Flack 2016
Flack 2016
6, 2016
DOI: 10.1007/s11664-016-4435-3
 2016 The Minerals, Metals & Materials Society
                      1.—Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Texas Tech University, 1012 Boston
                      Avenue, Lubbock, TX 79409, USA. 2.—e-mail: tyler.flack@ttu.edu
                                                                                                                    2673
2674                                                                              Flack, Pushpakaran, and Bayne
considered. Finally, a brief discussion of prototypes      4H-SiC. In addition, GaN exhibits critical electric
currently employing GaN devices is given.                  field strength of about 11 times greater than Si and
                                                           only slightly smaller than 4H-SiC. GaN is not,
  MATERIAL PROPERTIES COMPARISON:                          however, without disadvantages as a material for
           Si, SiC AND GaN                                 use in power devices, specifically thermal conduc-
                                                           tivity. As illustrated in Table I, GaN’s thermal
   Properties of semiconductor materials relevant to
                                                           conductivity is less than both 4H-SiC (roughly four
power devices include bandgap (Eg), critical field
                                                           times lower) and Si.
strength (Ec), carrier mobility (l), and thermal
conductivity.2 The bandgap of a material determi-
nes the carriers generated in the depletion region of                 BULK GaN FABRICATION
a semiconductor device; a larger bandgap correlates
to lower intrinsic carrier concentration, thus, lower         Due to inherently beneficial material properties,
levels of leakage current during blocking condi-           as detailed in the previous section, it is reasonable
tions.3 Critical field strength directly impacts the       to see why there is so much focus on GaN as a
on-state resistance of the drift region in a vertical      prospect for the manufacture of wide bandgap
power device: the larger the critical field strength,      power switching devices. There is, however, a
the smaller the drift region thickness, and hence,         disparity between theoretical material properties
the lower the on-state resistance; leading to a            and realizable device properties for GaN. Specifi-
reduction in conduction losses.4 The relationships         cally for the fabrication of GaN power devices, the
of critical field strength of a material to the on-state   lack of bulk-quality GaN for native device growth is
resistance of a vertical unipolar power device and a       a big issue. Additionally, GaN fabrication suffers
lateral high electron mobility transistor (HEMT)           typical fabrication issues (i.e. economics of available
device are shown in Eqs. 1 and 2, respectively.5,6         processes, packaging concerns, etc.) In order to
                                                           address these concerns, research is continuously
                                  4  BV                   ongoing to produce affordable, high-quality bulk
             Ron ðverticalÞ ¼                       ð1Þ    GaN for fabrication of devices9,10 as well as the
                                es  l  E3c
                                                           resulting vertical device profiles.11,12 Additionally,
                                                           research into GaN devices fabricated on non-native
                                 BV2
           Ron ðHEMTÞ ¼                             ð2Þ    substrate materials (i.e. Si and SiC) is being con-
                           q  l  Qs  E2c                ducted.13–17 Research conducted on high-quality
                                                           bulk GaN is necessary for the realization of vertical
  A standard method of summarizing the efficacy of         power structures (i.e. power PIN diodes, vertical
a material as a power switching device is to use           MOSFETs, etc.) Vertical unipolar power device
baliga’s figure-of-merit (BFOM) given by Eqs. 3 and        structures (e.g. power MOSFETs) are desirable for
4 for vertical devices and lateral high-electron           their ease of control and high voltage capabilities
mobility transistors, respectively.6 These equations       (without sacrificing current capabilities)18 Vertical
indicate how fundamental material properties influ-        GaN p-n diodes were tested for avalanche capabil-
ence the resistance of a power switching device.5          ities in Ref. 12, and a general overview of research
                                                           into GaN p-n devices based on extremely low defect
           BFOM ðverticalÞ ¼ es  l  E3c           ð3Þ    (104–106 cm2) GaN native substrates has been
                                                           discussed in Ref. 11.
         BFOMðHEMTÞ ¼ q  l  Qs  E2c              ð4Þ       For the fabrication of high-quality GaN to be used
                                                           as substrate material epitaxial growth processes are
where es is the dielectric constant of the semicon-        used. This is due to traditional methods of crystal
ductor material, l is the mobility of free carriers        growth (e.g. Czochralski growth) are not viable for
(electrons in the case of a unipolar vertical device),     nitride materials.14 Common examples of these
Qs is the sheet carrier density (in HEMT structures)       processes are ammonothermal growth, liquid phase
and Ec is the critical electric field of a given           epitaxy (LPE) (or solution growth) and hydride
semiconductor material. Thermal conductivity is            vapor phase epitaxy (HVPE).9,19–23 Each of these
paramount when designing power devices, as it is           processes has inherent advantages and disadvan-
the ability of a material to dissipate generated heat;     tages associated with growth rates, dislocation
materials with high thermal conductivity require           densities and repeatability.
