Wang 2004
Wang 2004
CarbonatePolypropylene Composites.
                             2: Effect of Compounding on the Dispersion and the
                             Impact Properties of Surface-Modified Composites
                                                            YEH WANG* and WEI-C. LEE
                           This study was carried out to investigate the influences of compounding process
                        and surface treatment on calcium carbonate (CaCO3) filled polypropylene. The com-
                        pounding process is discussed with reference to a twin-screw extruder and an in-
                        ternal mixer. The calcium carbonate filler was surface-treated with a liquid titanate
                        coupling agent (LICA 12) and stearic acid. Composites of different weight fractions
                        were prepared by both compounding processes, and their impact properties were
                        evaluated. The notched Izod impact strength increased with CaCO3 content up to a
                        maximum at about 10 vol%, and then decreased. Surface treatment of CaCO3 filler
                        generally yielded composites of higher impact strength than untreated system.
                        Though LICA 12 was more effective than stearic acid in modifying the filler, the low-
                        cost stearic acid proved to be more effective when dealing with the impact properties
                        of composites. Moreover, the composites from a Brabender Plasti-corder exhibited
                        better gross uniformity than that from the twin-screw extruder. However, good
                        filler dispersion and uniform microscopic morphology, as revealed by SEM micros-
                        copy, was observed in the samples from the twin-screw extruder. Polym. Compos.
                        25:451– 460, 2004. © 2004 Society of Plastics Engineers.
the quality of finished products, it is necessary to define        Compounding was carried out on a co-rotating self-
and quantify the state of dispersion generated from             wiping twin-screw extruder. The PSM30 machine was
compounding operations. For thermoplastic systems,              manufactured by Sino-Alloy Machinery Inc. with a
SEM of fractured surfaces and image analysis meth-              screw diameter D of 31.2 mm, the distance between
ods are commonly used in order to define various dis-           screw axes was 26.2 mm, screw tip clearance was
persion indexes and mean particle diameters (18,                0.25 mm, and the length to the diameter ratio L/D 
2022).                                                         45. The screw consisted of ten segmented barrels with
   To control and to improve the mechanical properties          three kneading zones. The first kneading zone started
of particulate-filled polymeric composites, it is desir-        at the 2nd barrel consisting of high shear disk blocks,
able to understand the interactions between surface             and ended with neutral blocks. The second zone
treatment, processing, and properties. Therefore, this          started at the 4th barrel also consisting of high shear
study was initiated to investigate the difference be-           elements with reverse elements at the end. The third
tween the continuous process, the twin-screw ex-                zone started at the 7th barrel with only neutral ele-
truder, and the batch process, the internal mixer. We           ments. In the first and the second kneading zones,
characterized the structure of composites in terms of           more severe shearing action is assumed due to the
the state of dispersion of the filler through the use of        high shear disk blocks and due to the presence of re-
scanning electron microscopy in conjunction with a              verse flighted elements. The reverse elements increase
commercial image analysis system. Special attention             the resistance to flow resulting in an increase of the
has been paid to the investigation of large aggregates          fill degree and the residence time in the mixing section.
and agglomerates existing in the composites. Notched            The neutral elements only induce gentle shearing and
Izod impact properties were analyzed, and their rela-           homogenization of the polymer melt (24, 25). There-
tions to the state of dispersion were investigated. The         fore, it is expected that the filler particles experience
effects of filler concentration and processing condi-           high intensity of dispersive mixing in the first and the
tions are discussed as well.                                    second kneading zones; and the distributive mixing
                                                                action dominates in the third kneading zone. The de-
                   EXPERIMENTAL                                 tails of the screw configuration and element geome-
                                                                tries are shown in Fig. 1. A standard pelletizing die
Materials
                                                                plate was installed at the screw end. The strand was
   The general-purpose isotactic polypropylene homo-            solidified in a water bath and pelletized.
