Election Integrity Filmmaker Sees Own Vote Flipped on ESS Touch-Screens in TN

David and Patricia Earnhardt Report Their Problems During Early Voting in Nashville

Obama Vote Won't Register, Then Flips to Other Candidate, as Similarly Reported Recently in WV...

Share article:

Now comes the vote-flipping on touch-screen machines in Davidson County (Nashville), TN, where early voting has also begun. This time, the problems occurred for David and Patricia Earnhardt, the director and executive producer of the award-winning election integrity documentary, Uncounted: The New Math of American Elections which details the history of problems with electronic voting across the nation and some of the whistleblowers and EI advocates who’ve helped to bring the matter to light. [Disclosure: The BRAD BLOG is prominently featured in the film.]

The Earnhardts’ story of what happened to them last Friday when, among other things, Patricia’s attempt to vote for Obama on the ES&S touch-screen wouldn’t register at all, and at one point, with a poll-worker trying to help, had actually registered a vote for Green Party candidate Cynthia McKinney — five rows away from Obama on the screen — follows below.

The first reports of vote-flipping on touch-screen machines (we expect many more, as we saw in both ’04 and especially in ’06) came in from two counties last week in West Virginia, which also uses ES&S touch screens across the entire state.

The machines in both TN and WV need to be taken out of use and impounded immediately. So far, it’s been Democrats, again, who are being affected by these problems, while votes are flipping from Democratic candidates to others. While the DNC and the Obama campaign ought to be raising holy hell, so far they are not…

Here’s the email sent by David Earnhardt yesterday…

My wife, Patricia Earnhardt, had an early voting experience here in Nashville, Tennessee, where she saw her vote momentarily flip from Barack Obama to Green Party candidate Cynthia McKinney. She voted on a touch-screen paperless machine. Here is her story:

“A poll worker directed me to a touch screen voting machine & instructed me how to use it. I touched “Obama” for president & nothing lit up. I touched 2 or 3 more times & still nothing lit up. I called the poll worker back over to tell him I was having a problem. He said I just needed to touch it more lightly. I tried it 2 or 3 more times more lightly with the poll worker watching & still nothing lit up. The poll worker then touched it for me twice — nothing lit up.

The third time he touched the Obama button, the Cynthia McKinney space lit up! The McKinney button was located five rows below the Obama button. The poll worker just kind of laughed and cancelled the vote. He hit the Obama button again & it finally lit up. I continued on to cast the rest of my votes.

After completing the process & reviewing my votes, I went to the VOTE page, hit the VOTE button & nothing happened. Again after several tries, I called the poll worker over & he finally got the machine to register my votes.” Patricia Earnhardt – Friday, Oct. 17 – Howard School Building – Nashville, Tennessee

I also had similar problems with the machine I was voting on that same day, although no vote flipping. I would touch the screen numerous times before I could get my various candidate choices to light up. It was strange and very frustrating. When I finally got through my slate of candidate choices, I could not get the VOTE button to light up when I touched it. I finally called over a poll worker and he told me that I needed to touch lightly. I touched the VOTE button more lightly, but was only able to get it to work after several more failed attempts.

The same ES&S iVotronic touch-screens now failing in WV and TN were responsible for losing some 18,000 votes in a very close FL Congressional race in Democratic-leaning Sarasota County in 2006, where the race went to the Republican by just 369 votes. Ironically, the race in FL’s 13th Congressional district was for former FL-SoS Katherine Harris’ old House seat. Though the race was challenged in Congress, under the Federal Contested Elections Act, the House Democrats eventually dismissed the case, even though an explanation for the disappeared 18,000 votes was never found

A startling expose on the lack of quality control and regular vote-flipping on ES&S iVotronics aired, to almost no fanfare in the corporate media, on HDNet in 2007 (watch it here).

In 2007 we had the displeasure of attending a meeting of the Davidson County, TN, Election Commission ourselves. While the Democrats on the committee were in the majority, the three hapless Democratic members were run roughshod over by the two Republicans who virtually ran the entire meeting themselves.

