Op09 Eng
Op09 Eng
Investors
OP 9 Investors
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
  12.1.   Substitution of evaluation.......................................................................................................... 20
13.   Procedure: Investors destined to Quebec........................................................................................ 21
14.   Procedure: Refusals......................................................................................................................... 21
Appendix    A Refusal letter – Investors - Applications received pre-April 1, 1999 .................................. 21
Appendix    B Refusal letter – Investors – Definition or insufficient points ............................................... 22
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
Updates to Chapter
Listing by date:
Date: 2008-08-08
The manual has been updated throughout to reflect that policy responsibility and administration of the
investment component for the Investor Program is the responsibility of Permanent Resident Policy and
Programs Division, Immigration Branch
Section 8.3, What is a qualifying business?, has been amended to provide instructions on how to assess
entrepreneur or investor applicants’ “business experience.” Officers are now required to consider the
aggregate financial information of more than one business.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
         This chapter outlines the broad objectives of the Business Immigration Program. It focuses
         specifically on procedures used at missions abroad to process investor foreign nationals.
         The Business Immigration Program includes three classes of foreign nationals:
• entrepreneurs;
• investors;
• self-employed persons.
• operational issues.
         Procedures related to federal skilled workers are contained in chapter OP 6. Procedures related
         to entrepreneurs and self-employed foreign nationals are discussed in chapter OP 8.
2. Program objectives
         The principles of the Business Immigration Program are in keeping with the overall objectives of
         the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (A3) and specifically those in A3(1)(a) and (c).
         The Program's objectives are:
•    to promote economic development and employment by attracting people with capital, business
     acumen and entrepreneurial skills;
•    to develop new commercial opportunities and to improve access to growing foreign markets by
     "importing" people who are familiar with those markets and their special requirements and customs;
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
         Specific Regulations applying to entrepreneurs, investors or self-employed foreign
         nationals
Provision                                                               Act and Regulations
Definition of:
Investor                                                                R88
Business Experience                                                     R88
Full-time job equivalent                                                R88
Net assets, net income, net worth                                       R88
Percentage of equity                                                    R88
Qualifying business                                                     R88
Selection criteria, investor                                            R102
Authority to issue visas                                                A11
Points, investor and entrepreneur                                       R78, R79, R81, R103,
                                                                        R104
Foreign nationals to the province of Quebec                             R96(b)
Selection criteria - experience factor (entrepreneurs and investors)    R103
Substitution of evaluation                                              R109
Minimum points to pass Investor                                         R108(2)
3.1.    Forms required
Form title                                           Form number
Application for Permanent Residence in Canada        IMM0008EGEN
The Guide for Business Applicants and the            IMM4000
Business Immigration Application Form
http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/applications/
business.html
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
5. Departmental policy
Where potential demand warrants, business immigration seminars may be held to:
• clarify the roles and responsibilities of the federal government and the provincial governments.
       Application information: The Guide for Business Applicants and the Business Immigration
       Application Form can be found on the Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) Web site at
       http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/pdf/kits/guides/4000ESap.pdf (Simplified Application Process) or
       http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/pdf/kits/guides/4000E.PDF(Regular Application Process) or can be
       obtained at visa offices abroad.
       Other promotional material may be available from the provinces or other agencies.
       Officers are well placed to provide objective information about the investor program to applicants
       and third party representatives and are encouraged to take an active promotion and marketing
       role. This approach is subject to operational constraints.
       Promotional efforts should familiarize potential applicants with the services offered by provincial
       governments to business foreign nationals. Where feasible, officers should coordinate their
       promotional efforts with those of provincial government representatives who may also be active in
       this field.
       The onus is on the applicant to produce all relevant information in support of their application.
       The applicant is expected to provide original supporting documentation or certified copies as part
       of the application. If copies are provided with the application, originals must be produced at
       interview if requested.
       The applicant will need to provide certified translations in English or French, and an interpreter, as
       required. The interpreter must be a professional, and neither a friend, relative, employee, lawyer
       nor consultant of the applicant.
5.6. Interviews
       Under the IRPA Regulations, members of the business foreign nationals class may or may not be
       called to an interview. This puts them on a par with other classes of foreign nationals:
       • where the documentation submitted with the application clearly establishes eligibility, and you
         are satisfied it is authentic, waiving the interview may be appropriate;
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
• where it clearly establishes that the applicant is not eligible, officers must refuse.
        Officers may require the dependants' presence if their presence is necessary for the purpose of
        assessing the application. This applies whether or not they will accompany the principal applicant
        to Canada. Members of a family do not have to be interviewed at the same time and place.
        A15 authorizes officers to interview the principal applicant and any dependants at the visa office
        or at any other appropriate location. There are no limitations upon what is considered appropriate,
        but the officer should have reasons for requiring the presence of dependants at an interview.
        As always, all statutory requirements (including medical, criminal, security, truthfulness and proof
        of relationship to the dependants) must be met before a visa may be issued.
