Clinical
Clinical
 STUDY TIP
 When revising the Beck Depression Inventory, you could download a copy from the
 internet (see https://tinyurl.com/j9ed7rwb). Choose a few of the items and create a
 mnemonic to help you remember them. For example, the first three items are sadness,
 pessimism and past failure; you could remember these as SPF: ‘study prominent facts’.
▼ Table 6.10 ICD-11 definitions of mood disorders (World Health Organization, 2018)
                       Symptoms                                                                     Duration
 Depressive            Depressed mood; reduced interest in activities; difficulty             Most of the day,
 disorder (unipolar)   concentrating; feeling worthless; excessive or inappropriate guilt;    nearly every day, for
                       hopelessness; recurring thoughts of death/suicide; changes in appetite at least two weeks
                       or sleep; feeling agitated; slow movements; low energy; fatigue
 Bipolar disorders     Alternating depressive and manic episodes; manic episodes include            Mania for at least one
                       euphoria, irritability, grandiosity, highly active, subjective sense of      week; depressive and
                       increased energy, rapid speech, rapidly changing thoughts/ideas,             manic symptoms may
                       decreased need for sleep, easily distracted, impulsive and reckless          be experienced within
                                                                                                    the same week or even
                                                                                                    day (mixed episodes)
                       Cambridge International AS/A Level Psychology Study and Revision Guide Third Edition                  99
           SKILLS BUILDER
       Describe one symptom of unipolar disorder.                                            [2]
       ‘Describe’ means to give a detailed account. Avoid simply identifying or stating
       a symptom. Write a full sentence that gives detail about what it might be like to
       experience this symptom. For example, ‘Difficulty concentrating means that,
       although you are focusing on a task, your mind might wander onto thoughts
       about other things that you have to do, or you might be distracted by sights
       and sounds around you.’ You could also give an example, such as how the
       symptoms might affect a person at school or work.
                             Strengths                                               Weaknesses
       ICD-11 diagnosis of   Reliability – inter-rater reliability is high (84!per   Reliability – ICD-11 is less reliable when
       mood disorders        cent) for bipolar disorder and recurrent depressive     diagnosing dysthymia (45 per cent)
                             disorder using ICD-11 (Reed et al., 2018).              (Reed!et al., 2018).
       The BDI               Validity – there is a positive correlation between      Self-report – social desirability bias may
                             the BDI and the Hamilton Psychiatric Rating             reduce validity; symptoms may be under-
                             Scale for Depression.                                   reported or exaggerated.
                             Practical – provides quick and precise data; good       Quantitative data – ignores contextual
                             for assessing treatment efficacy in research and        information (e.g. why a person has
                             clinical practice.                                      depressive symptoms).
           SKILLS BUILDER
       Explain one strength of the Beck Depression Inventory         of quantitative data and how these strengthen the
       with reference to quantitative data.               [2]        BDI as a measure of the severity of depressive
                                                                     symptoms. Think about what the BDI does: it
       Read the question carefully. You are not being
                                                                     categorises people’s symptoms as mild, moderate
       asked for a strength of quantitative data or just
                                                                     and severe. Why is this a good thing and why is
       any strength of the BDI. Think about the strengths
                                                                     using numerical data helpful in achieving this goal?
           SKILLS BUILDER
       a Describe the Beck Depression Inventory.               [6]   and two weaknesses. Use the points in Table 6.11
       b Evaluate the Beck Depression Inventory,                     to create full PEEL paragraphs (state your point,
         including a discussion of psychometrics.             [10]   explain evidence, link back to your argument, e.g.
                                                                     ‘This is important because … ‘). When discussing
       Although this question seems unlikely, it is still a          psychometrics (see page 65), you could give an
       legitimate Paper 3 extended response question.                alternative, such as the trauma-informed approach,
       It is a good one to practise as it will push you to           which uses a psychological formulation and is
       really elaborate your points. Your evaluation is              therefore more idiographic.
       likely to include two well-elaborated strengths
    SKILLS BUILDER
 When answering question 6.16 below, think about         is based. This could be the ICD-11 criteria for
 general features such as aim(s), procedure, sample/     unipolar depression or the BDI, which you could
 sampling technique and ethical considerations, as       use as your measure of severity of symptoms. The
 well as ensuring that the findings will be valid and    required method is correlation, so you will need two
 reliable. Also think about the type(s) of data Sissi    variables, each measured using quantitative data.
 might collect and the descriptive statistics she        Remember, if you use a rating scale, show how the
 should use to analyse her data.                         responses will be scored, e.g. ‘How often do you
                                                         exercise? 1 (never) to 7 (at least once a day)’.
