BEFORE THE HONNDURABLE SUPREME
COURT OF INpIA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 36 o 20to
BET WEEN
PHULEL SING H APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA RES PON DENT CS)
SueMISSION UN BEHALF OF THE APPE LLA NT
Aleesha MYoosu? CRol No:4)
Amal musalí Roll Alo l6)
KnishnajaE (Roll NO:65)
1
TABLE OF.CoNTETS
INDEX oF AUTHORYTIES 3
LIST OF ABBREATIONS
STATEMENT OF JURISD1CTION -
STATE ENT OF FACT
1ssUE OF THE CASE - 4
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENTS
ARGUMENTS AOVANCED
PRAYER
2
|NDEX OF AuTHORITIES
Cases
1 Kaligpesumal
3. Kans
5. Mavahan
6. lan
Jogama Vs Se koonatata (2, Jan, 2029)
Sektes
Anteelot
ntps://lega vcdhya corn phualel - Gorgnv-s-skate-o
horyana
LIsT OE ABBREVIATLONS
AR A tnda Reponlea
Cape Cnrat pocoabuaQ cocle
lHon' ble- Horgode
- Indaa enal Cole
.
Scc
4
STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION
Bel<oae he Honouheole uprumo
Cout
5
STATeMeNT Of FACTS
way
) Th manlage betmern tk oeleant and te dereayed
Solemniz ed In mech t487. hey wert ble srd cuth a boy
ond a gr.
2) h paent of tk ceeaed ha naicd cn amun ot
m Cah tte crlat Lat
in t440 ,thy see a Sorte and old oTnament ueyhy
(onplain to her fmidy obot h mtetrent eewe
at thk mctmoni'al home and wd do (ane ond Shy
in her houye.
) Ta fatr t te
3)Th cueard opyoated -the faspanh arn
to etter tey Com to falk to the thr in daw o te
duceayed and Care fo an
atrane and woronsiblity Uncbrtaen by mohan Siryh,
He n iolaws of Jota tnyh ,th fathr nlaw
otte
ofhe
dueaed ,, ghe wa broyht t te matnmenl hene.
4) Latr tt bethor of th deeased ent cto het maste
horeto Vt her h inomed hod brhuy of the
reneated clonand for cloury mad by tke neant and
-th fam membert ot tt duemed cen ngored obout
Dayanand Medrel Galy ond Hosp:td Ludarand (ome)
day ,th dot opind that fh dheeaed ha
5) On the Samt
tt
Suitertd q1% bury on her body and Gent vnot to
Sfacton Houe ottex abost tte admi gston. On /al e4al,
te dueaed rqjained Congiaune, h told ker fami ly
membon that tt wa the ayellant ho had bunt her and
hor Glatenent woy recocad by tte eneoutve Matrte
he deeal e d <o mako hor Statmont.
) Baed on tt staerrent of the chee artd . an Fir wy
rytord e oypellat and hm tamy u 499h,
307, 406 and 34 of IpC: e setstong (ourt haed tte
chay vls 30d afpc yan o/w sed1un 34 of pc ane
304 Bof (Pc ayant the fethoy tndaw and th mothr
inlaw o f th decemed and tte appellant .The tr'al (oat
Allquted all the actwed of te choe vf 30a f Pe and
Pon w'ed all tte attuel U's 3o4ß of pc.
7) Te ace wed portory prefod Cln
fout vith reyard fo the Coneton and Sendonu awoxced
kt-e tr'a Coutt.Als «tte Sfate and te brten ot
-e dueyed aso Aled an cppeal wtA rejat d to tte
acyputal ot te ac yeel ofs 3od of ipe. h Hyh (oat
7
ma hey. indaw of te
derr ated She ho ed cur'y but allan
poceetry
chasget ls po4B of tpc: h (oucd hoverey d-Miymred }e
Cmvton nd enterne of he opellan eho way Conytted
pmarg
the
l13B deto0 ohathoa
Can
be Eviee
Aet
3313sUE
dug cohethes
Sole th maol beCon olaeo
2;
IS5UE
perol Inchtn the BO4
Htgh ancl coult Vatol Honble
etn uea Court
connien b appoant's Whethea
the
the
ISSUEI
CASE THE (SSUES
OF
SoMMARY OF ARaUMt NTS
155 UE I- No-he (oveton of te apelort hy te Hon ble
trial Coort and Hyh (oat ols 30y B of dh tpe way
hoy failkd
to ertablt a (onnecton betncen tte du ath ot te
clure oved «t tk horanrot madk by the apellant ond
his fomily.
SS0é-2 No--Dying dutacaton Connot be mad te sele bas)
Conwtdron in all Caei In ordor to rely delh on clymy ckelacy
-tte proscntron must mk Valil eyeln and t
Auch ohelacaton teaw ns room for doubt.
ISsve 3- No sectvn 9B of eieln At (annot be anolel
he peecudton Cannot pove or hae filed to rre he
e asenabe rcletun betneen fe
fh Cnult and hoeai rent eed
bu fe dueged and her d h Hne a dhelar atn by the
depaecd bort hoy ath with no enclene to nye fhat
fat Consbt be taken aa aa prej umron by the Coe th
prMot in golty the offene.
