0% found this document useful (0 votes)
56 views57 pages

Polity Brainstrom

The document outlines key aspects of India's Constitution, including the Preamble, Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles, and various amendments. It highlights the challenges faced in governance, such as political misuse and public ignorance, while suggesting ways forward like civic education and legal reforms. The importance of maintaining constitutional values and ensuring accountability in governance is emphasized throughout.

Uploaded by

GovindKumarRowdy
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
56 views57 pages

Polity Brainstrom

The document outlines key aspects of India's Constitution, including the Preamble, Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles, and various amendments. It highlights the challenges faced in governance, such as political misuse and public ignorance, while suggesting ways forward like civic education and legal reforms. The importance of maintaining constitutional values and ensuring accountability in governance is emphasized throughout.

Uploaded by

GovindKumarRowdy
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 57

1.

Preamble: Terms and Interpretations

INTRODUCTION

The Preamble introduces the Constitution’s goals: Sovereign, Socialist,


Secular, Democratic Republic. Though not legally enforceable, it guides
interpretation, especially post Kesavananda Bharati (1973).

MAIN BODY

• Sovereign : Full authority in domestic and foreign affairs

• Socialist : Economic justice — reflected in schemes like PM Garib Kalyan


Yojana (2020)

• Secular : Equal respect to all religions — upheld in S.R. Bommai Case


(1994)

• Democratic : Elected government, universal adult franchise

• Republic : Elected head, not monarch — ensures accountability

• 42nd Amendment (1976) : Inserted 'Socialist', 'Secular', 'Integrity'

• Judicial Use : Maneka Gandhi (1978), Berubari Union (1960) interpret it


as part of Constitution

• Exam Tip : Link with SDGs, schemes like Ayushman Bharat, Digital India

CHALLENGES

• Misuse in political rhetoric

• Public ignorance of its value

• Loose interpretations of terms

• No legal enforceability
WAY FORWARD

• School-level civic education

• Annual Preamble readings (Samvidhan Diwas)

• Promote public discourse

• Train public servants on constitutional values

CONCLUSION

The Preamble reflects India’s aspirations. It is the soul of the Constitution


and must guide all governance efforts toward inclusive development.

------------------------------------------------------------

2. Fundamental Rights (Articles 14–32)

INTRODUCTION

Fundamental Rights ensure liberty, equality, and dignity. Mentioned in Part


III (Articles 12–35), they are justiciable under Article 32.

MAIN BODY

• Right to Equality (Articles 14–18) : Non-discrimination, equality before


law — Indra Sawhney (1992) on reservations

• Right to Freedom (Articles 19–22) : Speech, movement, liberty —


Maneka Gandhi (1978) widened scope of Article 21

• Right against Exploitation (Articles 23–24) : Ban on child labor,


trafficking — reinforced through PENCIL Portal

• Right to Constitutional Remedies (Article 32) : "Heart and Soul" — basis


of PILs, activism

• Exam Tip : Use Shreya Singhal (2015) for Article 19, Kesavananda for
rights vs DPSPs

CHALLENGES
• Abuse of sedition laws

• Rural and poor unaware of rights

• Delay in enforcement

• Overlap with DPSPs creating friction

WAY FORWARD

• Expand legal aid access (eCourts, Nyaya Bandhu app)

• Civic education in schools

• Rights-based approach in welfare schemes

• Police reforms for enforcement

CONCLUSION

Fundamental Rights are the spine of our democracy. Their protection


ensures true Swaraj and constitutional governance.

------------------------------------------------------------

3. Directive Principles and Uniform Civil Code

INTRODUCTION

DPSPs (Articles 36–51) are ideals for state policy. Article 44 directs state to
secure Uniform Civil Code (UCC).

MAIN BODY

• Article 38–39 : Ensure welfare state — reflected in Food Security Act,


POSHAN Abhiyan

• Article 41–43 : Work, education, living wage — led to MGNREGA, RTE Act

• Article 44 : Common civil code for all religions — sparked debate post
Shah Bano (1985)

• Goa’s UCC model : Example of uniformity


• Minerva Mills (1980) : Balanced FRs and DPSPs

• Exam Tip : Cite Law Commission 2018 paper on UCC

CHALLENGES

• Religious opposition, lack of consensus

• Varying personal laws

• Politicization of UCC

• Limited public discourse

WAY FORWARD

• Law Commission-led consultations

• Start with gender-neutral reforms

• Model laws for voluntary adoption

• Educate communities and faith leaders

CONCLUSION

DPSPs are the conscience of the Constitution. UCC must evolve through
dialogue, not coercion.

------------------------------------------------------------

4. Constitutional Amendments – 42nd, 44th, 103rd

INTRODUCTION

Article 368 empowers Parliament to amend the Constitution, with limits


via Basic Structure Doctrine.

MAIN BODY

• 42nd Amendment (1976) : Added ‘Socialist’, ‘Secular’, centralised power


• 44th Amendment (1978) : Undid Emergency excesses — restored
liberties under Article 21

• 103rd Amendment (2019) : 10% EWS quota — challenged in court vs


50% ceiling

• Key Cases : Kesavananda Bharati (1973), I.R. Coelho (2007) on 9th


Schedule

• Exam Tip : Mention Golaknath (1967), NJAC Case (2015) for limits to
amendment

CHALLENGES

• Lack of public debate before changes

• Political misuse

• Uncertainty on EWS criteria

• States' lack of consensus

WAY FORWARD

• Pre-legislative consultation

• Engage academia and civil society

• Set up Constitutional Review Body

• Regular review of past amendments

CONCLUSION

Amendments should reflect change but protect values. Transparency and


inclusiveness must guide reforms.

------------------------------------------------------------

5. Basic Structure Doctrine

INTRODUCTION
The doctrine limits Parliament’s power to alter foundational constitutional
principles.

MAIN BODY

• Defined in Kesavananda Bharati (1973) : Parliament can amend, not


destroy Constitution’s core

• Elements : Rule of law, secularism, separation of powers, judicial review

• SR Bommai (1994) : Upheld secularism

• NJAC Case (2015) : Judicial independence is basic

• Exam Tip : Always connect doctrine with Parliament, judiciary, and


federal debates

CHALLENGES

• No exhaustive list of core features

• Occasional judicial overreach

• Lack of public understanding

WAY FORWARD

• Consensus through case law

• Legal education campaigns

• Avoid frequent constitutional tinkering

• Harmonious balance between institutions

CONCLUSION

Basic Structure ensures stability with change. It defends constitutional


morality and democratic integrity.

------------------------------------------------------------
6. Federal Structure: Cooperative and Fiscal Federalism

INTRODUCTION

India’s federalism is ‘quasi-federal’ — strong Centre but states also


autonomous. Post-NITI Aayog and GST, cooperation over competition is
promoted.