polymer (Yungsox 1040) provided by the Yung-Chia                   In addition to the screw configuration, the principal
Chemical Co., Taiwan, was used in this study. The               processing variables were throughput rate, screw
density of polypropylene was 904 kg/m3 measured                 speed, and barrel temperature profiles. After several
with an electronic densimeter. The calcium carbonate            trials, the screw speed was set at 100 rpm, and the
with the trade name Hydrocarb 90 was supplied by                barrel temperatures were set from 180°C at the first
Omya, Switzerland. Its average particle size was 0.8            barrel to 200°C at the last barrel. The barrel tempera-
m and the specific gravity was 2.7, which were pro-            ture profiles are also shown in Fig. 1. The screw speed
vided by the manufacturer. The surface treatment                and the barrel temperatures were fixed for all experi-
was carried out by the dissolution method, whose de-            mental runs. Finally, the throughput rate was in the
tails are given in part 1 (23). The calcium carbonate           range from 5 kg/hr to 8 kg/hr for compounds of dif-
filler were treated with 0.3 phf LICA 12 (Kenrich Petro-        ferent formulations.
chemicals Inc., USA), or treated with 7.4 phf stearic              We also employed an internal mixer besides the
acid (Lancaster, UK). Here ‘phf ’ denotes parts per             twin-screw extruder for the comparison purpose. The
hundred filler. LICA 12 is a liquid titanate coupling           internal mixer was a Brabender PL 2000 Plasti-
agent that has been well known for its effectiveness in         corder. A mixing head of W 50 type with a mixing vol-
modifying inorganic fillers, and stearic acid has been          ume of 60 cm3 was installed. After loading polypropyl-
a widely used surfactant for inorganic fillers. To all          ene, the calcium carbonate filler was fed into the
the compounds, 0.2 wt% heat stabilizer (Evernox-10)             mixing chamber sequentially. The mixing temperature
from Everspring Chemical Co., Taiwan, was added to              was set at 180°C, rotation speed was 100 rpm, and
prevent degradation of the polymer during compound-             the total mixing time was 30 min, during which the
ing. Polypropylene and the stablizer were dry-blended           imposed torque would reach an equilibrium value.
at room temperature after dehumidifying.
                                                                Notched Izod Impact Test
Compounding Procedures                                            Test pieces for impact testing were compression
  The polymer pellets and mineral additive were me-             molded from the pellets under pressure at 200°C for
tered independently in the required proportions using           30 minutes before slow cooling. The notched Izod test
volumetric dosing units. The pellets were fed into the          specimens followed the ASTM D256 norms. All test
hopper of the extruder through a forced feeder, and             pieces had a sharp notch using a diamond cutter. The
the mineral powder was introduced separately through            initial crack depth was 1 mm. The notched samples
the secondary feeding port where the polymer was                were used for studying the impact properties with an
partially melted.                                               Izod impact tester at room temperature around 25°C.
Fig. 2. Measured weight concentration from TGA versus preset concentration for untreated samples.
filler concentrations is due to limited plastic flow of             depends on the structure and properties of the com-
the PP matrix, i.e., the ductile matrix of PP is replaced           posites. Structural inhomogeneities, such as aggrega-
by the rigid dispersed particulates.                                tion, voids, etc., in a poorly dispersed system would
   Surface treatment shows a positive effect on impact              favor initiation of fracture.
strength. As can be seen from Fig. 4, impact strengths                 Figure 5 shows the results of the notched Izod
of the treated composites are higher than those of                  impact strength versus filler concentration of i-PP/
untreated ones. It can also be seen that stearic acid               CaCO3 composites with and without surface treat-
treated composites generally give higher strengths                  ment from the Plasti-corder. Note that we did not add
than LICA 12. The difference in impact strength be-                 stabilizer into untreated and LICA 12 treated compos-
comes more significant at higher volume concentra-                  ites. However, since stearic acid is less thermally sta-
tions. While the impact strength of LICA 12 treated                 ble than LICA 12, the stabilizer was added to stearic
compounds at 20 vol% is lower than the neat PP,                     acid treated composites in order to prevent the dra-
stearic acid treated compounds show higher strengths                matic drop of the equilibrium torque due to excessive
than the neat PP. We noticed that stearic acid treated              degradation. As expected, stearic acid treated compos-