        Officers are obliged to apply the regulatory definition of investor and not the policy choice of the
        federal or provincial government.
        Some provinces or territories may have developed other definitions for use within their
        jurisdictions. These reflect provincial or territorial priorities, experience and knowledge of local
        conditions. However, they are not requirements under the Immigration and Refugee Protection
        Act and Regulations and do not have the force of law.
        Officers should encourage successful applicants to take advantage of the post-right of entry
        counselling services that some provinces or territories may offered.
5.9. Cost recovery fee and right of permanent residence fee (RPRF)
        The cost recovery fee is payable at the time the application is made and is not refundable. The
        cost recovery fee must only be charged for persons who intend to immigrate to Canada.
        The RPRF is only refundable, upon request, to applicants who do not obtain permanent resident
        status. RPRF is also only for persons who intend to immigrate to Canada.
        Successful applicants who decide not to use their visas must return them to the visa office in
        order to obtain a RPRF refund. Unsuccessful applicants should be informed as part of the refusal
        letter that they are entitled to a RPRF refund. The visa office that finalized a case is responsible
        for processing any related RPRF refund if the RPRF has been paid.
        Non-accompanying dependants do not pay these fees even though they must undergo statutory
        processing.
        Requests for information from the provinces and territories should be accommodated, subject to
        the provisions of the Privacy Act and Access to Information Act.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
        A number of provinces have negotiated Memoranda of Understanding to facilitate the exchange
        of information. Permanent Resident Policy and Programs Division manages this.
        Officers may request documentation to support the applicant's application. The documentation
        requested should primarily provide evidence about the applicant's financial position and previous
        business experience. Prior business experience is a prerequisite.
        Officers should accord the same processing priority to business foreign nationals as to other
        categories of foreign nationals. Applicants must understand that their application will not receive
        special consideration because they may have chosen to be represented by a lawyer or
        consultant. Lawyers and consultants representing business applicants should comply with the
        same standards applying to third party representatives in any other kind of foreign national case.
        When the officer has concerns about eligibility or admissibility, the applicant must be given a fair
        opportunity to correct or contradict those concerns. The applicant must be given an opportunity to
        rebut the content of any negative provincial assessment that may influence the final decision.
        The officer has an obligation to provide a thorough and fair assessment in compliance with the
        terms and spirit of the legislation and procedural fairness requirements.
        The records of successful investors must be retained for three years from the date of visa
        issuance. Records of refused applicants must be retained five years from the date of final
        disposition
        The visa office should make its microfilmed or CAIPS records available to inland offices upon
        request, subject to the Privacy Act. Information from the visa office may assist in determining
        whether there has been any misrepresentation on the application for permanent residence.
        Permanent Resident Policy and Programs Division at NHQ has access to CAIPS. The Division
        will review case notes from time to time, following contact with a province or a mission.
6. Definitions
6.1. Audits
        The objective of an audit is to express an opinion as to whether the financial statements present
        fairly, in all material respects, the financial position in accordance with generally accepted
        accounting principles. This is the highest form of assurance. The auditor performs the audit with
        an attitude of professional scepticism and seeks reasonable assurance whether the financial
        statements are free of material misstatement.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
           In Canada, it would be unusual for a small private business to have an audit. The Canadian
           Business Corporations Act requires an audit if sales exceed $10,000,000 but even in that case, if
           the company is closely held, it can waive the audit requirement.
•      income statement (or Statement of Income and Retained Earnings), (see Financial statements:
       income statement, section 6.5);
           Any asset or liability which will be converted into cash within one year is defined as current and
           the difference between current assets and current liabilities provides some indication of a
           company's liquidity and solvency.
           The balance sheet provides a snapshot in time (usually at the business's year-end). Assuming
           that the information provided is accurate, it provides an indication of the assets available to
           conduct business operations and an indication of the scope of operations.
           The balance sheet's accounting equation is liabilities (the money supplied by creditors) plus the
           owners' equity (money supplied by owners) equals the assets (the total money invested in the
           company) as shown in the following table.
Balance sheet accounting equation
This                             Plus this                              Equals this
Liabilities                      Owners' Equity                         Assets
the money supplied by            money supplied by owners and           the total money invested in the
creditors                        retained earnings                      company
           A series of balance sheets can reveal the soundness of the company's structure.
           When reviewing the balance sheet, it should be remembered that it is based on historical
           transactions. As a result, it discloses a book value that may not correspond to the market value of
           an enterprise.
Note: Fixed assets will be recorded at historical cost less an estimate for depreciation which may not
   bear any resemblance to fair market value. This is especially true with land since fair market value
   may be many times the original cost.
           The income statement measures a company's sales (revenue), expenses and earnings over a
           specified time period, usually one year. It provides an indication of the scope of operations (along
           with the balance sheet).
           The income statement is a good indicator of a company's financial performance. Earnings and
           trends in earnings are the best indicators of a company's financial well-being. Changes or trends
           in financial position should indicate whether the company is growing or declining.