MAIN BODY

• Inter-State Council : Article 263 — consultative mechanism, reactivated


post-2016

• NITI Aayog : Replaced Planning Commission, fosters cooperative


federalism — Aspirational Districts Programme

• GST Council : Constitutional body under Article 279A — Centre–State


synergy on tax sharing

• Finance Commission : Article 280 — recommends vertical and horizontal


devolution

• 15th Finance Commission (2020–25) : 41% devolution; flagged tax


buoyancy, demographic gaps

• Vertical vs Horizontal imbalance : States lack resource autonomy

• Exam Tip : Cite Punchhi Commission (2010) for federal suggestions

CHALLENGES

• Centre’s dominance in devolution

• Delays in GST compensation

• Political divergence affecting councils

• Limited fiscal space for states

WAY FORWARD

• Strengthen Inter-State Council

• Regular GST Council meetings

• Broader tax base for states


• Capacity building for fiscal management

CONCLUSION

Cooperative and fiscal federalism must mature with trust, equity, and
institutional respect.

------------------------------------------------------------

7. Inter-State Water Disputes and Article 262

INTRODUCTION

Water disputes test India’s federalism. Article 262 allows Parliament to


adjudicate water conflicts.

MAIN BODY

• Key Disputes : Cauvery (Karnataka-TN), Krishna (Maharashtra-Karnataka-


AP), Ravi-Beas (Punjab-Haryana)

• Article 262 : Excludes Supreme Court jurisdiction when tribunal created

• Interstate Water Disputes Act, 1956 : Tribunal formation

• Cauvery Water Tribunal : Formed in 1990, SC gave final verdict in 2018

• River Boards Act (1956) : Never effectively implemented

• Exam Tip : Quote Mihir Shah Committee (2016) on river basin


governance

CHALLENGES

• Delayed tribunal decisions

• Non-enforcement of awards

• Political rhetoric aggravates disputes

• Lack of integrated water management


WAY FORWARD

• Permanent Tribunal (2019 Bill proposal)

• Inter-state MoUs with river basin approach

• Promote consensus via NITI Aayog forums

• Improve hydrological data transparency

CONCLUSION

Water sharing must balance federalism and equity. Consensus and legal
finality are crucial.

------------------------------------------------------------

8. Role of Governor and Recent Controversies

INTRODUCTION

Governor is a constitutional link between Centre and State (Articles 153–


162). Recent political issues raised debates.

MAIN BODY

• Article 163 : Governor acts on CM’s aid but can use discretion

• Discretionary Powers : Reserving bills (Article 200), dismissing


government, reporting breakdown

• Controversies : Maharashtra (2019), Punjab-Bengal (2023), Tamil Nadu


delay in bill assent

• Sarkaria Commission (1988) : Suggested neutrality, fixed tenures

• Nabam Rebia Case (2016) : Governor can’t interfere in legislative


business

• Exam Tip : Link with federalism, basic structure, President’s Rule

CHALLENGES

• Political appointments dilute neutrality


• Misuse of discretionary powers

• No judicial timelines on bill assent

• Role in hung assemblies creates tension

WAY FORWARD

• Review Governor appointment process

• Amend Articles 155–156 for criteria

• Establish judicial timelines on bills

• Promote transparency through reports

CONCLUSION

Governor’s post must serve as a constitutional guardian, not political


agent. Reforms needed to depoliticize the role.

------------------------------------------------------------

9. Parliament and State Legislature: Structure and Functioning

INTRODUCTION

Parliament (Article 79–122) and State Legislatures (Article 168–212) are


law-making bodies ensuring democracy.

MAIN BODY

• Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha : Bicameral — 543 and 245 members

• State Assemblies : Unicameral or bicameral

• Sessions : Budget, Monsoon, Winter — declining sittings noted by PRS


India

• Committee System : Standing and ad hoc — improves scrutiny

• Speaker’s Role : Conducts House, ensures discipline — cite Kihoto


Hollohan (1992)
• Exam Tip : Mention Productivity Report (2023) on disruptions and delays

CHALLENGES

• Frequent disruptions and walkouts

• Lack of discussion on bills

• Ordinance overuse bypasses legislature

• Weak role of Opposition

WAY FORWARD

• Mandatory minimum sittings

• Strengthen committee referrals

• Curb ordinance route

• Empower Opposition through structured debates

CONCLUSION

Legislatures must reclaim their deliberative role. Functioning institutions


are the pillars of democracy.

------------------------------------------------------------

10. Anti-Defection Law and Speaker’s Role

INTRODUCTION

Tenth Schedule (added by 52nd Amendment, 1985) aims to prevent


defections and political instability.

MAIN BODY

• Disqualification : If voluntarily resigns or votes against party —


exceptions for mergers

• Speaker decides on disqualification


• Kihoto Hollohan (1992) : Speaker’s decision subject to judicial review

• Nabam Rebia (2016) : Speaker can’t initiate disqualification while facing


removal motion

• Issues : Delays in decision, biased actions, conflict of interest

• Exam Tip : Cite ongoing cases in Maharashtra and Manipur (2023)

CHALLENGES

• Lack of time limit for decisions

• Speaker's partisanship

• Rise of mass defections with loopholes

• Undermines electoral mandate

WAY FORWARD

• Time-bound decision (as per SC)

• Transfer power to independent tribunal

• Clarify merger provisions

• Strengthen internal party democracy

CONCLUSION

Anti-defection must ensure accountability while respecting representation.


Reforms are urgent to stop misuse.

------------------------------------------------------------
11. Structure of Indian Judiciary and Recent Reforms

INTRODUCTION

Judiciary under Articles 124–147 (Union) and 214–237 (States) ensures


rule of law, constitutional supremacy.

MAIN BODY

• Supreme Court : Apex court, final interpreter, Article 124 — 34 judges


(2023)

• High Courts : Article 214 — 25 High Courts, some with multiple


jurisdiction

• Subordinate Courts : Article 233 onwards — district and lower courts

• All India Judicial Services : Proposed for uniform recruitment — not


implemented

• Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 : Replacing IPC to simplify criminal law

• Mediation Act, 2023 : Promotes alternative dispute resolution

• Exam Tip : Mention pendency data — over 4.5 crore cases pending
(NCRB 2023)

CHALLENGES

• Case backlog and delays

• Infrastructure and manpower issues

• Uneven access to justice

• Slow adoption of technology

WAY FORWARD

• Judicial infrastructure scheme (2021–26)

• Regional benches of SC

• Promote e-courts and AI-based filing

• Implement AIJS for quality judges


CONCLUSION

Judicial reforms must ensure access, speed, and independence.


Technology and accountability are key.

------------------------------------------------------------

12. Judicial Appointments: Collegium, NJAC, and Reforms

INTRODUCTION

Appointments under Article 124 and 217 — Collegium system evolved by


judicial interpretation.

