International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.

com

International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation

ISSN: 2582-7138
Received: 15-12-2020; Accepted: 17-01-2021
www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com
Volume 2; Issue 1; January-February 2021; Page No. 608-622

Developing a Framework for Digital Transformation in Retail Banking Operations

David Olanrewaju Olutimehin 1*, Titilola Olufunke Falaiye 2, Chikezie Paul-Mikki Ewim 3, Augustine Ifeanyi Ibeh 4
1
Department of Management Science and Human Resources, Lagos State University, Nigeria
2
Zenith Bank Plc, Nigeria
3
Independent Researcher, Lagos, Nigeria
4
Independent Researcher, Lagos Nigeria
Corresponding Author: David Olanrewaju Olutimehin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.54660/.IJMRGE.2021.2.1.608-622

Abstract
Digital transformation is reshaping the retail banking of digital initiatives across all operational layers. Regulatory
industry, driving efficiency, enhancing customer experience, compliance, data security, and privacy are identified as
and fostering competitive advantage. This paper focuses on pivotal challenges in the transformation process,
developing a comprehensive framework for digital necessitating a focus on governance and risk management.
transformation in retail banking operations, emphasizing key The paper presents case studies of leading banks that have
elements such as technological adoption, process successfully embraced digital transformation, offering
optimization, and customer-centric innovation. The valuable lessons and insights. It underscores the role of
framework identifies essential components for successful digital ecosystems, such as fintech collaborations and open
digital transformation, including leveraging advanced banking models, in driving innovation and expanding service
technologies like artificial intelligence (AI), machine delivery. Furthermore, the research explores future trends,
learning (ML), and blockchain to optimize core banking including the increasing use of AI-driven chatbots,
processes, enhance decision-making, and ensure secure blockchain for fraud prevention, and green banking practices
transactions. Additionally, the integration of Internet of supported by digital technologies. By providing a structured
Things (IoT) devices and big data analytics facilitates real- roadmap, this paper aims to guide retail banks in leveraging
time insights into customer behavior, enabling banks to digital transformation to achieve operational excellence,
deliver personalized services and build stronger customer improve customer satisfaction, and adapt to the evolving
relationships. The framework also highlights organizational financial landscape. The proposed framework serves as a
factors, such as fostering a culture of innovation, upskilling strategic tool for decision-makers seeking to navigate the
employees, and aligning digital strategies with business complexities of digital transformation while remaining agile
objectives. A robust change management approach is critical and competitive.
to overcoming resistance and ensuring seamless integration

Keywords: Digital Transformation, Retail Banking, Artificial Intelligence, Blockchain, Internet of Things, Big Data Analytics,
Customer Experience, Operational Efficiency, Fintech Collaboration, Regulatory Compliance.

1. Introduction
Digital transformation in retail banking has become a critical driver for enhancing operational efficiency, improving customer
experiences, and maintaining competitive advantage in an increasingly digital and fast-paced financial environment. The
integration of advanced technologies such as artificial intelligence, machine learning, blockchain, and data analytics is reshaping
the way banks operate, deliver services, and interact with their customers (Ali, et al., 2020, Olufemi, Ozowe & Komolafe, 2011).
This transformation involves more than just the adoption of digital tools; it requires a complete overhaul of business processes,
organizational culture, and customer engagement strategies to fully leverage the benefits of technology.
The importance of digital transformation in retail banking cannot be overstated. With the rise of fintech companies, digital-only
banks, and shifting customer expectations, traditional banking models are under pressure to innovate and adapt. Retail banks
must now provide seamless, personalized, and accessible services that can meet the demands of a tech-savvy, mobile-first
consumer base (Chataway, Hanlin & Kaplinsky, 2014, de Almeida, Araújo & de Medeiros, 2017). The digital transformation

608
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

journey enables banks to optimize their operations, banks to scale their infrastructure, improve collaboration, and
streamline decision-making, reduce costs, and create new reduce costs associated with maintaining on-premise
revenue streams by tapping into data-driven insights. systems. Furthermore, data analytics plays a crucial role in
Furthermore, it plays a key role in strengthening security, helping banks understand customer behavior, optimize
improving compliance, and enhancing the overall agility of pricing models, and enhance customer engagement
banking operations. strategies.
The objective of this framework is to provide a structured Several trends and drivers are pushing the need for digital
approach to guide retail banks through the complexities of transformation in the banking sector. The rise of fintech
digital transformation. By focusing on key technological companies and digital-only banks has forced traditional retail
areas, organizational alignment, and strategic priorities, the banks to innovate and modernize their operations to stay
framework aims to support banks in their efforts to modernize competitive. These new entrants offer streamlined, user-
infrastructure, adopt innovative solutions, and position friendly services that attract customers who value speed,
themselves for long-term success in the digital age convenience, and lower costs (Ali, et al., 2015, Carter, Van
(Chataway, Hanlin & Kaplinsky, 2014, de Almeida, Araújo Oort & Barendrecht, 2014). Additionally, evolving customer
& de Medeiros, 2017). The scope of this framework includes expectations are a significant driver of digital transformation.
the assessment of current capabilities, the identification of Customers now expect 24/7 access to banking services,
gaps, and the establishment of best practices for integrating personalized experiences, and frictionless interactions. As
digital technologies into core banking functions such as digital-savvy consumers become the norm, traditional banks
payments, lending, customer service, and risk management. must meet these expectations to retain existing customers and
Through this comprehensive approach, the framework seeks attract new ones.
to ensure that retail banks can navigate the challenges of Regulatory pressures also play a key role in driving digital
digital transformation while maximizing the opportunities it transformation. Governments and regulatory bodies are
presents. increasingly focusing on financial institutions’ ability to
ensure data security, protect customer privacy, and comply
2.1 Understanding Digital Transformation in Retail with evolving regulations such as GDPR (General Data
Banking Protection Regulation) and PSD2 (Payment Services
Digital transformation in retail banking refers to the Directive 2) in the European Union. These regulations push
integration of digital technologies into all aspects of banking banks to adopt more secure and transparent systems,
operations, fundamentally changing how banks deliver prompting the integration of blockchain technology,
services, interact with customers, and manage their internal enhanced encryption protocols, and AI-based compliance
processes. This transformation is not merely about adopting tools (Carri, et al., 2021, Dominy, et al., 2018).
new technologies; it involves a comprehensive rethinking of In addition to these external pressures, the pandemic
the banking model, business processes, and organizational accelerated digital transformation in retail banking. The
culture to adapt to an increasingly digital world (Agupugo & global health crisis made in-person banking interactions more
Tochukwu, 2021, Diao & Ghorbani, 2018). The goal of difficult, leading to a rapid shift to online and mobile banking
digital transformation is to create more efficient, customer- platforms. Banks that had already made significant
centric, and agile operations while enabling banks to remain investments in digital technologies were better positioned to
competitive in the evolving financial landscape. weather the crisis and continue serving their customers
Key aspects of digital transformation in retail banking (Adejugbe Adejugbe, 2016, Mushtaq, et al., 2020, Shahbazi
include the automation of processes, the digitization of & Nasab, 2016). This shift also highlighted the need for
customer touchpoints, and the implementation of data-driven banks to offer contactless, remote services and enabled
decision-making. Automation allows banks to streamline greater adoption of mobile payments, digital wallets, and
back-office operations, reduce human error, and lower costs video banking.
by leveraging technologies such as robotic process Understanding digital transformation in retail banking also
automation (RPA) and artificial intelligence (AI). The involves recognizing the challenges that come with such a
digitization of customer touchpoints, on the other hand, comprehensive change. Banks must contend with legacy
ensures that customers have seamless access to banking systems, regulatory compliance, and cybersecurity threats as
services across digital channels like mobile apps, websites, they embark on their digital transformation journey
and chatbots (Agupugo & Tochukwu, 2021, Diao & (Allahvirdizadeh, 2020, Burrows, et al., 2020). Moreover,
Ghorbani, 2018). Furthermore, data-driven decision-making organizational change is required to create a culture that
enables banks to leverage large volumes of customer data, embraces digital innovation, collaboration, and continuous
machine learning algorithms, and predictive analytics to learning. In many cases, banks must overcome resistance
personalize services, manage risks, and enhance customer from employees who may be apprehensive about the
satisfaction. potential disruption to their roles or the technology’s
The role of digital technologies in reshaping banking complexity.
operations is profound. Artificial intelligence and machine The digital transformation of retail banking is not a one-size-
learning are being increasingly used in fraud detection, risk fits-all approach. Banks of different sizes, geographies, and
management, and customer service, allowing banks to market segments face varying challenges and opportunities.
respond to challenges in real-time and offer more tailored For example, large multinational banks may focus on
products (Bui, et al., 2018, Dickson & Fanelli, 2018). streamlining their global operations and improving
Blockchain technology is revolutionizing the way compliance across multiple jurisdictions, while smaller
transactions are processed, ensuring greater transparency, regional banks may emphasize enhancing customer
security, and efficiency, particularly in cross-border experience and improving operational efficiency (Dong, et
payments and asset management. Cloud computing enables al., 2019, Hadinata, et al., 2021). Similarly, banks operating