 Part b of the question asks about a piece of
 psychological knowledge on which your plan
                     Cambridge International AS/A Level Psychology Study and Revision Guide Third Edition           101
         – overly sensitive, post-synaptic receptor sites
         – high levels of monoamine oxydase (an enzyme)
         – abnormalities of the presynaptic reuptake pumps (transporter molecules).
      Genetic
      » Vulnerability is inherited.
      » Specific alleles of candidate genes linked to serotonin may increase the risk.
      » For example, short alleles of the 5-HTT gene appear to increase depression risk
        when facing stressful life events compared with long alleles (Caspi et al., 2003).
           SKILLS BUILDER
       Cordelia is worried about developing unipolar depression     vulnerable). Now your memory is refreshed,
       since she found out that both her biological parents have    start your answer. For example, Cordelia might
       this disorder. Explain why Cordelia might be worried,        be worried because she thinks she has inherited
       with reference to one or more biological explanations. [4]   specific gene variants (alleles) from her parents
                                                                    that could increase her vulnerability to depression.’
       This question gives you the option to include
                                                                    You could also explain why this is a worry. Improve
       one or more explanations. Bullet-point two
                                                                    your answer by referencing specific knowledge, like
       explanations in the margin before you start (e.g.
                                                                    the role of the S allele of the 5-HTR2c gene, which
       genetic and biochemical). Write down a few key
                                                                    codes for serotonin transporter molecules on the
       words associated with each explanation before
                                                                    presynaptic cell.
       you start writing your answer (e.g. alleles, inherit,
 Strengths                                                           Weaknesses
 Validity – two experienced psychiatrists checked                    Generalisation – the sample size was small; only three
 whether participants had bipolar or not using the                   people (all male) had the SS genotype of the 5-HTR2c
 Croatian version of a structured interview schedule.                gene.
 Reliability – other studies had the same results for both           Validity – cause and effect cannot be be established as
 the 5-HTR2c and 5-HTT genes (Gutiérrez et al., 1996;                the variables were naturally occurring and the groups
 Kelsoe et al., 1996).                                               were only matched on age and sex.
     SKILLS BUILDER
 Explain one strength of the key study by Oruč et al.               gene were determined with a blood test. This type
 (1997) with reference to reliability.                 [2]           of data requires little interpretation (objective); two
                                                                     or more researchers are likely to code the data in
 Reliability refers to the consistency of an instrument
                                                                     the same way, so the measurements are reliable.
 used to make measurements in a psychological
                                                                     Another way of answering would be to talk about
 study. In this study, S or C alleles of the 5-HTR2c
                                                                     the reliability of bipolar diagnoses.
Psychological explanations
Beck’s cognitive theory of depression
» Depressive symptoms are caused by negative thoughts stemming from
  dysfunctional core beliefs (Beck, 1962).
» The more negative thoughts a person has, the worse their symptoms.
» Depressed people hold negative beliefs about the self, the world and the future
  (the negative cognitive triad).
» These beliefs develop in childhood due to criticism, rejection, neglect, abuse,
  bullying, experiences of loss and overprotective parenting.
» Confirmation bias means depressed people focus on information that supports
  negative beliefs and ignore conflicting evidence.
» Other faulty thinking strategies include catastrophising and personalising.
Learned helplessness/attributional style
» Depression is a learned response to a negative experience.
» If a neutral stimulus becomes associated with an unavoidable negative stimulus,
  people may fail to initiate coping strategies when faced with a similar situation
  in the future.
» Apparent lack of control over the environment leads to hopelessness, passive
  acceptance and overgeneralisation to other situations.
» Depressive attributional style (pessimism) is a negative bias in the way that
  people process information about success and failure (see Table 6.13).
▼ Table 6.13 Psychological explanation of depression: depressive attributional style
       Strengths                                                    Weaknesses
       Validity – pessimism was relatively stable in the control    Generalisations – the sample included 50 per cent more
       group, suggesting that pessimism is a fixed trait rather     females than males, who may not represent all men with
       than a reaction to current circumstances, i.e. a cause of    depression.
       depression and not an effect.