MAIN BODY

• Collegium : Judges appoint judges — based on Second Judges Case


(1993)

• National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act, 2014 : Struck


down in 2015 (4th Judges Case)

• Issues : Opaqueness, lack of diversity, executive-judiciary tension

• Law Commission Report 230 (2012) : Recommended more transparency

• 2023 Developments : SC vs Centre on appointment delays

• Exam Tip : Cite IR Coelho (2007) — independence of judiciary is basic


structure

CHALLENGES

• No formal criteria for selection

• Delays in clearing names

• Collegium not accountable to public

• Increasing executive pressure

WAY FORWARD
• Memorandum of Procedure with clarity

• Mixed model: Judicial + Executive + Civil Society

• Publish reasons for appointments

• Promote regional and gender diversity

CONCLUSION

Appointments need transparency, trust, and constitutionality. Judicial


independence must be safeguarded.

------------------------------------------------------------

13. Judicial Activism vs Judicial Restraint

INTRODUCTION

Balance between intervention and self-restraint defines judiciary’s role in


governance.

MAIN BODY

• Judicial Activism : PIL, expanding rights — e.g., Vishaka vs State of


Rajasthan (1997), Environmental cases

• Judicial Restraint : Deference to legislature, separation of powers

• Key Cases : Kesavananda Bharati (1973), Olga Tellis (1985), Navtej Johar
(2018), Sabarimala (2018)

• Mediation Act 2023 : Reflects shift towards alternative remedies

• Exam Tip : Use comparative view — activism vital when


executive/legislature fails

CHALLENGES

• Overreach criticism — bypassing democratic process

• Vague PILs for publicity

• Judiciary lacks enforcement power


• Delay in core adjudication due to activism

WAY FORWARD

• Filter frivolous PILs

• Balanced activism within constitutional limits

• Encourage institutional accountability

• Build jurisprudence for restraint

CONCLUSION

Judicial activism must not substitute governance. Balanced intervention


safeguards democracy.

------------------------------------------------------------

14. Electoral Reforms and Recent Laws

INTRODUCTION

India’s electoral system faces issues of funding opacity, criminalization,


and lack of transparency.

MAIN BODY

• Representation of the People Act, 1951 : Regulates elections and


conduct

• Chief Election Commissioner and Other ECs Act, 2023 : Alters


appointment method — raised concerns on independence

• Electoral Bonds : Declared unconstitutional in 2024 — SC cited violation


of transparency and voter rights

• Model Code of Conduct : ECI enforces during elections — lacks statutory


backing

• Exam Tip : Mention ADR data — 40% MPs with criminal charges (2024)
CHALLENGES

• Money power and corporate influence

• Criminalization unchecked

• ECI autonomy under question

• Low voter awareness on funding

WAY FORWARD

• State funding of elections

• Real-time disclosure of funds

• Make MCC legally enforceable

• Strengthen Election Commission independence

CONCLUSION

Democracy demands clean, fair, and free elections. Reforming the


electoral process is central to public trust.

------------------------------------------------------------

15. Simultaneous Elections: One Nation One Election

INTRODUCTION

Proposal to hold Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections together to save
cost and governance disruption.

MAIN BODY

• Law Commission Report (2018) : Proposed constitutional amendments


for synchronized terms

• NITI Aayog (2020) : Cited benefits — reduced costs, continuous


governance

• Recent Push : High-level committee formed in 2023 to study feasibility


• Constitutional Provisions : Article 83 and 172 for terms; changes needed

• Exam Tip : Mention past synchrony — 1951–1967 elections were held


together

CHALLENGES

• Constitutional hurdles

• Regional diversity and federalism

• Mid-term dissolutions

• Opposition concerns on centralization

WAY FORWARD

• All-party consensus

• Pilot project with local bodies

• Amend RPA and Constitution carefully

• Use technology for electoral readiness

CONCLUSION

Simultaneous elections are ideal but need structural, legal, and political
groundwork.

------------------------------------------------------------
16. Civil Services and Governance: Mission Karmayogi and Reforms

INTRODUCTION

Civil services are the backbone of Indian administration under Article 312
— ensuring policy implementation and continuity.

MAIN BODY

• Mission Karmayogi (2020) : National Programme for Civil Services


Capacity Building — shift from rule-based to role-based training

• Civil Services Boards : Ensures tenure security, yet limited effectiveness

• Lateral Entry : Introduced for domain expertise — raises concerns on


merit and neutrality

• Performance Management : SPARROW platform, APAR reforms

• Exam Tip : Cite ARC II Report — called for HR reform, performance


orientation, ethical training

CHALLENGES

• Resistance to change

• Politicization and transfers

• Lack of specialization

• Gaps in ethics and empathy

WAY FORWARD

• Institutionalize merit and ethics

• Expand lateral entry with safeguards

• Strengthen training at all levels

• Promote digital tools for transparency


CONCLUSION

Mission Karmayogi marks a modern shift in governance. Empowered,


ethical, and efficient services are essential.

------------------------------------------------------------

17. Digital Governance and Data Laws

INTRODUCTION

Digital governance enhances service delivery, citizen empowerment, and


transparency.

MAIN BODY

• Digital India (2015) : E-governance, broadband, digital literacy — 100%


villages covered (2023)

• Aadhaar : Identity integration for services — backed by Aadhaar Act,


2016

• DPDP Act, 2023 : Digital Personal Data Protection — defines data


fiduciaries and user rights

• JAM Trinity : Jan Dhan, Aadhaar, Mobile — promoted inclusion and


subsidy delivery

• Exam Tip : Mention World Bank praise — Direct Benefit Transfer saved
₹1.7 lakh crore (2022)

CHALLENGES

• Data privacy and security gaps

• Digital divide in rural/tribal areas

• Low digital literacy

• Cybercrime rise and surveillance fears


WAY FORWARD

• Implement DPDP with oversight

• Strengthen CERT-In and cyber audits

• Digital literacy campaigns

• Promote open data with safeguards

CONCLUSION

Data governance must protect rights while enabling innovation. Trust is


key to digital state success.

------------------------------------------------------------

18. Key Legislations: GNCTD Act, CAA, Nari Shakti Vandan

INTRODUCTION

Recent laws reflect federal dynamics, inclusivity goals, and citizenship


debates.

MAIN BODY

• Government of NCT of Delhi (Amendment) Act, 2023 : Transfers control


to LG — raises federal concerns

• Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019 & Rules, 2024 : Fast-track citizenship


for persecuted minorities — excludes Muslims; protests across India

• Women Reservation Act (Nari Shakti Vandan), 2023 : 33% seats reserved
in Lok Sabha and State Assemblies — operational post-delimitation

• Exam Tip : Cite SR Bommai (1994) — federalism is basic structure; use


for GNCTD debate

CHALLENGES

• GNCTD weakens elected govt

• CAA lacks neutrality and transparency


• Reservation law delayed by census/delimitation

WAY FORWARD

• Strengthen cooperative federalism

• Transparent NRC-CAA mechanisms

• Early implementation of reservation

CONCLUSION

Laws must balance governance, inclusion, and constitutional principles.