609
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

in emerging markets may prioritize improving financial enhances digital transformation in banking operations. It
inclusion and increasing access to banking services for provides a secure, transparent way to handle transactions,
underserved populations. ensuring that all parties involved in a transaction can verify
To successfully navigate digital transformation, banks need its authenticity without relying on intermediaries. Blockchain
to develop a clear strategy that aligns technology adoption can also be used to facilitate cross-border payments, reduce
with their overall business objectives. This strategy should transaction costs, and minimize the risk of fraud by creating
encompass a roadmap for integrating digital tools, training an immutable ledger (Najibi, et al., 2017, Quintanilla, et al.,
employees, enhancing customer experience, and ensuring 2021). This technology improves the transparency of banking
compliance with regulatory standards. Additionally, banks processes and ensures that all transactions are securely
must prioritize security and data privacy, as these are critical documented, increasing customer trust and operational
issues in the digital landscape. As the financial services efficiency.
industry becomes more digitized, banks will need to continue The Internet of Things (IoT) is increasingly becoming an
evolving and refining their approach to digital transformation integral part of the digital transformation in retail banking.
(Dufour, 2018, Olufemi, Ozowe & Afolabi, 2012). By enabling the real-time collection and exchange of data,
The future of digital transformation in retail banking holds IoT devices help banks monitor and manage operational
significant promise. Emerging technologies, such as AI, activities more effectively. For instance, IoT sensors in
blockchain, and the Internet of Things (IoT), will continue to ATMs can alert banks to maintenance needs, while smart
drive innovation and create new opportunities for banks to devices used by customers can facilitate seamless
serve their customers. AI-powered chatbots will provide transactions and provide data for personalized banking
more personalized customer support, while blockchain services (Epelle & Gerogiorgis, 2020, Hafezi & Alipour,
technology will further streamline cross-border payments and 2021). IoT’s capacity to collect and transmit real-time data
enhance security. Additionally, the rise of 5G networks and empowers banks to make more informed decisions and
edge computing will enable even faster, more efficient respond to customer needs more promptly.
banking services, particularly in areas like real-time Big Data Analytics is another cornerstone of a digital
payments and mobile banking (Alvarez-Majmutov & Chen, transformation framework. Retail banks are collecting more
2014, Eldardiry & Habib, 2018). data than ever before, and the ability to extract actionable
In conclusion, understanding digital transformation in retail insights from this data can create significant value. Big Data
banking requires recognizing the fundamental changes in allows banks to analyze patterns in customer behavior,
technology, customer expectations, and operational identify emerging market trends, and predict future needs.
processes. Banks that successfully embrace these changes With this information, banks can offer personalized products
will be better equipped to meet the demands of today’s digital and services, develop targeted marketing strategies, and
economy and stay ahead of the competition (Najibi & Asef, optimize decision-making processes (Adejugbe Adejugbe,
2014, Ozowe, Zheng & Sharma, 2020). Digital 2020, Napp, et al., 2014, Shahbaz, et al., 2016). Big Data also
transformation is not just a technological shift; it is a cultural aids in risk management, helping banks assess
and strategic one that has the potential to redefine the future creditworthiness and detect fraud more accurately.
of retail banking. By integrating advanced digital Process optimization is essential for maximizing the benefits
technologies, retail banks can deliver more efficient, of digital transformation. Automation of routine banking
personalized, and secure services, ultimately enhancing both tasks, such as data entry, transaction processing, and
customer satisfaction and business performance. compliance checks, reduces human error, accelerates
operations, and lowers costs (Adejugbe, 2021, Anderson &
2.2 Core Components of the Framework Rezaie, 2019). Automation tools, powered by AI and robotic
The digital transformation in retail banking requires a process automation (RPA), help streamline customer service
comprehensive framework that integrates multiple core and back-office operations, improving both speed and
components, each of which plays a crucial role in enhancing accuracy. These tools enable banks to operate with greater
the efficiency, security, and customer experience within efficiency, reduce operational costs, and provide faster, more
banking operations. The core components of such a reliable services to customers.
framework are built upon technological integration, process Another significant aspect of process optimization is the
optimization, and customer-centric innovation, with each enhancement of transaction speed and accuracy. With the rise
component supporting the bank's ability to stay competitive of digital platforms, customers expect seamless, real-time
in an increasingly digital and customer-driven market transactions. Banks are integrating technologies like
(Agupugo & Tochukwu, 2021, Brown, et al., 2020). blockchain and AI to reduce transaction times and minimize
Technological integration is a key aspect of any digital errors, ensuring that every payment, transfer, or inquiry is
transformation strategy. The adoption of Artificial processed quickly and accurately (Adenugba, Dagunduro &
Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) is pivotal in Akhutie, 2018, Ozowe, 2021). The implementation of instant
this context, as these technologies offer powerful tools to payments and real-time processing ensures that banks can
automate decision-making processes, predict customer meet the growing demand for speed and reliability, a crucial
needs, and identify trends. AI and ML algorithms can assist factor in retaining customer loyalty and satisfaction.
banks in personalizing services, detecting fraud, optimizing Customer-centric innovation forms the backbone of any
risk management, and streamlining operations (Adenugba & digital transformation in retail banking. The ability to offer
Dagunduro, 2019, Ozowe, 2018). These tools can analyze personalized banking services through digital tools is
large datasets to provide predictive insights, enabling banks increasingly important in a competitive market. By utilizing
to anticipate customer behavior and market shifts with a level AI and Big Data, banks can offer tailored financial products,
of accuracy and efficiency that was previously unattainable. personalized recommendations, and customized alerts that
Blockchain technology is another critical component that are aligned with individual customer needs and preferences

610
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

(Brevik, et al., 2016, Ozowe, et al., 2020). Customers expect Building a culture of innovation within retail banks is crucial
banks to understand their unique financial situations and to the successful integration of digital transformation
deliver solutions that make their lives easier. For example, strategies. In the past, banks were typically characterized by
AI-powered chatbots and virtual assistants can provide 24/7 rigid hierarchies, conservative risk management practices,
support and offer advice based on customer data, while and traditional ways of operating. However, the evolving
mobile apps can deliver personalized notifications about financial ecosystem demands more agile and flexible
account activity, financial planning tips, and available approaches to business. To foster innovation, banks must
services. create an environment where employees at all levels are
Improving the user experience is another crucial element of encouraged to think creatively and contribute ideas that drive
customer-centric innovation. Mobile and online banking new digital solutions (Binley, et al., 2015, Farajzadeh, et al.,
platforms need to be intuitive, user-friendly, and responsive 2020). This involves breaking down silos within the
to customer needs. By providing easy access to banking organization and promoting cross-functional collaboration. A
services through these platforms, banks can ensure that culture of innovation thrives when employees are empowered
customers can manage their finances anytime, anywhere to experiment with new ideas and technologies without the
(Bogdanov, et al., 2021, Ericson, Engel-Cox & Arent, 2019). fear of failure. Banks need to invest in ideation platforms,
Mobile banking apps are increasingly becoming a central innovation labs, and hackathons that promote collaboration
point of contact between banks and customers, offering and encourage employees to bring forward fresh ideas that
features like remote check deposits, money transfers, and address both operational challenges and customer needs.
balance tracking. These innovations simplify banking for Moreover, retail banks must emphasize the importance of
customers and increase engagement with the bank’s services, customer-centricity, ensuring that innovation is always
leading to higher customer satisfaction and loyalty. focused on delivering better experiences and outcomes for
Furthermore, digital transformation in retail banking clients.
emphasizes enhancing accessibility and inclusivity for Upskilling and reskilling employees for digital roles is
diverse customer groups. As banking services move online, another critical element of digital transformation. The
it’s crucial to ensure that digital platforms are accessible to introduction of digital technologies such as AI, machine
all customers, including those with disabilities or those who learning, and data analytics requires a workforce with a new
may not be as digitally savvy (Erofeev, et al., 2019, Halabi, set of skills. As these technologies become integral to
Al-Qattan & Al-Otaibi, 2015). Banks must design their banking operations, employees must be equipped with the
digital services to accommodate people with varying needs technical and soft skills needed to work effectively in the
and ensure that their platforms are easy to navigate, secure, digital environment (Hassani, Silva & Al Kaabi, 2017,
and accessible on a variety of devices. Additionally, digital Nguyen, et al., 2014, Salam & Salam, 2020). This requires a
banking solutions can increase financial inclusion by concerted effort by banks to implement continuous learning
providing access to banking services in underserved areas programs and offer training opportunities that help staff stay
where traditional bank branches are not present. ahead of the curve. Upskilling programs should not be limited
In conclusion, developing a framework for digital to technical roles but should also include the development of
transformation in retail banking operations requires digital literacy across all areas of the bank. For instance,
integrating advanced technologies, optimizing banking customer service representatives need to understand how to
processes, and prioritizing customer-centric innovations. By interact with customers through digital channels, and
leveraging AI, machine learning, blockchain, IoT, and Big relationship managers must learn how to leverage data
Data, banks can create more efficient, secure, and analytics to offer more personalized services (Adejugbe
personalized services that meet the evolving demands of the Adejugbe, 2014, Okwiri, 2017, Olayiwola & Sanuade, 2021).
digital economy (Eshiet & Sheng, 2018, Hamza, et al., 2021). Reskilling programs can help employees transition into new
Furthermore, optimizing operational processes and roles that emerge as part of the digital transformation, such as
enhancing the customer experience will allow banks to data analysts, AI specialists, or cybersecurity experts. By
remain competitive, reduce costs, and improve customer making learning an ongoing priority, banks can ensure that
satisfaction. Ultimately, embracing these technologies will their workforce is equipped to handle new technologies and
empower retail banks to navigate the rapidly changing adapt to changing customer expectations.
financial landscape, build stronger relationships with their Leadership plays a pivotal role in driving digital
customers, and thrive in the future of banking. transformation within retail banks. For digital transformation
to succeed, leaders must provide clear vision, direction, and
2.3 Organizational and Cultural Transformation support for the transformation initiatives. Leaders must not
The digital transformation of retail banking is not just a only champion the adoption of new technologies but also
technological shift but also a profound organizational and embody the cultural and organizational changes that
cultural change. While the adoption of new technologies such accompany the digital shift (Garia, et al., 2019, Heidari,
as AI, blockchain, and IoT plays a central role in reshaping Nikolinakou & Flemings, 2018). They should communicate
the operations of banks, the success of these transformations the strategic value of digital transformation to the entire
largely depends on how effectively banks can foster an organization, ensuring that employees understand how these
environment that encourages innovation, supports continuous changes will benefit both the bank and its customers.
learning, and embraces change at every level of the Leadership must also be willing to make tough decisions,
organization (Anwar, et al., 2018, Eyinla, et al., 2021). such as reallocating resources, revising business models, and
Building a culture of innovation, upskilling employees, and challenging existing processes that may no longer be viable
implementing strong leadership strategies are essential in in the digital age. Moreover, leaders should foster an open
ensuring that retail banks remain competitive and relevant in and inclusive environment where diverse ideas are valued,
a rapidly evolving digital landscape. and collaboration is encouraged. By setting an example of