The Republican who seemed to be in charge of things, Commissioner Lynn Greer, while the actual Chair Eddie Bryan did almost nothing, actually told us after the meeting — and after we’d spoken during it, to warn about the troubles they would have with their touch-screen systems — that “paper ballots are the greatest fraud ever perpetrated on America.”

It seemed as though he actually believed those words as they came out of his mouth.

Meanwhile, more reports of vote-flipping have now come out of Putnam County, WV, the second county to report problems in the state were the ES&S iVotronic is used at every polling place. The Sunday Gazette Mail reports:

[Martha Louise] Harrington, a retired home health worker who lives in Hurricane, said, “I was very cautious to put my fingernail in the middle of the square. I hit it in the square to vote for Obama. Immediately, it went to McCain.

[Michael K.] Koon said he had no problem casting an early vote for president.

“However, when I chose Jay Rockefeller – and there is at least a finger’s distance between the two choices – it selected Jay Wolfe and printed his name on the receipt.

“I pushed Jay Rockefeller again a few times and it canceled Jay Wolfe. Then I chose Jay Rockefeller again and it verified it.”

In 2007, CA Secretary of State Debra Bowen found ES&S iVotronic touch-screens to be so unreliable, and prone to malicious attacks, that they were decertified in the state for all but optional use by voters with disabilities, in order to meet federal requirements for such voters.

UPDATE 10/22/08: ES&S touch-screens failing to show races, candidates on final review screens in SC. Details here…

And 2nd TN county now reporting vote-flips on ES&S machines. This time from D to R! It’s time to take these machines out of service now! Details here…

The BRAD BLOG covers your electoral system, fiercely and independently, like no other media outlet in the nation. Please support our work with a donation to help us keep going.Please CLICK HERE to help support our work today!

Share article:

Reader Comments on

Election Integrity Filmmaker Sees Own Vote Flipped on ESS Touch-Screens in TN

26 Comments

(Comments are now closed.)


26 Responses

  1. 1)
    Kira said on 10/21/2008 @ 12:28pm PT: [Permalink]

    A McCain “Win” Will Be Theft, Resistance Is Planned

    OpEd News; David Swanson

    If your television declares John McCain the president elect on the evening of November 4th, your television will be lying. You should immediately pick up your pre-packed bags and head straight to the White House in Washington, D.C., which we will surround and shut down until this attempt at a third illegitimate presidency is reversed.

    A McCain “win” will not be illegitimate because I disagree with his policies, but because he himself has rendered it illegitimate. He and his campaign and allied supporters have sought to illegally remove hundreds of thousands of voters from the rolls, fraudulently registered people as Republicans without their knowledge and against their will, obstructed voter registration drives, falsely warned students against voting where they attend school, falsely accused community groups of voter registration fraud, falsely alleged the widespread existence of voter fraud, and encouraged supporters to falsely believe McCain’s opponent is a foreign terrorist through speeches, recorded phone messages, and flyers. Already in early voting in a number of states there have been cases of votes on electronic machines visibly flipping to McCain or McKinney when intended for Obama. We will see McCain supporters on November 4th challenging people’s right to vote, seeking to force people to vote on provisional ballots, and seeking to have provisional ballots discarded. And we will see electronic vote counts wildly out of step with the most recent polls, although not with exit polls — which we will be denied any access to unless they have been “adjusted” to match the official counts.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    Newspaper endorsements – 124 Obama / 42 McPoot

    Why Obama’s Shocking Landslide in Newspaper Endorsements Really Matters

  2. 2)
    Karen said on 10/21/2008 @ 1:48pm PT: [Permalink]

    Brad,

    You should be on Thom’s show, I work during his show and so if he mentioned your updates, I did not hear them, but if not, we really need to drive traffic here so that we are all linked and can help out when a suggestion is made as to how we can help out.

    I posted the contact info for West Virgina on the Obama board yesterday to see if we could get some more people to call their offices.