Dialogue and clarity build legitimacy.

------------------------------------------------------------

19. Panchayati Raj and Rural Governance

INTRODUCTION

73rd Constitutional Amendment, 1992 institutionalized Panchayati Raj —


decentralizing democracy to the grassroots.

MAIN BODY

• Article 243 : Three-tier system, Gram Sabha, 5-year term

• State Finance Commissions : Meant for fiscal devolution — poor


implementation

• eGramSwaraj : Digital dashboard for transparency

• Women Representation : 46% in Bihar Panchayats (2023), SC/ST quota


as per population

• Exam Tip : Cite 2nd ARC — Panchayats lack funds, functionaries, and
functions (3Fs)

CHALLENGES

• Capacity gaps
• Irregular elections and weak audits

• Low fund autonomy

• Elite capture and gender barriers

WAY FORWARD

• Strengthen SFCs and audits

• Promote training and e-governance

• Ensure timely elections and social audits

• Reserve leadership training for women

CONCLUSION

Panchayati Raj is key to inclusive rural governance. Empowered


institutions enhance democracy at the base.

------------------------------------------------------------

20. Urban Local Bodies and 74th Amendment

INTRODUCTION

74th Constitutional Amendment, 1992 empowered urban local governance


via municipalities and wards.

MAIN BODY

• Article 243P–243ZG : Created Nagar Panchayats, Municipal Councils,


Corporations

• Smart Cities Mission (2015) : 100 cities, integrated infrastructure and IT


— ₹2 lakh crore sanctioned

• AMRUT Scheme : Water supply, sewerage, non-motorized transport

• Property Tax and User Fees : Low collection affecting revenue autonomy

• Exam Tip : Cite HPEC Report (2011) — Indian cities need $600 billion
over 20 years
CHALLENGES

• Funds, Functions, Functionaries gap

• Poor citizen participation

• Weak mayoral leadership

• Urban sprawl and informal growth

WAY FORWARD

• Empower mayors with real authority

• Integrate GIS, digital tools in planning

• Promote municipal bonds and public-private partnerships

• Use SDG-11 metrics for planning

CONCLUSION

Urban governance needs democratic depth and financial strength to


ensure livable, resilient cities.

------------------------------------------------------------

21. Landmark Judgments: Article 370, Hate Speech, Amish Devgan Case

INTRODUCTION

Judiciary plays a vital role in interpreting the Constitution and balancing


rights and unity.

MAIN BODY

• Abrogation of Article 370 (2019) : Ended special status of Jammu and


Kashmir — upheld by Supreme Court in 2023; stated it's a temporary
provision
• Amish Devgan Case (2021) : Hate speech against Sufi saint — Court
upheld FIRs; stressed speech must not harm communal peace

• Shreya Singhal Case (2015) : Struck down Section 66A of IT Act —


upheld freedom of speech

• Tehseen Poonawalla Case (2018) : SC directed states to curb mob


lynching and hate crimes

• Exam Tip : Mention Court's role in balancing unity with civil liberties

CHALLENGES

• Hate speech not clearly defined

• Political misuse of sedition and UAPA

• Need for constitutional morality and restraint

WAY FORWARD

• Define hate speech legislatively

• Train police and judiciary for sensitivity

• Promote civic education on pluralism

CONCLUSION

Judiciary remains the guardian of fundamental values. Clear doctrines and


timely judgments reinforce the republic.

------------------------------------------------------------

22. Caste Census and Demand for Ladakh Autonomy

INTRODUCTION

Recent protests and data demands reflect a deeper quest for justice,
representation, and regional identity.

MAIN BODY
• Bihar Caste Census (2023) : First state-driven socio-economic caste
survey in post-independence India

• Findings : 63% OBC-EBC population — renewed demand for proportional


reservations

• Ladakh Protest : Demand for 6th Schedule under Article 244 — for tribal
autonomy and cultural preservation

• Exam Tip : Cite Indra Sawhney Case (1992) — reservation cap, creamy
layer concept; used to interpret current demands

CHALLENGES

• Risk of political polarization

• Lack of updated SECC data at national level

• Administrative hurdles in granting autonomy

WAY FORWARD

• National SECC with transparency

• Parliamentary debate on reservation structure

• Consultative framework for tribal aspirations

CONCLUSION

Demands reflect democratic participation. Policy must balance equity with


national unity.

------------------------------------------------------------

23. OTT Regulation, One Nation One Language, IT Rules Debate

INTRODUCTION

Information and technology have grown fast — raising concerns on


content control, cultural identity, and free speech.
MAIN BODY

• OTT/IT Rules, 2021 : Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics


Code — 3-tier grievance redressal system

• One Nation One Language Proposal : Advocates Hindi as link language —


opposed by non-Hindi states

• Freedom of Speech vs Regulation : Key tension in OTT content, hate


speech, misinformation

• Exam Tip : Mention Supreme Court in Puttaswamy Case (2017) —


privacy is fundamental right; use to critique overreach

CHALLENGES

• Regulatory overreach and chilling effect

• Linguistic diversity vs unification

• Lack of self-regulation in digital content

WAY FORWARD

• Strengthen independent regulators

• Promote multilingual federalism

• Ensure transparent content codes

CONCLUSION

Policy must preserve creativity, unity, and liberty — regulation should not
become censorship.

------------------------------------------------------------

24. Women and Child Rights: PENCIL, Nari Shakti, Child Welfare

INTRODUCTION

Constitutional rights and schemes seek to empower women and safeguard


children from exploitation.
MAIN BODY

• PENCIL Portal : Platform for Effective Enforcement for No Child Labour —


tracks and rescues children

• Nari Shakti Vandan Act, 2023 : 33% women reservation in legislatures —


marks political empowerment

• Beti Bachao Beti Padhao : Promotes girl child education — improvement


in sex ratio in Haryana (SRB 933 in 2014 to 952 in 2022)

• Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act : Stringent


safeguards and special courts

• Exam Tip : Cite National Family Health Survey-5 — 88.6% girls enrolled
in secondary education (Bihar)

CHALLENGES

• Gender violence, malnutrition

• High dropout rate among girls in rural areas

• Child labour in informal sectors

WAY FORWARD

• Strengthen tracking systems like Baal Swaraj

• Gender budgeting and education incentives

• Strict implementation of child labour laws

CONCLUSION

Empowerment needs legal support, economic access, and societal change


for lasting outcomes.

------------------------------------------------------------

25. Health and Education: Ayushman Bharat and NEP 2020


INTRODUCTION

Social sector reforms aim to build human capital — essential for inclusive
development.