CaCO3 showed greater drop in surface energy than                    ites again exhibit higher strength than that of LICA12
LICA 12 treated filler (23), though it took much higher             treated composites, and untreated composites have
concentration of stearic acid than LICA 12 in order to              the lowest strength. Note that even at 20 vol% the im-
achieve similar effect of surface treatment. Therefore              pact strength of stearic acid treated composites is still
the particle-particle interaction was reduced more ef-              higher than the neat PP. Moreover, when comparing
fectively in stearic acid treated CaCO3 fillers, particu-           Fig. 5 with Fig. 4, it can be clearly seen that the impact
larly at high loadings of filler.                                   strengths of composites, either treated or untreated,
   It has been well known that the extent of stress                 from the Plasti-corder are lower than those from the
concentration around the inclusion in a matrix is pro-              twin-screw extruder. Though the mixing time and ro-
portional to the inclusion size. Thus a low degree of               tation speed of the Plasti-corder may not be properly
filler dispersion, which will be discussed through mi-              adjusted to achieve the same mixing quality as in the
croscopic observation in the following section, may give            twin-screw extruder, too long mixing time or too high
rise to large agglomerates of CaCO3 particles, which                rotation speed would induce excessive degradation of
would initiate sample failure and lower the impact                  the PP matrix. Note that the macroscopic analysis
energy. Furthermore, failure initiation and propagation             through TGA and density measurement indicates better
gross uniformity for compounds from the Plasti-corder.            proceeds along the PP-CaCO3 interface so that abun-
However, it does not guarantee better ultimate proper-            dant CaCO3 particles can be observed on the fracture
ties like impact strength, which is intimately related            surfaces, except for a few embedded fillers. It is rather
to the microscopic morphology and dispersion degree               clear here that the untreated CaCO3 fillers do not
of compounds. Further study of mixing quality, the                bond the matrix well, which reveals that the filler-ma-
dispersion degree in the composites, and the morphol-             trix interface is weak and adhesive failures prevail.
ogy of the fracture surfaces through scanning electron               The micrograph shown in Fig. 6b at high magnifica-
microscopy shall be undertaken next.                              tion allows us to take a close look at the interface be-
                                                                  tween fillers and matrix. The popped-up particles are
Morphological Observation                                         scattered on the fracture surface without PP residue
                                                                  covering the surface of the particle. Many uneven holes
  Scanning electron micrographs of the fractured sur-             suggest the occurrence of filler pullout. Moreover, the
faces of the i-PP/CaCO3 composites from impact test-              clean surface of CaCO3 particles with bordered pits
ing are presented in Figs. 6 through 8. Since the effect          printed in the matrix clearly indicates they are merely
of surface treatment is most significant at high con-             embedded in the matrix without interfacial bonding.
centrations, we show only the pictures of composites                 Figures 7a and 7b show the fracture surfaces of
at 20 vol%, such that the effectiveness of surface                composites with LICA 12 treated CaCO3 from the
treatment could be judiciously evaluated.                         twin-screw extruder at magnifications of 1000 and
  Figures 6a and 6b show the fracture surface of com-             5000, respectively. Both micrographs display nearly
posites with untreated CaCO3 from the twin-screw ex-              the same morphology as shown in Figs. 6a and 6b for
truder at magnifications of 1000 and 5000, re-                  untreated CaCO 3. Figure 7a shows the randomly
spectively. We first examine the fracture surfaces at             propagated fracture surface; and Fig. 7b shows popped-
1ow magnification in Fig. 6a. It can be seen that the             up particles and uneven holes. In short, surface treat-
randomly propagated fracture surfaces in these mi-                ment of CaCO3 filler by LICA 12 does not seem very
crographs clearly confirm the brittle behavior induced            effective, and indeed the impact strength of LICA 12
by the PP matrix at room temperature (21, 28, 29).                treated composites is only slightly greater than that of
The observed crack has spread mainly through the                  untreated systems at all loadings of filler, as seen
weakest track in the composite. Hence, the fracture               from Figs. 4 and 5.
Fig. 4. Impact strength versus filler concentration of treated and untreated composites from twin-screw extruder.