611
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

agility, flexibility, and commitment to innovation, leaders upgrades, a focus on change management and employee
can inspire the entire organization to embrace change and engagement is necessary to ensure that the entire organization
drive transformation from the top down. is aligned with the goals of digital transformation. By
Change management strategies are essential in overcoming embracing these cultural and organizational shifts, retail
resistance to digital transformation. While the benefits of banks can create a competitive edge, improve operational
digitalization in banking are clear, resistance to change is a efficiency, and deliver enhanced services to customers in a
common challenge. Employees who have worked with rapidly evolving digital world.
traditional systems and methods may feel threatened by the
introduction of new technologies or worried about job 2.4 Challenges and Barriers to Digital Transformation
displacement. To overcome this resistance, banks must adopt The digital transformation of retail banking is essential for
comprehensive change management strategies that address meeting the evolving demands of customers, staying
both the emotional and practical aspects of change (Ghani, competitive, and ensuring operational efficiency. However,
Khan & Garaniya, 2015, Rahman, Canter & Kumar, 2014, the path to digital transformation is fraught with challenges
Raliya, et al., 2017). Communication is key in this process, and barriers that can hinder progress. These challenges
as employees need to understand the reasons behind the encompass a wide range of issues, including regulatory
transformation and how it will impact their work. Regular compliance and legal constraints, data security and privacy
communication from leadership, as well as clear and concerns, the balance between technological costs and
transparent messaging, can help to alleviate concerns and operational budgets, and the interoperability issues between
build trust within the organization. In addition to legacy systems and emerging technologies (Adenugba, Excel
communication, banks should involve employees early in the & Dagunduro, 2019, Hossain, et al., 2017). Addressing these
transformation process by soliciting their feedback and input. barriers is crucial for retail banks to successfully navigate the
This participatory approach helps employees feel more digital transformation journey.
invested in the process and can lead to better outcomes. Regulatory compliance and legal constraints present one of
Change management also involves providing adequate the most significant challenges in the digital transformation
support and training throughout the transformation journey. of retail banking. Banks are subject to stringent regulations
Employees should be equipped with the resources and designed to ensure the stability, security, and integrity of the
guidance they need to successfully navigate the changes, financial system. These regulations vary by country and
whether through formal training programs, mentorship, or region and often include requirements related to customer
ongoing support from leadership and peers. data protection, anti-money laundering (AML), know-your-
One of the challenges that banks face in digital customer (KYC), and financial transaction transparency.
transformation is the shift in mindset required across the When implementing new technologies, especially those
organization. Traditional banking cultures, which have involving the storage and transmission of customer data,
historically been focused on risk aversion, must evolve into retail banks must ensure that their digital systems comply
environments that embrace experimentation and continuous with all applicable legal frameworks (Agupugo & Tochukwu,
improvement. In this context, leadership must be committed 2021, Bagum, 2018, Huaman & Jun, 2014). These
to changing the mindset of employees at all levels regulations can slow down the adoption of innovative
(Armstrong, et al., 2016, Glassley, 2014). Encouraging a technologies as banks must thoroughly review and adapt their
“fail-fast” mentality, where mistakes are seen as learning systems to meet compliance requirements. Furthermore, the
opportunities, is essential in driving innovation. This shift evolving nature of technology often outpaces the
also involves redefining the roles of employees and how they development of regulatory frameworks, making it difficult
contribute to the organization’s success. Instead of simply for banks to ensure ongoing compliance. This creates a
executing tasks, employees need to think of themselves as tension between the desire for technological advancement
contributors to a dynamic, evolving organization. This and the need to adhere to regulations. Banks must invest
transformation requires strong leadership to model new considerable resources in understanding the regulatory
behaviors, reward innovation, and encourage collaboration landscape and adapting their digital strategies to mitigate
across departments. risks of non-compliance.
Retail banks must also pay attention to customer-facing Ensuring data security and privacy is another critical concern
teams, ensuring that they are aligned with the digital in the digital transformation of retail banking. As banking
transformation goals. For customer service representatives, operations increasingly rely on digital platforms, the volume
relationship managers, and sales teams, the integration of of sensitive customer data being collected, stored, and
digital tools must enhance their ability to provide transmitted grows exponentially. This makes banks attractive
personalized, data-driven services to clients. These teams targets for cybercriminals seeking to exploit vulnerabilities in
need to be equipped with the skills and knowledge to leverage the system. Any breach or leak of customer data can result in
new digital platforms effectively. By enabling customer- severe reputational damage, regulatory fines, and legal
facing employees with the tools they need to provide superior consequences (Adenugba & Dagunduro, 2021, Jamrozik, et
service, banks can ensure that customers have positive al., 2016). In addition to the risk of external threats, banks
experiences with both digital and traditional channels. must also address internal security measures, ensuring that
In conclusion, the organizational and cultural transformation employees and third-party vendors with access to sensitive
required for successful digital transformation in retail data adhere to strict security protocols. Protecting customer
banking is a complex and ongoing process. Building a culture privacy is paramount, and banks must implement advanced
of innovation, upskilling employees, and fostering strong encryption methods, multi-factor authentication, and other
leadership are essential elements that will help banks security technologies to safeguard data. Additionally, with
navigate the challenges of digitalization (Griffiths, 2017, the advent of cloud computing, banks must ensure that data
Heinemann, et al., 2021). In addition to technological stored off-premise is secure and compliant with data

612
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

protection regulations. While security measures are evolving, of job displacement due to automation, or simply a lack of
the constant threat of cyberattacks makes data protection an understanding of how digital technologies can improve
ongoing challenge that requires continuous investment in performance (Adejugbe, 2020, Kabeyi, 2019, Soeder &
new technologies and strategies to maintain trust with Soeder, 2021, Zhang, et al., 2021). Overcoming this
customers. resistance requires strong leadership, effective
Balancing technological costs with operational budgets is a communication, and a culture of continuous learning. Banks
challenge that many retail banks face when embarking on a must invest in training and upskilling employees to ensure
digital transformation journey. The implementation of new they are equipped to handle new technologies and processes.
technologies often requires significant upfront investments, In addition, leadership must clearly communicate the vision
which can strain operational budgets, especially for smaller and benefits of digital transformation, ensuring that all
or mid-sized banks. These costs can include purchasing stakeholders are aligned with the goals of the initiative.
hardware, licensing software, hiring specialized talent, and Change management strategies must be implemented to ease
investing in infrastructure upgrades (Ball, 2021, Karad & the transition and minimize disruptions to daily operations.
Thakur, 2021, Jharap, et al., 2020, Ozowe, Russell & Sharma, The complexity of these challenges is compounded by the
2020). While the long-term benefits of digital transformation, need to balance short-term operational goals with long-term
such as improved efficiency, better customer service, and strategic objectives. While digital transformation offers long-
reduced operational costs, are clear, the initial financial term benefits, such as improved customer experience, better
outlay can be a barrier to entry. In addition, the pace of decision-making, and more streamlined operations, the
technological advancements means that banks must immediate pressure to meet profitability targets and
continuously invest in upgrading systems to avoid regulatory requirements can make it difficult to prioritize
obsolescence. This creates a situation where banks must innovation. Retail banks must navigate this tension by
make difficult decisions about where to allocate resources. adopting an incremental approach to transformation,
Should they invest in core banking system upgrades, new focusing on quick wins while gradually implementing more
customer-facing apps, or advanced analytics platforms? The complex technologies over time.
financial pressure to make these investments while In conclusion, while digital transformation offers substantial
maintaining profitability can delay the adoption of benefits to retail banks, it also presents a range of challenges
transformative technologies. Retail banks must find a balance that must be addressed for successful implementation.
between the need for innovation and the practical constraints Regulatory compliance, data security, financial constraints,
of their budgets, often requiring careful prioritization and and interoperability with legacy systems all represent
phased implementation plans. significant barriers to progress (Khalid, et al., 2016, Pan, et
Interoperability between legacy systems and new al., 2019, Rashid, Benhelal & Rafiq, 2020). However, by
technologies is another significant challenge in the digital carefully planning their transformation strategies, investing
transformation of retail banking. Many banks have legacy in the right technologies, and fostering a culture of
systems that have been in place for decades, and these innovation, retail banks can overcome these obstacles and
systems are deeply integrated into the bank’s operations. successfully navigate the digital age. Despite the challenges,
These older systems were not designed to accommodate the the potential benefits of digital transformation—improved
latest technological innovations and may not easily integrate efficiency, enhanced customer experience, and long-term
with newer platforms such as AI, blockchain, or cloud competitiveness—make it an essential undertaking for any
computing. This presents a significant barrier to innovation, forward-thinking retail bank.
as banks are forced to either retrofit their existing systems or
replace them entirely, both of which can be costly and time- 2.5 Case Studies and Best Practices
consuming (Bahmaei & Hosseini, 2020, Jomthanachai, The digital transformation of retail banking is a complex,
Wong & Lim, 2021). Additionally, the complexity of banking multifaceted process that requires innovation, strategic
operations means that different departments within the same planning, and the ability to adapt to a rapidly changing
institution may rely on disparate systems that are not easily landscape. As the financial services industry continues to
compatible with one another. For example, the customer evolve, many banks are leveraging new technologies and
service department might use one platform to manage client digital platforms to streamline their operations, improve
interactions, while the finance department uses a different customer service, and stay competitive. Case studies of
system to manage accounts and transactions. Integrating successful digital transformation initiatives can provide
these systems to create a seamless experience for customers valuable insights into the strategies, best practices, and
and improve operational efficiency requires careful planning lessons learned from banks that have navigated this transition
and significant technical expertise. Moreover, the sheer scale effectively.
of operations in large retail banks means that even small One of the most well-known examples of successful digital
changes to legacy systems can have wide-ranging transformation in retail banking is the case of DBS Bank in
consequences, making the process of digital transformation Singapore. As part of its strategy to become the “world’s best
slow and difficult. digital bank,” DBS undertook a comprehensive
Beyond these technical and financial challenges, there is also transformation effort that involved not just upgrading
the issue of organizational inertia. Many retail banks have technology, but also reshaping its organizational culture
well-established operational structures, and employees are (Kinik, Gumus & Osayande, 2015, Nimana, Canter &
accustomed to traditional ways of working. Digital Kumar, 2015, Raza, et al., 2019). The bank began by
transformation requires a fundamental shift in mindset, and investing heavily in digital technologies such as cloud
convincing employees to adopt new technologies and computing, data analytics, artificial intelligence (AI), and
processes can be difficult. Resistance to change can manifest automation. This allowed the bank to improve the speed and
in various ways, including reluctance to adopt new tools, fear efficiency of its operations, streamline processes, and provide

