Assessment of Sleep and Circadian Rhythm Disorders in The Very Old: The Newcastle 85+ Cohort Study
Assessment of Sleep and Circadian Rhythm Disorders in The Very Old: The Newcastle 85+ Cohort Study
27. Charlson ME, Pompei P, Ales KL et al.. A new method of clas-         30. Manderbacka K. Examining what self-rated health question is
                sifying prognostic comorbidity in longitudinal studies: devel-           understood to mean by respondents. Scand J Soc Med 1998;
                opment and validation. J Chronic Dis 1987; 40: 373–83.                   26: 145–53.
            28. Wolinsky FD, Callahan CM, Fitzgerald JF et al.. Changes in           31. Walker JD, Maxwell CJ, Hogan DB et al.. Does self-rated
                functional status and the risks of subsequent nursing home               health predict survival in older persons with cognitive impair-
                placement and death. J Gerontol 1993; 48: S94–101.                       ment? J Am Geriatr Soc 2004; 52: 1895–900.
            29. Idler EL, Kasl S. Health perceptions and survival: do global
                evaluations of health status really predict mortality? Journal of    Received 29 November 2012; accepted in revised form
                Gerontology 1991; 46: S55–65.                                        22 May 2013
            Age and Ageing 2014; 43: 57–63              © The Author 2013. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the British Geriatrics Society.
            doi: 10.1093/ageing/aft153                                   All rights reserved. For Permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oup.com
Abstract
            Objectives: to examine the association between subjective and objective measures of sleep and wake and other health para-
            meters in a cohort of the very old.
            Design: a population-based cohort study.
            Setting: primary care, North East England.
            Participants: four hundred and twenty-one men and women, aged 87–89, recruited to the Newcastle 85+ Study cohort.
            Methods: sleep questionnaires were administered and sleep–wake patterns were assessed over 5–7 days with a novel wrist tri-
            axial accelerometer. Associations between sleep measures and various health parameters, including mortality at 24 months,
            were examined.
            Results: only 16% of participants perceived their sleep as severely disturbed as assessed with questionnaire responses. Wrist accel-
            erometry showed marked variation between normal and abnormal sleep–wake cycles that did not correlate with the participants’
            perception of sleep. Impaired sleep–wake cycles were significantly associated with cognitive impairment, disability, depression,
            increased falls, body mass index and arthritis but not with any other specific disease markers and with decreased survival.
            Conclusions: commonly used sleep questionnaires do not differentiate well between those with objectively determined disturbance
            of sleep–wake cycles and those with normal cycles. Abnormal sleep–wake patterns are associated with institutionalisation, cognitive
            impairment, disability, depression and arthritis but not with other diseases; there is also an association with reduced survival.
Keywords: accelerometry, sleep, 85+, circadian rhythm, novel accelerometer, impaired sleep and mortality, lder people
            Introduction                                                             have at least one chronic sleep-related problem with high rates
                                                                                     of sleep apnoea, insomnia and restless legs [1, 2]. Changes in
            Sleep complaints and disruptions in the sleep–wake cycle are             circadian rhythms can be demonstrated with advancing age,
            common in older people. Over 50% of adults aged over 65                  with a decline in the cortisol and melatonin rhythms that
                                                                                                                                                        57
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ageing/article-abstract/43/1/57/24018
by guest
on 19 November 2017
                K. N. Anderson et al.
                entrain day–night activity patterns [3, 4]. With ageing there is        within their normal home environment. The GENEA records
                reduced amplitude of the circadian rhythm, a phase shift (in            continuous acceleration rather than epoch-based summary
                particular phase advance) [5] and a loss of the robustness of           measures more typical of studies employing commercial acti-
                the rhythm. However, within older populations there is signifi-          watches (actigraphy) and has been validated for monitoring ac-
                cant variability between individuals with some hypothesising            tivity levels [13]. Only participants who had worn the watch
                an age-related disruption to the suprachiasmatic nucleus [6].           continuously for 5 days or more within the 7-day period were
                    Poor sleep in older adults is associated with an increase in        included in the analysis. In those with seven full days of moni-
                mortality, accidents and falls and a decline in health status           toring, 5 and 7 day measures were compared and no significant
                [2]. There is a particular association between disrupted circa-         differences were found.
                dian rhythms and dementia [7]. For the very old, variously                  The following accelerometry measures were obtained: the
                defined as those aged 80+ or 85+, sleep and circadian                    least active 5 h period (L5); the most active 5 h period (M5);
                rhythm data are limited yet these are now the fastest growing           the mean rest-active transition count in the least active 5 h
                age sector of the population [8].                                       (L5_TN) and the difference between M5 and L5 (ΔM5L5).