    Having problems sleeping – Schindler’s List…

  3. 4)
    Kira said on 10/21/2008 @ 2:47pm PT: [Permalink]

    SUKABI #3 — WTF?????

    Does their depravity know no bounds?

    Of course I know the answer to my question … Nope.

  4. 5)
    Ancient said on 10/21/2008 @ 3:01pm PT: [Permalink]

    Hey Brad, does this mean if I want to vote for Cynthia McKinney I should press Obama? 🙂 But seriously, do the poll workers know enough to unplug the machine and hand people a paper ballot? And I guess, instead of a contingency of lawyers, can we please get the behind-the-times-states to do ANOTHER emergency paper ballot measure???????????? Aint it a great dog and pony show! 🙁

  5. 6)
    Kira said on 10/21/2008 @ 3:08pm PT: [Permalink]

    Woot!

    Even with all the dirty tricks, Red State Georgia has turned PINK!

    Polls show Obama only 2 points behind McFailin’!!!

    Let’s go GA! You know the only reason you turned RED was the Diebold Steal Your Vote Machines that flipped the vote in ’02.

  6. 7)
    Nunyabiz said on 10/21/2008 @ 3:43pm PT: [Permalink]

    I am seeing McSame ahead in Georgia by 7% and given the snake dancing mouth breathing inbreds that infest that area it is not surprising.

    http://www.electoral-vote.com/icon.html

    /Sigh I live in NC and since this state has Obama ahead in every poll by 1-3% for the past few weeks I guess I am going to go out everyday until Nov 4th and video odd happenings and also take exit polls from as many people as I can.
    These 15EV could very well be the difference if other states are stolen.
    Obama has to win by a MASSIVE margin to even stand a chance.

    I have been hoping to avoid this because if Reich wing lunatics get in my face there is a very good chance I will end up getting arrested.
    I don’t put up with ANY shit at all.

  7. 8)
    Kira said on 10/21/2008 @ 4:37pm PT: [Permalink]

    Well, I know how polls are, Nunya … however your figures are from Oct. 15 and mine are from Oct. 20 from TPM Poll Tracker Interactive Map. You have to scroll down a tad to see the map.

    You are sooo cool, Nynyabiz! Keep up the good work.

  8. 10)
    Nunyabiz said on 10/21/2008 @ 5:48pm PT: [Permalink]

    Kira, True those are from 6 days ago however it is from 4 polls not just one.
    Either way it is a good sign that even in such a backwards Red state he is that close.
    It is also a good sign that Obama draws MASSIVE crowds where ever he goes even in Red states while McSame can barely scrounge up 15-20,000 at most even in Red states.

    I bet he is much further ahead than the polls are stating.

  9. 11)
    Nunyabiz said on 10/21/2008 @ 5:55pm PT: [Permalink]

    and BTW I totally agree with David Swanson from the article you linked.
    It is basically what I have been saying for months now.

  10. 12)
    Kira said on 10/21/2008 @ 10:29pm PT: [Permalink]

    Nunya – ok, I admit I did sorta cherry-pick the Oct. 20 poll from Democracy Corps 😀 I do like it!

    I, too, fully believe the polls have been weighted to favor repubs – for many years. It’s an integral part of karl’s “The Math.”

    But, I want to talk about GA being “such a backwards Red State” as you suggested in #10. Not just GA, but other so-called RED states. [Admittedly, there are those wonderful pockets of “snake dancing mouth breathing inbred” real Americans – but we’re seeing those in Ohio & really, all across America.]

    Anyway, I think Liberals & Democrats do themselves a big disservice buying into the Red State propaganda. Consider this – Gore won in 2000 & Kerry won in 2004. Um … we won – we didn’t lose.