           The income statement should help the officer determine the company's net book value (if the
           business were to be sold, how much would it realize?) and the number of its employees (from the
           wage and salary expenses).
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
           In some cases, small businesses may only be able to produce an income statement generated
           specifically for tax purposes.
           Full-time equivalent means 1950 hours per year of paid employment and may consist of either
           one person working full-time, or several people working the equivalent of a full-time position.
           The promissory note is the physical equivalent of the debt obligation referred to in the
           Regulations. The promissory note is provided to the investor by CIC, on behalf of the provinces,
           as evidence of their $400,000 investment. Investors are required to present their promissory
           notes to Permanent Resident Policy and Programs Division at the indicated redemption date for
           repayment.
           The IIP Subscription Agreement sets out the operation and administration of the program within
           the context of the regulatory framework and is a legally binding contract.
6.9. Investor
• indicates in writing to an officer that they intend to or have made an investment of CDN $400,000.
           The personal net worth statement includes both business and personal assets and liabilities of
           the applicant as well as those of the spouse or common-law partner.
           Review engagements are distinguishable from audits in that the scope of review is less than that
           of an audit and therefore the level of assurance provided is lower. A review consists primarily of
           enquiry, analytical procedures and discussion related to information supplied to the public
           accountant by the enterprise with the limited objective of assessing whether information being
           reported on is plausible within the framework of appropriate criteria.
           The following sections outline procedures officers will follow to assess investor applications. The
           sections are set out as follows:
           Pre-Application Counselling, see Section 7.2
           Assessing Eligibility - Selection Criteria, see Section 8
           Making the Eligibility Decision, see Section 10
           Making the Admissibility Decision, see Section 12
           Issuing the Immigrant Visa, see Section 12.1
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
           Investors Destined to Quebec, see Section 13
           Refusals, see Section 14
           Handling Payment of Investment, see Section 9
           With the exception of Quebec, the provinces and territories are not directly involved in the
           selection process. There are, however, federal-provincial agreements that allow specific
           provinces to nominate foreign nationals who have investment experience. The federal
           government has exclusive responsibility for selecting foreign nationals in the investor category. A
           number of provinces may, in the future, enter into agreements that would allow them to select
           investors.
           The Canada-Quebec Accord gives Quebec authority to select investors and to operate its own
           Immigrant Investor Program (IIP). R96 provides regulatory authority.
           Investors in Quebec's IIP must intend to settle in the province of Quebec and must obtain a
           Certificat de sélection (CSQ) as proof of their selection by Quebec.
7.2. Forms
           Schedule 6, together with the IMM 0008EGEN, provides a snapshot of the applicant’s financial
           status and business experience. Missions may need to tailor additional forms that are location
           specific.
Pre-Application Counselling
           As operational exigencies allow, the officer should provide information to the prospective investor
           prior to receiving the application. The officer, for example, could:
• discuss with the applicant the possibility of an exploratory visit to Canada; and
           The Immigration and Refugee Protection Act encourages investors to make exploratory visits to
           Canada and grants six assessment points for doing so.
7.3. Ensuring that the applicant has all necessary documentation to make the application
•      in addition to the usual counselling material, the information package given to a prospective applicant
       includes clear information on what supporting documentation will be needed to assess an applicant's
       ability to meet the definition;
•      applicants are asked to submit a version of the Personal Worth Statement and Business Applicant
       Summary with their application.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
           This section outlines the elements an officer must consider to determine whether the regulatory
           definition of investor is met.
           R90(2) mandates the refusal of any application where the applicant does not meet the regulatory
           definition of investor. If it is clear that an applicant does not meet the definition, no further analysis
           is required.
           The officer determines whether the applicant meets the regulatory definition, which consists of
           three distinct criteria. The investor must:
•      provide a written statement to an officer that they intend to make or have already made an investment
       of $400,000.
           Investors must pay CDN $400,000 to the Receiver General for Canada before a visa can be
           issued.
           The Regulations set out three clear criteria that must be met for the applicant's business
           experience to be satisfactory to an officer:
• qualifying business;
• time;
• role.
• which is not a business for deriving investment income (interest, dividend, or capital gains); and
•      for which documentary evidence of the applicant's participation in the business must be provided for
       at least two of the following attributes:
Attribute          Equity                     Multiplied by:             Equal or greater than
1                  Percentage of equity       Number of full-time jobs   2 full-time job equivalents
                   controlled by applicant    (equivalents)
2                  Percentage of equity       Total annual sales($)      $ 500,000
3                  Percentage of equity       Annual net income($)       $ 50,000
4                  Percentage of equity       Net assets                 $ 125,000
           In the past, officers were instructed to assess each business in which an applicant holds a
           percentage of equity, and if no single business could satisfy the requirements, then the definition
           of “qualifying business” was deemed to have not been met.
2008-08-08
         OP 9 Investors
                However, in Thomas v. MCI (FCC 2006), the judge held that visa officers commit a reviewable
                error when they fail to consider the aggregate financial result from all of an applicant's
                businesses.
