Report
Report
ABSTRACT
The objective of this paper is to design, simulate and check the performance analysis using
experimental setup of a DGS (Defected Ground Structure) low profile printed microstrip patch
antenna for multiband 5G wireless applications. The design is made using FR4 epoxy substrate
on the HFSS (High Frequency Structure Simulator) software with a compact size of 8x9 mm2
with operating frequencies 10.5GHz, 26.11GHz and 50.5GHz and the second design at 21.6
GHz, 26.11 GHz and 50.5 GHz. The relative dielectric permittivity and the thickness of the
substrate are 4.4 and 1.4mm. Main motive of this research is to analyse the performance of the
designed antenna in terms of gain, return loss, VSWR (Voltage Standing Wave Ratio) and
radiation pattern. The DGS is utilized for bandwidth improvement and for decreasing
interference in the communication system for 5G. This is done due to increased demand of
consumer for services requiring high data rates (greater than 10Gbps). Simulation results show
that such antennas can be used effectively since they are light weight, low in volume and
requires low fabrication cost and this is also validated by experimental results.
1
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
CHAPTER 1
1. INTRODUCTION
In this era of wireless communication, the major challenge which the cellular operators face is, to
provide high traffic capacity to the customers [1]. Apart from achieving high data rates, it is also
important that a communication network provides wide area coverage and low latency. 5G
serves this purpose, since it provides the customers with extraordinary bandwidth availability
with unlimited up gradation possibilities. It prompts spectrum harmonization which incorporates
encouraging economies of scale, empowering worldwide meandering, lessening hardware plan
multifaceted nature, safeguarding battery life, improving spectrum effectiveness and possibly
diminishing cross fringe obstruction [2, 3].
For 5G applications, microstrip patch antennas are profoundly prescribed as they are low-profile,
light-weight, involve low fabrication cost and has capacity of working over multiple frequency
bands and being patch in the meantime adds to its planar structure [4, 5]. But the limitation is its
narrow bandwidth which can be overcome by using slotted patch antennas [6, 7, 8]. Significant
efforts are made to lead to the miniaturisation of such antennas with robust construct and without
compromising with its capabilities [9].
The main motive of this paper is to design a concave rectangular shaped microstrip patch
antenna using low cost FR4 substrate and coaxial feed line which is based on CMOS technology
for simultaneous use of mobile phones using 5G network and to avoid shortage of bandwidth
[10].
In this paper, a simple low profile microstrip patch antenna is proposed which is designed to
perform at 10.5GHz, 26.11GHz and 50.5GHz frequencies. Simulations are analysed in terms of
gain, VSWR, return loss and radiation pattern and shows promising results [11]. After
fabrication, the physically obtained designed antenna is subjected to vector network analyser and
anechoic chamber testing for a frequency of 10.5GHz, 26.11GHz and 50.5 GHz for obtaining
further results experimentally. The designed antenna will then be capable of:
2
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Also known as a printed antenna usually means an antenna fabricated using microstrip
techniques on a printed circuit board (PCB)[20].It is a kind of internal antenna. They are mostly
used at microwave frequencies. An individual microstrip antenna consists of a patch of metal foil
of various shapes (a patch antenna) on the surface of a PCB (printed circuit board), with a metal
foil ground plane on the other side of the board. Most microstrip antennas consist of multiple
patches in a two-dimensional array [21]. The antenna is usually connected to the transmitter or
receiver through foil microstrip transmission lines. The radio frequency current is applied (or in
receiving antennas the received signal is produced) between the antenna and ground plane.
Microstrip antennas have become very popular in recent decades due to their thin planar profile
which can be incorporated into the surfaces of consumer products, aircraft and missiles; their
ease of fabrication using printed circuit techniques; the ease of integrating the antenna on the
same board with the rest of the circuit, and the possibility of adding active devices such as
microwave integrated circuits to the antenna itself to make active antennas [20].
1.1.1 Patch antenna
The most common type of microstrip antenna is the patch antenna. Antennas using patches as
constitutive elements in an array are also possible. A patch antenna is a narrowband, wide-beam
antenna fabricated by etching the antenna element pattern in metal trace bonded to an insulating
dielectric substrate, such as a printed circuit board, with a continuous metal layer bonded to the
opposite side of the substrate which forms a ground plane. Common microstrip antenna shapes
are square, rectangular, circular and elliptical, but any continuous shape is possible [20, 21, 22].