613
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

a better customer experience. One of the most notable assistance, helping them manage their accounts, pay bills, and
successes of DBS’s digital transformation is its mobile track spending. Additionally, Capital One has adopted
banking platform, which has become the go-to banking blockchain technology to enhance the security and
solution for millions of customers. The platform offers a wide transparency of its financial transactions, allowing customers
range of services, from account management to loan to conduct secure, real-time payments. The bank’s success
applications, and provides customers with a seamless, can be attributed to its focus on technological innovation, a
intuitive user experience. DBS’s success in digital commitment to data-driven decision-making, and its ability
transformation can be attributed to its commitment to to integrate new technologies into existing systems
customer-centric innovation, a strong focus on employee seamlessly. Capital One has also embraced an agile working
engagement and reskilling, and its ability to leverage cutting- environment, allowing it to quickly adapt to emerging trends
edge technologies to enhance operational efficiency. and rapidly develop new digital solutions.
Another successful case study is that of ING, a global One of the most significant lessons learned from these
financial services company based in the Netherlands. ING’s successful digital transformation initiatives is the importance
digital transformation journey has been characterized by its of aligning digital strategies with customer expectations.
focus on simplifying banking services and embracing a Customers today demand more personalized, convenient, and
customer-first approach. The bank implemented a strategy efficient banking experiences (Bayer, et al., 2019, Leung,
that prioritized the development of digital channels, including Caramanna & Maroto-Valer, 2014). Retail banks that have
mobile banking, online banking, and a robust digital successfully transformed their operations have done so by
customer support system (Adejugbe Adejugbe, 2018, Bashir, placing the customer at the center of their digital initiatives.
et al., 2020). One of the key elements of ING’s digital For instance, DBS Bank focused on improving customer
transformation was the creation of a “one-click” banking engagement through mobile platforms, while ING prioritized
experience, where customers can access and manage all their simplicity and accessibility in its digital offerings. By
financial needs with minimal effort. The bank also introduced understanding and responding to customer needs, these banks
an advanced AI-powered virtual assistant to handle customer were able to create digital experiences that are both practical
queries and improve response times. ING’s transformation and enjoyable, leading to higher customer satisfaction and
efforts were supported by a culture of agility and innovation, loyalty.
which enabled the bank to rapidly adapt to changing market Another key success factor is the importance of
conditions and customer expectations. One of the main organizational culture in driving digital transformation. In
success factors of ING’s digital transformation was its ability many of the case studies, banks that have succeeded in digital
to align digital initiatives with the bank’s core values of transformation have done so by fostering a culture of
simplicity and transparency, creating a cohesive and user- innovation, agility, and continuous learning. For example,
friendly experience for customers. both DBS and ING placed a strong emphasis on employee
In the UK, Lloyds Banking Group has also embarked on a engagement and upskilling, ensuring that their staff were
significant digital transformation journey, focusing on equipped to navigate the changes brought about by digital
enhancing customer experience and operational efficiency. transformation (Benighaus & Bleicher, 2019, Li & Zhang,
The bank’s approach to digital transformation was centered 2018). A culture of innovation encourages employees to
around improving accessibility and convenience for its experiment with new ideas and technologies, driving
customers through a range of digital channels, including creativity and problem-solving across the organization.
mobile apps, online banking, and automated customer service Additionally, successful banks have invested in leadership
platforms (Elujide, et al., 2021, Kiran, et al., 2017). One of that is committed to driving change and inspiring teams to
the key success factors for Lloyds was its investment in AI embrace new ways of working.
and big data analytics to provide personalized services to Technology adoption is another critical factor in the success
customers. By using data analytics, the bank was able to gain of digital transformation. Banks that have embraced
valuable insights into customer behavior and preferences, emerging technologies such as AI, blockchain, cloud
enabling it to offer tailored financial products and services. computing, and big data analytics have been able to enhance
Lloyds also introduced robotic process automation (RPA) to their operational efficiency, improve decision-making, and
automate routine tasks, such as processing loan applications offer better services to their customers. For example, Capital
and updating account information, which significantly One’s use of AI to optimize decision-making and improve
reduced operational costs and improved service speed. The customer interactions has been a significant driver of its
bank’s digital transformation was also supported by a culture success (Lindi, 2017, Waswa, Kedi & Sula, 2015). Similarly,
of collaboration and innovation, with cross-functional teams the use of blockchain by Capital One and other banks has
working together to drive change and ensure a smooth helped enhance security, reduce fraud, and enable real-time
transition to digital platforms. payments. The ability to integrate new technologies into
Another noteworthy example is the transformation of Capital existing systems is crucial for minimizing disruptions and
One, a major American bank known for its innovation in ensuring that digital transformation initiatives are effective
digital banking. Capital One’s approach to digital and sustainable in the long term.
transformation focused on the use of data and AI to enhance Finally, the importance of change management cannot be
customer service and optimize decision-making processes overstated. Digital transformation is not only about
(Adejugbe Adejugbe, 2015, Kumari & Ranjith, 2019). The implementing new technologies; it is also about shifting
bank has heavily invested in AI-powered technologies such mindsets and behaviors within the organization. Successful
as machine learning, predictive analytics, and natural digital transformation requires a clear strategy, strong
language processing to streamline operations and improve leadership, and a commitment to continuous improvement
customer interactions. For example, the bank’s AI-powered (Bilgen, 2014, Liu, et al., 2019, Nduagu & Gates, 2015,
virtual assistant, Eno, provides customers with personalized Seyedmohammadi, 2017). Banks that have embraced change