    Please remember this before citing GA as a Red State:

    Opinion polls in Georgia on the eve of the 2002 general election showed Democratic incumbent Gov. Roy Barnes leading by 9-11 points and Sen. Max Cleland ahead of his Republican challenger by 2-5 points, so it was a shock on election night when the returns showed Barnes losing to Republican Sonny Perdue, 46 to 51 percent, a swing of as much as 16 points from the last opinion polls, and Cleland losing to Saxby Chambliss by 46 to 53 percent, a last-minute swing of 9-12 points. Pundits credited a surge of “angry white men” punishing Barnes for removing the Confederate symbol from the state flag, but the London Independent noted in a special investigative report on Oct. 14 that a demographic breakdown published by the Georgia Secretary of State showed no such surge of white men; the only subgroup showing a modest increase in turnout was black women.

    There were also big, puzzling swings in different parts of the state, the Independent noted. In 58 counties, the vote was broadly in line with the primary election. In 27 counties in Republican-dominated north Georgia, however, Cleland unaccountably scored 14 points higher than he had in the primaries. And in 74 counties in the Democrat south, Saxby Chambliss garnered a whopping 22 points more for the Republicans than the party as a whole had won less than three months earlier.

    The big difference was that in November 2002 Georgia was the first state in the country to conduct an election entirely with touchscreen voting machines, after lavishing $54 million on a new system that promised to deliver the most secure, most up-to-date, most voter-friendly election in the nation’s history.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    According to Chris Hood [a former consultant with Diebold Election Systems,] Diebold employees altered software in some 5,000 machines in DeKalb and Fulton counties – the state’s largest Democratic strongholds.

    To avoid detection, Hood and others on his team entered warehouses early in the morning. “We went in at 7:30a.m. and were out by 11,” Hood says. “There was a universal key to unlock the machines, and it’s easy to get access. The machines in the warehouses were unlocked. We had control of everything.

    The state gave us the keys to the castle, so to speak, and they stayed out of our way.” Hood personally patched fifty-six machines and witnessed the patch being applied to more than 1,200 others.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    So – GA didn’t really become a Red State, it’s just a perception following the theft and ensuing right-wing propaganda.

  11. 15)
    Kira said on 10/21/2008 @ 11:15pm PT: [Permalink]

    Wow! Drew Rickets #14 – thank you for the link & your excellent article Media Chases the White Joe Vote.

    Mind if I send it around?

  12. 16)
    Jeannie Dean (not in) FL-13 said on 10/22/2008 @ 12:48am PT: [Permalink]

    Has anyone reported these incidents to the 1-866-OUR VOTE hotline? I’m going to try them first thing in the morning, see if they can’t get someone to ISOLATE/ SEQUESTER and INVESTIGATE these machines before even MORE people vote on them! Jeezus.

    Can a citizen insist that a faulty machine be removed from his or her polling place? I think Brad did that back in the CA Primaries when the Hart Intercivic disabled voters machine did that nasty little candy dance, bait-n-switch-a-roo on his ballot. But, that might’ve been because he’s Brad.
    Anyone know…?

    Harry Melon (#13) YES, SIR! Video tape everything you can and upload it to http://www.videothevote.org! It will automatically be linked to a national YOUTUBE/ PBS project called “Video YOUR Vote” and will act as critical documentation for the 2008 election record. The earlier we can get the footage up, the better informed the voters are, the more likely the (new) media outlets will pick it up, the more likely there will be pressure put on the candidate to NOT concede before every vote has been reconciled.

    And Kira, you rock. Great Swanson piece, and yes–I’m in, too, Nunya.

  13. 18)
    Nunyabiz said on 10/22/2008 @ 7:00am PT: [Permalink]

    All true Kira and I agree.

    However the reason Georgia and other such Red states are even remotely able to be stolen in the first place is because these religious zealots which have clearly divorced themselves from reality are a large percentage of the population in those areas.
    They also have by & large installed many of these lunatics into prominent positions of power so they can control much of what happens in the entire state.