1.1.2 Advantages
Microstrip antennas are relatively inexpensive to manufacture and design because of the simple
2-dimensional physical geometry [20]. They are usually employed at UHF and higher
frequencies because the size of the antenna is directly tied to the wavelength at the resonant
frequency. A single patch antenna provides a maximum directive gain of around 6-9 dB. It is
relatively easy to print an array of patches on a single (large) substrate using lithographic
techniques [1].
3
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Metallic Patch: Is usually a copper metal which is placed at the top of the substrate and it
decides the radiation of the antenna.
Substrate: The substrate between patch and ground plane plays important role in design it
decides the bandwidth as well as size of the microstrip antenna.
Bandwidth increases with increase in substrate thickness or with decrease in dielectric constant.
However there is limit on increasing thickness if increased beyond h=0.1effective wavelength.
4
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Ground plane: As a field reflector and it has a large effect on the radiation patterns and the
resonance frequency you cold notice that by using numerical methods for analysing your
microstrip while most of the analytical methods assume that the ground plane is infinite in size
and hence no radiation fields appear in the back of microstrip[22,23].
1. Radiation Pattern
2. Beamwidth
3. Radiation Power Density
4. Radiation Intensity
5. Directivity
6. Antenna Efficiency and Gain
7. Polarization
5
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
There can be field patterns (magnitude of the electric or magnetic field) or power patterns
(square of the magnitude of the electric or magnetic field).
Often normalized with respect to their maximum value.
The power pattern is usually plotted on a logarithmic scale or more commonly in decibels
(dB).
Pattern:
E(θ, φ)= d, A = r 2 sinθdθdφ.
Azimuth: φ
Elevation: π/2−θ. 2
6
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
All three patterns yield the same angular separation between the two half power points, 38.64◦ ,
on their respective patterns, referred to as HPBW.
A radiation lobe is a portion of the radiation pattern bounded by regions of relatively weak
radiation intensity.
Main lobe
Minor lobes
Side lobes
Back lobes
Minor lobes:-Usually represent radiation in undesired directions, and they should be minimized.
Side lobes are normally the largest of the minor lobes.
The level of minor lobes is usually expressed as a ratio of the power density, often termed the
side lobe ratio or side lobe level.
7
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
In most radar systems, low side lobe ratios are very important to minimize false target
indications through the side lobes (e.g., -30 dB). Components in the Amplitude Pattern
There would be, in general, three electric-field components (Er, Eθ, Eφ) at each observation
point on the surface of a sphere of constant radius.
In the far field, the radial Er component for all antennas is zero or vanishingly small. • Some
antennas, depending on their geometry and also observation distance, may have only one, two, or
all three components[13,14,23].
1.2.2 Beamwidth
The beamwidth of an antenna is a very important figure of merit and often is used as a trade-off
between it and the side lobe level; that is, as the beamwidth decreases, the side lobe increases
and vice versa. The beamwidth of the antenna is also used to describe the resolution capabilities
of the antenna to distinguish between two adjacent radiating sources or radar targets.
Half-Power Beam Width (HPBW):- In a plane containing the direction of the maximum of a
beam, the angle between the two directions in which the radiation intensity is one-half value of
the beam.
First-Null Beamwidth (FNBW):- Angular separation between the first nulls of the pattern.
8
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
9
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Resolution
The most common resolution criterion states that the resolution capability of an antenna to
distinguish between two sources is equal to half the first-null beamwidth (FNBW/2), which is
usually used to approximate the HPBW.
That is, two sources separated by angular distances equal or greater than FNBW/2 ≈ HPBW of
an antenna with a uniform distribution can be resolved.
If the separation is smaller, then the antenna will tend to smooth the angular separation distance.
The half-power beamwidth HPBW (in radians and degrees).Intensity of an antenna is
represented half-power beamwidth HPBW (in radians and degrees) and first-null beamwidth
FNBW (in radians and degrees).
Antenna Fields
Near- and Far-Fields
10
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Reactive near-field region R1:- The portion of the near-field region immediately surrounding
the antenna wherein the reactive field (non-radiating field) predominates.
Radiating Near-Field (Fresnel) Region:-The region of the field of an antenna between the
reactive near-field region and the far-field region wherein radiation fields predominate and
wherein the angular field distribution is dependent upon the distance from the antenna. If the
antenna has a maximum dimension that is not large compared to the wavelength, this region may
not exist.