MAIN BODY

• Ayushman Bharat : Launched 2018 — world’s largest health coverage


scheme; covers ₹5 lakh per family/year; 55 crore beneficiaries (2023)

• Health and Wellness Centres : 1.5 lakh targeted — focus on preventive


care

• National Education Policy 2020 : Replaced 1986 policy — focuses on


early childhood care, multidisciplinary education, mother tongue
instruction till Class 5

• PM SHRI Schools : 14,500 schools to be developed as NEP-model


institutions

• Exam Tip : Cite Economic Survey 2022–23 — education spending still


below 6% GDP target

CHALLENGES

• Health infrastructure and rural access

• Learning outcomes and teacher training gaps

• Low public expenditure and dropout rate

WAY FORWARD

• Increase health and education budget

• Universalize quality primary care

• Monitor NEP rollout via real-time dashboards

CONCLUSION

Health and education build demographic strength. Timely reform


implementation determines success.

------------------------------------------------------------
26. Rights of Transgender Persons, PVTGs, and Forest Rights

INTRODUCTION

Inclusive governance ensures dignity and representation of all social


groups.

MAIN BODY

• NALSA v. Union of India (2014) : Recognized transgender persons as


third gender — right to self-identification

• Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 : Prohibits


discrimination — provides for ID certificates, rehabilitation

• Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs) : 75 groups notified — face


socio-economic backwardness, poor health and education indicators

• Forest Rights Act, 2006 : Recognizes land and forest rights of Scheduled
Tribes and traditional forest dwellers — democratic decentralization

• Exam Tip : Mention Bhuria Committee (1995) — key recommendation for


tribal self-rule and land rights

CHALLENGES

• Poor implementation of welfare schemes

• Land alienation and forced displacement

• Transgender persons still face stigma, lack access to healthcare

WAY FORWARD

• Dedicated fund allocation for PVTGs

• Sensitization campaigns for inclusivity

• Digital tracking of rights delivery for vulnerable groups


CONCLUSION

Equity in rights and representation is key for an inclusive and just


democracy.

------------------------------------------------------------

27. Disability Rights and Digital Inclusion

INTRODUCTION

Differently abled persons must be mainstreamed through rights-based and


tech-enabled governance.

MAIN BODY

• Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 : Defines 21 disabilities —


ensures education, reservation, accessibility

• Sugamya Bharat Abhiyan : Launched 2015 — aims at universal


accessibility in built environment, ICT

• Digital India Initiatives : Screen readers, e-sign, telemedicine — critical


for digital inclusion

• UDID (Unique Disability ID) Project : Centralized database — streamlines


benefits

• Exam Tip : Cite Census 2011 — 2.21% of India’s population disabled;


actual numbers may be underreported

CHALLENGES

• Infrastructural barriers and lack of accessible content

• Skill gaps and low literacy among disabled persons

• Delayed certification and social stigma

WAY FORWARD

• Ensure website and service compliance with WCAG 2.1


• Promote inclusive education with ICT

• Community-based rehabilitation and digital skilling

CONCLUSION

A digitally inclusive nation reflects constitutional values of equality and


dignity.

------------------------------------------------------------

28. India’s Constitutional Comparison with UK and US

INTRODUCTION

India’s Constitution draws from global experiences but creates its own
synthesis for democratic governance.

MAIN BODY

• UK Model : Parliamentary system, rule of law, unwritten conventions

• US Model : Written Constitution, separation of powers, judicial review,


Bill of Rights

• Indian Approach : Fusion of parliamentary executive with judicial review


— detailed written Constitution

• Fundamental Rights (India vs US) : Both justiciable — US has absolute


rights, India allows reasonable restrictions

• Exam Tip : Mention A.K. Gopalan Case (1950) vs Maneka Gandhi Case
(1978) — shift from procedure to due process

CHALLENGES

• Balancing federalism with strong Centre

• Over-dependence on executive in UK vs checks in US

• Indian model suits diverse, populous democracy but faces stress from
centralizing tendencies
WAY FORWARD

• Continue judicial innovation within Indian framework

• Study global best practices — ensure democratic decentralization

• Promote legal awareness and comparative jurisprudence

CONCLUSION

India’s constitutionalism blends global ideas into a functional system


rooted in pluralism and unity.

------------------------------------------------------------

29. Rule of Law and Democracy Index: Global Reflection

INTRODUCTION

International indices reflect governance quality and constitutional


adherence.

MAIN BODY

• Rule of Law Index (World Justice Project) 2023 : India ranked 79 out of
142 countries — concerns on fundamental rights and executive
accountability

• Democracy Index (Economist Intelligence Unit) 2023 : India labeled as


‘Flawed Democracy’ — score 6.41/10

• Areas of concern : Press freedom, judicial pendency, political polarization

• Strengths : Electoral participation, digital governance, civil society


activism

• Exam Tip : Use these indices to support answers on constitutional


performance or democratic backsliding

CHALLENGES
• Delay in justice delivery

• Political interference and misinformation

• Rising incidents of censorship and sedition misuse

WAY FORWARD

• Institutional reforms in judiciary and police

• Strengthen RTI, press freedom, electoral reforms

• Promote data transparency and rights audits

CONCLUSION

Global indices provide accountability mirror — governance must align with


constitutional promises.

------------------------------------------------------------

30. Parliamentary vs Presidential System: Indian Debate

INTRODUCTION

Debate around India's system focuses on effectiveness, stability, and


accountability.

MAIN BODY

• Indian System : Borrowed Westminster model — collective responsibility,


head of state is nominal

• Presidential System (e.g., US) : Separation of powers, fixed tenure, direct


mandate

• Arguments for Indian Model : Better suited to diversity — coalition


politics allows representation

• Criticisms : Frequent disruptions, horse-trading, unstable state


governments
• Exam Tip : Refer to 2nd Administrative Reforms Commission —
highlighted need to improve quality of legislators and institutional support

CHALLENGES

• Personality-driven politics undermining collective cabinet responsibility

• Fragmented mandates causing political instability

• Delay in policy decisions

WAY FORWARD

• Electoral reforms to reduce fragmentation

• Encourage inner-party democracy and debates

• Strengthen committees, increase legislative sittings

CONCLUSION

Parliamentary democracy remains viable — but reforms needed to


enhance performance and accountability.

------------------------------------------------------------

31. Simultaneous Elections in India

INTRODUCTION
Simultaneous elections aim to streamline governance and reduce election
fatigue.

MAIN BODY

• Concept : Hold Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections together —


proposed since 1983 Election Commission report

• Law Commission (2018) : Suggested legal amendments and phased


implementation

• Benefits : Cost saving, continuous governance, reduced model code of


conduct disruptions

• Concerns : Federal spirit dilution, local issues sidelined, logistical


complexity

• Supreme Court View : Not unconstitutional but needs consensus and


major legal overhaul

• Exam Tip : Cite NITI Aayog (2017) paper on "One Nation, One Election"
— emphasizes national efficiency

CHALLENGES

• Synchronizing tenures without dissolutions

• Need for constitutional amendments to Articles 83, 172, 85, 174

• Consensus among political parties lacking

WAY FORWARD

• Pilot in selected states first

• Constitutional review committee

• Voter awareness and administrative readiness

CONCLUSION

Concept is reformative but must balance practicality with federal


principles.