minimal external heat sinking, thus lowering sys-             HVPE is an epitaxial growth process which
tem cost. Material properties of Si, 4H-SiC and GaN        utilizes a halide vapor and a hydride as group III
are provided in Table I.7,8                                and group V precursors, respectively.24 Halides
   Table I illustrates GaN’s inherent benefits when        exhibit large surface migration and good thermal
compared with Si (traditional power devices) and           stability which, paired with pure seed materials
4H-SiC (currently the wide bandgap material of             allow the HVPE process to produce high growth
choice for power devices). GaN exhibits a bandgap          rates relative to LPE and ammonothermal growth
roughly three times that of Si and 1.1 times that of       techniques. HVPE is currently a dominant force in
GaN Technology for Power Electronic Applications: A Review                                                        2675
commercialized GaN bulk materials. Boasting high                  (10 lm/h). It is imperative that the inherent
growth rates (£300 lm/h), control of impurities                   scalability of this process be exploited to combat
(doping), high volume output, relatively large wafer              these very low growth rates.
size and high purity of resulting substrates are the
primary advantages of this process.23 GaN sub-                                DEVICE FABRICATION
strates produced using HVPE are not without their
                                                                    Several thin film growth techniques are currently
limitations, specifically material uniformity is not
                                                                  used for the heteroepitaxial growth of GaN on non-
quite up to par with some of the competing growth
                                                                  native substrates; namely HVPE, molecular beam
mechanisms. Additionally, HVPE GaN substrates
                                                                  epitaxy (MBE) and metalorganic chemical vapor
suffer from high strain resulting in bowing and
                                                                  deposition (MOCVD); MOCVD is currently the most
cracking at the interface of GaN and the non-native
                                                                  widely implemented method.27 These techniques
substrate material used for growth due to mis-
                                                                  were used, at first, to grow thin-films of GaN
matches in their thermal expansion coefficients.
                                                                  directly onto non-native substrate materials (e.g.
Recent research advances in GaN-on-sapphire and
                                                                  sapphire or SiC), typically resulting in large
GaN-on-Si processing to reduce cracking have been
                                                                  amounts of defects extending through the thin-film
able to reduce some of the limitations due to bowing
                                                                  material and rough surfaces. However, circa 1986,
and cracking. Results of this experimentation on
                                                                  Amono et al. published results of a great technical
thick GaN films to be used as freestanding substrate
                                                                  innovation in GaN device fabrication using the
material using the HVPE process, presented in,19
                                                                  MOCVD technique to grow GaN epitaxially on a
yield a 600-lm-thick (crack-free) GaN film with
                                                                  sapphire substrate. Through the use of an alu-
dislocation densities lower than 1 9 106 cm2. In
                                                                  minum nitride (AlN) buffer layer, the GaN surface
this research, two commercial 2-in. (c.5-cm) sap-
                                                                  manifested in a much smoother form, substantially
phire substrate were processed simultaneously. The
                                                                  increasing both the optical and electrical properties
first sapphire substrate was processed using a laser-
                                                                  of thin-film GaN layers grown.28 Important to note
induced stress process, detailed in Refs. 25 and 26,
                                                                  is the required high source-drain activation tem-
while the second substrate was processed without
                                                                  perature of 1100–1200C,29 which requires special
using the laser process.
                                                                  attention to desired gate-oxide materials for use in
   The ammonothermal growth process is quite
                                                                  MOSFET structures.
similar to other processes used to produce other
materials, such as quartz, at very high volumes
                                                                        LATERAL DEVICE STRUCTURES
with great quality.23 The process uses a solvent
comprised of supercritical ammonia with added                       GaN-based power semiconductors are largely
mineralizers to grow GaN via recrystallization at                 lateral structures, such as HEMTs shown in
seed crystals.23 Ammonothermal growth has the                     Fig. 1. This structure is a heterostructure which
benefit of being a true-bulk process, meaning the                 utilizes the inherently polarized nature of GaN to
process does not require a non-native starting                    develop a 2-degree electron gas layer to achieve high
substrate.22 Other benefits of the ammonothermal                  electron mobility.30,31
process include the potentially huge scalability and                GaN HEMTs have numerous operational benefits,
reduction of manufacturing cost.23 Detriments to                  including high-frequency operation in power appli-
the ammonothermal process include very slow                       cations, large breakdown fields and good transport
growth rates (72 times slower than HVPE), small                  properties.32 GaN HEMT structures are not without
resulting wafer size and greater complexity of                    deficiencies, one of which is that, in order for this
growth chemistry. Research in the production of                   structure to obtain suitably high breakdown volt-
large-size substrate quality GaN wafers, via the                  ages, a large amount of space must be left between
ammonothermal process, have yielded 1-in. (c.2.5-                 the gate and drain of the device. This causes the
cm) GaN wafers with defect densities of 5 9 103                  current density ratings of HEMT devices to be
cm2.22 It is important to note even in these                     inherently low, thereby increasing the cost to
promising results, growth rates are still very low                current density ratio.30 Additionally, HEMT
2676                                                                                        Flack, Pushpakaran, and Bayne
Fig. 1. Generic AlGaN/GaN HEMT structure30    2015 IEEE. Rep-    off operation. Important to note is that this device
rinted, with permission, from Ref. 30.                            structure is not without setbacks, namely high-
                                                                  temperature operation is expected to be severely
                                                                  limited due to the inclusion of a Si device.