Far-Field (Fraunhofer) Region:-The region of the field of an antenna where the angular field
distribution is essentially independent of the distance from the antenna.
1.2.3 Radiation Power Density
Pointing Vector
The quantity used to describe the power associated with an electromagnetic wave is the
instantaneous Pointing vector defined as W = E ×H
Where,
W = instantaneous Pointing vector (W/m2) a power density
E = instantaneous electric-field intensity (V/m)
H = instantaneous magnetic-field intensity (A/m)
11
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
12
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
The observations are usually made on a large sphere of constant radius extending into the far
field.
In practice, absolute power patterns are usually not desired, but the performance of the antenna is
measured in terms of relative power patterns.
Three-dimensional patterns cannot be measured, but they can be constructed with a number of
two-dimensional cuts.
Radiation Intensity: - intensity in a given direction is defined as the power radiated from an
antenna per unit solid angle. The radiation intensity is a far-field parameter. It can be obtained by
simply multiplying the radiation density by the square of the distance.
U = r 2Wrad.
1.2.5 Directivity
The ratio of the radiation intensity in a given direction from the antenna to the radiation intensity
averaged over all directions.
The average radiation intensity: total power radiated by the antenna divided by 4π.
Stated more simply the directivity of a nonisotropic source is equal to the ratio of its radiation
intensity in a given direction over that of an isotropic source.
If the direction is not specified, the direction of maximum radiation intensity is implied.
Dmax = D0 = U/U0 = U|max/U0 = Umax/U0 = 4πUmax/ Prad.
D = directivity (dimensionless)
D0 = maximum directivity (dimensionless)
U = U (θ, φ) = radiation intensity (W/sr)
Umax = maximum radiation intensity (W/sr)
U0 = radiation intensity of isotropic source (W/sr)
Prad = total radiated power (W
13
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
1.2.6.1 Gain
The gain of the antenna is closely related to the directivity. In addition to the directional
capabilities it accounts for the efficiency of the antenna. Gain does not account for losses arising
from impedance mismatches (reflection losses) and polarization mismatches (losses).
Gain the ratio of the intensity in a given direction, to the radiation intensity that would be
obtained if the power accepted by the antenna were radiated isotopically.
Absolute Gain
We can introduce an absolute gain Gabs that takes into account the reflection or mismatch losses
(due to the connection of the antenna element to the transmission line
14
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
If the antenna is matched to the transmission line, that is, the antenna input impedance Zin is
equal to the characteristic impedance Zc of the line (|Γ| = 0), then the two gains are equal (Gabs
= G). For the maximum values G0abs = eoD0.
Bandwidth
For broadband antennas, the bandwidth is usually expressed as the ratio of the upper-to-lower
frequencies of acceptable operation. For example, a 10:1 bandwidth indicates that the upper
frequency is 10 times greater than the lower.
For narrowband antennas, the bandwidth is expressed as a percentage of the frequency
difference (upper minus lower) over the center frequency of the bandwidth. For example, a 5%
bandwidth indicates that the frequency difference of acceptable operation is 5% of the center
frequency of the bandwidth.
1.2.7 Polarization
Polarization is the curve traced by the end point of the arrow (vector) representing the
instantaneous electric field. The field must be observed along the direction of propagation.
Polarization is classified as linear, circular, or elliptical.
If the vector that describes the electric field at a point in space as a function of time is always
directed along a line, the field is said to be linearly polarized.
In general, the figure that the electric field traces is an ellipse, and the field is said to be
elliptically polarized.
15
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
16
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
.
Since the current has a sinusoidal distribution, moving in a distance R from the end will increase
the current by cos (pi*R/L) this is just noting that the wavelength is 2*L, and so the phase
difference is 2*pi*R/(2*L) = pi*R/L.
The voltage also decreases in magnitude by the same amount that the current increases. Hence,
using Z=V/I, the input impedance scales as:
In the above equation, Zin(0) is the input impedance if the patch was fed at the end. Hence, by
feeding the patch antenna as shown, the input impedance can be decreased. As an example, if
R=L/4, then cos(pi*R/L) = cos(pi/4), so that [cos(pi/4)]^2 = 1/2. Hence, a (1/8)-wavelength inset
would decrease the input impedance by 50%. This method can be used to tune the input
impedance to the desired value.