                It is anticipated that the majority of Investor and Entrepreneur applicants will rely on a single
                business or, in the case of Investor applicants, choose to declare management experience in
                order to demonstrate “business experience.”
                Given the potential workload implications, such aggregate assessments should be made only
                where they are clearly relevant to the selection decision, such as a decision to refuse the
                applicant.
Example:
An applicant owns a percentage of equity in three businesses with the following characteristics:
                                                                                               Total:      Minimum
           Company    Applicant's    Company      Applicant's    Company      Applicant's                               Min.
                                                                                              (A) + (B)    Required
              A         Share           B           Share           C           Share                                   Met?
                                                                                               + (C)       by R88(1)
% of
Equity          33%                        50%                         25%
                As this example illustrates, the definition of “qualifying business” is not successfully met by any
                one business on its own. However, when one considers the aggregate total for the applicant’s
                share of sales, net assets, net income and full-time equivalents in all three businesses, the
                definition is met.
                In order to determine the percentage of equity controlled by an Investor applicant (and their
                spouse, where applicable) it may be necessary to look beyond the legal or de jure control of
                shares in the qualifying business.
                In certain circumstances, legal control of a portion of the qualifying business' equity may rest with
                another individual—but may still be considered part of the applicant's percentage of equity. For
                example, in jurisdictions where the law precludes non-citizens from legally controlling a majority
         2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
       interest in a business, other documents may exist, such as trust or licensing agreements, that
       better reflect the effective or de facto control of the business.
       In many of the Gulf States, non-citizen applicants legally own 49% of the capital stock of a
       corporation, with agreements stipulating full control over the assets, obligations and profits of the
       corporation in return for a small licensing fee to the Gulf national or 51% shareholder. In such a
       scenario, the equity percentage for the "qualifying business" calculation would be 100%.
       Where there are serious concerns that such documents or agreements were produced solely for
       the purposes of satisfying Immigration requirements, an officer must be satisfied that the
       applicant has not engaged in an artificial transaction [R89]. However, these agreements should
       always be considered within the local context, as the legal environment in certain countries can
       make them a necessity for a non-citizen operating a business.
8.5.   What is the time factor?
       For the applicant's business experience to count, it must have been accumulated during at least
       two years in the five-year period before the date of application or decision. What role must the
       investor have played?
       The investor’s role in the business must have been either:
       a) management and control of a percentage of equity of the qualifying business as shown in the
       following table. (There is no minimum percentage of equity requirement and the investor must
       provide documentary evidence for at least two attributes out of four.)
Attribute       Percentage of equity controlled by applicant
                100 %                  50 %                         33.33 %
Employment      2                        4                          6
Total Annual    500,000                  1000,000                   1,500,000
Sales ($)
Annual Net      50,000                   100,000                    150,000
Income($)
Net Assets at   125,000                  250,000                    375,000
Year-End
       Or
       b) management of five full-time job equivalents (each job equivalent is 1,950 hours of paid
       employment per year). The management experience must be in business.
       The Regulations anticipate that an applicant would have to establish ownership and valuation of
       the assets. Concerns over the provenance of funds are addressed in both the IRPA and the
       Regulations. Officers have authority to require evidence to establish admissibility and the power
       to reject an applicant for failing to discharge the obligation.
       The Regulations set out a requirement for a minimum net worth of $800,000, although there is no
       requirement for a minimum amount to be transferred to Canada. Net worth is critical to the
       assessment of business intent and ability.
       A16(1) imposes the obligation on applicants ‘to answer truthfully’ and ‘produce … all relevant
       evidence and documents’ reasonably required by the officer. A11(1) requires that a visa may
       only be granted if the officer ‘is satisfied that the foreign national is not inadmissible and meets
       the requirements of the Act.’
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
           The new Act also provides broader grounds and less onerous conditions to reject applicants.
           A40(1)(a) provides for the rejection of applicants for misrepresentation of a material fact, namely
           "for directly or indirectly misrepresenting or withholding material facts relating to a relevant matter
           that induces or could induce an error in the administration of this Act." A41 provides officers
           authority to find applicants inadmissible for "an act or omission which contravenes directly or
           indirectly a provision of this Act." The new legislation provides officers with the tools to
           reasonably require evidence to establish admissibility A16(1) and subsequently to reject the
           applicant when not satisfied of their admissibility A11(1) or else when provided false material
           information such as control and ownership of the business and net worth A40(1)(a). Similarly,
           officers may refuse applicants under A41 for any act or omission.
           In addition to broader legal authorities, the Act provides a wide context for officers to examine
           business applicants. Net worth is required of both entrepreneurs and investors, enabling officers
           to consider its provenance for both categories. Similarly, the similar definition of business
           experience provides a context for officers to examine, in detail, the business operations of both.
           The requirement to evaluate business experience and net worth, and the onus on the applicant to
           document each requirement ostensibly provides the means to satisfy concerns about provenance
           of funds and past business behaviour.