ARGG UNENTS ADVAN CED
(PETITIONER)
()
coto he
hon b/e fad covit od Cot cncle
&etiin 304 8
lauful?
Setion 04 6(D he hdo Prool Cool4
Shees hat, " cokene (keto leath
Cased buuno
Oues koewse thon
withio seres eos
doat '8he aas o ceuelby
ment by ku kusbagl o ebtie of
hes husbayd for, or in conitio with ory
demand for dooy Sueh doat ghall be catee
sueb hens borgd o
death' nelatue
douy deeroed to kwe
&utio 3go4
o4 B C2) of lpc states thd,
BC3S.
thoerer co mmot
hed cwit% igroe for a deeng skal beoliL
shall not be fhog 8eren
euferd to ye ispriorot.
e eseatial gnedu Rat one Aed
Code ae
() Thre shoutd be. a
Causcd by buens or booliby i y
eeneabnomal cé cunsages.
CM) e deatt lowtd o
mamiag uoh kare been
he coogag
Karnan tt by lee lusbad
ctuelly melalie lee kobond.
ceuelty oe karran en ould kane
kappened sooy befoe kee deat
b te prexnd ca te intde
deelarat
kapad S-/-19/ 6at kee
seconclad thre cays
|afe an applcatio and asarae
eokatne koeded to be to d wasbld to haa
mececdead,asd on hat a fIR
io-last
against he opelatanand34.
exdee Sets 498 A, 3o , ho6
wonelabite,
a it wcon attese6y k cloct.
The, an cinde 304 - B e IRC
at e daceased e kanmasseod due fo ao
tha eshioyy
dey denm and. Evenas ft e ,4 doo
icok auy laueassre far dowy:
|2
Aot undos seetion 307 oy 498-4 ef pc 6at
udee seution 309; e veifud,
e pp and
6y kyphekataltPoijes Dpand
S#o. Nfekir eealod ke cdo ceaod kod
a sherl krpen and hal e falle -io -lao
oe boden doy
ke Bkopig forDinli.
kamagma
boRoe, Randhin spß (Pas-. he deeeaeds
atee and sja sigs (P-) ke villeg sanpab
oelatine of te cleceag
Heie festioonies aeed Canepd erulny Arile
Reis biclo
de
for vsge claiins,
supate pooseufoos Caoe f doy laran
statod hat ke
Rodli S k tkat he deceaads e -la
dood
Jos
kor. bat ke did nat pefiaty
ere
Lararetd due to dowy
sbld eridere prouipKat he lecoadd
karand for
degod, rod ke case cune getioo tsA
paseutbo.
he signifiaa
kat the High Coer isc didao! 6elieve the
ying de elaretino Coneenip ora si
he fage
yeng declaratin Qas ccol to cobvid he
a used.
Pima fae, tkere should be a reasonable
cleroand
ha keld hat,o eey
erslad ioto e deat af te uiclio ood
conneetio
dbene Ps ony Boxiak
.befreenR cdomod 4,douy
og honrasne anhe deats aenot
eaened couoscl made he contni hoa he
Bfaderoen gade he de ceased fefone
ke death ee.
and is he absea f degonpcl of doony
tofenee
bseane hatig eele gkowgto peone. heaat
304- B,it uot be Hat
e a dueet asult
a olemeds
eonneetiio wrth dowy odeoady
To cout aloo keld kat he peoseutig gut
esteblsh aclea and csplefe ckaio oforend
9hih ledd to tRe deats f tlo ceg og
AtR 20D0 S 2324,(20o)5 sce 2o
he visi o 4- B a eoolucLl
anerlesed to the pe
onues oneke peaciiu
clowyeileted viobnle a l oleatls io
f to be no edhat wd hent
hdia. tonener, it kos pooiin
hame bes insovgces akere the false ad
Setuin 3os B ko been sugd ioith
kaeesment
oggretud alegatia loy i
made agint
people ei np aeeste osd peoseekd. lo
Apex to dlealt sth e itsue f o) sue
p . e Coued
e tio 3o4 BOd 498 A of osfashete
kAieeed kat keee hove been
I PC Kkane beeg
ont eogos
peagors kané bees faltyin pheatf
lene,it is cmelear, wgfist bnd
he saoe
tolafd e
bocd to eonict oY agohes
euted a ud
alued.
oasene.kot7s no Solid
hat
agd kare
deceaged oas acd the ae unole
te cdouy
a deoond, suppor tod by
rpc s aod
Sutioo 304 8ef e
e feoseutöo
s.203 )2 sco
SCc 40
15
2)ahethr cdying dalacaton Con be madk cthe le bayt or
Convtctorn
() cuhethor dyng celarahon ra clad ofo admit agputt
an acuwed be a ban foi Connny (or aicued .