17
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
The goal is to match the input impedance (Zin) to the transmission line (Z0). If the impedance of
the antenna is ZA, then the input impedance viewed from the beginning of the quarter-
wavelength line becomes
This input impedance Zin can be altered by selection of the Z1, so that Zin=Z0 and the antenna is
impedance matched. The parameter Z1 can be altered by changing the width of the quarter-
wavelength strip. The wider the strip is, the lower the characteristic impedance (Z0) is for that
section of line.
18
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
The position of the feed can be altered as before (in the same way as the inset feed, above) to
control the input impedance.
The coaxial feed introduces an inductance into the feed that may need to be taken into account if
the height h gets large (an appreciable fraction of a wavelength). In addition, the probe will also
radiate, which can lead to radiation in undesirable directions.
1.3.4 Coupled (Indirect) Feeds
The feeds above can be altered such that they do not directly touch the antenna. For instance, the
probe feed in Figure 3 can be trimmed such that it does not extend all the way up to the antenna.
The inset feed can also be stopped just before the patch antenna, as shown in Figure 4.
The advantage of the coupled feed is that it adds an extra degree of freedom to the design. The
gap introduces a capacitance into the feed that can cancel out the inductance added by the probe
feed.
19
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
C= 3*10^8 m/s
f0=
εr=
20
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Step 2: Calculation of the Effective Dielectric Constant. This is based on the height, dielectric
constant of the dielectric and the calculated width of the patch antenna.
=1.922
Step 3: Calculation of the Effective length
=0.081 cm
Step 5: Calculation of actual length of the patch
L= 6.54695 but we are taking L=9 by checking various values to get good results
Where the following parameters are used
f0 = Resonance Frequency
W = Width of the Patch
L = Length of the Patch
h = thickness
εr =relative Permittivity of the dielectric substrate
c = Speed of light: 3 x 10
21
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
1.5 5G Technology
5G is the term used to describe the next-generation of mobile networks beyond LTE mobile
networks.
The International Telecommunications Union (ITU) has released several reports on the standards
for the 5G network that it refers to as the International Mobile Telecommunications (IMT)-2020
network [1].
The 3GPP is a mobile industry standards body that created its own standards for 5G New Radio
specifications, published in December 2017. Both mobile operators and vendors participate in
the 3GPP specification process[24].
According to ITU guidelines, 5G network speeds should have a peak data rate of 20 Gb/s for the
downlink and 10 Gb/s for the uplink. Latency in a 5G network could get as low as 4 milliseconds
in a mobile scenario and can be as low as 1 millisecond in Ultra Reliable Low Latency
Communication scenarios. Not only will people be connected to each other but so will
machines, automobiles, city infrastructure, public safety and more.
5G networks are also designed to have always-on capabilities and aim to be energy efficient by
minimizing how much power a modem uses based on the amount of traffic going through it.
5G ( 5th generation mobile networks or 5th generation wireless systems ) is a name used in some
research papers and projects to denote the next major phase of mobile telecommunications
standards beyond the upcoming 4G standards (expected to be finalized between approximately
22
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Network Layer:
The network layer will be IP (Internet Protocol), because there is no competition today on this
level. The IPv4 (version 4) is worldwide spread and it has several problems such as limited
address space and has no real possibility for QoS support per flow. These issues are solved in
IPv6, but traded with significantly bigger packet header. Then, mobility still remains a problem.
23
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
There is Mobile IP standard on one side as well as many micro-mobility solutions (e.g., Cellular
IP, HAWAII etc.). All mobile networks will use Mobile IP in 5G, and each mobile terminal will
be FA (Foreign Agent), keeping the CoA (Care of Address) mapping between its fixed IPv6
address and CoA address for the current wireless network. However, a mobile can be attached to
several mobile or wireless networks at the same time. In such case, it will maintain different IP
addresses for each of the radio interfaces, while each of these IP addresses will be CoA address
for the FA placed in the mobile Phone. The fixed IPv6 will be implemented in the mobile phone
by 5G phone manufactures.
The 5G mobile phone shall maintain virtual multi-wireless network environment. For this
purpose there should be separation of network layer into two sub-layers in 5G mobiles (Fig. )
i.e.: Lower network layer (for each interface) and Upper network layer (for the mobile terminal).