    Just read these 2 links to get a good idea.

    http://www.theocracywatch.org/index.html

    http://www.yuricareport.com/Dom...gOfAmerica.htm

    and definitely watch this excellent video that was aired back in 1982 and narrated by Burt Lancaster.

    http://www.theocracywatch.org/a...ty-256kbps.wmv

  14. 19)
    Marcy said on 10/22/2008 @ 9:29am PT: [Permalink]

    What is being done to make voters aware, on a large scale, of the vote flipping taking place in touch-screen machines in states where early voting has begun (i.e. W. Virginia, Florida, Tennesee)? Voters must be made aware of this situation so they can alert poll workers if their vote is changed, and make sure it is fixed. THese machines should be junked and paper ballots provided. THis could cause the entire election to “flip” to McCain (votes are only being flipped from Dem to Rep candidates. Doesn’t sound kosher to me!)

  15. 20)
    Kira said on 10/22/2008 @ 11:28am PT: [Permalink]

    *fist-bump* Nunya! Didn’t you get those links from me – several years ago? 😀

    Yurica has written several excellent articles exposing the evangelical Dominionists and how they’ve infiltrated all levels of government [according to their plan, led by pat robertson … think Monica Goodling … & countless others.]

    I could go into a long discussion about how Newt Gingrich bought a NLP therapist to create the original GOP manual [passed around with orders to memorize and utilize in any conversation or interview with the media] which contains lists of derogatory words to be used when talking about Democrats & Liberals along with the list of very flattering words to be used when talking about republicans & “conservatives.” I call it The Hypnotizing of America via the Contract ON America. Thom Hartmann has the whole story here

    But it’s not just GA – these anti-American evangelicals are spread out, in those wonderful little pockets, all across America. The good news is that a lot of America is waking up and noticing that these people aren’t representing the true message of Christ. I think the tide is turning.

  16. 21)
    Kira said on 10/22/2008 @ 11:42am PT: [Permalink]

    Jeannie Dean – thanks for the compliment, but really, it is YOU! YOU REALLY ROCK, girl!

    I don’t know how you manage to get your exposé videos but they are simply top-notch. There are signs posted everywhere at my precinct that say cameras & cellphones are illegal. How else can they maintain their secrets?

  17. 22)
    Kira said on 10/22/2008 @ 1:07pm PT: [Permalink]

    PS to NUNYABIZ – the Thom Hartmann article on NLP [Neuro Linguistic Programming] is pretty long and the part referring to Newt Gingrich is a little more than 3/4 down the page.

    It’s all kind of important … to get the background info y’know. I just didn’t want you to give up & think I gave you a bum link.

  18. 23)
    Nunyabiz said on 10/22/2008 @ 2:47pm PT: [Permalink]

    “”Didn’t you get those links from me – several years ago”‘

    Nope, been an avid reader of both the Yurica report and Theocracy watch for many years and been using those ever since they were first published.
    I am always glad to see someone else that knows what the hell is really going on though.

  19. 24)
    Kira said on 10/22/2008 @ 2:54pm PT: [Permalink]

    That was actually my attempt at a wee joke, however I have posted the links here & at other blogs ever since I discovered her either ’04 or early ’05. Most people pooh-pooh it … kinda like they do regarding 9/11 Truth.

    Anyway – I too “am always glad to see someone else that knows what the hell is really going on.”

  20. 26)
    Greg Forest said on 10/29/2008 @ 12:14pm PT: [Permalink]

    Have any voting machine irregularities been in favor of Obama’s campaign or is it always a glitch that helps the GOP? If it is the machine, I would think the errors should be about equal for both parties eh?

    Is there such thing as a “voting irregularity” that doesn’t benefit the GOP?

(Comments are now closed.)


BB SIDEBAR NOTICE

Thanks to you, The BRAD BLOG has been trouble-making and muckraking for … 22 YEARS!!!

Please help The BRAD BLOG, BradCast and Green News Report remain independent and 100% reader and listener supported in our 23rd YEAR!!!

ONE TIME
any amount...

MONTHLY
any amount...