- Te cyiny delaratsn Canno-t be madk the Sole
bals fr (avictton . Dyty clelae ton tac cled to aczut
an accwed is nott a banir for (on cton ea th (oraqwe
Tu rebonte plaved on cyiny ole lacnhon B totally cunantrgh
te Veny yt stterent ren by tte deeavel b te cloctor
tte docr cleah &hous that te deueared ha pt teoosene
on tosel ond Set torelt on re . Then on T/u/1221, Jhe
mhor htement to br relathvy hat Aher huband he
anplant ad poued kenorone en hon. h repotd dhng
delarohon -e cxuthe megttate on
slul1441 , ehh wa te corded 3-4 dy ater th naelnt
ehuh Canrot de ganid a a sole en'elae Th faud
dying dula aston Cannot be rgeled e a sole ewrclne r
Convi'eton a it my be a tutoved r at h tnctnee
cf hor relatveg
|6
the dreard ater guning (on servu nen macle the fyt
Statomt sto her elate hnee, kone -tH shtement g
ed tb tte mgihte not chend of eujt.
bv tte lue av
prdeeed tun tastt otme the Credh br didy o
delacetsn, thy ate -
evas made at th cachyt
uhety tor any rayenable supicnin o helane dhe
hethy the deiy deelacatror wa apndut of poty
pxty.
Casetn bastd on a dyiny cleclasoctron alore, in te (ase
Tlsed. n uh Cajey the (ouet may
t du trg cuelacaton on a a pr
t hy to be Ctrded hat te mater of Conviehon
of tte
ot yrellat on th ey fame Cebne,echut he
-tk tath ot tte yrellant wa impfer
sbted thad it way
her hus band uho had ertnsswhed tie fr by pociry cwatr
Cn hor.
dying clucoton that not
Bee yom clobt cy tte Sle eiclne fr (on vtton is not
re ayonable.
In Jayamma stte of kacnntaka
analy sed te admn bulety of chyy oklacaonA Cout
bld tha t net Ye aohable to Cawt Solels on bast t
ot dyy delutron when dtor's cloht tn te ceclarton:
In stte of punoh y veon kumar
IA tte stademet pourck driternt Ventay ,thon te Court
ast
owt ot to otter evrekne inther otend to claaity thyy
myt
& that truth Can he mfored
>'Jaamna Vr shue of kuwraea Jan ra)
t staté of fugab prven kumar ( ta74 CRILJI3q
laid don o an absolk 7ad of law thad daig
(onnot frm 4th Sole bntr f h vihsr (ualegr i
Cnbbnated
feah ue ha odd by it fct and mealtr
tb be Jaded
clethenhon war mad1
the myetaner tndor ahh th
dle
abo nped to be sordened (aeh ,. 4hh be ma
olularahn
ab:tity to geral h Sitaation, and hoy muyd be dee
rorm any runt o.f ahr pojon.
Veerpal and anot (oa)
9stade ot otta< pvadey h 14
Swhethea C3euo 13 o eilons Au can bebe apploo
Cae nng he on
hillimg tha
Conneo0
i9 the
cletn,pmuma aee,te
bualen of proo cip upon he proseuvoo to b
eDonoo 0a cernard ot doo
O tho oomon and the
lo Ban Lad a Sae og Heayana, tho Couat ha
ho that, in evOay Dun
Cose the c9M hapto ralye the
pavmate canen beReN clanan
cleath
he leoar
Counyo noe he conkendao hat the atement md
by the. orooyd be'ae he ceath ene not odméssibe
I, Ban Lal s State o hegana AAR 201 (u) sec 359
2. kans Ro s. sale o penjasAR 2000 Se (2324),(eooossce 207
20
olaty- bo tane the alleged oCwanue no q d
dhan tha
lo
han even ohch lad
a cloon cn corethe
to the cleabh o the uore).
1
Ooralasnon Nabcl loy hegiea
hoghaa auh
tap. e eiclenue melcatcl the dlercaya oa
hea -tonmpacd and throt Joa orgh haala, ht
the mden Aeshmoncg
Rolalrre's tostomonuep loqyad cane nme
nahbn, but no olefpunhno doay
holoard molthv
koacsoa
pouncot
had aot ns de
Sostes en hiq
to m dotoa)eal
coel oveclen ayA theut hansanySeet
the and
puoseutun 3 poMSrg
hero clouaotio9
hn at
omieuop hanasman
ohsch dole. one thup he aaller
Conitchg to toutoacd
a
be cohy, tha aind
Saomont eclonuQ.
3oe ap
thuclent y Cauthout
dyg
ypellcnt mogahats the Cquslby
antthe aloalolCauelby
ad by
sotal-enep. lt eaorable.
hee
to
tha
the
reset tho oele Sheomu. cooaythe
-la to
be ae crerosed aqbea be
con\aorctoy'he
to abou 22
Paher-in annot pormwle suoool applecd
huband, prooe
Sho Ahe oloy
olesloootSoo beyonal o be
-hen hea cleradto Cannot
(he thalt g-4 murt
He PaOseron
he a
been
OkthakFor
on anue hoeprorne
loa thekhale haptha 198
2
PRAVER
that thsf hornaole cou may be ple
al the
cutyt tho ppatont choogt
hon anal to
23