614
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

management strategies, such as clear communication, information quickly. In the future, AI will play an even more
stakeholder engagement, and employee training, have been central role in driving efficiency and personalization in retail
able to overcome resistance and ensure that their digital banking, enabling banks to offer highly customized services
initiatives are embraced at all levels of the organization. and reduce human error and operational costs.
In conclusion, the case studies of successful digital Another trend that will significantly impact the future of retail
transformation in retail banking provide valuable insights banking is the use of blockchain technology. Blockchain,
into the strategies, best practices, and lessons learned from with its decentralized and secure ledger system, is
banks that have effectively navigated this process. Key transforming various aspects of the banking industry, from
success factors include customer-centric innovation, a culture payments to identity verification. Blockchain’s potential to
of agility and innovation, technology adoption, and effective reduce fraud, enhance transaction transparency, and enable
change management (Adejugbe Adejugbe, 2018, Elujide, et real-time cross-border payments makes it a game-changer for
al., 2021, Lohne, et al., 2016). By learning from these case retail banks (Li, et al., 2019, Tula, et al., 2004, Martin-
studies, other retail banks can better understand the Roberts, et al., 2021, Stober & Bucher, 2013). As blockchain
challenges and opportunities associated with digital technology continues to mature, it is expected to be further
transformation and develop strategies to successfully integrated into banking systems, particularly in areas like
implement digital solutions that enhance customer cross-border payments, supply chain finance, and digital
experience and improve operational efficiency. identity management. Banks will increasingly explore
blockchain solutions to streamline operations, reduce costs,
2.6 Future Directions and Emerging Trends and improve the security and efficiency of their services.
The future of digital transformation in retail banking is Additionally, blockchain’s ability to create tamper-proof
evolving rapidly, driven by advancements in technology, records will ensure greater transparency in financial
changing customer expectations, and the increasing demand transactions, boosting trust and security among customers
for operational efficiency. The next phase of this and regulators.
transformation is likely to be shaped by a combination of The rise of green banking and sustainability initiatives is
innovations, collaborations, and trends that not only enhance another emerging trend in the future of digital banking. As
customer experience but also redefine how banks operate and environmental concerns become more pressing and climate
deliver their services (Luo, et al., 2019, Szulecki & Westphal, change awareness grows, there is an increasing demand for
2014). As we look toward the future, several emerging trends sustainable financial products and services. Green banking
will continue to shape the landscape of digital banking. practices, which focus on funding environmentally friendly
One of the most significant trends is the growing role of projects and offering products that promote sustainability, are
fintech collaborations and open banking models. Open expected to become a core part of the banking sector’s digital
banking, which allows third-party providers to access transformation (McCollum, et al., 2018, Spada, Sutra &
financial data via APIs (Application Programming Burgherr, 2021). Digital tools will be used to facilitate the
Interfaces), is fundamentally changing the way banks interact monitoring and reporting of sustainable investments, as well
with their customers and offer financial services (Mac as to help customers track their carbon footprint and make
Kinnon, Brouwer & Samuelsen, 2018, Suvin, et al., 2021). more environmentally conscious decisions. The future of
By enabling third-party developers to build applications and retail banking will likely see an increasing focus on
services around the bank’s data, open banking creates sustainability, with banks using digital platforms to promote
opportunities for more personalized, competitive, and green investments and align their operations with global
innovative financial products. Fintech companies, which are sustainability goals. This shift toward green banking is not
often more agile and customer-focused, have become key only driven by consumer demand but also by regulatory
players in the banking ecosystem, partnering with traditional pressures and the need for financial institutions to
banks to bring new technologies and solutions to market demonstrate their commitment to corporate social
faster. This collaboration between established banks and responsibility.
fintech startups is expected to deepen, creating more Looking ahead, the next phase of digital transformation in
seamless, integrated services that enhance the customer retail banking will be characterized by increased automation
experience. In the future, banks will need to focus on and the use of predictive analytics to optimize banking
establishing robust partnerships with fintech firms to stay operations. Automation is already making waves in areas like
competitive and meet the growing demand for personalized back-office processing, customer service, and loan approvals.
and frictionless banking experiences. Robotic process automation (RPA) is being used to reduce
Advancements in AI-driven tools are another key factor manual tasks, improve accuracy, and speed up operations
driving the digital transformation of retail banking. Artificial (Adejugbe Adejugbe, 2019, Mikunda, et al., 2021, Soltani, et
intelligence and machine learning technologies are being al., 2021). In the future, banks will continue to leverage
increasingly integrated into banking operations to enhance automation to improve operational efficiency and lower
decision-making, improve customer service, and automate costs. Additionally, predictive analytics, fueled by big data
various processes. AI can be used to analyze vast amounts of and AI, will allow banks to anticipate customer needs, detect
data in real-time, providing banks with insights into customer fraud before it happens, and optimize financial strategies.
behavior, creditworthiness, and investment opportunities This shift from reactive to proactive banking will enable
(Adejugbe Adejugbe, 2019, Marhoon, 2020, Sule, et al., banks to offer more personalized services and create more
2019). This allows banks to offer more tailored and targeted value for their customers.
financial products, increasing customer satisfaction and The future of retail banking will also be shaped by the
engagement. AI-powered chatbots and virtual assistants are growing demand for seamless, omnichannel banking
also enhancing the customer experience by providing 24/7 experiences. As customers increasingly engage with banks
support and enabling customers to resolve issues or access across multiple devices and platforms, it is essential that

615
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

banks provide a unified and consistent experience. This this transformation cannot be overstated, as the financial
means that digital banking services must be accessible via sector continues to evolve rapidly, with consumer
mobile apps, websites, and even voice-activated assistants, expectations shifting towards more seamless and
offering customers the flexibility to manage their finances in personalized services. Retail banks that fail to adopt these
ways that suit their preferences (Mohd Aman, Shaari & technological advancements risk losing market share to more
Ibrahim, 2021, Soga, t al., 2016). In addition, the integration agile and tech-savvy competitors.
of IoT (Internet of Things) technology will further enhance To implement the framework effectively, retail banks should
the customer experience by providing real-time data on prioritize a customer-centric approach, invest in employee
everything from account balances to the status of loan training and development, and ensure robust cybersecurity
applications. For example, IoT-enabled devices could be used measures are in place to safeguard sensitive data. Moreover,
to automate payments, track spending habits, or notify fostering a culture of innovation and collaboration within the
customers of upcoming bills and due dates. As customers organization will enable banks to adapt to emerging trends
become more accustomed to having access to real-time, and respond to challenges proactively. By following these
personalized information, the ability to provide a seamless recommendations, retail banks can create a strong foundation
and consistent experience across all touchpoints will be a key for digital transformation, positioning themselves for long-
factor in differentiating successful banks from their term success in a dynamic and competitive market.
competitors.
Cybersecurity will remain a critical consideration as banks References
continue to expand their digital offerings. As the volume of 1. Adejugbe A. Comparison Between Unfair Dismissal
data being generated by customers increases, so too does the Law in Nigeria and the International Labour
risk of cyber threats. Banks will need to invest heavily in Organization’s Legal Regime. Social Science Research
robust cybersecurity measures to protect customer data and Network Electronic Journal. 2020.
maintain trust. Blockchain, with its emphasis on security and DOI:10.2139/ssrn.3697717.
transparency, may play a critical role in enhancing data 2. Adejugbe A. From Contract to Status: Unfair Dismissal
security in retail banking, particularly in the areas of identity Law. Nnamdi Azikiwe University Journal of
verification and transaction monitoring (Mohsen & Commercial and Property Law. 2021;8(1):39-53.
Fereshteh, 2017, Zhang, et al., 2021). In addition, Available from:
advancements in encryption, biometric authentication, and https://journals.unizik.edu.ng/jcpl/article/view/649/616.
AI-driven security systems will help safeguard customer 3. Adejugbe A, Adejugbe A. Cost and Event in Arbitration
information and mitigate the risks associated with digital (Case Study: Nigeria). Social Science Research Network
banking. Electronic Journal. 2014. DOI:10.2139/ssrn.2830454.
In conclusion, the future of digital transformation in retail 4. Adejugbe A, Adejugbe A. Vulnerable Children Workers
banking will be shaped by a range of technological and Precarious Work in a Changing World in Nigeria.
advancements and emerging trends. Fintech collaborations Social Science Research Network Electronic Journal.
and open banking models will facilitate the development of 2015. DOI:10.2139/ssrn.2789248.
more personalized and competitive financial services. AI and 5. Adejugbe A, Adejugbe A. A Critical Analysis of the
blockchain technologies will play central roles in enhancing Impact of Legal Restriction on Management and
operational efficiency, improving customer experience, and Performance of an Organization Diversifying into
securing financial transactions. Sustainability initiatives, Nigeria. Social Science Research Network Electronic
driven by green banking practices, will become increasingly Journal. 2016. DOI:10.2139/ssrn.2742385.
important as banks align their operations with global 6. Adejugbe A, Adejugbe A. Women and Discrimination in
environmental goals (Mrdjen & Lee, 2016, Shortall, the Workplace: A Nigerian Perspective. Social Science
Davidsdottir & Axelsson, 2015). As digital transformation Research Network Electronic Journal. 2018.
continues to reshape the retail banking landscape, it is DOI:10.2139/ssrn.3244971.
essential for financial institutions to remain agile, embrace 7. Adejugbe A, Adejugbe A. Constitutionalisation of
new technologies, and prioritize customer needs to stay ahead Labour Law: A Nigerian Perspective. Social Science
in a rapidly evolving market. The next phase of digital Research Network Electronic Journal. 2019.
banking promises to bring even more innovation, efficiency, DOI:10.2139/ssrn.3311225.
and value to both banks and their customers. 8. Adejugbe A, Adejugbe A. The Certificate of Occupancy
as a Conclusive Proof of Title: Fact or Fiction. Social
2.7 Conclusion Science Research Network Electronic Journal. 2019.
In conclusion, the framework for digital transformation in DOI:10.2139/ssrn.3324775.
retail banking operations presents a comprehensive approach 9. Adejugbe A, Adejugbe A. The Philosophy of Unfair
to navigating the evolving landscape of the financial industry. Dismissal Law in Nigeria. Social Science Research
By leveraging cutting-edge technologies, enhancing Network Electronic Journal. 2020.
customer experiences, and optimizing internal processes, the DOI:10.2139/ssrn.3697696.
framework empowers retail banks to stay competitive and 10. Adejugbe A, Adejugbe A. Emerging Trends in Job
meet the growing demands of an increasingly digital world. Security: A Case Study of Nigeria (1st ed.). LAP
The significance of adopting this framework lies in its ability LAMBERT Academic Publishing. 2018. Available
to drive operational efficiency, foster innovation, and from: https://www.amazon.com/Emerging-Trends-Job-
enhance customer satisfaction, ensuring that retail banks Security-Nigeria/dp/6202196769.
remain relevant in the face of technological disruption. 11. Adenugba AA, Dagunduro AO. Leadership style and
Retail banks must embrace digital transformation as an Decision Making As Determinants of Employee
essential strategy for growth and survival. The urgency for Commitment in Local Governments in Nigeria.