This is due to the initial design of the Internet, where all the routing is based on IP addresses
which should be different in each IP network worldwide. The middleware between the Upper
and Lower network layers (Fig. 3) shall maintain address translation from Upper network
address (IPv6) to different Lower network IP addresses (IPv4 or IPv6), and vice versa.
Features
5G technology offer high resolution for crazy cell phone user and bi- directional large
bandwidth shaping.
The advanced billing interfaces of 5G technology makes it more attractive and
effective.
5G technology also providing subscriber supervision tools for fast action.
The high quality services of 5G technology based on Policy to avoid error.
5G technology is providing large broadcasting of data in Gigabit which supporting
almost 65,000 connections.
5G technology offer transporter class gateway with unparalleled consistency.
The traffic statistics by 5G technology makes it more accurate.
Through remote management offered by 5G technology a user can get better and fast
solution.
The remote diagnostics also a great feature of 5G technology.
24
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
ANSYS HFSS is 3D electromagnetic (EM) simulation software for designing and simulating
high-frequency electronic products such as antennas, antenna arrays, RF or microwave
components, high-speed interconnects, filters, connectors, IC packages and printed circuit
boards. Engineers worldwide use ANSYS HFSS to design high-frequency, high-speed
electronics found in communications systems, radar systems, advanced driver assistance systems
(ADAS), satellites, internet-of-things (IoT) products and other high-speed RF and digital
devices.
HFSS (High Frequency Structure Simulator) employs versatile solvers and an intuitive GUI to
give you unparalleled performance plus deep insight into all your 3D EM problems. Through
integration with ANSYS thermal, structural and fluid dynamics tools, HFSS provides a powerful
and complete multiphysics analysis of electronic products, ensuring their thermal and structural
reliability. HFSS is synonymous with gold standard accuracy and reliability for tackling 3D EM
challenges by virtue of its automatic adaptive meshing technique and sophisticated solvers,
which can be accelerated through high performance computing (HPC) technology.
The ANSYS HFSS simulation suite consists of a comprehensive set of solvers to address diverse
electromagnetic problems ranging in detail and scale from passive IC components to extremely
large-scale EM analyses such as automotive radar scenes for ADAS systems. Its reliable
automatic adaptive mesh refinement lets you focus on the design instead of spending time
determining and creating the best mesh. This automation and guaranteed accuracy differentiates
HFSS from all other EM simulators, which require manual user control and multiple solutions to
ensure that the generated mesh is suitable and accurate. With ANSYS HFSS, the physics defines
the mesh rather than the mesh defining the physics.
25
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
ANSYS HFSS is the premier EM tool for R&D and virtual design prototyping. It reduces design
cycle time and boosts your product’s reliability and performance. Beat the competition and
capture your market with ANSYS HFSS.
26
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
CHAPTER 2
2. LITERATURE SURVEY
1 Multiband Low 2017 Patch Inset 58.5m 10mm 1.4mm 28GHZ -23 RT5580
profile printed feed m (2.2)
monopole
antenna for
Future 5G
Wireless
Application
With DGS
2 Design of a 2016 Patch Inset 5mm 5mm 0.127m 28/38GHZ -46 RT5580 3.6-
Dual-Band feed m (2.2) 4.4
printed slot
dB
Antenna with
Utilizing a Band
Rejection
element for 5G
wireless
Applications
3 A 9-shaped 2017 9 shape Inset 30mm 38mm 1.6mm 24.5 – FR4 (1.94
Antenna for 5G patch feed 27.5 GHZ (4.4) -10
Applications
)dB
4 A Wideband 2018 Array Coaxi 5.85m 7.35mm 24 GHz, <- RT5880 5.34
mm-Wave al m 25 GHz, 10 (2.2) dB
Printed Dipole
feed 28 GHz,
Antenna for 5G
Applications 32 GHz,
38 GHz
40GHZ
5 A Compact 2017 Patch Inset 5mm 5mm 1.6mm 28 -45 FR4
Elliptical feed (4.4)
Microstrip Patch
Antenna for
Future 5G
Mobile Wireless
Communication
6 Multiband 2018
Antennas
Design
------ ------ ------- -------- -------- ----- ------ ------
Techniques for
5G Networks:
Present and
27
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Future Research
Directions
7 Design of 2017 Patch Feed ---- ----- 0.5mm 28.3 GHz - RT 5880 2.6
Microstrip Patch line 30. dB
Antenna for 5g
777
Applications
4
8 Wide-band 2018 Patch Inset 50mm 50mm 24.5-27.5 <- RT 5880
Circular feed ------- GHz, 10
Antenna for 5G
31.8-33.4
Applications
GHz and
40.5-43.5
GHz.