OR VIA SNAIL MAIL
Make check out to...
Brad Friedman / BRAD BLOG
7095 Hollywood Blvd., #594
Los Angeles, CA 90028

RECENT POSTS

More GOP Vote Rigging Underway. Hey, Maryland Dems! Time to Get Crackin’!: ‘BradCast’ 5/14/2026

Also: GA GOP rigs Atlanta D.A. elections; MT's new voter suppression law nixed by state court; Much more...

‘Green News Report’ – May 14, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen...

Do Dems Have the Courage Required to Restore and Reform American Democracy? (Do You?): ‘BradCast’ 5/13/2026

Guest: Kate Riga of Talking Points Memo; Also: SC Senate leader blocks U.S. House gerrymandering; Primary results from WV, NE...

Offshore Oil Rig Fire in SoCal a Preview of Trump’s NEXT Huge Failure: ‘BradCast’ 5/12/2026

Guest: Brady Bradshaw of Center for Biological Diversity; Also: Inflation spiked to 3-year high in April; Dems still favored to win House, despite GOP map rigging...

‘Green News Report’ – May 12, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen...

Virginia Supremes Void Special Election on Redistricting Referendum in Huge Gift to Vote Rigging GOP: ‘BradCast’ 5/11/2026

Voting rights disappearing, Jim Crow returning before our eyes in GOP-controlled state after state; Callers ring in...

Sunday ‘Redlining Democracy’ Toons

THIS WEEK: The Voting Whites Act ... Iran and Iran We Go ... Happy Mother's Day! ...

Repubs Seek Immunity Law for Big Oil; White South Rising Again After SCOTUS Ruling: ‘BradCast’ 5/7/2026

Guest: Laura Peterson of Union of Concerned Scientists; Also: Trump panel calls for FEMA cuts as MS slammed by another tornado swarm...

‘Green News Report’ – May 7, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen...

Time to Reform our Illegitimate Supreme Court: ‘BradCast’ 5/6/2026

Guest: Alicia Bannon of NYU's Brennan Center for Justice; Also: Primary and special election results in OH, IN, MI...

The Corrupt Hypocrisy of SCOTUS’ VRA Ruling in the Middle of Primary Election Season: ‘BradCast’ 5/5/2026

Also: 'Project Deadlock' in Strait of Hormuz as Admin pretends ill-fated, unlawful, continuing Iran War is over; The conflict's very real, if ironic, upside...

‘Green News Report’ – May 5, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen...

Billionaires Spending Millions to Fight Against, Lie to Voters About CA’s Proposed, One-Time Billionaires Tax: ‘BradCast’ 5/4/2026

Guest: Harold Meyerson of 'The American Prospect'; Also: GOP states scramble to write Black districts out of existence; A warning for CA vote-by-mail voters...

Steyer Facing Deceptive Fire in CA Gubernatorial Race for Call to Eliminate ‘Trump Loophole’

Trump-allied GOP opponent lying about progressive billionaire's proposal to end state's corporate 'property transfer loophole'...

Sunday ‘Dead to Rights’ Toons

THIS WEEK: RIP VRA ... '86 47' by the Seashore ... Ballroom Grift ...

About Brad Friedman...

Brad is an independent investigative journalist, blogger and broadcaster. Full Bio & Testimonials… Media Appearance Archive… Articles & Editorials Elsewhere… Contact…

He has contributed chapters to these books…
…And is featured in these documentary films…

BRAD BLOG ON THE AIR!

THE BRADCAST on KPFK/Pacifica Radio Network (90.7FM Los Angeles, 98.7FM Santa Barbara, 93.7FM N. San Diego and nationally on many other affiliate stations! ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneInApple Podcasts/iTunesiHeartAmazon Music

GREEN NEWS REPORT, nationally syndicated, with new episodes on Tuesday and Thursday. ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneInApple Podcasts/iTunesiHeartAmazon Music

Media Appearance Archives…

AD
CONTENT

ADDITIONAL STUFF

Brad Friedman/
The BRAD BLOG Named...

Buzz Flash's 'Wings of Justice' Honoree
Project Censored 2010 Award Recipient
The 2008 Weblog Awards