1
Athena Campbell
Dr. Jessie Herrada Nance
WR 121
02 June 2024
Preservation or Modernization?
Nestled along the banks of the Sacramento River, Old Sacramento stands as a vivid
testament to California's Gold Rush era, with its cobblestone streets, wooden sidewalks, and
preserved 19th-century buildings. This historic district, rich in cultural heritage, attracts visitors
from all over the world eager to experience a slice of America's past. However, in recent years,
pressures for modern development and commercialization have threatened the integrity of this
unique area. Prioritizing historical preservation over modern development and
commercialization is crucial for maintaining Old Sacramento's unique cultural heritage and
historical significance, thereby educating future generations, fostering community pride, and
sustaining a thriving tourism industry that benefits the local economy.
Preserving historical sites like Old Sacramento is essential for safeguarding our cultural
heritage. These sites offer far more than just a glimpse into the architectural styles of bygone
eras; they serve as living records of our collective history. Historical buildings are not merely
relics but rather the physical embodiment of memory. As Madhaven emphasizes, “historical
buildings are the physical manifestation of memory. Historic preservation's role in helping us
understand who we are, where we have been, and where we are going is central to the social
2
component of sustainable development”(236). This quote underscores the intrinsic value of
historic sites as pivotal components of our social and cultural development. They provide a
continuous link to our heritage vital to our ongoing social and cultural development, aiding us
navigate the present and plan for the future. Preserving historical sites like Old Sacramento is not
solely an act of conservation but rather a crucial investment in our cultural and social
sustainability. By safeguarding these sites, we ensure that the invaluable lessons and legacies of
the past endure, enriching our memories and guiding future generations.
Modern development and commercialization pose significant threats to the integrity and
authenticity of historical sites like Old Sacramento. As urbanization and economic interests
encroach upon these cultural treasures, preserving their historical significance and original
character faces becomes increasingly challenging. As Long notes in“Lost Charlston”,
“Modernity is the natural enemy of preservation” (10), highlighting the inherent tension between
new developments and the imperative need to maintain historical integrity. Even seemingly
minor changes can erode the historical fabric of an area, diminishing its value as a cultural and
educational resource. When historic buildings are supplanted by modern structures, the unique
character and aesthetic of the district are lost, supplanted by generic, homogenized architecture.
Moreover, commercialization often prioritizes profit over cultural value, resulting in a dilution in
the sense of historical authenticity and community connection. Businesses fixated solely on
profit may disregard the historical significance of their surroundings, opting instead for flashy
contemporary designs that clash with the historical context. This shift can reduce a historically
rich area into a mere backdrop for commercial activities, undermining its educational and
cultural value.
3
Preserving cultural heritage not only stimulates the local economies but also nurtures
community pride and identity by upholding a tangible connection to the past. This dual impact is
vividly evident in various regions, including Oklahoma, where the significance of historic
preservation evidently extends beyond mere economic metrics. As noted in a recent study,
“While numbers are important to quantitatively frame the many economic contributions of
historic preservation of Oklahoma, they do not convey the significant qualitative contribution of
preservation to local revitalization in this state” (Preservation Oklahoma Inc, 19). The authors
highlight two critical aspects of historic preservation. Firstly, they acknowledge its economic
benefits, including job creation, tourism revenue, and augmented property value, which provide
tangible financial impetus and spur further investment in the region. Moreover, the quote adeptly
emphasizes the intangible contributions that cannot be measured solely by statistics. These
contributions play a pivotal role in fostering community pride and identity. The preservation of
historical sites and structures facilitates a tangible connection to the past, enabling residents to
immerse themselves in and celebrate their shared heritage. This connection strengthens
community bonds as individuals take pride in their distinct history and cultural landmarks,
fostering a distinct sense of continuity and identity that allows communities to understand their
roots and evolve with a profound appreciation of their roots.
Analyzing successful preservation models can offer valuable strategies for revitalizing
Old Sacramento or similar historic sites. For instance, “the revitalization of Cleveland’s
warehouse district, now a successful mixed-use downtown neighborhood, began in the 1970s
with artists illegally occupying former industrial warehouse buildings,” (Tighe and
Ryberg-webster, 11). This example illustrates how community-driven initiatives can spark
4
significant urban renewal, offering valuable lessons for preserving and revitalizing areas with
historical significance. The transformation of Cleveland's district highlights the potential for
creative and community driven approaches to breathe new life into historic sites. This
transformation demonstrates that with the right strategies and mindsets, such areas can continue
to thrive.
While we’ve explored the benefits of preserving historical sites, it’s crucial to address
opposing arguments. Some argue that modern development and commercialization are vital for
economic growth, as preservation may not seem immediately profitable. However, it’s crucial to
recognize that the long-term economic benefits from tourism and preservation outweigh the short
term gains from development. Additionally, while some believe that commercialization would
enhance accessible and enjoyment, authentic, well-preserved sites hold greater value for both
tourists and residents. For instance, during my time in Sacramento, the Old Sacramento district
was deeply cherished for its historical significance. This underscores the importance of
maintaining physical connections to our past. Another common argument is that development is
necessary to accommodate population growth and modern needs. While valid, smart planning
and adaptive reuse of existing historical structures can meet modern needs without sacrificing
heritage.
Ultimately, safeguarding Old Sacramento through historical preservation is essential for
maintaining its cultural heritage and historical significance. Choosing to prioritize preservation
over modern development not only allows for a deep connection with the past but also nurtures a
collective sense of community pride and continuity. Furthermore, investing in heritage tourism
and nurturing the vibrant cultural life that preservation sustains presents a sustainable alternative
5
to the fleeting benefits of commercialization. As we gaze into the future, it becomes increasingly
crucial for policymakers, community members, and stakeholders alike to collaborate in
safeguarding and cherishing Old Sacramento for its uniqueness and historical assets. Through
collaborative efforts, we can ensure that this iconic district continues to serve as a beacon of
education, inspiration, and enrichment for both visitors and residents for generations to come.
6
Works Cited
Legacy Cities : Continuity and Change amid Decline and Revival, edited by J. Rosie Tighe, and
Stephanie Ryberg-Webster, University of Pittsburgh Press, 2019. ProQuest Ebook
Central,
https://ebookcentral-proquest-com.cgcc-access.sage.eou.edu/lib/cgcc/detail.action?docID
=5789179.
Long, J. Grahame. Lost Charleston, The History Press, 2019. ProQuest Ebook Central,
https://ebookcentral-proquest-com.cgcc-access.sage.eou.edu/lib/cgcc/detail.action?docID
=5742302
Practicing Sustainability, edited by Guru Madhavan, et al., Springer, 2012. ProQuest Ebook
Central,
https://ebookcentral-proquest-com.cgcc-access.sage.eou.edu/lib/cgcc/detail.action?docID
=1030820
Preservation Oklahoma Inc. Economic Impacts of Historic Preservation in Oklahoma. 2008.
https://cgcc.on.worldcat.org/oclc/1121624521