  Figures 8a and 8b show the fracture surfaces of                     twin-screw extruder are shown in Fig. 9. It can be
composites with stearic acid treated CaCO3 from the                   clearly seen that stearic acid treated CaCO3 shows
twin-screw extruder at magnifications of 1000 and                    higher fractions of particles with size less than 1 m,
5000, respectively. Both micrographs display quite                   while untreated CaCO3 shows higher fractions of par-
different morphologies from those shown in the previ-                 ticles bigger than 3 m. The calculated mean particle
ous figures. In Fig. 8a, though the propagation of the                sizes are 1.69 m for untreated CaCO3, 1.21 m for
fracture is not very regular, there are many fewer                    LICA 12 treated CaCO3, and 1.15 m for stearic acid
structural inhomogeneities, such as uneven cracks                     treated CaCO3, which is the smallest. Smaller mean
and voids, compared to the composites filled with un-                 particle size would suggest better quality of particle
treated or LICA 12 treated CaCO3. In Fig. 8b, it can be               dispersion.
seen that more particles are embedded in the polymer                     Figures 10a and 10b show the fracture surfaces of
matrix without gaps between fillers and matrix, and                   composites with stearic acid treated CaCO3 from the
the fracture surface looks more uniform than that                     Plasti-corder at magnifications of 1000 and 5000,
shown previously. These morphological observations                    respectively. It can be clearly seen that these micro-
indicate improved adhesion between fillers and matrix                 graphs display more voids and irregular cracks, and
due to surface treatment with stearic acid, and explain               more popped-up particles without the PP matrix ad-
why the impact strengths of stearic acid treated com-                 hering to the surface of particle, when compared with
posites are better than untreated or LICA 12 treated                  Figs. 8a and 8b. However, the mean particle size is
systems, particularly at high loadings of filler.                     1.19 m, which is only slightly larger than that from
  Image analysis of the fracture surfaces was carried                 the twin-screw extruder. Apparently, the degree of
out in order to look into the particle size distribution,             filler dispersion is comparable to that from the twin-
which is closely related to the quality of filler disper-             screw extruder, but thermal degradation may induce
sion. We used only micrographs with magnifications                    the deterioration of interfacial adhesion due to im-
at 1000. We think, with lower magnification, more                    proper compounding conditions in the Plasti-corder,
particles would be available for analysis, leading to                 and this confirms the inferior impact strengths of
more unbiased results. The particle size distributions                composites from the Plasti-corder relative to those
of untreated and treated CaCO3 at 20 vol% from the                    from the twin-screw extruder.
Fig. 5. Impact strength versus filler concentration of treated and untreated composites from Plasti-corder.
                            (a)                                                                      (b)
Fig. 6. Scanning electron micrographs of fractured composites with untreated CaCO3 at 20 vol% from twin-screw extruder; (a) magni-
fication at 1000, (b) magnification at 5000.
                            (a)                                                                   (b)
Fig. 7. Scanning electron micrographs of fractured composites with L ICA 12 treated CaCO3 at 20 vol% from twin-screw extruder;
(a) magnification at 1000, (b) magnification at 5000.
                            (a)                                                                   (b)
Fig. 8. Scanning electron micrographs of fractured composites with stearic acid treated CaCO3 at 20 vol% from twin-screw extruder;
(a) magnification at 1000, (b) magnification at 5000.
Fig. 9. Particle size distribution of CaCO3 filled composites from twin-screw extruder at 20 vol%.
                           (a)                                                                      (b)
Fig. 10. Scanning electron micrographs of fractured composites with stearic acid treated CaCO3 at 20 vol% from Plasti-corder;
(a) magnification at 1000, (b) magnification at 5000.
related to inferior notched impact strength. Enhanced              3. M. Sumita, T. Ookuma, K. Miyasaka, and K. Ishikawa,
dispersions, revealed by SEM microscopy, were ob-                     J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 27, 3039 (1982).
                                                                   4. M. Sumita, T. Shizuma, K. Miyasaka, and K. Ishikawa,
tained through surface treatment. Furthermore, the                    J. Macromol. Sci. Phys., B22, 601 (1983).
stearic acid modified composites yield better disper-              5. V. P. Chacko, R. J. Farris, and F. E. Karasz, J. Appl.
sion with decreased size of filler agglomerates than                  Polym. Sci., 28, 2701 (1983).
the LICA 12 treated system. In other words, the exten-             6. S.-R. Dai and M. R. Piggott, Polym. Compos., 7, 19
                                                                      (1986).
sive acid-base interaction between stearic acid and
                                                                   7. G. Levita, A. Marchetti, and A. Lazzeri, Polym. Compos.,
CaCO3 filler would, on the one hand, diminish the                     10, 39 (1989).
particle-particle interaction and better facilitate the            8. I. Sasaki, K. Ito, T. Kodama, and F. Ide, Kobunshi Ron-
dispersion of the filler in the non-polar matrix, and,                bunshui, 33, 162 (1976).
on the other hand, the long alkyl chain of stearic acid            9. T. Nakatuka, H. Kawasaki, and K. Itadani, J. Colloid In-
                                                                      terface Sci., 82, 298 (1981).
promote interfacial adhesion between the filler and               10. Y. N. Sharma, R. D. Patel, I. H. Dhimmar, and I. S.
the matrix (23).                                                      Bhardwai, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 27, 97 (1982).