                    We have assessed the sleep and wake patterns of a large,            L5 and M5 activity counts were averaged for the entire 5-day
                well characterised UK cohort of people aged 87–89 years, in-            period.
                cluding in institutional care, and report the extent of sleep               Participants were divided into quartiles for each accelero-
                disorders, the contribution of different diseases and condi-            metry measure and then the middle two quartiles were
                tions to disrupted sleep and whether very old individuals               grouped together to represent low, medium and high activity
                with sleep disorders have a higher risk of mortality.                   counts for all the subsequent analyses. We investigated three
                                                                                        objective measures of sleep disturbance, defining abnormal
                                                                                        sleep patterns as those in the lowest quartile of ΔM5L5and
                Methods                                                                 the highest quartiles of L5 and L5_TN.
                Participants
                The study was nested in the Newcastle 85+ Study, a                      Morbidity and mortality measures
                population-based longitudinal study of health and ageing in the         Measures assessed for association with sleep disorders were
                very old [9]. People living in Newcastle or North Tyneside (NE          those indicated in younger populations: disability (difficulties
                England) were recruited at around age 85 through general                in 17 daily activities coded as 0 difficulties/1-6/7-12/13-17),
                practitioner patient lists; those living in institutions and the cog-   depressive symptomatology using the Geriatric Depression
                nitively impaired were included. Following baseline assessment          Scale (ref) and coded as none/mild/severe, cognition assessed
                (Phase 1: 2006–7, n = 849) Newcastle 85+ Study participants             by the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE), number of
                were re-assessed at 18 months (Phase 2: 2007–9, n = 630) and            falls in last year (none/1/2/3+) and body mass index (BMI),
                again at 36 months (Phase 3: 2009–10, n = 484). Loss between            (assessed at 36 months). Data on pre-existing diseases were
                phases 1 and 3 was mainly due to deaths (63.6%, 232/365)                extracted from the general practice medical records and
                with the remainder due to drop out. Participants were invited           included presence at baseline, of ischaemic heart disease, arth-
                to take part in this sleep study as part of the 36-month follow-        ritis, cerebrovascular disease, cancer (excluding non-melanoma
                up assessment when participants were aged 87–89 years. All              skin cancer) in last 5 years, chronic obstructive airways disease,
                assessments were conducted in the participant’s usual resi-             as well as a total chronic disease count (18 diseases and condi-
                dence (home or institution). Ethical approval was obtained              tions coded as none/1–2/3–6/7+) [9]. The National Health
                from Newcastle and North Tyneside Local Research Ethics                 Service Medical Research Information Service provided the
                Committee. Written informed consent was obtained from par-              date of death. Survival time was measured from date of
                ticipants and where people lacked the capacity to consent, a            actigraphy to death or censored at 1/8/2011 (mean follow-up
                formal written opinion was sought from a relative/carer in ac-          24 months).
                cordance with the UK Mental Capacity Act [10].
                                                                                        Statistical analysis
                Sleep questionnaires                                                    Associations between measures of disturbed sleep and socio-
                A research nurse administered the Pittsburgh Sleep                      demographic and health characteristics of participants were
                Questionnaire Inventory (PSQI) [11] and the Epworth                     assessed by Mann–Whitney U tests (ESS, PSQI) or Kruskal–
                Sleepiness Score (ESS) [12] as subjective measures of sleep             Wallis tests (accelerometry measures in three categories) for
                and wake. These well-validated questionnaires assess sleep–             ordinal data (disability score, disease count, depression, BMI,
                wake disturbance and daytime sleepiness, respectively.                  self-rated health, MMSE, number of falls) and Chi-square
                                                                                        tests for categorical variables (sex, where living, presence of
                                                                                        individual diseases). The associations between accelerometry
                Accelerometry measures                                                  measures of disturbed sleep and subjective measures (ESS
                Participants wore a triaxial accelerometer (GENEA, Unilever)            and PSQI scores) were assessed by Kruskal–Wallis tests. The
                on their right wrist continuously for a period of 5–7 days              impact of objective and subjective sleep measures on
                58
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ageing/article-abstract/43/1/57/24018
by guest
on 19 November 2017
                                                                                 Assessment of sleep and circadian rhythm disorders
            subsequent survival was investigated by Cox proportional                Association between accelerometry measures of
            hazards regression models with adjustment initially for sex,            disturbed sleep and subjective sleep measures
            then added disease count, disability, cognitive function and            Of the objective measures of abnormal sleep patterns only
            BMI. P-values were two-sided; the level of significance was              ΔM5L5 was associated with significantly higher ESS scores
            0.05. Missing values were excluded from the data set and per-           (Mann–Whitney U test, P < 0.007), most participants report-
            centages were calculated from the number of valid                       ing daytime sleepiness having little difference in levels of activ-
            responses.                                                              ity between the most and least active 5 h (low ΔM5L5)
                                                                                    (Supplementary data are available in Age and Ageing online,
                                                                                    Table S4). In addition participants reporting daytime sleepiness
            Results                                                                 were significantly more likely to have low activity levels in the
            Sleep questionnaires                                                    most active 5 h (low M5) (Mann–Whitney U test, P = 0.012).
