When asked which campaigns they most disliked, consumers convicted
Mr. Whipple. . . . Charmin may have not been popular advertising,
but it was number one in sales.2
And there is the crux of the problem. The mystery. How did
Whipple’s commercials sell so much toilet paper?
These shrill little interruptions that irritated nearly everyone, that
were used as fodder for Johnny Carson on late-night TV, sold toilet
paper by the ton. How? Even if you figure that part out, the question
then becomes, why? Why would you irritate your buying public
with a twittering, pursed-lipped grocer when cold, hard research
told you everybody hated him? I don’t get it.
Apparently, even the agency that created him didn’t get it. John
Lyons, author of Guts: Advertising from the Inside Out, worked at
Charmin’s agency when they were trying to figure out what to do
with Whipple.