years. An (2020) reports that girls                the review strengthen other studies that underline
a potentially grown prevalence of overweight and       Brooks CG, Spencer JR, Sprafka JM, Roehl KA,
obesity. Therefore, the results of this review could         Ma J, Londhe AA, He F, Cheng A, Brown
serve as a consideration to determine a better               CA, Page J. 2021. Pediatric bmi changes
preventive strategy for dealing with the prevalence          during covid-19 pandemic: An electronic
of overweight and obesity in children. Some                  health      record-based        retrospective
strategies include adding or activating children’s           cohort       study.       Eclinicalmedicine
daily physical activities at home and at school.             38:101026.        https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
The unavoidable increase in screen time due to               eclinm.2021.101026
the pandemic must be immediately addressed             Cachon-Zagalaz J, Zagalaz-Sanchez Ma,
to increase children’s physical activities outside           Arufe-Giraldez V, Sanmiguel-Rodriguez
school hours at home. All parties must respond               A, Gonzalez-Valero G. 2021. Physical
to changes in the nutritional status of children             activity and daily routine among children
by suppressing the causative factors, such as                aged 0‒12 during the covid-19 pandemic
low physical activities, increased sedentary                 in Spain. Int J Environ Res Public Health
lifestyle, and screen time, during the pandemic.             18(2):703.          https://doi.org/10.3390/
                                                             ijerph18020703
           ACKNOWLEDGEMENT                             Chooi YC, Ding C, Magkos F. 2019. The
                                                             epidemiology of obesity. Metabolism
       The authors would like to thank the                   92:6‒10.          https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Professional Study Program, Department of                    metabol.2018.09.005
Nutrition, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universitas     Chusna PA, Utami ADM. 2020. Dampak
Brawijaya Malang for their support.                          pandemi COVID-19 terhadap peran
                                                             orang tua dan guru dalam meningkatkan
      DECLARATION OF CONFLICT                                kualitas pembelajaran daring anak usia
           OF INTERESTS                                      sekolah dasar. Premiere: Journal of Islamic
                                                             Elementary Education 2(1):11‒30. https://
       The authors state that there is no conflict           doi.org/10.51675/jp.v2i1.84
of interest in the implementation of this research     Cucinotta D, Vanellli M. 2020. Who declares
from start to finish.                                        covid-19 a pandemic. Acta Biomedi
                                                             91(1):157‒160. https://doi.org/10.23750/
                 REFERENCES                                  abm.v91i1.9397
                                                       Dunton GF, Do B, Wang SD. 2020. Early effects
Alonso-Martinez AM, Ramirez-Velez R, Garcia-                 of the covid-19 pandemic on physical
     Alonso Y, Izquierdo M, Garcia-Hermoso                   activity and sedentary behavior in children
     A. 2021. Physical activity, sedentary                   living in the US. BMC Public Health
     behavior, sleep and self-regulation in                  20(1):1‒13.         https://doi.org/10.1186/
     Spanish preschoolers during the covid-19                s12889-020-09429-3
     lockdown. Int J Environ Res Public                [GNR] Global Nutrition Report. 2022.
     Health 18(2):693. https://doi.org/10.3390/              Country nutrition profiles. GNR https://
     ijerph18020693                                          globalnutritionreport.org/resources/
An R. 2020. Projecting the impact of the                     nutrition-profiles/asia/south-eastern-asia/
     coronavirus disease-2019 pandemic on                    indonesia [Accessed 28th April 2022].
     childhood obesity in The United States:           Gilbert AS, Schmidt L, Beck A, Kepper MM,
     A microsimulation model. J Sport Health                 Mazzucca S, Eyler A. 2021. Associations of
     Sci 9:302‒312. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.               physical activity and sedentary behaviors
     jshs.2020.05.006                                        with child mental well-being during the
Arum AE, Susilaningsih E. 2020. Pembelajaran                 covid-19 pandemic. BMC Public Health
     Daring dan Kajian Dampak Pandemi                        21(1):1‒12.         https://doi.org/10.1186/
     Covid-19 di Sekolah Dasar Kecamatan                     s12889-021-11805-6
     Muncar Prosiding Seminar Nasional                 Gobbi E, Maltagliati S, Sarrazin P, Di Fronso S,
     Pascasarjana (page 438‒444), 2020.                      Colangelo A, Cheval B, Escriva-Boulley
     Semarang (ID): UNNES.                                   G, Tessier D, Demirhan G, Erturan G
                                                             et al. 2020. Promoting physical activity
      during school closures imposed by the                2021. Impact of the covid-19 pandemic on
      first wave of the covid-19 pandemic:                 sedentary time and behaviour in children
      Physical education teachers' behaviors in            and adults: A systematic review and meta-
      France, Italy and Turkey. Int J Environ Res          analysis. Int J Environ Res Public Health
      Public Health 17(24):9431. https://doi.              18(21):11286.       https://doi.org/10.3390/
      org/10.3390/ijerph17249431                           ijerph182111286
Lange SJ, Kompaniyets L, Freedman DS, Kraus          Sahoo K, Sahoo B, Choudhury AK, Sofi NY,
      EM, Porter R, Black HM, Goodman AB.                  Kumar R, Bhadoria AS. 2015. Childhood
      2021. Longitudinal trends in body mass               obesity: Causes and consequences. J
      index before and during the covid-19                 Family Med Prim Care 4(2):187‒192.