  Finally, the macroscopic analysis through thermo-               11. K. Mitsuishi, S. Kodama, and H. Kawasaki, Polym. Eng.
gravimetric analysis (TGA) and density measurement                    Sci., 25, 1069 (1985).
                                                                  12. K. Mitsuishi, S. Kodama, and H. Kawasaki, Kobunshi
indicates better gross uniformity for compounds from                  Ronbunshu, 43, 43 (1986).
the Plasti-corder than from the twin-screw extruder,              13. J. W. Ess, P. R. Hornsby, S. Y. Yin, and M. J. Bevis,
because the volumetric dosing unit for twin-screw                     Plas. Rubber Proc. Appl., 4, 7 (1984).
compounding may not be very precise. However, mor-                14. A. M. Riley, C. D. Paynter, P. M. McGenity, and J. M.
                                                                      Adams, Plas. Rubber Proc. Appl., 14, 85 (1990).
phological uniformity and high degree of filler disper-           15. S. F. Xavier, J. M. Schultz, and K. Friedrich, J. Mater.
sion, as revealed by SEM microscopy, was observed                     Sci., 25, 241 (1990).
in the compounds from the twin-screw extruder. The                16. A. Tabtiang and R. Venables, Composite Interfaces, 6,
microscopic uniformity confirms the high impact                       65 (1999).
                                                                  17. S. J. Monte, Paper 16, presented at the ACS Rubber Di-
strength of composites from the twin-screw extruder,
                                                                      vision Meeting, Rhode Island (2001).
even at high loadings of CaCO3 filler. In short, the              18. Y. Wang and J.-S. Huang, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 60, 1779
maximum improvement in the mechanical properties                      (1996).
of the composites could be achieved only through a                19. B. Haworth, C. L. Raymond, and I. Sutherland, Polym.
proper combination of mixing device and compound-                     Eng. Sci., 40, 1953 (2000).
                                                                  20. J. W. Ess and P. R. Hornsby, Plast. Rubber Tech., 8,
ing conditions in conjunction with effective surface                  147 (1987).
treatment of filler particles.                                    21. Y. Suetsugu, Inter. Polym. Proc., 5, 184 (1990).
                                                                  22. M. Bories, M. A. Huneault, and P. G. Lafleur, SPE
                 ACKNOWLEDGMENT                                       ANTEC Tech. Paper, 350 (1999).
                                                                  23. Y. Wang and W.-C. Lee, Polym. Compos., 24, 119 (2003).
   The financial support of this research by the Na-              24. J. L. White, Twin Screw Extrusion, Hanser Publishers,
tional Science Council of Taiwan, Republic of China,                  Munich (1990).
                                                                  25. Y. Wang, Compounding in Co-Rotating Twin-Screw Ex-
under grant NSC-89-2216-E-029-001 is gratefully ac-                   truders, Rapra Review Report, vol. 10, no. 8 (2000).
knowledged.                                                       26. S. N. Maiti and P. K. Mahapatro, J. Appl. Polym. Sci.,
                                                                      42, 3101 (1991).
                     REFERENCES                                   27. V. Svehlova and E. Poloucek, Die Angewandte Makro-
                                                                      molekulare Chemie, 153, 197 (1987).
 1. L. E. Nielsen, Mechanical Properties of Polymers and          28. M. Bramuzzo, A. Savadori, and D. Bacci, Polym. Compos.,
    Composites, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1974, p. 380.                8, 1 (1985).
 2. L. Nicolais and R. A. Mashelker, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 20,    29. E. Nezbedova, J. Ponesicky, and M. Sova, Acta Polymer-
    561 (1976).                                                       ica, 41, 36 (1990).