------------------------------------------------------------
32. Electoral Reforms: Model Code of Conduct, AI, and Transparency

INTRODUCTION

Free and fair elections require robust legal, ethical, and technological
frameworks.

MAIN BODY

• Model Code of Conduct (MCC) : A moral guideline enforced by Election


Commission — lacks statutory backing

• Representation of the People Act, 1951 : Governs qualifications,


disqualifications, offences

• Technological Integration : Voter helpline app, cVigil, remote voting pilots


— AI used in prediction and data analysis

• Electoral Bonds Scheme : 2024 SC verdict struck it down for violating


voter’s right to information

• Exam Tip : Cite Dinesh Trivedi Committee (1998) on political funding


reforms and Vohra Committee (1993) on criminal-politician nexus

CHALLENGES

• Money power and paid news

• Lack of transparency in candidate funding

• Weak enforcement of MCC

WAY FORWARD

• Legislate MCC into law

• Cap election expenditure and mandate public disclosure

• Promote voter literacy on AI-generated content

CONCLUSION
Electoral reform is essential to deepen democracy and preserve electoral
integrity.

------------------------------------------------------------

33. Role of Civil Services in Modern Governance

INTRODUCTION

Civil services are the permanent administrative machinery enabling policy


continuity and execution.

MAIN BODY

• Constitutional Basis : Article 311 safeguards, All India Services under


Article 312

• Challenges : Politicization, rigidity, skill gaps, low innovation culture

• Reforms : Mission Karmayogi (2020) — capacity building through iGOT


Karmayogi platform

• Lateral Entry : Recommended by NITI Aayog — infusion of domain


expertise

• Exam Tip : Cite Hota Committee (2004) and ARC Reports on civil service
accountability and reform

CHALLENGES

• Resistance to change within bureaucracy

• Lack of performance-linked evaluation

• Public service motivation decline

WAY FORWARD

• Modern HRM practices and performance audits

• Institutionalize ethics and conduct code

• Tech-based service delivery and continuous training


CONCLUSION

A motivated, skilled and ethical civil service is key to responsive and


inclusive governance.

------------------------------------------------------------

34. Digital Governance and Data Protection

INTRODUCTION

Digital transformation is redefining governance, but requires data


safeguards and transparency.

MAIN BODY

• Digital India Mission (2015) : Infrastructure, digital literacy, digital


delivery of services

• Aadhaar and JAM Trinity : Improved DBT efficiency, reduced leakage

• Data Protection : Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 —


recognizes rights and obligations

• e-Governance Tools : DigiLocker, UMANG, MyGov — promote


transparency and citizen engagement

• Exam Tip : Mention Justice B.N. Srikrishna Committee (2018) report on


data protection framework

CHALLENGES

• Data breaches and surveillance fears

• Digital divide — rural and gender gaps

• Limited grievance redressal systems

WAY FORWARD

• Data localization safeguards


• Citizen-centric service design

• Strengthen privacy regulators and audits

CONCLUSION

Digital governance must uphold citizen trust, rights, and ethical


governance practices.

------------------------------------------------------------

35. Key Legislative Developments: GNCTD Act, CAA, and Nari Shakti
Vandan

INTRODUCTION

Legislative changes reflect the dynamic balance between governance


needs and constitutional ethos.

MAIN BODY

• Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Act,


2023 : Clarified role of LG vs elected government — criticized for curbing
autonomy

• Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019 and Rules, 2024 : Fast-tracks


citizenship to religious minorities from 3 neighboring countries —
controversial for exclusion of Muslims

• Nari Shakti Vandan Act, 2023 : 33% reservation for women in Lok Sabha
and State Assemblies — implementation dependent on delimitation

• Exam Tip : Link each law with constitutional debates — Article 239AA
(Delhi), Article 14 and secularism (CAA), Article 243D and 243T (Women
Reservation)

CHALLENGES

• Judicial scrutiny and federalism concerns (GNCTD)

• Polarization and protest (CAA)


• Delay in implementation (Women’s Bill)

WAY FORWARD

• Judicial review to clarify scope of powers

• Inclusive citizenship laws respecting constitutional morality

• Political will for timely operationalization of reservation

CONCLUSION

Law-making must align with constitutional values and democratic


principles.

------------------------------------------------------------

36. Urban Governance: 74th Amendment and Smart Cities

INTRODUCTION

Urban governance is central to sustainable development and citizen-


centric planning.

MAIN BODY

• 74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992 : Gave constitutional status to


Urban Local Bodies — provided for elected mayors, ward committees,
State Finance Commissions

• Smart Cities Mission, 2015 : Focused on core infrastructure, technology,


e-governance — 100 cities covered

• AMRUT (Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation) : Basic


civic amenities in 500+ towns

• Governance Challenges : Lack of autonomy, weak revenue base,


administrative overlap

• Exam Tip : Cite JNNURM (2005) and HPEC Report (2011) — importance
of empowered mayors and decentralization
CHALLENGES

• Limited devolution of functions and funds

• Poor citizen participation and service delivery

• Urban poverty and informal housing

WAY FORWARD

• Direct election and empowerment of mayors

• Urban finance reform and own revenue generation

• Integrate sustainability and participatory planning

CONCLUSION

Empowered urban governance can lead India’s transition to resilient,


inclusive cities.

------------------------------------------------------------

37. Panchayati Raj and Rural Governance

INTRODUCTION

Decentralized rural governance is crucial for bottom-up development and


inclusive democracy.

MAIN BODY

• 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992 : Provided three-tier structure,


Gram Sabha, reservation for women and marginalized groups

• Article 243 : Institutionalized Panchayats as units of self-government

• Financial Devolution : 14th and 15th Finance Commission increased


untied funds to PRIs

• State of PRIs : Variance in powers, lack of professional staff, capacity


issues
• Exam Tip : Cite Balwantrai Mehta Committee (1957), Ashok Mehta
Committee (1978), and BPSC PYQ (2020) on Panchayati Raj in Bihar

CHALLENGES

• Interference by bureaucracy and state governments

• Weak Gram Sabha and public participation

• Gender-based barriers in leadership roles

WAY FORWARD

• Institutionalize social audit and training

• Devolve 3Fs — funds, functions, functionaries

• Leverage e-Gram Swaraj and digital platforms

CONCLUSION

Strengthened Panchayati Raj Institutions are essential for rural


development and democratic deepening.

------------------------------------------------------------

38. Article 370 Abrogation and Its Implications

INTRODUCTION

Article 370 granted special status to Jammu and Kashmir — abrogated in


2019 for integration.