       Validity – triangulation (BDI and interviews) increased      Attrition – 33 per cent dropped out before the final
       the validity of measures of symptom severity.                follow-up. The remaining participants may not be
                                                                    representative of all people with depression (e.g. they
                                                                    may have had less severe symptoms).
     SKILLS BUILDER
 When answering ‘Plan a study’ questions such as 6.20 below, think about the
 key studies you have revised for the topic area named in the question, such
 as Oruč et al. (1997). You could use a similar design as the basis of your study.
 How would you recruit a representative sample using random sampling, for
 example? Would this be practical? Part b of question 6.20 asks you to justify
 your choice of hypothesis. As Oruč et al. (1997) did not find significant results
 overall (only the results for women were significant) but others have, which
 type of hypothesis would be most sensible, directional or non-directional?
                     Cambridge International AS/A Level Psychology Study and Revision Guide Third Edition          105
      6.2.3 Treatment and management of mood (affective)
      disorders
      Biological treatments
      ▼ Table 6.16 Antidepressant drugs
                 Strengths                                            Weaknesses
 Biological      Evidence – all 21 drugs investigated in a meta-      Side effects – side effects can be debilitating;
                 analysis of 522 double-blind trials were more        some of the most effective drugs have the worst
                 effective than placebos (Cipriani et al., 2018).     compliance rates.
                 Practical – biological treatments are a cheap        Limited effects – differences between drugs and
                 and low commitment solution for many people,         placebos may be statistically significant but may
                 unlike cognitive therapy, which is time-             not lead to a great deal of change in everyday life.
                 consuming and costly.
 Psychological   Remission rate – 75 per cent of people who           Non-compliance – some people are not
                 received drug treatment plus cognitive therapy       sufficiently organised/self-motivated to carry
                 were symptom-free after two years, compared with     out weekly homework exercises.
                 25 per cent using drugs alone (Fava et al., 1998).
                 No side effects – compliance rates may be            Accessibility – cognitive therapy requires well-
                 higher than drug treatments.                         trained therapists; location and financial cost
                                                                      may mean this is not an option for many people.
     SKILLS BUILDER
 Joel is carrying out research into patient experiences regarding the treatment of
 mood disorders. Plan a study using semi-structured interviews to help
 Joel to investigate this topic. Remember to think about the aim(s), procedure,
 sampling and ethical considerations.                                            [10]
 Think of some open and closed questions Joel could ask and then think about
 how he would analyse the answers. Would the interviews be better face to
 face, online or over the phone? Think about how he could ensure people
 answer the questions honestly, to increase validity, and how he can check that
 his data is reliable.
     SKILLS BUILDER
 Evaluate one or more psychological treatments for mood (affective) disorders,
 including a discussion of reductionism versus holism.                         [10]
 If the essay question asks explicitly about biological or psychological
 treatments, you can always use the other one as part of your evaluation. You
 could mention that the treatment named in the question is either stronger
 or weaker than the alternative (e.g. why psychological treatments might be
 considered better than biological treatments). Often people are prescribed
 antidepressants and offered cognitive therapy (e.g. restructuring or REBT).
 This is known as eclectic approach and could lead into a discussion of
 reductionism versus holism.
                     Cambridge International AS/A Level Psychology Study and Revision Guide Third Edition                    107
             NOW TEST YOURSELF
          6.21 Annie has weekly REBT for unipolar depression. She is not enjoying the
               sessions and wants to stop going. Suggest one reason that Annie may
               not enjoy REBT.                                                         [2]
          6.22 Explain one similarity and one difference between Beck’s cognitive
               restructuring and Ellis’s rational emotive behaviour therapy.           [4]
          6.23 With reference to studies investigating the effectiveness
               of treatment, suggest one reason why the findings might not be
               generalisable.                                                          [2]
          6.24 Outline one individual and one situational factor that might reduce the
               effectiveness of treatments for mood disorders.                        [4]
             SKILLS BUILDER
          Omid works in a casino. He wonders whether any of          might see people with gambling disorders coming
          his customers have a gambling disorder. Explain one        to the casino when he knows they should be at work
          difference Omid might observe between people with          (prioritising gambling over other daily activities),
          and without a gambling disorder.                   [2]     whereas other people only visit the casino after
                                                                     working hours.’ Notice how the example includes
          Your answer needs to link a characteristic of
                                                                     ‘whereas’, showing that the answer includes both
          gambling disorder to something Omid might
                                                                     people with and without gambling disorder.
          observe in his customers. For example, ‘Omid