9 A Novel Planar 2017 Patch Inset 4mm 26mm 1.6mm 6.37 GHz <- Feko 11.13
Slot Antenna feed and 14.06 10 simulator dB
Structure for 5G GHz and ADS
Mobile (4.4)
Networks
Applications
10 2018 Patch Inset 4.5mm 5.5mm 0.4mm 28GHz <- FR4 2.875
feed 10 (4.4) dB
A Microstrip Patch
Antenna Design at
28GHz for 5G
Mobile Phone
Applications
11 A compact 2018 RFID Coaxi 2mm 4mm 0.127mm 64Hz <- FR(2.55) 20dB
printed RFID Reader al 10
reader dipole
feed
array antenna for
5G- IOT
applications
12 Characteristics 2017 - - - - - 38GHz - - 16.2d
of beam faced B
array antenna for
5G applications
13 Slot antenna 2017 slot Coaxi 4mm 26mm 4.4mm 8.69GHz - Feko 6.14d
design for 5G al B
Mobile networks
feed
14 Wideband high 2017 High Inst 2mm 4mm 0.125mm 28GHz - - 12dB
gain antenna sub gain feed
array for 5G
application
28
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
CHAPTER 3
3. EXPERIMENT WORK
29
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
The top view of the proposed antenna is shown in Fig.1. The radiating element is a monopole,
having concave-rectangular shape with the edge having a well-defined curvature. The monopole
is inset fed with a microstrip line that has a step transition to obtain optimum matching.
The substrate used for the considered design is FR4 epoxy having a dielectric constant of ℇr =
4.4. The thickness of the substrate is 1.4mm whereas the width and the length are given as 8x9
mm2 respectively. The dimensions of the monopole antenna are reflected in Table 2.
30
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
31
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
The ground plane comprising of three circular slots is a defected ground structure (DGS) as
shown in Fig21. The outer radii of the circular slots are 0.46mm and the inner radii are
0.39mm.The resulting antenna provides wide bandwidth coverage as compared to other antennas
and is small in size with high performance results.
32
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
CHAPTER 4
The simulations of the proposed patch antenna structure were performed using HFSS software.
The antenna performances were evaluated in terms of return loss, VSWR, E and H plane
radiation plots and gain.
The validation of simulated results will then be performed by testing and measurement. This
section explains the comparison between the different designs that were worked on and from
there how the current design, emerged to be the best for the proposal.
The gain of an antenna in the given direction is defined as the ratio of intensity in a given
direction to the radiation intensity that would be obtained if the power accepted by the
antenna were radiated isotopically. The gain of our design gives worthy results.
33
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Figure 22: Simulation results for S11 parameter for the ground plane
As shown in fig.22, the plot for S11 parameter is generated for the ground plane having 1, 2 and
3 circular slots on it using HFSS software. It is found that the best results are obtained when
there are 3 circular slot on the ground plane since the values obtained are -22.3dB, -22.29dB and
-19.2dB for the respective dips at the three points. In contrast when 2 circles are considered the
values obtained are -16dB, -22dB and -22dB, while for 1 circular slot on the ground plane, the
values obtained are -15dB, -21dB and -28dB. Thus it is better to go for the ground plane having
3 circular slots.
34
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Figure 23: Simulation Results for VSWR for the ground plane
As shown in fig.23, the plot for VSWR is generated for the ground plane having 1 2 and 3
circular slot on it using HFSS software. It is found that the best results are obtained when there
are 3 circular on the ground plane since the values obtained are 1.32, 1.33 and 1.91 for the
respective dips at the three points. In contrast, when 2 circular are considered the values obtained
are 2.6, 1.2 and 1.3, while for 1 circle on the ground plane, the values obtained are 1.8, 3.5 and
0.75. Thus it is better to go for the ground plane having 3 circular slot.
35
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Figure 24: Simulation Results for S11 parameter for thickness of the substrate
As shown in fig.24, the plot for S11 parameter is generated for 3 different thicknesses of the
substrate depending on the number of circular slot on the ground plane using HFSS software. It
is found that the best results are obtained when there are 3 circular slots on the ground plane
since the values obtained are -22.3dB, -22.29dB and -19.2dB for the respective dips at the three
points. In contrast when 2 circular slots are considered the values obtained are -6dB, -8dB and -
9dB, while for 1 circle on the ground plane, the values obtained are -3dB, -4dB and -5dB. Thus,
ground plane having circular slots is considered.