616
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

International Journal of Management Studies and Social and Production Technology. 2020;10:1051-1062.
Science Research (IJMSSSR). 2021;3(4):257-267. 26. Ball PJ. A review of geothermal technologies and their
Available from: role in reducing greenhouse gas emissions in the USA.
https://www.ijmsssr.org/paper/IJMSSSR00418.pdf. Journal of Energy Resources Technology.
12. Adenugba AA, Dagunduro AO. Collective Bargaining. 2021;143(1):010903.
In: Okafor EE, Adetola OB, Aborisade RA, Abosede AJ, 27. Bashir I, Lone FA, Bhat RA, Mir SA, Dar ZA, Dar SA.
editors. Human Resources: Industrial Relations and Concerns and threats of contamination on aquatic
Management Perspectives. Nigeria: June, 2019. p. 89- ecosystems. Bioremediation and Biotechnology:
104. ISBN 078-978-55747-2-2. Sustainable Approaches to Pollution Degradation.
13. Adenugba AA, Dagunduro AO, Akhutie R. An 2020:1-26.
Investigation into the Effects of Gender Gap in Family 28. Bayer P, Attard G, Blum P, Menberg K. The geothermal
Roles in Nigeria: The Case of Ibadan City. African potential of cities. Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Journal of Social Sciences (AJSS). 2018;8(2):37-47. Reviews. 2019;106:17-30.
Available from: 29. Benighaus C, Bleicher A. Neither risky technology nor
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1eQa16xEF58KTmY6- renewable electricity: Contested frames in the
8x4X8HDhk-K-JF1M/view. development of geothermal energy in Germany. Energy
14. Adenugba AA, Excel KO, Dagunduro AO. Gender Research & Social Science. 2019;47:46-55.
Differences in the Perception and Handling of 30. Bilgen SELÇU K. Structure and environmental impact
Occupational Stress Among Workers in Commercial of global energy consumption. Renewable and
Banks in IBADAN, Nigeria. African Journal for the Sustainable Energy Reviews. 2014;38:890-902.
Psychological Studies of Social Issues (AJPSSI). 31. Binley A, Hubbard SS, Huisman JA, Revil A, Robinson
2019;22(1):133-147. Available from: DA, Singha K, Slater LD. The emergence of
https://ajpssi.org/index.php/ajpssi/article/view/371. hydrogeophysics for improved understanding of
15. Agupugo CP, Tochukwu MFC. A model to Assess the subsurface processes over multiple scales. Water
Economic Viability of Renewable Energy Microgrids: A Resources Research. 2015;51(6):3837-3866.
Case Study of Imufu Nigeria. 2021. 32. Binley A, Hubbard SS, Huisman JA, Revil A, Robinson
16. Agupugo CP, Tochukwu MFC. A model to Assess the DA, Singha K, Slater LD. The emergence of
Economic Viability of Renewable Energy Microgrids: A hydrogeophysics for improved understanding of
Case Study of Imufu Nigeria. 2021. subsurface processes over multiple scales. Water
17. Ali JA, Kalhury AM, Sabir AN, Ahmed RN, Ali NH, Resources Research. 2015;51(6):3837-3866.
Abdullah AD. A state-of-the-art review of the 33. Bogdanov D, Ram M, Aghahosseini A, Gulagi A,
application of nanotechnology in the oil and gas industry Oyewo AS, Child M, Breyer C. Low-cost renewable
with a focus on drilling engineering. Journal of electricity as the key driver of the global energy
Petroleum Science and Engineering. 2020;191:107118. transition towards sustainability. Energy.
18. Ali N, Jaffar A, Anwer M, Khan S, Anjum M, Hussain 2021;227:120467.
A, Ming X. The greenhouse gas emissions produced by 34. Bogdanov D, Ram M, Aghahosseini A, Gulagi A,
cement production and its impact on environment: a Oyewo AS, Child M, Breyer C. Low-cost renewable
review of global cement processing. International electricity as the key driver of the global energy
Journal of Research (IJR). 2015;2(2). transition towards sustainability. Energy.
19. Allahvirdizadeh P. A review on geothermal wells: Well 2021;227:120467.
integrity issues. Journal of Cleaner Production. 35. Brevik EC, Calzolari C, Miller BA, Pereira P, Kabala C,
2020;275:124009. Baumgarten A, Jordán A. Soil mapping, classification,
20. Alvarez-Majmutov A, Chen J. Analyzing the energy and pedologic modeling: History and future directions.
intensity and greenhouse gas emission of Canadian oil Geoderma. 2016;264:256-274.
sands crude upgrading through process modeling and 36. Brevik EC, Calzolari C, Miller BA, Pereira P, Kabala C,
simulation. Frontiers of Chemical Science and Baumgarten A, Jordán A. Soil mapping, classification,
Engineering. 2014;8:212-218. and pedologic modeling: History and future directions.
21. Anderson A, Rezaie B. Geothermal technology: Trends Geoderma. 2016;264:256-274.
and potential role in a sustainable future. Applied 37. Brown S, Coolbaugh M, DeAngelo J, Faulds J, Fehler
Energy. 2019;248:18-34. M, Gu C, Mlawsky E. Machine learning for natural
22. Anwar MN, Fayyaz A, Sohail NF, Khokhar MF, Baqar resource assessment: An application to the blind
M, Khan WD, Nizami AS. CO2 capture and storage: a geothermal systems of Nevada. Transactions-
way forward for sustainable environment. Journal of Geothermal Resources Council. 2020;44.
Environmental Management. 2018;226:131-144. 38. Brown S, Coolbaugh M, DeAngelo J, Faulds J, Fehler
23. Armstrong RC, Wolfram C, De Jong KP, Gross R, Lewis M, Gu C, Mlawsky E. Machine learning for natural
NS, Boardman B, Ramana MV. The frontiers of energy. resource assessment: An application to the blind
Nature Energy. 2016;1(1):1-8. geothermal systems of Nevada. Transactions-
24. Bagum M. Development of an environmentally safe Geothermal Resources Council. 2020;44.
additive with natural material for drilling fluid 39. Bui M, Adjiman CS, Bardow A, Anthony EJ, Boston A,
application. Doctoral dissertation, Memorial University Brown S, Mac Dowell N. Carbon capture and storage
of Newfoundland; 2018. (CCS): the way forward. Energy & Environmental
25. Bahmaei Z, Hosseini E. Pore pressure prediction using Science. 2018;11(5):1062-1176.
seismic velocity modeling: case study, Sefid-Zakhor gas 40. Bui M, Adjiman CS, Bardow A, Anthony EJ, Boston A,
field in Southern Iran. Journal of Petroleum Exploration Brown S, Mac Dowell N. Carbon capture and storage