           Schedule 6 is submitted with the application. This captures the personal net worth statement of
           both business and personal assets and liabilities for the applicant and spouse, common law or
           conjugal partner.
           Officers should:
•      review this document to satisfy themselves as to the completeness, valuation, ownership, existence
       and presentation of the component assets and liabilities;
•      require applicants to provide documentation to support the value of assets referred to on this
       statement (bank statements, property valuations, etc.);
•      funds tied up in jointly owned businesses, real estate, stocks, antiques or jewellery may not be
       available for transfer to Canada;
9.1. Ensuring the applicant has the intent to make or has made an investment of $400,000
           The officer must ensure that a direct payment of CDN $400.000 has been made to the Receiver-
           General for Canada. Before visa issuance, the officer must receive verification from CIC in
           Ottawa.
           Applicants can make their $400,000 investment anytime after an application has been submitted;
           however, payment will not be required until immediately prior to visa issuance when all other
           immigration matters have been resolved. Visas will not be issued prior to such payment.
           The wire transfer form allowing applicants to wire their $400,000 directly to CIC in Ottawa is on
           the CIC Web site.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
           Citizenship and Immigration Canada
           Revenue Accounting
           Jean Edmonds Tower North
           4th Floor, 300 Slater Street
           Ottawa, Ontario
           Canada
           K1A 1L1
       Arrangements to finance the $400,000 investment are the applicant's responsibility.
       CIC will confirm receipt of any such arrangements directly with the lender. Again, all
       correspondence should clearly note the applicant's complete name, immigration file number, and
       the Canadian visa office where the application is being processed. This is critical to ensure the
       investment is quickly and accurately linked to the immigration application.
       If the IIP promissory note is to be pledged as collateral, applicants must arrange with the lender to
       notify CIC at the address above.
       The Subscription Agreement can be found at the CIC Web site or may be obtained at visa offices
       abroad. Two copies of this document must be signed and submitted along with the $400,000
       payment.
       The Subscription Agreement also sets out the operation and administration of the program within
       the context of the regulatory framework.
       As a legally binding contract, applicants must read it carefully and indicate acceptance by signing
       two copies and sending them to the address above.
       CIC in Ottawa will execute the Subscription Agreement and return one copy to the applicant.
       The debt obligation or promissory note, which advises investors of the provincial distribution of
       their $400,000 and redemption date will be sent to the investor or his designated lender upon
       allocation to the provincial funds.
Verification of investment
       CIC-NHQ (Permanent Resident Policy and Programs Division) will advise the visa office once
       payment has cleared, so that the case can be finalized and visas issued to investors and their
       dependants.
       There are no refunds after visa issuance.
       If an investor wishes to withdraw the application before visa issuance, they should immediately
       inform the visa office and CIC in Ottawa. If a visa has not been issued, CIC will return the
       $400,000 to the applicant within 90 days of the request. In the event an investor has made an
       investment and a visa is refused, investors will be advised and their investment will be refunded
       within 90 days of a request for refund.
       Investors will be repaid by CIC in Ottawa. The date of repayment depends on the date CIC
       receives the investment and is 30 days after the maturity date provided for on the Investor’s
       Promissory Note. At the earliest, this will be in five years, two months and at the latest, five years,
       three months from the date of receipt.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
          Based on a review of the above elements of the application, the officer will either determine that
          the applicant:
• meets the regulatory definition and proceed to examine the case according to the selection criteria.
          This section outlines the procedures an officer must follow in assessing an applicant against the
          selection criteria for investors, once the regulatory definition has been satisfied.
          The officer must assess the applicant against the selection criteria for investors by examining the
          applicant's business and financial background.
          If an officer is satisfied that the applicant meets the regulatory definition of investor, the applicant
          is assessed on a selection grid.
          The applicant will require 35 points out of a maximum of 100 available, as determined by
          the Minister.
          The following grid outlines the criteria against which to assess the applicant and the points to be
          awarded.
Investors: Selection factors and maximum points
Business experience*                                                                      Maximum
                                                                                          35
Five years business experience                                                            35
Four years business experience                                                            30
Three years business experience                                                           25
Two years business experience                                                             20
* within five years preceding date of application. Any additional experience gained
in the period prior to selection decision is to be counted.
Age                                                                                       Maximum
                                                                                          10
21 49 years of age at time of application                                                 10
Less 2 points for each year of age over 49 years or under 21 years
Education                                                                                 Maximum 25
Doctorate or Master’s Degree + 17 years full-time or full-time equivalent studies         25
3-year Trade Certificate or LLB or Medical Degree + 15 years full-time or full-           22
time equivalent studies
Bachelor’s Degree or 2-year Trade Certificate + 14 years full-time or full-time           20
equivalent studies
Bachelor’s Degree or 1-year Trade Certificate + 13 years full-time or full-time           15
equivalent studies
1 year post-secondary + 12 years full-time or full-time equivalent studies                12
Secondary school education                                                                5
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
                                                                  language
High Proficiency                               16                 8                  Maximum 24
Moderate Proficiency                           8                  8                  Maximum 16
Basic Proficiency                              2                  2                  Maximum 4
No Proficiency                                 0                  0
Adaptability                                                                          Maximum 6
Business exploration trip to Canada within 5 years of application                     6
Participation in designated joint federal-provincial business immigration initiatives 6
        Officers should begin their assessment by examining documentation submitted by the applicant to
        determine the applicant's business experience. Relevant documents include:
        Business Immigration Application Form
• financial statements
        These documents provide an accounting of the applicant's assets and liabilities and help the
        officer to determine whether the applicant has the required business experience.