                                                                                    The global PSQI score was not significantly associated
            Four hundred and twenty-seven/484 participants completed                with any of the accelerometry measures of disturbed sleep
            both PSQI and ESS questionnaires without any missing data;              (Supplementary data are available in Age and Ageing online,
            63.5% were women (156 men: 271 women), the majority                     Table S4), although those with poorer sleep quality (PSQI
            (80.3%) lived independently at home, 41% rated their health             component 1) were significantly more likely to have higher
            as excellent or very good, 7.3% had no difficulty with activities        activity levels in the least active 5 h (high L5 activity) (Kruskal–
            of daily living and 69.9% had no cognitive impairment                   Wallis test, P = 0.014) (data not shown).
            (MMSE score 26–30). Some disturbance of sleep (PSQI >5)
            was reported by 50.1% although only 15.7% had severe sleep
            disturbance (PSQI >10). Daytime sleepiness (ESS >10) was                Association between accelerometry measures of
            reported by only 10.8% (Supplementary data are available in             disturbed sleep and other health parameters
            Age and Ageing online, Table S1).                                       Participants with abnormal sleep–wake cycles defined by little
                Those reporting disturbed sleep (PSQI >5) were more                 difference in activity between the most and least active periods
            likely to be female, to report poorer self-rated health, to have        (ΔM5L5) were significantly more likely to have poorer cogni-
            depressive symptomatology, were less likely to have cerebro-            tive function, depressive symptomatology, more falls, be obese,
            vascular disease but had a similar prevalence of other diseases,        arthritis, higher disease count and more disability (Table 1).
            disability, cognitive impairment and obesity as participants not        Neither of the two other objective measures of sleep abnor-
            experiencing disturbed sleep (Supplementary data are available          mality (L5 and L5_TN) appeared to be significantly associated
            in Age and Ageing online, Table S2). Participants who had sig-          with sociodemographic characteristics, disease burden or
            nificant daytime sleepiness (ESS >10) were more likely to have           functioning.
            higher levels of disability and depressive symptomatology than
            those without daytime sleepiness (Supplementary data are
            available in Age and Ageing online, Table S3).                          Subjective and objective measures of sleep and
                                                                                    mortality
            Accelerometry                                                           Only abnormal sleep–wake cycles, defined by ΔM5L5, was
                                                                                    significantly associated with reduced survival after adjust-
            Of the 427 participants with complete sleep scores, 337 (79%)           ment for sex (P = 0.002). After further adjustment for dis-
            wore the accelerometer for at least five continuous days. When           ability, cognitive function, disease count and BMI ΔM5L5
            compared with those with accelerometry data (n = 337, 130               remained significantly associated with subsequent 2-year
            M: 207 F), those without accelerometry (n = 90) were more               mortality (P = 0.018) (Figure 2), participants with abnormal
            likely to live in an institution (χ2, P < 0.001), more disabled         sleep-wake cycles (low ΔM5L5) having over 3 times the risk
            (Mann–Whitney U, P = 0.003), had worse cognitive function               of death (hazard ratio: 3.18, 95% CI: 1.25–8.09) compared
            (Mann–Whitney U, P < 0.001) and reported more falls                     with participants having high differentiation between active
            (Mann–Whitney U, P = 0.04) although PSQI and ESS scores                 and inactive periods (high ΔM5L5). Neither of the two other
            were similar (data not shown).                                          objective measures or the subjective measures were signifi-
                Accelerometry provided a clear representation of daily              cantly associated with survival (L5: P = 0.91; L5_TN
            activity and a robust assessment of sleep–wake cycles with              P = 0.23; PSQI: P = 0.77; ESS P = 0.18).
            decreased activity during the night and increased activity
            during the day. There was marked variation between parti-
            cipants, with some individuals being much more active                   Discussion
            during the day and demonstrating much greater differences
            between day and night time activity patterns. Data from                 This population-based study is the first to subjectively and
            two participants are shown in Figure 1. Although the total              objectively assess the sleep and circadian rhythms of a UK
            amount of physical activity varies between the two indivi-              cohort of very old people (87–89 years) and report the rela-
            duals, it is possible to distinguish a sleep-wake pattern               tionship with morbidity, functioning and mortality.
            in both.                                                                Significantly disturbed sleep (PSQI >10) was reported by
                                                                                                                                                    59
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ageing/article-abstract/43/1/57/24018
by guest
on 19 November 2017
                K. N. Anderson et al.
                Figure 1. Accelerometry Data. Accelerometry data over a 7-day period of continuous recording with two different participants.