617
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

(CCS): the way forward. Energy & Environmental in power generation: review of impacts and opportunities
Science. 2018;11(5):1062-1176. for water sustainability. Energy, Sustainability and
41. Burrows LC, Haeri F, Cvetic P, Sanguinito S, Shi F, Society. 2018;8(1):1-15.
Tapriyal D, Enick RM. A literature review of CO2, 57. Elujide I, Fashoto SG, Fashoto B, Mbunge E, Folorunso
natural gas, and water-based fluids for enhanced oil SO, Olamijuwon JO. Application of deep and machine
recovery in unconventional reservoirs. Energy & Fuels. learning techniques for multi-label classification
2020;34(5):5331-5380. performance on psychotic disorder diseases. Informatics
42. Burrows LC, Haeri F, Cvetic P, Sanguinito S, Shi F, in Medicine Unlocked. 2021;23:100545.
Tapriyal D, Enick RM. A literature review of CO2, 58. Elujide I, Fashoto SG, Fashoto B, Mbunge E, Folorunso
natural gas, and water-based fluids for enhanced oil SO, Olamijuwon JO. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked.
recovery in unconventional reservoirs. Energy & Fuels. 2021.
2020;34(5):5331-5380. 59. Epelle EI, Gerogiorgis DI. A review of technological
43. Carri A, Valletta A, Cavalca E, Savi R, Segalini A. advances and open challenges for oil and gas drilling
Advantages of IoT-based geotechnical monitoring systems engineering. AIChE Journal.
systems integrating automatic procedures for data 2020;66(4):e16842.
acquisition and elaboration. Sensors. 2021;21(6):2249. 60. Ericson SJ, Engel-Cox J, Arent DJ. Approaches for
44. Carri A, Valletta A, Cavalca E, Savi R, Segalini A. integrating renewable energy technologies in oil and gas
Advantages of IoT-based geotechnical monitoring operations. National Renewable Energy Lab. NREL/TP-
systems integrating automatic procedures for data 6A50-72842. Golden, CO (United States); 2019.
acquisition and elaboration. Sensors. 2021;21(6):2249. 61. Erofeev A, Orlov D, Ryzhov A, Koroteev D. Prediction
45. Carter KM, van Oort E, Barendrecht A. Improved of porosity and permeability alteration based on machine
regulatory oversight using real-time data monitoring learning algorithms. Transport in Porous Media.
technologies in the wake of Macondo. In: SPE 2019;128:677-700.
Deepwater Drilling and Completions Conference; 2014 62. Eshiet KII, Sheng Y. The performance of stochastic
Sep. p. D011S007R001. SPE. designs in wellbore drilling operations. Petroleum
46. Carter KM, van Oort E, Barendrecht A. Improved Science. 2018;15:335-365.
regulatory oversight using real-time data monitoring 63. Eyinla DS, Oladunjoye MA, Olayinka AI, Bate BB.
technologies in the wake of Macondo. In: SPE Rock physics and geomechanical application in the
Deepwater Drilling and Completions Conference; 2014 interpretation of rock property trends for overpressure
Sep. p. D011S007R001. SPE. detection. Journal of Petroleum Exploration and
47. Chataway J, Hanlin R, Kaplinsky R. Inclusive Production. 2021;11:75-95.
innovation: an architecture for policy development. 64. Farajzadeh R, Eftekhari AA, Dafnomilis G, Lake LW,
Innovation and Development. 2014;4(1):33-54. Bruining J. On the sustainability of CO2 storage through
48. Chataway J, Hanlin R, Kaplinsky R. Inclusive CO2–Enhanced oil recovery. Applied Energy.
innovation: an architecture for policy development. 2020;261:114467.
Innovation and Development. 2014;4(1):33-54. 65. Garia S, Pal AK, Ravi K, Nair AM. A comprehensive
49. Dagunduro AO, Adenugba AA. Failure to Meet up to analysis on the relationships between elastic wave
Expectation: Examining Women Activist Groups and velocities and petrophysical properties of sedimentary
Political Movements in Nigeria. De Gruyter; Open rocks based on laboratory measurements. Journal of
Cultural Studies. 2020;4:23-35. Petroleum Exploration and Production Technology.
50. de Almeida PC, Araújo ODQF, de Medeiros JL. 2019;9:1869-1881.
Managing offshore drill cuttings waste for improved 66. Ghani A, Khan F, Garaniya V. Improved oil recovery
sustainability. Journal of Cleaner Production. using CO2 as an injection medium: a detailed analysis.
2017;165:143-156. Journal of Petroleum Exploration and Production
51. Diao H, Ghorbani M. Production risk caused by human Technology. 2015;5:241-254.
factors: a multiple case study of thermal power plants. 67. Glassley WE. Geothermal Energy: Renewable Energy
Frontiers of Business Research in China. 2018;12:1-27. and the Environment. CRC Press; 2014.
52. Dickson MH, Fanelli M. What is geothermal energy? In: 68. Griffiths S. A review and assessment of energy policy in
Renewable Energy (Vol 1_302-Vol 1_328). Routledge; the Middle East and North Africa region. Energy Policy.
2018. 2017;102:249-269.
53. Dominy SC, O'Connor L, Parbhakar-Fox A, Glass HJ, 69. Hadinata D, Mulia Y, Rudyanto T, Laharan A, Haurissa
Purevgerel S. Geometallurgy—A route to more resilient P, Soemantri H, Sugianto R. A Success of Modified
mine operations. Minerals. 2018;8(12):560. Water-Based Mud as Drilling Fluid Optimization to Drill
54. Dong X, Liu H, Chen Z, Wu K, Lu N, Zhang Q. Shale Formation at South-S Wells. In: International
Enhanced oil recovery techniques for heavy oil and Petroleum Technology Conference; 2021 Mar. p.
oilsands reservoirs after steam injection. Applied D041S016R001. IPTC.
Energy. 2019;239:1190-1211. 70. Hafezi R, Alipour M. Renewable energy sources:
55. Dufour F. The Costs and Implications of Our Demand Traditional and modern-age technologies. In: Affordable
for Energy: A Comparative and Comprehensive and Clean Energy (pp. 1085-1099). Cham: Springer
Analysis of the Available Energy Resources. The Costs International Publishing; 2021.
and Implications of Our Demand for Energy: A 71. Halabi MA, Al-Qattan A, Al-Otaibi A. Application of
Comparative and Comprehensive Analysis of the solar energy in the oil industry—Current status and
Available Energy Resources. 2018. future prospects. Renewable and Sustainable Energy
56. Eldardiry H, Habib E. Carbon capture and sequestration Reviews. 2015;43:296-314.

618
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

72. Hamza A, Hussein IA, Al-Marri MJ, Mahmoud M, overview of current status of carbon dioxide capture and
Shawabkeh R, Aparicio S. CO2 enhanced gas recovery storage technologies. Renewable and Sustainable
and sequestration in depleted gas reservoirs: A review. Energy Reviews. 2014;39:426-443.
Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering. 88. Li H, Zhang J. Well log and seismic data analysis for
2021;196:107685. complex pore-structure carbonate reservoir using 3D
73. Hassani H, Silva ES, Al Kaabi AM. The role of rock physics templates. Journal of Applied Geophysics.
innovation and technology in sustaining the petroleum 2018;151:175-183.
and petrochemical industry. Technological Forecasting 89. Li W, Zhang Q, Zhang Q, Guo F, Qiao S, Liu S, Heng
and Social Change. 2017;119:1-17. X. Development of a distributed hybrid seismic–
74. Heidari M, Nikolinakou MA, Flemings PB. Coupling electrical data acquisition system based on the
geomechanical modeling with seismic pressure Narrowband Internet of Things (NB-IoT) technology.
prediction. Geophysics. 2018;83(5):B253-B267. Geoscientific Instrumentation, Methods and Data
75. Heinemann N, Alcalde J, Miocic JM, Hangx SJ, Systems. 2019;8(2):177-186.
Kallmeyer J, Ostertag-Henning C, Rudloff A. Enabling 90. Lindi O. Analysis of kick detection methods in the light
large-scale hydrogen storage in porous media—the of actual blowout disasters. Master's thesis, NTNU.
scientific challenges. Energy & Environmental Science. 2017.
2021;14(2):853-864. 91. Liu W, Zhang G, Cao J, Zhang J, Yu G. Combined
76. Hossain ME, Al-Majed A, Adebayo AR, Apaleke AS, petrophysics and 3D seismic attributes to predict shale
Rahman SM. A critical review of drilling waste reservoirs favourable areas. Journal of Geophysics and
management towards sustainable solutions. Engineering. 2019;16(5):974-991.
Environmental Engineering & Management Journal 92. Lohne HP, Ford EP, Mansouri M, Randeberg E. Well
(EEMJ). 2017;16(7). integrity risk assessment in geothermal wells—Status of
77. Huaman RNE, Jun TX. Energy related CO2 emissions today. GeoWell, Stavanger. 2016.
and the progress on CCS projects: a review. Renewable 93. Luo Y, Huang H, Jakobsen M, Yang Y, Zhang J, Cai Y.
and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 2014;31:368-385. Prediction of porosity and gas saturation for deep-buried
78. Jamrozik A, Protasova E, Gonet A, Bilstad T, Żurek R. sandstone reservoirs from seismic data using an
Characteristics of oil-based muds and influence on the improved rock-physics model. Acta Geophysica.
environment. AGH Drilling, Oil, Gas. 2016;33(4). 2019;67:557-575.
79. Jharap G, van Leeuwen LP, Mout R, van der Zee WE, 94. Mac Kinnon MA, Brouwer J, Samuelsen S. The role of
Roos FM, Muntendam-Bos AG. Ensuring safe growth of natural gas and its infrastructure in mitigating
the geothermal energy sector in the Netherlands by greenhouse gas emissions, improving regional air
proactively addressing risks and hazards. Netherlands quality, and renewable resource integration. Progress in
Journal of Geosciences. 2020;99:e6. Energy and Combustion Science. 2018;64:62-92.
80. Jomthanachai S, Wong WP, Lim CP. An application of 95. Marhoon TMM. High pressure high temperature
data envelopment analysis and machine learning (HPHT) wells technologies while drilling. Doctoral
approach to risk management. IEEE Access. dissertation, Politecnico di Torino. 2020.
2021;9:85978-85994. 96. Martin-Roberts E, Scott V, Flude S, Johnson G,
81. Kabeyi MJB. Geothermal electricity generation, Haszeldine RS, Gilfillan S. Carbon capture and storage
challenges, opportunities, and recommendations. at the end of a lost decade. One Earth. 2021;4(11):1569-
International Journal of Advances in Scientific Research 1584.
and Engineering (IJASRE). 2019;5(8):53-95. 97. Matthews VO, Idaike SU, Noma-Osaghae E, Okunoren
82. Karad S, Thakur R. Efficient monitoring and control of A, Akwawa L. Design and construction of a smart
wind energy conversion systems using Internet of Things wireless access/ignition technique for automobile.
(IoT): a comprehensive review. Environment, International Journal for Research in Applied Science &
Development and Sustainability. 2021;23(10):14197- Engineering Technology (IJRASET). 2018;6(8):165-
14214. 173.
83. Khalid P, Ahmed N, Mahmood A, Saleem MA, Hassan. 98. McCollum DL, Zhou W, Bertram C, De Boer HS,
An integrated seismic interpretation and rock physics Bosetti V, Busch S, Riahi K. Energy investment needs
attribute analysis for pore fluid discrimination. Arabian for fulfilling the Paris Agreement and achieving the
Journal for Science and Engineering. 2016;41:191-200. Sustainable Development Goals. Nature Energy.
84. Kinik K, Gumus F, Osayande N. Automated dynamic 2018;3(7):589-599.
well control with managed-pressure drilling: a case study 99. Mikunda T, Brunner L, Skylogianni E, Monteiro J,
and simulation analysis. SPE Drilling & Completion. Rycroft L, Kemper J. Carbon capture and storage and the
2015;30(02):110-118. sustainable development goals. International Journal of
85. Kiran R, Teodoriu C, Dadmohammadi Y, Nygaard R, Greenhouse Gas Control. 2021;108:103318.
Wood D, Mokhtari M, Salehi S. Identification and 100. Mohd Aman AH, Shaari N, Ibrahim R. Internet of things
evaluation of well integrity and causes of failure of well energy system: Smart applications, technology
integrity barriers (A review). Journal of Natural Gas advancement, and open issues. International Journal of
Science and Engineering. 2017;45:511-526. Energy Research. 2021;45(6):8389-8419.
86. Kumari WGP, Ranjith PG. Sustainable development of 101. Mohsen O, Fereshteh N. An extended VIKOR method
enhanced geothermal systems based on geotechnical based on entropy measure for the failure modes risk
research—A review. Earth-Science Reviews. assessment–A case study of the geothermal power plant
2019;199:102955. (GPP). Safety Science. 2017;92:160-172.\
87. Leung DY, Caramanna G, Maroto-Valer MM. An 102. Mosca F, Djordjevic O, Hantschel T, McCarthy J,

