SA605WY
SA605WY
Alyazia Al TENEIJI
College of Interdisciplinary Studies, Zayed University
Abu Dhabi, UAE
Amira Al SHAER
College of Interdisciplinary Studies, Zayed University
Abu Dhabi, UAE
Ghaya Al JABERI
College of Interdisciplinary Studies, Zayed University
Abu Dhabi, UAE
Areej ELSAYARY
College of Interdisciplinary Studies, Zayed University
Abu Dhabi, UAE
ISBN: 978-1-950492-79-4
ISSN: 2771-0947
185 https://doi.org/10.54808/WMSCI2024.01.185
Proceedings of the 28th World Multi-Conference on Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics (WMSCI 2024)
important to understand how platforms may be influencing social comparisons on the platform [13]. Along with this,
mental health and self-esteem in order to support these objectives according to Jan et al. [3], when people view the profiles of others
[7]. Additionally, this research would directly contribute to while using Facebook, envy begins to spark towards those who
advancing several of the United Nations’ Sustainable appear superior or better off than them. He also found that
Development Goals, particularly Goal 3, which aims to ensure Facebook is often used to learn about and judge others based on
healthy lives and promote well-being for all at all ages [8]. With cues from their profiles. This can lead to upward social
social networking so ingrained in daily life, gathering insight into comparisons that make individuals feel inferior due to appearing
its relationship to aspects of well-being like anxiety, body image, less privileged than the lives of others shown online. Such
and self-confidence would prove valuable for developing negative feelings stemming from social comparisons directly
targeted strategies in line with the UAE's national vision and impact users' self-esteem levels [3]. Excessive social media
global priorities. engagement has also been tied to spending less time offline and
building confidence through meaningful activities and
2. LITERATURE REVIEW connections [15]. Another study specifically examining
Instagram usage linked viewing peers' seemingly "ideal"
When studying the impact that social media has on self-esteem, lifestyles with worse depression and body image in teen girls
Social Cognitive Theory provides a useful framework. LaMorte [14]. This previous empirical work and application of Social
[9] explains that Social Cognitive Theory was developed by Cognitive Theory justify further investigating relationships
Albert Bandura to explain human learning and behavior. At its between social media usage patterns, social comparison
root, the theory proposes that portions of an individual's processes, and impacts on self-esteem among young adults.
knowledge acquisition and behavior can come from observation
of and interaction with others within social, environmental, and 3. METHODOLOGY
psychological contexts. When applied to social media usage,
people may model behaviors and form perceptions of norms This study adopts an observational design to investigate the
based on what they see from others online [9]. This theory relationship between social media use and self-esteem over time.
underscores that individuals learn not solely from their personal Respondents will be asked to complete questionnaires on a bi-
experiences but also through observing and imitating others [10]. monthly basis. As an observational study, the design is non-
For example, through social comparison on platforms, users experimental; participants are not exposed to manipulated
could come to evaluate themselves based on heavily curated conditions by researchers. Rather, the researcher observes and
representations they observe [1]. Exposure to seemingly perfect collects data on existing behaviors, attitudes, and experiences as
highlight reels may diminish how positively they view their own they naturally occur [16]. This investigation employs an
lives and capabilities through observational learning processes as observational cross-sectional design. Cross-sectional studies
outlined by Social Cognitive Theory [11]. The relationship collect data on exposures and outcomes from a population at a
between social media usage and self-esteem has been the subject single point in time [18]. In this case, self-reported social media
of extensive research, with various theories and perspectives usage and self-esteem data will be collected via bi-monthly
contributing to understanding this dynamic interaction. Building questionnaires, but each assessment represents a distinct
upon previous research, studies conducted over the past few snapshot of their social media usage and self-esteem levels at that
decades have explored the impact of social media on individuals' particular time. This allows researchers to monitor how social
beliefs and overall well-being, with a particular focus on young media exposures, as they naturally vary, may impact changes in
adults. Notably, these studies, such as those conducted by self-esteem outcomes within the cohort over time. Unlike
Steinsbekk et al. [12], have revealed that self-perceived physical experimental designs, exposures are not actively manipulated by
appearance significantly influences overall self-esteem among researchers [18]. In summary, while this study uses an
young adults. Moreover, further research has shown a significant observational methodology of repeated surveys, its cross-
connection between social media use and decreased self-esteem, sectional design strengthens the ability to assess how social
particularly among young adult females. Studies conducted by media may influence self-esteem.