MAIN BODY

• Article 370 (1949) : Temporary provision, limited Parliament's legislative


powers over J&K

• August 2019 : Presidential order used Article 370(3) to declare the


Article inoperative — bifurcated state into Union Territories of J&K and
Ladakh
• Legal Debate : Use of President’s Rule and Parliament acting as state
legislature challenged

• Exam Tip : Cite Prem Nath Kaul vs J&K (1959) and current 5-judge
constitutional bench hearings (as of 2024)

IMPACT

• Administrative integration and extension of central laws

• End of separate Constitution and flag

• Concerns over federalism, trust deficit, and statehood delay

WAY FORWARD

• Restore statehood as promised

• Build local capacity and confidence

• Promote development and rights protection

CONCLUSION

While legally upheld, integration must ensure justice, dignity, and


democratic restoration.

------------------------------------------------------------

39. Hate Speech, Free Speech, and Judicial Intervention

INTRODUCTION

Balancing free speech and societal harmony is central to constitutional


morality.

MAIN BODY

• Constitutional Protection : Article 19(1)(a) ensures freedom of speech;


Article 19(2) allows reasonable restrictions
• Notable Judgments : Amish Devgan v Union of India (2020) — speech
inciting hatred not protected

• Laws Applicable : Sections 153A, 295A, 505 IPC — punish promotion of


enmity, religious insult, misinformation

• Exam Tip : Cite Pravasi Bhalai Sangathan vs Union of India (2014) —


urged legislature to frame hate speech law

CHALLENGES

• Vague definitions and arbitrary application

• Online hate speech unregulated

• Politically sensitive enforcement

WAY FORWARD

• Codify clear hate speech law

• Use AI tools to monitor digital content

• Promote civic education and inter-faith dialogue

CONCLUSION

Protecting dignity while preserving free expression is essential in a diverse


democracy.

------------------------------------------------------------

40. Ladakh’s Sixth Schedule Demand

INTRODUCTION

Post Article 370 abrogation, Ladakh seeks constitutional safeguards to


preserve tribal identity and autonomy.

MAIN BODY
• Sixth Schedule : Provides for Autonomous District Councils in tribal areas
— applicable to NE states

• Demand Justification : 95% tribal population in Ladakh, fears over land,


culture, demography

• Government Response : High Powered Committee constituted in 2023 —


no consensus reached

• Constitutional Debate : Ladakh being UT without legislature creates legal


roadblocks

• Exam Tip : Mention BPSC CSE 2023 question on “Autonomy vs


Integration” and cite examples from Bodoland, Garo Hills

CHALLENGES

• Structural limitations due to UT status

• Internal divisions among local groups

• Center-state coordination gaps

WAY FORWARD

• Explore Fifth Schedule-type arrangement

• Empower LAHDCs with financial and legislative powers

• Constitutional amendment or legislative creativity

CONCLUSION

Culturally sensitive autonomy is vital for inclusive governance in Ladakh.

------------------------------------------------------------

41. Bihar Caste Census: Implications and Constitutional Validity

INTRODUCTION
Bihar’s 2022–2023 caste-based survey reignited debates on social justice,
data governance, and federal powers.

MAIN BODY

• Objective : Identify socio-economic conditions of various castes for


better-targeted policies

• Constitutional Basis : State List Entry 45 (Census) — Center’s domain;


but socio-economic survey allowed

• Legal Status : Patna High Court upheld state’s right to conduct such
surveys — Supreme Court refused stay in 2023

• Policy Relevance : Supports 27% OBC reservation, schemes for


Extremely Backward Classes

• Exam Tip : Cite Indra Sawhney case (1992) — social backwardness


needs empirical proof

CHALLENGES

• Overlapping caste categories and inconsistencies

• Politicization and vote-bank concerns

• Lack of linkage to income and education data

WAY FORWARD

• Transparent, objective database and digital enumeration

• Synchronize with SECC and decadal census

• Use data for inclusive, evidence-based policymaking

CONCLUSION

Caste-based data, if handled responsibly, can empower policymaking for


equity and dignity.

------------------------------------------------------------
42. One Nation One Language: Federalism and Identity Politics

INTRODUCTION

The proposal to make Hindi the national language has drawn criticism for
undermining linguistic diversity and federal ethos.

MAIN BODY

• Constitutional Position : Article 343 — Hindi as official language, but


English to continue

• 8th Schedule : Recognizes 22 languages; all equal in status — no


mention of "national language"

• Political Debate : Southern states, especially Tamil Nadu, resist


imposition; cites cultural identity and historical protests

• Exam Tip : Cite BPSC questions on linguistic federalism (e.g., 2018) and
references to Official Language Rules (1976)

CHALLENGES

• Threat to multilingualism and plural identity

• Lack of universal access to Hindi education

• Polarization and alienation in non-Hindi speaking regions

WAY FORWARD

• Promote multilingualism and choice-based language policies

• Strengthen three-language formula with regional language emphasis

• Respect constitutional spirit of unity in diversity

CONCLUSION

India's strength lies in its linguistic diversity — uniformity should not


replace inclusivity.

------------------------------------------------------------
43. OTT Platforms and Information Technology Rules, 2021

INTRODUCTION

Rise of digital media content has triggered regulatory reforms — balancing


creative freedom with accountability.

MAIN BODY

• IT Rules, 2021 : Mandated self-regulation by OTTs, grievance redressal,


classification (U/A/18+)

• OTT Growth : 500 million+ users (as of 2024), 40+ major platforms —
disrupts traditional media

• Free Speech Debate : Content curbs seen as censorship, lacks legislative


backing

• Key Judgments : Justice for Rights Foundation vs Union (2019) — PIL for
OTT regulation

• Exam Tip : Refer to Ministry of I&B guidelines and cite BPSC question
(2023) on digital governance

CHALLENGES

• Vague content standards, government overreach

• Lack of third-party review or appellate body

• Jurisdictional gaps in transnational platforms

WAY FORWARD

• Enact comprehensive digital content law

• Strengthen self-regulation with legal clarity

• Encourage audience rating literacy

CONCLUSION
OTT content regulation must balance innovation, freedom, and citizen
sensitivities.

------------------------------------------------------------

44. Women and Children: Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam and PENCIL Portal

INTRODUCTION

Empowering women and protecting children are foundational to inclusive


and participatory democracy.

MAIN BODY

• Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam, 2023 : Reserved 33% seats for women in
Lok Sabha and state legislatures — implementation post-delimitation
(2029)

• PENCIL Portal : Platform for Effective Enforcement for No Child Labour —


integrates complaints, tracking, rescue

• Related Schemes : Beti Bachao Beti Padhao, Poshan Abhiyan, Mission


Shakti

• Impact : Boosts gender parity in political participation, strengthens child


labour monitoring

• Exam Tip : Cite BPSC question (2021) on child rights and 108th CAA
(women reservation)

CHALLENGES

• Delay in implementation of reservation

• Poor digital access in rural areas

• Deep-rooted socio-cultural barriers

WAY FORWARD

• Build gender-sensitive institutions and leadership

• Integrate digital tools in local language for child protection


• Public awareness and inclusive governance models

CONCLUSION

Women's representation and child safety must be sustained through legal,


institutional, and social efforts.