                                                                        Fig. 6. HFET with buried p-type GaN buffer layers38    2015 Else-
                                                                        vier. Reprinted, with permission, from Ref. 38.
operation between the two JFET device structures                       the resistance of the device during the on-state. As
has to do with the channel structures. In the                          for the lateral channel structure, the amount the
vertical channel structure, the width and thickness                    gate contact overlaps the p-type layer controls the
of the current aperture are used to control the                        amount of modulation of electrons transported
amount of leakage current in the off-state as well as                  through the channel. Thus, this metric is used to
                                                                       control the amount of leakage current in the off-
                                                                       state of the device.
                                                                         The performance of devices discussed in this
                                                                       review are summarized in Table II, additionally
                                                                       this table provides a comparison of these two
                                                                       devices with available power devices (both GaN
                                                                       and SiC).39,42 In addition this research used these
                                                                       two structures to investigate the impact of mobility
                                                                       on breakdown voltage and RON, it is shown that as
                                                                       mobility goes down breakdown voltage increases;
                                                                       the same is true for RON, as mobility decreased RON
                                                                       increased.
                                                                    Fig. 12. Sine wave power output from a GaN-based inverter motor
                                                                    drive operating at 100-kHz switching frequency47  2013
                                                                    Transphorm. Reprinted, with permission.
Fig. 10. 4-kW three-phase inverter evaluation kit developed46   
2013 Transphorm. Reprinted, with permission.
                                                                    half-bridges. The inverter operates at a switching
                                                                    frequency of 100 kHz which is beneficial in reducing
   The converter was designed for an output bus                     harmonics and increasing overall operational effi-
voltage of 400 V. The converter was able to main-                   ciency. Figure 10 shows the three-phase motor drive
tain an efficiency of over 98% in the entire range of               evaluation unit.46
output load varying from 700 W to 2 kW. An                             The high frequency operation helps in reducing
efficiency of over 99% was obtained for power output                the size of energy storage elements thereby result-
in the range 2–4 kW. At an output power of 5 kW,                    ing in a compact filter design. The GaN inverter
the converter was able to achieve an efficiency of                  motor drive was compared to an equivalent system
98.5%. The complete hardware unit had a mass of                     designed using state-of-the-art silicon IGBT. The
approximately 487 g which corresponds to a gravi-                   sinusoidal output waveforms obtained from both the
metric power density of approximately 10 kW/kg.                     systems have been compared in Figs. 11 and 12.47
The high system efficiency translates to lower losses                  The spike-free pure sine wave output from the
thereby requiring only passive air cooling.43–45                    GaN-based inverter significantly improved the
                                                                    motor efficiency. The efficiency of the GaN-based
4-kW Three-Phase Inverter Evaluation Kit                            inverter including filer loss was higher than the
   The 4-kW three-phase inverter was developed by                   silicon IGBT-based system (w/o filter loss) as shown
Transphorm to evaluate the performance advan-                       in Fig. 13. An overall increase in the system effi-
tages of GaN semiconductor in motor drive applica-                  ciency (including motor efficiency) was observed in
tions. The three-phase inverter is formed by six                    the GaN-based inverter drive as shown in
GaN HEMTs in a module configured as three 600-V                     Fig. 14.47,48
2680                                                                                               Flack, Pushpakaran, and Bayne
Fig. 13. Comparison of efficiency and power loss with respect to the
power output of a GaN-based inverter and a Si IGBT-based in-
verter48  2014 Transphorm. Reprinted, with permission.                Fig. 16. Comparison of system efficiency with respect to the power
                                                                       output of GaN-based PFC circuit to silicon power MOSFET-based
                                                                       version 50  2014 Transphorm. Reprinted, with permission.
