“Quietly Pressing” explores the class, gender, racial, and labor politics in the U.S. massage work industry by focusing on the work and lived experiences of Chinese and Chinese American women massage workers (hereinafter “Chinese massage workers”). Grounded in ethnography and in-depth interviews with Chinese massage workers in the Los Angeles metropolitan area, my research brings workers’ stories to explore how they experience, wrestle with, and do massage work in the context of racialized, sexualized Asian massage work. I argue that Chinese massage workers’ stories and strategies reveal the deep hierarchies of labor used to justify the ongoing devaluation of women of color’s labor, particularly migrant women. Nevertheless, Chinese massage workers learned to push back and create better conditions for their work and life. This dissertation investigates the range of creative strategies Chinese women develop, from highlighting genuine care to displaying health knowledge to remaining quiet, as they navigate their lives as Chinese massage workers. Chinese women’s stories teach us about the demands of care, the blurred boundaries between health and sex, and how we can minimize, refuse, and even resist work in the meantime. By minimizing emotional labor exerted at work through quiet tactics of withholding, these women are preserving the bandwidth for engaging in emotional labor with the care recipient they select. In other words, by withholding care from the client, the intended care recipient, Chinese massage workers are pilfering their care, which is expected by management to be exerted at work, to preserve their energy to redistribute it to their chosen care recipient such as their friends and children. This preservation and redistribution of care is resisting the working conditions of socially necessary care and refusing the capitalist logic of care that hierarchize deserving care receiving and giving subjects.
My work frames Chinese workers as knowledge producers, recognizing and examining the various working conditions they navigate and struggle against, often with grace and sometimes quietly. Centering Chinese workers’ negotiations of massage work, my research takes seriously the racialized and sexualized history of Asian women’s care labor to highlight how workers push back against narratives that oversexualize their work and seek to redefine the value of their labor. Drawing from feminist theories of work, I examine both Chinese massage workers’ disavowal of sex work and parallel insistence on the significance of intimate care work, highlighting how they engage subversive tactics to redefine hard work. I use a multisensorial ethnographic method to highlight how Chinese massage workers’ stories expose the problem with racializing and sexualizing massage work, the problem is with work at large, and how we might imagine and study new strategies of wrestling with and maybe even resisting work. Altogether, the story I tell unfurls some of the brilliant strategies these Chinese women massage workers use to fight against this complex nexus of power relations that misunderstands, diminishes, and criminalizes their labor.