11.2. Business balance sheet and business income statement (financial statements)
        For the purposes of assessing the applicant, the most important statements are the balance sheet
        and income statement.
        Officers should:
•   consider the performance of the business over time. Financial statements for the previous five years
    should be provided for comparative purposes. Previous business failures do not in themselves signify
    the refusal of an application, but should be thoroughly explained by the applicant;
•   review the income statement to verify the completeness, measurement, occurrence and presentation
    of the component revenue and expenses.
Note: When reviewing the income statement, keep in mind that it is based on transactions. Particularly
   in the case of a small enterprise, it is advisable to look at the individual components and not simply
   the net income. For example, business valuators normalize income by considering how much has
   been expended by the owner in salaries and how much would be a reasonable salary to pay an
   employee to do the same job. An owner may not charge any salary at all and as a consequence may
   show considerable net income or alternatively allocate a large amount to salary expenses and show
   very little net income or even a loss for tax purposes. It would therefore be in order to inquire as to the
   number of employees and the amount of salary expenses which can be attributed to the owner.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
        Integrity of financial statements
        Officers must carefully consider the integrity of the financial statements provided.
        In Canada, there are essentially three levels of assurance that a public accountant can provide to
        the users of financial information:
• audits;
• compilation engagements.
        The majority of small companies or companies which do not have to report to a bank or other
        creditors will just get a compilation when they get their tax returns professionally prepared.
        Most countries have a similar range of reporting engagements. In particular, if there has been a
        British influence in the past (i.e., Hong Kong), the standards will be very close to ours.
        When the veracity of the documentation is in doubt, the officer should:
•   first request further documentation. In the absence of suspicious circumstances, it will ordinarily be
    appropriate to accept financial statements which have been reported on by a reputable external
    accountant. Most small businesses are extremely unlikely to have been audited.
        Officers should review other supporting documentation as necessary. This documentation may
        include:
• minute books;
• share certificates;
• payroll lists;
• sales taxes;
• related parties;
• duration of operations.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
Note: Net income (per the financial statements) and taxable income (per the tax return) will differ as a
   consequence of the different treatment of certain items such as depreciation. However there should
   be a reconciliation to explain the difference.
Note: It would certainly be cause for concern if it appears that different information is being presented
   for the purposes of financial statements and tax reporting (two sets of books).
        Inability to produce tax records would be a cause for concern, as would a pattern of insufficient
        profit to at least provide for the cost of living of the applicant and their dependants.
        Officers may encounter cases where they suspect some degree of tax evasion. In such cases,
        the officer should be guided by the principle that it is the applicant's responsibility to discharge the
        onus of proof and that this is best done through the provision of objective documentation.
Minute books
• shareholders' register;
• shareholders' resolutions ;
• minutes of meetings ;
• articles of incorporation.
Share certificates
        Officers may wish to review municipal permits, business licences and other similar
        documentation, which should show the type of business organization.
        Most business undertakings are conducted either as proprietorships, partnerships or corporations
        (legal entities organized for specific purposes with limited liability).
        As a general rule, most small businesses start as proprietorships or partnerships and evolve into
        corporations as the level of business activity expands.
        Most businesses must be registered or licensed. The business registration certificate shows in
        whose name a business is registered. Though it may not indicate who owns or operates the
        business, it may give the business address and indicate whether the business is a sole
        proprietorship, a partnership or a corporation.
Payroll records
        With rare exceptions, payroll records are essential when determining eligibility for this class of
        applicants.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
          Sales taxes and property deeds, land registrations, appraisals, etc.
Officers may:
•     request property deeds or bank letters to verify ownership of property or stocks, amounts of
      outstanding mortgages and banking facilities used.
          Property appraisals are an extra expense to the applicant and should only be requested if the
          property value given by the applicant is questionable and this assessment is critical to total net
          worth.
          If the applicant meets the requirements of the selection criteria and the regulatory definition of
          investor, the officer will:
• proceed to verify that the CDN $400,000 investment has been received by NHQ;
• ensure that all other requirements (medical, security, etc.) are met; and
          R108 and R109 provide authority to issue or refuse a permanent resident visa in specific cases
          regardless of the points awarded. R109 applies if, in the officer's opinion, there are good reasons
          why the points awarded do not reflect the chances of the foreign national and their dependants
          becoming economically established in Canada. Substitution of evaluation (positive or negative
          discretion) may be used for economic reasons (i.e., involving the ability to support oneself).