27. S. Pearton, C. Abernathy, and F. Ren, Gallium Nitride          41. I. Ben-Yaacov, Y.-K. Seck, and U. Mishra, J. Appl. Phys.
    Processing for Electronics, Sensors and Spintronics (Lon-          95, 2073 (2004).
    don: Springer, 2006), p. 1.                                    42. S.-H. Ryu, S. Krishnaswami, B. Hull, J. Richmond, A.
28. H. Amano, N. Sawaki, I. Akasaki, and Y. Toyoda, Appl.              Agarwal, and A. Hefner, IEEE International Symposium
    Phys. Lett. 48, 353 (1986).                                        on Power Semiconductor Devices and IC’s (ISPSD), 2006,
29. S. Pearton, C. Abernathy, and F. Ren, Gallium Nitride              pp.1–4.
    Processing for Electronics, Sensors and Spintronics (Lon-      43. A. Bindra. GaN Power Modules Promise To Raise The
    don: Springer, 2006), p. 313.                                      Performance Bar. How2Power Today, 2013, pp. 1–4.
30. T. Heidel, P. Gradzki, and D. Henshall, 73rd Annual De-        44. GaN Systems Corp. APEI and GaN Systems Demonstrate
    vice Research Conference (DRC), pp.27–28, 21–24 (2015).            High Efficiency DC-DC Boost Converter with Ultra-High
31. U. Mishra, P. Parikh, and Y.-F. Wu, Proc. IEEE 90, 1022            Speed Gallium Nitride Switch. (Thomas Publishing Com-
    (2002).                                                            pany, 2013). Web. http://www.gansystems.com/_uploads/
32. Y.-F. Wu, D. Kapolnek, J. Ibbetson, P. Parikh, B. Keller,          news/589943_0313%20GaN%20Systems%20APEI.pdf. Ac-
    and U. Mishra, IEEE T. Electron. Dev. 48, 586 (2001).              cessed 12 Feb 2015.
33. S. Hamady, Micro and nanotechnologies/Microelectronics         45. GaN Systems Inc. High efficiency 2 kW–5 kW boost con-
    (Toulouse: Universite Toulouse III Paul Sabatier, 2014).           verter. Application brief (2013).
34. T. Kikkawa, T. Hosoda, K. Shono, K. Imanishi, Y. Asai, Y.-     46. Transphorm Inc., Transphorm Motor-Drive Development
    F. Wu, L. Shen, K. Smith, D. Dunn, S. Chowdhury, P.                Kits, TDMC4000E0I datasheet (2013).
    Smith, J. Gritters, L. McCarthy, R. Barr, R. Lal, U. Mishra,   47. Y.-F. Wu, Applied Power Electronics Conference (2013).
    and P. Parikh, IEEE International Reliability Physics          48. K. Shirabe, M. Swamy, J.-K. Kang, M. Hisatsune, Y.-F. Wu,
    Symposium (IRPS), 2015, pp. 6C.1.1–6C.1.6, 19–23.                  D. Kebort, and J. Honea, IEEE T. Ind. Appl. 50, 566 (2014).
35. L.-Y. Su, F. Lee, and J. Huang, IEEE T. Electron. Dev. 61,     49. Transphorm Inc., GaN Power Low-Loss Switch,
    460 (2014).                                                        TPH3002PS datasheet (2014).
36. J. Du, D. Liu, Z. Bai, Y. Liu, and Q. Yu, Superlattices Mi-    50. Transphorm Inc., EZ-GaN Evaluation Board, 750 kHz
    crostruct. 85, 690 (2015).                                         PFC, TDPS300E1A8 datasheet (2014).
37. I. Kizilyalli, A. Edwards, O. Aktas, T. Prunty, and D. Bour,   51. A. Wienhausen and D. Kranzer, Mater. Sci. Forum 740–
    IEEE Trans. Electron Dev. 62, 414 (2015).                          742, 1123 (2013).
38. J. Du, D. Liu, Z. Zhao, Z. Bai, L. Li, J. Mo, and Q. Yu,       52. Fraunhofer-Institut Für Solare Energiesysteme ISE.
    Superlattices Microstruct. 83, 251 (2015).                         Towards Smaller Sizes, Lower Weight and Higher Effi-
39. D. Ji and S. Chowdhury, IEEE T Electron. Dev. 62, 2571             ciency with Gallium Nitride Devices. https://www.ise.
    (2015).                                                            fraunhofer.de/en/press-and-media/press-releases/press-
40. S. Chowdhury, M. Wong, B. Swenson, and U. Mishra,                  releases-2012/gallium-nitride-devices. Accessed 12 Feb
    IEEE Electron. Dev. 33, 41 (2012).                                 2015.