researchers at Facebook found that exposure to overly positive
portrayals of peers' lives on the platform led to greater social Target population
comparison [1]. Furthermore, Dr. Hamlet from the Child Mind A sampling method will recruit university students aged 18-25,
Institute notes that constant viewing of curated, potentially as emerging adulthood is optimal for exploring social media's
photoshopped photos on friends' and influencers' accounts can potential impacts on developing self-esteem. The late teens
negatively impact self-confidence in teenage girls [15]. These through mid-twenties period involve important identity
studies provide support for how Social Cognitive Theory can development. This occurs alongside widespread social media use
help explain relationships between social media use and self- for social interaction [19]. That is why universities provide
esteem. According to Social Cognitive Theory, human learning access to students experiencing parallel transitions because they
and behavior are influenced by observing and interacting with contain the majority of young adults with different backgrounds,
others [11]. Additional studies have found that greater Facebook ethnicities, religions, and genders.
usage is correlated with lower reported self-esteem and life
satisfaction, partially explained by a tendency towards upward
186
Proceedings of the 28th World Multi-Conference on Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics (WMSCI 2024)
187
Proceedings of the 28th World Multi-Conference on Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics (WMSCI 2024)
5. FIGURES AND TABLES The cross-tabulation table shows the distribution of participant
age and self-esteem scores from the survey data. Along with this,
it provides insight into the relationships that will be explored
through further statistical tests.. A total of 75 participants are
represented in the table. This cross-tabulation analysis allows us
to examine patterns in the data, such as if and how self-esteem
may vary across different age groups.
The line graph in Figure 1 illustrates the relationship between age age category. This pattern provides initial insight into how self-
and self-esteem among the participants. As portrayed on the perceptions of worth may develop over this life stage, with older
graph, there were no participants in the survey aged 22. The y- participants generally reporting higher self-esteem than their
axis represents the percentage of self-esteem scores within each younger counterparts.
188
Proceedings of the 28th World Multi-Conference on Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics (WMSCI 2024)
6. RESULTS
The study's findings support the hypothesis that a significant
negative correlation exists between social media usage and self-
This section provides a detailed analysis of the relationships
esteem among young adults aged 18-25. The analysis reveals an
between social media usage, age, and self-esteem among young
inverse relationship between age and self-esteem, indicating a
adults aged 18-25. The findings contribute to our understanding
general increase in self-esteem as age progresses.
of well-being and digital life, offering insights into the intricate
Simultaneously, the data underscores a negative association
189
Proceedings of the 28th World Multi-Conference on Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics (WMSCI 2024)
between social media engagement and self-esteem, suggesting to imply a strong or moderate dominance of social media on self-
that higher levels of social media usage correlate with lower self- esteem levels. The negative correlation coefficient supports the
esteem on average. While acknowledging the complexity of this hypothesis and aligns with previous research that has found links
relationship and recognizing age-specific nuances, these results between greater social media use and lower self-esteem
contribute valuable insights into the intricate dynamics of self- (Bergagna & Tartaglia, 2018). These findings are consistent with
esteem development in the digital age. The study highlights the the theorized relationship suggested by Social Cognitive Theory
need for ongoing investigations to validate these trends and to and the studies discussed in the introduction. Also, the table
consider individual differences, content consumption, and results provide additional support for the hypothesis. The mean
diverse experiences that play pivotal roles in shaping self-esteem self-esteem level for participants after limiting social media
among young adults in the context of social media use. These usage (mean = 6.72, SD = 2.010) is higher than the mean self-
findings are essential for informing interventions and strategies esteem level for participants overall (mean = 6.48, SD = 1.968).