------------------------------------------------------------

45. New Education Policy, 2020: Vision and Implementation

INTRODUCTION

National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 aims to transform Indian education


with flexibility, equity, and digital readiness.

MAIN BODY

• Structural Change : 5+3+3+4 model — integrates ECCE, foundational


literacy

• Curriculum Reform : Multidisciplinary, skill-based learning, mother


tongue in early years

• Higher Education : Holistic education, National Research Foundation,


credit bank system

• Digital Push : DIKSHA, PM eVidya, National Digital University (2023)

• Exam Tip : Cite Kasturirangan Committee, and link to BPSC PYQ (2022)
on education policy goals

CHALLENGES

• Uneven digital infrastructure and teacher readiness

• Implementation gap at state and local levels

• Budget constraints — education expenditure still ~2.9% of GDP (2023)

WAY FORWARD
• Capacity building of teachers and school leaders

• Inclusive access for marginalized communities

• States must tailor NEP to local realities

CONCLUSION

NEP 2020, if effectively implemented, can revolutionize education and


social mobility in India.

------------------------------------------------------------

46. Transgender Rights in India: Legal Milestones and Policy Gaps

INTRODUCTION

Recognition of transgender rights represents a constitutional shift towards


dignity, equality, and inclusion.

MAIN BODY

• Key Case : NALSA v. Union of India (2014) — affirmed right to self-


identify gender under Articles 14, 15, 21

• Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 — prohibits


discrimination, mandates ID cards, welfare boards

• Schemes : SMILE 2021 (Support for Marginalized Individuals for


Livelihood and Enterprise), Garima Greh for shelter

• BPSC Relevance : 2022 PYQ on marginalized rights — link constitutional


provisions and governance failures

• Socio-Economic Data : National Human Rights Commission study (2018)


— 92% of transgender persons deprived of basic jobs

CHALLENGES

• Delay in ID issuance and medical board complexities

• Social stigma and lack of public sensitization


• Poor implementation of inclusive education and employment

WAY FORWARD

• Simplify ID processes with self-identification

• Mainstream trans persons in education and public service

• Focused awareness drives and trans-inclusion audits

CONCLUSION

Legal recognition must be matched with administrative empathy and


institutional support.

------------------------------------------------------------

47. Governance and Civil Services Reform: Mission Karmayogi

INTRODUCTION

India’s administrative machinery needs transformation from rule-based to


role-based performance systems.

MAIN BODY

• Mission Karmayogi (2020) : National Programme for Civil Services


Capacity Building (NPCSCB) — focuses on competency, behavioral
training, e-learning

• SPV Created : Karmayogi Bharat Ltd. — platform iGOT Karmayogi


enables customized learning paths

• Linked to : Lateral entry reforms, outcome budgeting, PM Gati Shakti for


integrated governance

• BPSC Exam Tip : Link with governance theme — 2021 PYQ on


administrative reform

CHALLENGES
• Resistance to change and departmental silos

• Digital illiteracy in lower bureaucracy

• Uniform assessment framework lacking

WAY FORWARD

• Mandatory digital onboarding for all officers

• Create accountability linkages with PRAGATI dashboard

• Capacity-building at Panchayati Raj level

CONCLUSION

Karmayogi can become a keystone reform in building agile, citizen-centric


governance.

------------------------------------------------------------

48. Forest Rights Act, 2006: Tribal Justice and Implementation Gaps

INTRODUCTION

Scheduled Tribes and forest dwellers depend on forests for livelihood,


culture, and identity.

MAIN BODY

• Key Provisions : Individual and community forest rights, decision-making


through Gram Sabhas

• Constitutional Backing : Article 244 (Fifth and Sixth Schedule), PESA Act
1996

• Case : Odisha’s Similipal Tiger Reserve — conflicts over relocation and


FRA rights

• Data : MoTA (2023) — Only 49% of eligible claims fully settled nationally

• Exam Link : BPSC 2019 PYQ — Forest rights and constitutional


safeguards
CHALLENGES

• Rejection of claims without hearings

• Conflict with wildlife and mining laws

• Limited awareness among tribal communities

WAY FORWARD

• Empower Gram Sabhas through training

• Map forest lands digitally with community participation

• Integrate FRA with livelihood schemes like MGNREGA, NRLM

CONCLUSION

FRA is a tool of restorative justice — must not be undermined by


bureaucratic apathy.

------------------------------------------------------------

49. Role of Finance Commission in Fiscal Federalism

INTRODUCTION

The Finance Commission ensures equitable financial distribution between


Union and States, essential for cooperative federalism.

MAIN BODY

• Constitutional Mandate : Article 280 — periodic review of sharing


formula, grants

• 15th Finance Commission (2021–26) — recommended 41% devolution,


performance-linked grants (health, SDGs)

• Horizontal Sharing Formula : Based on income distance, population


(2011 census), forest cover, demographic performance
• Vertical Imbalance : Center retains ~60% resources, but states bear
expenditure responsibilities

• Exam Tip : Use Bihar-specific example — grants for disaster


management and agriculture

CHALLENGES

• Political influence in grant distribution

• Lack of autonomy in state borrowing

• Delay in fund transfers

WAY FORWARD

• Strengthen Finance Commission as an autonomous fiscal body

• Institutionalize GST Council-Finance Commission dialogue

• Encourage state fiscal discipline via incentives

CONCLUSION

A robust Finance Commission framework sustains financial federalism and


cooperative governance.

------------------------------------------------------------

50. Representation of the People Act, 1951: Electoral Integrity and Reform
Needs

INTRODUCTION

The RPA, 1951 governs qualifications, disqualifications, and conduct of


elections, ensuring democratic legitimacy.

MAIN BODY

• Key Provisions : Disqualification for corrupt practices, false affidavit,


conviction > 2 years (Section 8)
• VVPAT and EVM Rule : Introduced via Election Commission directions and
Supreme Court approval

• Case Reference : Lily Thomas v. Union of India (2013) — struck down


Section 8(4), immediate disqualification upon conviction

• Electoral Bonds Case (2024) : SC ruled bonds unconstitutional for


violating right to information

• BPSC Link : Repeated PYQs on electoral reforms and criminalization in


politics

CHALLENGES

• Lack of transparency in party funding

• Criminal background of MPs/MLAs — over 43% (ADR report 2024)

• Delayed trials and political influence

WAY FORWARD

• Fast-track courts for electoral offences

• Public disclosure of candidate expenses and social audit

• Strengthen Election Commission’s autonomy and manpower

CONCLUSION

RPA must evolve to meet transparency, accountability, and voter trust


demands in modern elections.

------------------------------------------------------------

Would you like the next batch (51–55) covering any final themes like
comparative constitutions, Lokpal reforms, GNCTD Act, or others?

You might also like