36
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Figure 25: Simulation Results for the VSWR for the thickness of the substrate
As shown in fig.25, the plot for VSWR is generated for 3 different thicknesses of the substrate
depending on the number of circular slots on the ground plane using HFSS software. It is found
that the best results are obtained when there are 3 circular slots on the ground plane since the
values of obtained are 1.3, 1.3 and 1.9 for the respective dips at the three points. In contrast when
2 circular slots are considered the values obtained are 8, 6 and 5, while for 1 circular slot on the
ground plane, the values obtained are 24, 14 and 12. Thus, ground plane having 3 circular slots is
considered.
37
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Figure 26: Simulation Results for S11 parameter for the height of the substrate
As shown in fig.26, the plot for S11 parameter is generated for 3 different heights of the
substrate depending on the number of circles on the ground plane using HFSS software. It is
found that the best results are obtained when there are 3 circles on the ground plane since the
values obtained are -22.3dB, -22.29dB and -19.2dB for the respective dips at the three points. In
contrast when 2 circles are considered the values obtained are -17dB, -24dB and -18dB, while
for 1 circle on the ground plane, the values obtained are -19dB, -27dB and -21dB. Thus, ground
plane having 3 circles is considered.
38
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Figure 27: Simulation Results for VSWR for the height of the substrate
As shown in fig.27, the plot for VSWR is generated for 3 different heights of the substrate
depending on the number of circles on the ground plane using HFSS software. It is found that the
best results are obtained when there are 3 circles on the ground plane since the values of obtained
are 1.3, 1.3 and 1.9 for the respective dips at the three points. In contrast when 2 circles are
considered the values obtained are 1, 2 and 1.3, while for 1 circle on the ground plane, the values
obtained are 1.8, 0.7 and 1.4. Thus, ground plane having 3 circles is conside
39
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
40
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
41
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
42
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
43
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
44
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Figure 39:: Simulation results for S11 parameter for the ground plane
45
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
As shown in fig.39, the plot for S11 parameter is generated for the ground plane having 1, 2 and
3 circular slots on it using HFSS software. It is found that the best results are obtained when
there are 3 circular slots on the ground plane since the values obtained are -15.19dB,-22.2dB,-
27.6dB for the respective dips at the three points. In contrast when 2 circles are considered the
values obtained are, while for 1 circle on the ground plane, the values obtained are. Thus it is
better to go for the ground plane having 3 circular slots .
As we know that the ideal value of VSWR is 1, but practically, it is from 1 to 2. In our design for
all three bands we are getting the best value of VSWR, which is nearly equal to the ideal values.
The fig.40, the plot for VSWR is generated for the ground plane having 1, 2 and 3 circular slots
on it using HFSS software. It is found that the best results are obtained when there are 3 circular
slots on the ground plane since the values obtained are 1.1, 1.9 and 1.1 for the respective dips
at the three points. In contrast, when 1and 2 circular slots are considered the values obtained are
not the expected values ,Thus it is better to go for the ground plane having 3 circles.
46
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
47
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
48
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
CHAPTER 5
5. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
49
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
50
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
51
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
Figure 49: Smith chart measured on Network Analyzer shown with antenna
The fabricated antenna was tested in the DRDO Laboratory and the results obtained were even
better than the simulated results as shown above. We observed a wide band for 5G from
34.5GHz to 50GHz.
For the fabricated antenna only the return loss, VWRS and smith chart are measured. Comparing
it with the simulated results the experimental results are better.
52
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
CHAPTER 6
The proposed antenna design makes use of multiple frequency bands and satisfies 5G operations
for the frequencies 10.5GHz, 26.11GHz and 50.5GHz. The second design 21.6GHz, 25.5GHz
and 50GHz. Because of its compact area, low weight and low cost of fabrication, the antenna is
dependable for different portable devices for wireless applications and has improved
performance. Validation of the simulation results is done by measurement thus satisfying the
needs for 5G technology. This will enable timely availability of spectrum for mobile calls.
Further modifications can be made in the proposed design to make it more efficient for use in the
near future.