aimed at promoting positive digital well-being in this This suggests that reducing social media usage may have a
demographic. positive impact on self-esteem. The mean shock media usage
score (mean = 5.393, SD = 2.585) also indicates that participants
7. DISCUSSION reported moderate levels of exposure to shocking or distressing
media content (Jan et al., 2017). Figure 2 similarly showed
The results of the study provide mixed support for the hypothesis decreasing self-esteem corresponding to increasing social media
that higher social media use is significantly correlated with lower hours. These findings are consistent with the theory and studies
self-esteem among young adults. Previous literature highlighted discussed in the introduction. Therefore, taken together the
in the review suggested potential detrimental effects. In mixed quantitative and qualitative findings collectively
particular, past research found social media negatively impacted suggested higher social media usage is associated with lower
self-esteem in young adult females specifically [12]. Studies by reported self-esteem levels among young adults.
Facebook researchers also demonstrated that exposure to
seemingly positive portrayals of peers' lives on social media led 8. LIMITATIONS
to greater social comparison and lower reported self-esteem [1].
These prior findings align with the proposed hypothesis, The study faced several limitations that should be acknowledged.
indicating social media use may indeed negatively influence self- For example, while we aimed to recruit a sample of 200
perception. The present study's results from Figure 1 partially university students, we only obtained responses from 75
support this relationship. Specifically, studies by Orth and participants, making the sample size relatively small. This
Robins (2014) as well as Jan et al. (2017) found that self-esteem limited our statistical power to detect possible effects. As an
tends to increase substantially during emerging adulthood as observational study relying entirely on self-reported data, we
identity develops. Consistent with this, the current study found could only examine associations and not determine causality, as
The graph shows Participants aged 18 showed low self-esteem experimental manipulation was not possible. Our use of
levels, while those aged 19 showed slightly higher self-esteem. voluntary response sampling also introduced potential self-
Self-esteem levels increased further for participants in the 20-21 selection bias, since the study relied on self-report measures for
age range, with the highest levels observed for participants aged both social media use and self-esteem. Self-report measures are
23-24 [12]. These findings suggest that self-esteem may subject to biases, such as social desirability and recall bias. The
fluctuate throughout the young adult years. This preliminary use of objective measures, such as behavioral observations or
evidence tentatively aligns with predictions. However, it is physiological indicators, could provide a more objective
important to note that increasing self-esteem with age does not assessment of social media use and its effects on self-esteem as
directly prove the influence of social media usage. Other factors, the sample may have overrepresented more engaged students and
such as natural maturation, could explain this pattern [12]. not fully captured the target population. Another limitation was
Therefore, the graph showing the relationship between age and the cross-sectional design, providing only a snapshot rather than
self-esteem levels, while informative, does not alone establish a potential long-term changes. As a cross-sectional rather than
causal link between social media use and self-esteem. Along with cohort study, it could not assess impacts over an extended period.
this the results from the study's data analysis in Table 3, including The short duration limited the examination's long-term
the correlation coefficient of -0.2035, indicate a weak negative influences on outcomes. Additionally, self-report measures are
correlation between social media use and self-esteem. This subject to biases like social desirability influencing portrayals.
finding suggests that while a negative correlation was observed Rather than subjective self-assessments alone, employing
between social media usage and self-esteem, supporting the objective behavioral observations of actual engagement or
hypothesis that a relationship exists, the relatively weak physiological indicators may have provided a more holistic
magnitude of the correlation coefficient indicates the relationship perspective to account for responses being skewed positive.
is not as robust as initially hypothesized. Specifically, the small Alongside this, the results suggest that the relationship between
correlation value implies that social media usage alone accounts social media use and self-esteem is complex and may vary
for only a minor portion of the variation seen in self-esteem depending on other factors. Future research should consider
scores, with other unmeasured factors likely having a stronger incorporating additional variables, such as personality and family
influence. Larger correlation values would have been necessary factors, and social support was also not able to be controlled for.
190
Proceedings of the 28th World Multi-Conference on Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics (WMSCI 2024)
191
Proceedings of the 28th World Multi-Conference on Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics (WMSCI 2024)
192