619
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

Krueger A, Phelps D, MacGregor A. Pore pressure 2020 Jul; URTEC.

prediction while drilling: Three-dimensional earth model 119. Ozowe W, Zheng S, Sharma M. Selection of
in the Gulf of Mexico. AAPG Bulletin. hydrocarbon gas for huff-n-puff IOR in shale oil
2018;102(4):691-708. reservoirs. Journal of Petroleum Science and
103. Mrdjen I, Lee J. High volume hydraulic fracturing Engineering. 2020;195:107683.
operations: potential impacts on surface water and 120. Pan SY, Gao M, Shah KJ, Zheng J, Pei SL, Chiang PC.
human health. International Journal of Environmental Establishment of enhanced geothermal energy utilization
Health Research. 2016;26(4):361-380. plans: Barriers and strategies. Renewable Energy.
104. Mushtaq N, Singh DV, Bhat RA, Dervash MA, Hameed 2019;132:19-32.
OB. Freshwater contamination: sources and hazards to 121. Quintanilla Z, Ozowe W, Russell R, Sharma M, Watts
aquatic biota. Fresh Water Pollution Dynamics and R, Fitch F, Ahmad YK. An experimental investigation
Remediation. 2020:27-50. demonstrating enhanced oil recovery in tight rocks using
105. Najibi AR, Asef MR. Prediction of seismic-wave mixtures of gases and nanoparticles. In:
velocities in rock at various confining pressures based on SPE/AAPG/SEG Unconventional Resources
unconfined data. Geophysics. 2014;79(4):D235-D242. Technology Conference; 2021 Jul; URTEC.
106. Najibi AR, Ghafoori M, Lashkaripour GR, Asef MR. 122. Rahman MM, Canter C, Kumar A. Greenhouse gas
Reservoir geomechanical modeling: In-situ stress, pore emissions from recovery of various North American
pressure, and mud design. Journal of Petroleum Science conventional crudes. Energy. 2014;74:607-617.
and Engineering. 2017;151:31-39. 123. Raliya R, Saharan V, Dimkpa C, Biswas P.
107. Napp TA, Gambhir A, Hills TP, Florin N, Fennell PS. A Nanofertilizer for precision and sustainable agriculture:
review of the technologies, economics and policy current state and future perspectives. Journal of
instruments for decarbonising energy-intensive Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 2017;66(26):6487-
manufacturing industries. Renewable and Sustainable 6503.
Energy Reviews. 2014;30:616-640. 124. Rashid MI, Benhelal E, Rafiq S. Reduction of
108. Nduagu EI, Gates ID. Unconventional heavy oil growth greenhouse gas emissions from gas, oil, and coal power
and global greenhouse gas emissions. Environmental plants in Pakistan by carbon capture and storage (CCS):
Science & Technology. 2015;49(14):8824-8832. A review. Chemical Engineering & Technology.
109. Nguyen HH, Khabbaz H, Fatahi B, Vincent P, Marix- 2020;43(11):2140-2148.
Evans M. Sustainability considerations for ground 125. Raza A, Gholami R, Rezaee R, Rasouli V, Rabiei M.
improvement techniques using controlled modulus Significant aspects of carbon capture and storage–A
columns. In: AGS Symposium on Resilient Geotechnics; review. Petroleum. 2019;5(4):335-340.
2014 Oct; The Australian Geomechanics Society. 126. Salam A, Salam A. Internet of things in sustainable
110. Nimana B, Canter C, Kumar A. Energy consumption and energy systems. In: Internet of Things for Sustainable
greenhouse gas emissions in upgrading and refining of Community Development: Wireless Communications,
Canada's oil sands products. Energy. 2015;83:65-79. Sensing, and Systems; 2020. p. 183-216.
111. Okwiri LA. Risk assessment and risk modelling in 127. Seyedmohammadi J. The effects of drilling fluids and
geothermal drilling. Doctoral dissertation, Politecnico di environment protection from pollutants using some
Torino. 2017. models. Modeling Earth Systems and Environment.
112. Olayiwola T, Sanuade OA. A data-driven approach to 2017;3:1-14.
predict compressional and shear wave velocities in 128. Shahbaz M, Mallick H, Mahalik MK, Sadorsky P. The
reservoir rocks. Petroleum. 2021;7(2):199-208. role of globalization on the recent evolution of energy
113. Olufemi BA, Ozowe WO, Komolafe OO. Studies on the demand in India: Implications for sustainable
production of caustic soda using solar powered development. Energy Economics. 2016;55:52-68.
diaphragm cells. ARPN Journal of Engineering and 129. Shahbazi A, Nasab BR. Carbon capture and storage
Applied Sciences. 2011;6(3):49-54. (CCS) and its impacts on climate change and global
114. Olufemi B, Ozowe W, Afolabi K. Operational warming. J Pet Environ Biotechnol. 2016;7(9).
simulation of solar cells for caustic. Cell (EADC). 130. Shortall R, Davidsdottir B, Axelsson G. Geothermal
2012;2(6). energy for sustainable development: A review of
115. Ozowe WO. Capillary pressure curve and liquid sustainability impacts and assessment frameworks.
permeability estimation in tight oil reservoirs using Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.
pressure decline versus time data. Doctoral dissertation, 2015;44:391-406.
Politecnico di Torino. 2018. 131. Shrestha N, Chilkoor G, Wilder J, Gadhamshetty V,
116. Ozowe WO. Evaluation of lean and rich gas injection for Stone JJ. Potential water resource impacts of hydraulic
improved oil recovery in hydraulically fractured fracturing from unconventional oil production in the
reservoirs. Doctoral dissertation, Politecnico di Torino. Bakken shale. Water Research. 2017;108:1-24.
2021. 132. Soeder DJ, Soeder DJ. Impacts to human health and
117. Ozowe W, Quintanilla Z, Russell R, Sharma M. ecosystems. In: Fracking and the Environment: A
Experimental evaluation of solvents for improved oil Scientific Assessment of the Environmental Risks from
recovery in shale oil reservoirs. In: SPE Annual Hydraulic Fracturing and Fossil Fuels; 2021. p. 135-153.
Technical Conference and Exhibition; 2020 Oct; SPE. 133. Soga K, Alonso E, Yerro A, Kumar K, Bandara S.
118. Ozowe W, Russell R, Sharma M. A novel experimental Trends in large-deformation analysis of landslide mass
approach for dynamic quantification of liquid saturation movements with particular emphasis on the material
and capillary pressure in shale. In: SPE/AAPG/SEG point method. Géotechnique. 2016;66(3):248-273.
Unconventional Resources Technology Conference; 134. Soltani M, Kashkooli FM, Souri M, Rafiei B, Jabarifar

620
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Growth Evaluation www.allmultidisciplinaryjournal.com

M, Gharali K, Nathwani JS. Environmental, economic,

and social impacts of geothermal energy systems.
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.
2021;140:110750.
135. Spada M, Sutra E, Burgherr P. Comparative accident risk
assessment with focus on deep geothermal energy
systems in the Organization for Economic Co-operation
and Development (OECD) countries. Geothermics.
2021;95:102142.
136. Sule I, Imtiaz S, Khan F, Butt S. Risk analysis of well
blowout scenarios during managed pressure drilling
operation. Journal of Petroleum Science and
Engineering. 2019;182:106296.
137. Suvin PS, Gupta P, Horng JH, Kailas SV. Evaluation of
a comprehensive non-toxic, biodegradable and
sustainable cutting fluid developed from coconut oil.
Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers,
Part J: Journal of Engineering Tribology.
2021;235(9):1842-1850.
138. Szulecki K, Westphal K. The cardinal sins of European
energy policy: Nongovernance in an uncertain global
landscape. Global Policy. 2014;5:38-51.
139. Tula OA, Adekoya OO, Isong D, Daudu CD, Adefemi
A, Okoli CE. Corporate advising strategies: A
comprehensive review for aligning petroleum
engineering with climate goals and CSR commitments in
the United States and Africa. Corporate Sustainable
Management Journal. 2004;2(1):32-38.
140. Waswa AM, Kedi WE, Sula N. Design and
implementation of a GSM based fuel leakage monitoring
system on trucks in transit. Abstract of Emerging Trends
in Scientific Research. 2015;3:1-18.
141. Zhang P, Ozowe W, Russell RT, Sharma MM.
Characterization of an electrically conductive proppant
for fracture diagnostics. Geophysics. 2021;86(1):E13-
E20.

621