                Both participants have cycles of decreased activity corresponding to a sleep period (marked with arrow) and increased activity during
                wake. However, the total amount of activity varies between the two participants.
                only 16% of the very old and significant daytime sleepiness           and with both polysomnography and accelerometry [14–16].
                by only 10.8%. Depressive symptomatology was higher in               In these studies, the PSQI was better than the ESS at distin-
                those with disturbed sleep and those with daytime sleepiness         guishing those with normal sleep from those with sleep dis-
                but no other disease or cognitive impairment was significant-         orders. Raised PSQI score was associated with female sex
                ly associated with the presence of reported sleep disorders.         and depressive symptoms, and this was confirmed by our
                    In contrast, very old people with disturbed sleep–wake           study. Other studies have demonstrated that the PSQI and
                cycles, objectively assessed using accelerometry, were more          ESS correlate poorly with objective measures of sleep assess-
                likely were had significantly worse cognitive function, higher        ment in older populations [17]. There was only a weak associ-
                BMI, more falls, more depressive symptoms, and were more             ation between proven sleep apnoea and elevated ESS in the
                likely to have arthritis and a higher number of diseases in total.   large MrOS cohort study (mean age of 75.6) and no associ-
                We found no evidence of association between the objective            ation with PSQI [18, 19]. In the MrOS study 13% of men
                and subjective measures of sleep disturbance with the excep-         had ESS >10 which matches the low reporting of significant
                tion of the difference in activity levels between the most and       sleep disturbance in our cohort (16% PSQI >10 and 11%
                least active periods (ΔM5L5) and the ESS. However, partici-          ESS >10). There are a number of possible explanations for
                pants with little difference in activity between the most and        low reporting of subjective sleep disturbance: this population
                least active periods (ΔM5L5) had significantly worse survival         may have different expectations of sleep and wake; cognitive
                even after adjustment for potential confounding factors.             impairment may have affected the accurate completion of
                    Previous studies have suggested that the ESS and PSQI            the questionnaires and the large number of participants who
                reliably detect sleep disturbance in adults over 60 both alone       lived and slept alone may have affected accurate reporting for
                60
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ageing/article-abstract/43/1/57/24018
by guest
on 19 November 2017
                                                                                 Assessment of sleep and circadian rhythm disorders
            some responses. Our results suggest that these widely used               studies across community-based populations described the in-
            screening tools do not accurately identify disrupted sleep and           creasingly fragmented sleep that occurred during ageing, with
            wake measured more objectively in the very old, although                 a tendency for older subjects to have an advanced sleep phase
            our findings of associations between sleep disturbance and                compared with younger subjects in several large population
            both female gender and depressive symptoms confirm these                  studies [3, 5]. Limitations of previous studies include the vari-
            across a broader age range.                                              ability and lack of standardisation of analysis methods, al-
               Accelerometry or actigraphy has been used to assess sleep             though many use non-parametric circadian rhythm analysis.
            and wake patterns for many years and is well established in              This is the first study to use continuous wave accelerometry in
            both clinical practice and research (for review 20). Early               a very old population; this technique allows for analysis of raw
                                                                                                                                                  61
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ageing/article-abstract/43/1/57/24018
by guest
on 19 November 2017
                K. N. Anderson et al.
                62
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ageing/article-abstract/43/1/57/24018
by guest
on 19 November 2017
                                                                                 Assessment of sleep and circadian rhythm disorders
            Supplementary data                                                      13. Esliger DW, Rowlands AV, Hurst TL, Catt M, Murray P, Eston
                                                                                        RG. Validation of the GENEA Accelerometer. Med Sci Sports
            Supplementary data mentioned in the text is available to sub-               Exerc 2011; 43: 1085–93.
            scribers in Age and Ageing online.                                      14. Buysse DJ, Cheng Y, Germain A et al. Night-to-night sleep
                                                                                        variability in older adults with and without chronic insomnia.
                                                                                        Sleep Med 2010; 11: 56–64.