      pandemic among persons aged 2‒19 years-              https://doi.org/10.4103/2249-4863.154628
      United States, 2018‒2020. Morb Mortal          Stverakova T, Jacisko J, Busch A, Safarova M,
      Wkly Rep 70(37):1278‒1283. https://doi.              Kolar P, Kobesova A. 2021. The impact
      org/10.15585/mmwr.mm7037a3                           of covid-19 on physical activity of Czech
Megawati RN, Norazizah R, Sofia N. 2021.                   Children. Plos One 16(7):e0254244. https://
      Pengaruh sedentary behavior terhadap                 doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0254244
      obesitas pada anak sekolah. Jurnal             Ten Velde G, Lubrecht J, Arayess L, Van Loo C,
      Kebidanan 11(2):651‒661. https://doi.                Hesselink M, Reijnders D, Vreugdenhil
      org/10.33486/jurnal_kebidanan.v11i2.152              A. 2021. Physical activity behaviour and
Moore SA, Faulkner G, Rhodes RE, Brussoni                  screen time in Dutch Children during
      M, Chulak-Bozzer T, Ferguson LJ, Mitra               the covid-19 pandemic: Pre-, during-
      R, O'reilly N, Spence JC, Vanderloo                  and post-school closures. Pediatr Obes
      LM, Tremblay MS. 2020. Impact of the                 16(9):e12779.       https://doi.org/10.1111/
      covid-19 virus outbreak on movement                  ijpo.12779
      and play behaviours of Canadian children       Treuth MS, Baggett CD, Pratt CA, Going SB,
      and youth: A national survey. Int J Behav            Elder JP, Charneco EY, Webber LS. 2009.
      Nutr Phys Act 17(1):1‒11. https://doi.               A longitudinal study of sedentary behavior
      org/10.1186/s12966-020-00987-8                       and overweight in adolescent girls. Obesity
Musa S, Elyamani R, Dergaa I. 2022. Covid-19               17(5):1003‒1008. https://doi.org/10.1038/
      and screen-based sedentary behaviour:                oby.2008.598
      Systematic review of digital screen time       Vilchez JA, Kruse J, Puffer M, Dudovitz RN.
      and metabolic syndrome in adolescents.               2021. Teachers and school health leaders'
      Plos One 17(3):e0265560. https://doi.                perspectives on distance learning physical
      org/10.1371/journal.pone.0265560                     education during the covid-19 pandemic.
Olive LS, Sciberras E, Berkowitz TS, Hoare E,              J Sch Health 91(7):541‒549. https://doi.
      Telford RM, O'neil A, Mikocka-Walus                  org/10.1111/josh.13030
      A, Evans S, Hutchinson D, Mcgillivray          Weaver RG, Hunt ET, Armstrong B, Beets MW,
      JA et al. 2021. Child and parent                     Brazendale K, Turner-Mcgrievy G, Pate
      physical activity, sleep, and screen time            RR, Youngstedt SD, Dugger R, Parker H
      during covid-19 and associations with                et al. 2021. Covid-19 leads to accelerated
      mental health: Implications for future               increases in children's bmi z-score gain:
      psycho-cardiological     disease?     Front          An interrupted time-series study. Am J
      Psychiatry 2332. https://doi.org/10.3389/            Prev Med 61(4):e161‒e169. https://doi.
      fpsyt.2021.774858                                    org/10.1016/j.amepre.2021.04.007
Rachmawati Y, Kurniawati L, Suardi M. 2021.          Zheng C, Huang WY, Sheridan S, Sit CH,
      Curiosity in young children. Proceedings             Chen XK, Wong SH. 2020. Covid-19
      of The 5th International Conference on               pandemic brings a sedentary lifestyle
      Early Childhood Education (Icece 2020),              In Young Adults: A cross-sectional and
      15‒16 October. Bandung (ID): UPI.                    longitudinal study. medRxiv. https://doi.
Runacres A, Mackintosh KA, Knight RL, Sheeran              org/10.1101/2020.05.22.20110825
      L, Thatcher R, Shelley J, Mcnarry MA.