80s Vogue patterns are made for people with matchstick wrists. I know this. And yet I always forget to adjust the wrists when making old patterns. This time I’d got as far as sewing all the buttons on my shirt before trying it on…and promptly had to cut off the sleeve ones and sew them on again at the very edge of the cuff in order to be able to move my arms. Luckily I was able to get enough extra wrist circumference to make it wearable, because this was a project and a half. So here it is.
The pattern is the shirt from vintage Vogue 2853 by Claude Montana, from 1982. It looked fairly simple on the illustration but the the pattern description says “Loose-fitting, pullover top has standing shaped collar, wide shaped button band, side hemline splits and full length, two piece raglan sleeves pleated into buttoned cuffs. Narrow hem, top-stitching and edge-stitching” which should have warned me that this pattern is a lot. They haven’t even mentioned the inset corners in the raglan seams. It took me over a month to sew.
There is some interesting construction on this one and some of it makes sense and some of it not so much. The bands, collar, and cuffs were attached backwards from the way I’m used to, but this is one of the things that turns out to make sense. With pieces whose function is to finish edges, such as collars, bands or cuffs, I’m used to sewing what’s going to be the outside layer of the band to the right side of the garment, then catching the edge of the inside layer of the band down by either top stitching or stitching in the ditch on the outside. This pattern reverses that so that the inside layer is sewn to the wrong side of the shirt first and the outside layer is top stitched down. And in fact this turned out to be a very good thing when sewing the front bands. There are square inset corners under that fancy curved and pointed end, and they frayed appallingly when I clipped them. Sewing down the outside edge last let me fudge things enough to cover up the mess. The corners aren’t beautiful on the inside but I don’t think they’re going to disintegrate now.
Despite the extra help from the construction method I think the moral is that if your fabric allows it, add interfacing to the shirt body around that opening on this one. Or choose a tightly woven fabric to start with. Alas my fabric, a translucent and wriggly ivory cupro, failed on both counts.
The curved and pointy end of the front band is not stitched down to the shirt body, which surprised me. I don’t know for sure why you’d want a tab flapping about loose there, but flap it does. The main purpose I have found for it is that a sharp yank on the tab helps the whole garment sit properly when putting it on, but I doubt that’s the real function. It was a pain to sew. The pattern instructions leave top stitching round the tab edge to the very end of the band sewing process, so you’re left trying to stitch along the edge of the tab right up to that very weak inset corner, while folding the shirt front out of the way in order to avoid catching the shirt body, No wonder my tab has little dimples at the junction with the shirt body, I’m amazed it’s come out as well as it has. I’m sure it makes more sense to top stitch the closed edges of the front band before attaching it to the shirt, but as I doubt I will be making this again I won’t be experimenting with the method.
The pattern envelope shows it worn buttoned up, but I find it more comfortable worn open and I also think it looks better like that. Luckily the messy bits don’t show.
The rest of it was fairly straightforward but complicated by the unstable fabric. Here’s the back view, not that there’s much to see on this one.
I wish I’d made the sleeves longer. I normally lengthen sleeves but the last Montana shirt I made ended up with comically long sleeves, so I carefully measured these in advance and decided they’d be long enough as is…which they are not. I think I lengthened the body 5cm, which is normal for me. There is plenty of length to tuck in, which is good because the hem isn’t great; the wriggly cupro shifted while I was sewing it (yes I should have basted) so it’s a bit ripply.
I’m wearing it here with the trousers from vintage Vogue 1492, which are remarkably similar in style to the trouser pattern that comes with the shirt pattern: the pleats, the welt pockets, the turnups, and the overall shape.
Funnily enough despite all the fitting issues I enjoy wearing this shirt, but I think the fabric is doing a lot of the work; it’s very soft with a lovely drape and a slight lustre. It’s an ivory cupro twill from Croft Mill, which appears to be sold out now. Uncharacteristically I bought 4m so I have enough of it left for another shirt. I was originally thinking I’d also make the shirt from the Vogue 1476 Issey Miyake pattern but now I’m not so sure.
Thanks to my husband for taking the photos.