                                                                                    15. Spira AP, Beaudreau SA, Stone KL et al. Reliability and validity
            References                                                                  of the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index and the Epworth
                                                                                        Sleepiness Scale in older men. Osteoporotic fractures in Men
             1. Foley DJ, Monjan AA, Brown SL, Simonsick EM, Wallace RB,                study. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 2012; 67: 433–9.
                Blazer DG. Sleep complaints among elderly persons: an epide-        16. Beaudreau SA, Spira AP, Stewart A et al. Validation of the
                miologic study of three communities. Sleep 1995; 18: 425–32.            Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index and the Epworth Sleepiness
             2. Ancoli-Israel S. Sleep and its disorders in ageing populations.         Scale in older black and white women. Study of Osteoporotic
                Sleep Med 2009; 10(Suppl. 1): 7–11.                                     Fractures. Sleep Med 2012; 13: 36–42.
             3. Lieberman HR, Wurtman JJ, Teicher MH. Circadian rhythms             17. Buysse DJ, Hall ML, Strollo PJ et al. Relationships between the
                of activity in healthy young and elderly humans. Neurobiol              Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), Epworth Sleepiness
                Aging 1989; 10: 259–65.                                                 Scale (ESS), and clinical/polysomnographic measures in a
             4. Mazzoccoli G, Vendemiale G, La Viola M et al. Circadian varia-          community sample. J Clin Sleep Med 2008; 4: 563–71.
                tions of cortisol, melatonin and lymphocyte subpopulations in       18. Kezirian EJ, Harrison SL, Ancoli-Israel S et al. Behavioral cor-
                geriatric age. Int J Immunopathol Pharmacol 2010; 23: 289–96.           relates of sleep-disordered breathing in older men. Study of
             5. Monk TH, Buysse DJ, Billy BD et al. Circadian type and bed-             Osteoporotic in Men Research Group. Sleep 2009; 32: 253–61.
                timing regularity in 654 retired seniors: correlations with sub-    19. Kezirian EJ, Harrison SL, Ancoli-Israel S et al. Behavioral cor-
                jective sleep measures. Sleep 2011; 34: 235–9.                          relates of sleep-disordered breathing in older women. Study of
             6. Hu K, Van Someren EJ, Shea SA, Scheer FA. Reduction of                  Osteoporotic Fractures Research Group. Sleep 2007; 30:
                scale invariance of activity fluctuations with aging and alzhei-         1181–8.
                mer’s disease: involvement of the circadian pacemaker. Proc         20. Ancoli-Israel S, Cole R, Alessi C, Chambers M, Moorcroft W,
                Natl Acad Sci USA 2009; 106: 2490–4.                                    Pollak CP. The role of actigraphy in the study of sleep and cir-
             7. Hatfield CF, Herbert J, van Someren EJ, Hodges JR, Hastings              cadian rhythms. Sleep 2003; 26: 342–92.
                MH. Disrupted daily activity/rest cycles in relation to daily       21. Blackwell T, Yaffe K, Ancoli-Israel S, Redline S et al.
                cortisol rhythms of home-dwelling patients with early                   Association of sleep characteristics and cognition in older
                Alzheimer’s dementia. Brain 2004; 127: 1061–74.                         community-dwelling men: the MrOS sleep study. Osteoporotic
             8. United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs.               Fractures in Men (MrOS) Study Group. Sleep 2011; 34:
                Population Division. World Population Ageing: 2009: United              1347–56.
                Nations, 2009.                                                      22. Paudel ML, Taylor BC, Ancoli-Israel S et al. Rest/activity
             9. Collerton J, Barrass K, Bond J et al. The Newcastle 85+ study:          rhythms and mortality rates in older men: MrOS Sleep Study.
                biological, clinical and psychosocial factors associated with           Osteoporotic Fractures in Men (MrOS) Study. Chronobiol Int
                healthy ageing: study protocol. BMC Geriatr 2007; 7: 14.                2010; 27: 363–77.
            10. Parliament: Mental Capacity Act. Stationery office. 2005.            23. Ensrud KE, Blackwell TL, Ancoli-Israel S et al. Sleep distur-
            11. Buysse DJ, Reynolds CF 3rd, Monk TH, Berman SR, Kupfer                  bances and risk of frailty and mortality in older men. Sleep
                DJ. The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index: a new instrument for            Med 2012; 13: 1217–25.
                psychiatric practice and research. Psychiatry Res 1989; 28:
                193–213.
            12. Johns MW. Sleepiness in different situations measured by the        Received 29 November 2012; accepted in revised form
                Epworth sleepiness scale. Sleep 1994; 17: 703–10.                   22 May 2013
                                                                                                                                                    63
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ageing/article-abstract/43/1/57/24018
by guest
on 19 November 2017