Note: The officer must obtain the concurrence of a second officer. In 1995, the Supreme Court
   confirmed that this discretionary authority is restricted to successful establishment in the economic
   sense.
          NHQ will verify receipt of an investor’s $400,000 payment by e-mail to the applicable post. On
          visa issuance, the post must inform NHQ by return e-mail.
          This is important because the majority of investors use facilitators who provide financing and are
          eligible for a $28,000 commission that is paid at time of visa issuance. It also informs the
          participating provinces that the investment is now irrevocable.
          In cases where payment has not been made and all immigration requirements (medical, criminal,
          security, etc.) have been met by applicants and their dependants, the visa office will notify the
          principal applicant, in writing, and request payment within 30 days of notification.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
       Investors destined to Quebec are selected by Quebec Immigration officials and must obtain a
       certificat de sélection du Québec (CSQ) as per R96(b) before a federal officer may consider their
       application.
       If there are no indications of a possible refusal on statutory grounds (concerns about possible
       criminality or concerns related to security, medical questions or relationship issues), the interview
       may be waived.
       Investor applicants who cannot meet the definition must be refused as per R90(2). Most refusals
       are based on the regulatory definition. For example, the applicant may not meet the business
       experience threshold. Beyond that, the applicant may not meet the legally obtained minimum net
       worth standard (see provenance of funds Section 11 above). Finally, in rare cases, the applicant,
       while eligible, may not meet the selection criteria as per R102.
       An applicant described in any of the inadmissibility sections will be refused.
       A person who applies as an investor is assessed in that class and accepted or refused. Officers
       are not required to assess a failed investor applicant as an entrepreneur or self-employed or in
       any other class.
       Where information is later presented that should have been disclosed at the interview and might
       have at that time led to a positive decision, the officer should invite the applicant (in the absence
       of special circumstances) to submit a new application and pay a new cost recovery fee.
       The refusal letter must clearly state all the reasons for refusal in detail. (For sample refusal letters,
       see appendixes.)
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
       investment in the sum of $(enter the appropriate investment amount based on the province)
       as described in subsection 2(1) of the Immigration Regulations since the date of the investor's
       application for an immigrant visa as an investor and c) has a net worth, accumulated by the
       immigrant's own endeavours, of at least $500,000.
       You do not meet the definition of investor because (insert reasons why applicant does not
       meet any or all of the above criteria (a), (b) or (c))
       Subsection 9(4) of the Immigration Act provides that where a visa officer is satisfied that it would
       not be contrary to the Act or Regulations to grant landing or entry to an applicant, that officer may
       issue a visa if, in his or her opinion, that applicant meets the requirements of the Act and the
       Regulations. You do not meet the requirements of the Act and Regulations for the reasons
       explained above. I am therefore refusing your application.
       If the applicant has paid the ROLF, add:
       The Right of Landing Fee that you have paid is refundable. (Add as appropriate) You will
       receive a cheque from the (choose as appropriate) Embassy/High Commission/Consulate
       within a few weeks. (or) Please contact the Canadian (choose as appropriate) Embassy/High
       Commission/ Consulate in _______________ for information concerning the method of
       reimbursement and the date at which you can obtain the refund.
       Thank you for the interest you have shown in Canada.
Yours sincerely,
Officer
       Our Ref.:
       INSERT ADDRESS
       Dear:
       I have now completed the assessment of your application and I have determined that you do not
       qualify for immigration to Canada as an investor.
       If application was received between 1 January 2002 and 28 June 2002, OR was received before
       01 January 2002 but no selection decision was made before 31 March 2003, please add:
       Your application was received on (DATE). Pursuant to subsection 361(3) of the Immigration and
       Refugee Protection Regulations, it was therefore assessed under the provisions of the
       Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and Regulations.
       Subsection 12(2) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act states that a foreign national
       may be selected as a member of the economic class on the basis of their ability to become
       economically established in Canada.
       Subsection 90(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations, 2002, states that for the
       purposes of subsection 12(2) of the Act, the investor class is prescribed as a class of persons
       who may become permanent residents on the basis of their ability to become economically
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
       established in Canada and who are investors within the meaning of subsection 88(1). Subsection
       90(2) states that if a foreign national who makes an application as a member of the investor class
       is not an investor within the meaning of subsection 88(1), the application shall be refused and no
       further assessment is required.
       If the applicant does not meet the definition of an investor, add:
       Subsection 88(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations, 2002, defines an
       investor as a foreign national who (a) has business experience; (b) has a legally obtained
       minimum net worth of at least $800,000; and (c) indicates in writing to an officer that they intend
       to make or have made an investment.