Further alterations can be made in the proposed structure to make it increasingly productive for
use sooner rather than later. In this design antenna is modified for better gain and performance in
the frequency range of proposed 5G applications. The ground of the structure is modified to
decrease the interference between the 5G system and other applications. The future of mobile
communications is likely to be very different to that which we are used to today. While demand
for mobile broadband will continue to increase, largely driven by ultra high definition video and
better screens, we are already seeing the growing impact of the human possibilities of technology
as the things around us become ever more connected. The upcoming 5th generation cellular
network 5G is anticipated to exhibit a uniform Gbps data throughput experience across a vast
range of user scenarios. Enabled by 5G, a programmable world will transform our lives,
economy and society. Data throughput will be enhanced by more than a hundred fold.
The proposed antenna will be used for mm application of 5G,which can be place at the of the
tower to be used for non-line of side communications of 5G
53
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
7. REFERENCES
1. R. G. S. Rao and R. Sai, 5G –Introduction & Future of Mobile Broadband
Communication Redefined.International Journal of Electronics, Communication &
Instrumentation Engineering Research and Development (IJECIERD), vol/issue: 3(4), pp. 119–
124, 2013.
7.L.H. Weng, Y.C. Guo, X.W. Shi, and X.Q. Chen, “An overview on defected ground structure,”
Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, vol. 7, pp. 173–189, 2008.
54
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
12. G. Wu, S. Talwar, K. Johnsson, N. Himayat, and K. Johnson, “M2M: From Mobile to
Embedded Internet,” IEEE Commun. Mag., vol. 49, no. 4, pp. 36-43, Apr. 2011.
13. X. Li et al., “Smart Community: An Internet of Things Application,” IEEE Commun. Mag.,
vol. 49, no. 11, pp. 68-75, Nov. 2011.
14. Y. El Gholb, N. El Amrani El Idrissi, H. Ghennioui, « 5G: An Idea Whose Time Has Come”
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 8, Issue 3, March-2017.
15. Ban, Y.-L., S.-C. Sun, P.-P. Li, J. L.-W. Li, and K. Kang, “Compact eight-band frequency
reconfigurable antenna for LTE/WWAN tablet computer applications,” IEEE Transactions on
Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 62, No. 1, 471–475, Jan. 2014.
16. Hwang, S.-G., C. Yoon, I. S. Yoon, L. Chares, C. S. Park, and W.-S. Kim, “A reconfigurable
mobile antenna for multiband operation using pin-diode,” Microwave and Optical Technology
Letters, Vol. 57, No. 2,406-409, Feb, 2015.
17. Zhang, P.-F., S.-Z. Liu, and S. Zhao, “A novel reconfigurable microstrip patch antenna with
frequency and polarization diversities,” Microwave and Optical Technology Letters, Vol. 57, No.
6, 1494–1500, Jun. 2015.
18. Xia Xiao, Wei-Hua Zong, Shan-Dong Li, Xiang-Yang Wei, and XiaoYun Qu “A Wideband
Slot Antenna for Mobile Phone Applications”, IEEE 5th Asia-Pacific Conference on Antennas
and Propagation (APCAP), 2016.
19. Jui-Han Lu, Jia-Ling Guo and Yong-Yong Zhang “Planar Multi-Band LTE/WWAN
Antenna for Internal Mobile Phone”, 5th IEEE AsiaPacific Conference on Antennas and
Propagation (APCAP) , 2016.
20. Pozar, D. M., “Microstrip antenna,” IEEE Proceedings, Vol. 80, 79–81, Jan. 1992.
55
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune
Printed Antenna for 5G Application
22. Herscovici, N., “A wide band single layer patch antenna,” IEEE Trans. on Antenna and
Propagations, Vol. 46, No. 4, 471–474, April 1998.
23. Chen, Z. N., “Broadband probe-fed L-shaped plate antenna,” Microwave and Optical Letters,
Aug. 2000.
24. T. Rappaport et al., “Millimeter Wave Mobile Communications for 5G Cellular: It Will
Work!,” IEEE Access, vol. 1, May 2013, pp. 335–49. [15] T. S. Rappaport et al., “Broadband
millimeter-wave propagation mea- surements and models using adaptive-beam antennas for
outdoor urban cellular communications,” IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag., vol. 61, no. 4, pp.
1850–1859, Apr. 2013
56
Department of E&TC, SIT, Pune