       If applicant lacks business experience, add the following three paragraphs:
       Subsection 88(1) of the Regulations states that “business experience”, in respect of an investor,
       means
       the management of a qualifying business and the control of a percentage of equity in the
       qualifying business for at least two years in the period beginning five years before the date of
       application for a permanent resident visa and ending on the day a determination in made in
       respect of the application, or
       the management of at least five full-time job equivalents per year in a business for at least two
       years in the period beginning five years before the date of application for a permanent resident
       visa and ending on the day a determination in made in respect of the application.
       Subsection 88(1) defines “qualifying business” as a business – other than a business operated
       primarily for the purpose of deriving investment income such as interest, dividends or capital
       gains – for which, in each of any two years in the period beginning five years before the date of
       application for a permanent resident visa and ending on the day a determination in made in
       respect of the application, there is documentary evidence of any two of the following:
       that the percentage of equity multiplied by the number of full-time job equivalents is equal to or
       greater than two full-time job equivalents per year;
       that the percentage of equity multiplied by the total annual sales is equal to or greater than
       $500,000;
       that the percentage of equity multiplied by the net income in the year is equal to or greater than
       $50,000; and
       that the percentage of equity multiplied by the net assets at the end of the year is equal to or
       greater than $125,000.
       “Percentage of equity” is defined in subsection 88(1) as
       in respect of a sole proprietorship, 100 per cent of the equity of the sole proprietorship;
       in respect of a corporation, the percentage of the issued and outstanding voting shares of the
       capital stock of the corporation controlled by the foreign national or their spouse or common-law
       partner; and
       in respect of a partnership or joint venture, the percentage of the profit or loss of the partnership
       or joint venture to which the foreign national or their spouse or common-law partner is entitled.
       If applicant does not have sufficient net worth, add:
       Subsection 88(1) of the Regulations defines “net worth” as, in respect of the foreign national and
       their spouse or common-law partner, the fair market value of all their assets minus the fair market
       value of all their liabilities.
       If the applicant has not made an investment, add:
       Subsection 88(1) of the Regulations defines an investment as a sum of $400,000 that is paid by
       the investor to the agent for allocation to all approved funds in existence as of the date the
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
        allocation period begins and that is not refundable during the period beginning on the day a
        permanent resident visa is issued to the investor and ending at the end of the allocation period.
        (Choose one or more:)
        You have not satisfied me that you have business experience because (add reasons). AND/OR
        You have not satisfied me that you have a legally obtained minimum net worth of at least
        $800,000 because (add reasons). AND/OR You have not indicated in writing that you intend to
        make or have made an investment because (add reasons). As a result, you do not meet the
        requirements of subsection 90(1).
        Subsection 11(1) of the Act states that a foreign national must, before entering Canada, apply to
        an officer for a visa or for any other document required by the Regulations. The visa or document
        shall be issued if, following an examination, the officer is satisfied that the foreign national is not
        inadmissible and meets the requirements of this Act. Subsection 2(2) specifies that unless
        otherwise indicated, references in the Act to “this Act” include regulations made under it.
        Following an examination of your application, I am not satisfied that you meet the requirements of
        the Act and the Regulations for the reasons explained above. I am therefore refusing your
        application.
        If the applicant meets the definition but does not obtain sufficient points, add:
        I am satisfied that you meet the definition of an investor. Subsection 102(1) of the Regulations
        sets out the factors to be considered in determining whether a foreign national, as a member of
        the investor class, will be able to become economically established in Canada. The factors for
        applicants in the investor class are age, education, proficiency in the official languages of
        Canada, experience, and adaptability. The assessment of your application follows:
Factors                                                   Points assessed         Maximum points
                                                                                  possible
Age                                                                               10
Education                                                                         25
Proficiency in official languages                                                 24
Experience                                                                        35
Adaptability                                                                      6
Total                                                                             100
        Although you meet the definition of an investor, you have obtained insufficient points to qualify for
        immigration to Canada because (add reasons that applicant has insufficient points). The
        minimum number of points required is 35 units. As a result, I am not satisfied that you have the
        ability to become economically established in Canada.
        Subsection 11(1) of the Act states that a foreign national must, before entering Canada, apply to
        an officer for a visa or for any other document required by the Regulations. The visa or document
        shall be issued if, following an examination, the officer is satisfied that the foreign national is not
        inadmissible and meets the requirements of this Act. Subsection 2(2) specifies that unless
        otherwise indicated, references in the Act to “this Act” include Regulations made under it.
        Following an examination of your application, I am not satisfied that you meet the requirements of
        the Act and the Regulations for the reasons explained above. I am therefore refusing your
        application.
        If the applicant has paid the ROLF, add:
        The Right of Landing Fee that you have paid is refundable. (Add as appropriate) You will
        receive a cheque from the (choose as appropriate) Embassy/High Commission/Consulate
        within a few weeks. (or) Please contact the Canadian (choose as appropriate) Embassy/High
        Commission/ Consulate in _______________ for information concerning the method of
        reimbursement and the date at which you can obtain the refund.
        Thank you for the interest you have shown in Canada.
2008-08-08
OP 9 Investors
Yours sincerely,
Officer
2008-08-08