A.6.RCD:4 - Solution
Name the blocked receiving claim and participants. Reuse a current direct predicate when it can state that claim. Derive only what the selected substrate warrants. Identify reusable predicate semantics when a receiving use needs a stable rule definition, including anticipated reuse. Admit a relation kind only with its direct obtaining and occurrence-identity laws. Stop when the receiving use works.
A.6.RCD:4.1 - Execute the demand-first method
- Name the blocked use. State the claim, check, decision, or continuation that cannot proceed, and what answer would close it.
- Recover participants and direct relations. Use
A.6.Pto name the participant referents under their relation-participant meanings and retrieve the smallest plausible base from the pattern content or declaration that defines each base predicate and its obtaining law. Similar tokens, shared field names, or adjacent graph edges are not a base. - Choose the least constructor admitted by the current substrate. State the constructor semantics and the base claim content it consumes. Do not infer an operator from punctuation or notation.
- Check the derivation and its use. Establish that the base claims and selected constructor support the required result and that it answers the named receiving use. Reuse an adequate existing proof or check; add positive or discriminating cases when needed to establish or explain applicability or failure. Keep hidden intermediates, polarity, scope, time, and base-definition editions visible when they change the result.
- Select the lightest disposition. Choose exactly one of the four dispositions in section 4.3 and stop at its stopping rule.
- Open reusable semantics when the receiving use needs one stable definition. This can support planned reuse or a reference to the rule; previously observed repetition is unnecessary. Decide whether the rule concerns one subject or is parameterized across subject instances. For one subject, identify a subject-bounded compound-law episteme whose EntityOfConcern is that subject and state the reuse limit. Across subjects, identify the reusable predicate definition itself as EntityOfConcern; that episteme may satisfy A.6.0 U.Signature membership before relation-kind admission, but it is not a RelationSignature.
- Open kind admission only when occurrence semantics are consumed. A derived kind needs a direct subject settlement with obtaining, applicability, base dependencies, and a non-optional occurrence-identity rule. A primitive candidate additionally carries the failed derivation, the action-facing distinction lost, its own obtaining and recurrence laws, independent receiving uses, and a standalone subject-pattern obligation.
When a separate note helps the live decision, use the applicable prompts below:
A.6.RCD working note:
blockedReceivingUse:
participantMeanings:
candidateBaseRelationClaims:
selectedSubstrateAndEdition:
constructorSemantics:
positiveCaseIfNeeded:
discriminatingFailureCaseIfNeeded:
receivingUseReplay:
disposition:
predicateDefinitionModeIfCurrent: subjectBounded | reusableAcrossSubjects
predicateDefinitionEntityOfConcernIfCurrent:
subjectBoundReuseBoundaryIfCurrent:
directSubjectSettlementIfKindCurrent:
stopOrReturn:
The note is a pattern-local prompt. A filled, claim-bearing use is an episteme under C.2.1; the printed shape is not a new record kind, RelationSignature, relation kind, or relation occurrence.
A.6.RCD:4.2 - Respect substrate authority
A constructor probe is usable only when the selected substrate defines its inputs, output claim, applicability, and relevant laws. The following table is a non-exhaustive set of recurring single-substrate semantic probes. It is neither a universal operator registry nor a claim that any substrate supports the whole list.
| Recurring single-substrate semantic probe | Minimum semantics to recover | Boundary |
|---|---|---|
| typed restriction | the base predicate, restricted participant kind or condition, and scope | a narrower claim is not automatically a new relation kind |
| participant permutation or converse | participant correspondence, polarity, and whether the direct subject ontology treats the inverse reading as the same occurrence | syntax does not decide occurrence identity |
| composition | the two or more base predicates, exact shared participant, order or direction, and intermediate witness policy | a hidden intermediate does not disappear from semantics because a query projects it away |
| projection | the source claim, retained participants, hidden participants, and existential or other projection law | projection can yield claim content without yielding an occurrence-identity rule |
| conjunction | all conjuncts, their common applicability, and one truth condition for the compound claim | co-truth does not create a cross-subject relation kind |
| negation or complement | the substrate’s closed-world, open-world, constructive, probabilistic, or other negation law | absence of a base assertion is not automatically a negative relation fact |
| transitive or path closure | admitted edge relation, direction, path rule, zero-length policy, cycle policy, and subject structure | a graph path is a representation or witness; it is not the obtaining relation occurrence |
| aggregation | the population or collection, grouping rule, aggregated value, aggregation operator, empty or duplicate treatment, scope, and applicability | an aggregate or scalar summary does not silently become a relation predicate or occurrence |
| probabilistic operator | the event or sample space, random variables or events, probability operator or model, conditioning, threshold or decision rule, applicability, and uncertainty boundary | a probability, likelihood, or posterior does not silently become a relation predicate, and shared event labels do not bridge algebras |
Cross-algebra claim-use boundary. First distinguish a relation between claim contents from an assertion about their actual use. A local content derivation or the applicable rule-content predicate in §4.5a can answer the former without inventing Work. When the sentence asserts that a particular decision or Work used a result, establish its premise-use, reference-use, decision-use or other direct predicate and facts. An actual application of a declared operation may instead use its A.6.1 argument binding. Return missing-governor for an absent use rule, factually unsupported for sufficient facts that fail its test, or missing-information for an unavailable deciding fact. Co-publication, a shared topic or the mere presence of one decision record establishes no use relation; its content may supply an assertion or supporting trace.
Stop there when those independent uses close the named decision or work question. Open a separate joint predicate only when the decision depends on a joint condition that the independent use relations cannot express; then name that condition and use A.6.RCD to derive exactly it. Do not add a generic joint-use relation or record merely because one decision cites results from two algebras.
When a consumed result relies on an obtaining F.9 Bridge between two exact F.17 SchemeSenseCell values, cite that Bridge and the separate bounded-use claim; add CL or a loss note only when the receiving use needs it. When the result instead crosses exact ReferencePlanes, cite the applicable plane relation and policy. If both facts are current, state both under their own predicates. A cell or plane difference alone creates neither relation, and one branch never fabricates the other. A Bridge-related penalty is current only when a named B.3 assurance claim uses an applicable declared domain model, calibrated mappings where needed, stated dependencies and assumptions, and current case facts whose rule yields that penalty. It affects only the calculated assurance result for that named use; it supplies no default fold and changes no independently stated characteristic.
A local compound claim needs recoverable constructor semantics, but it does not need a separately materialized substrate document. Authors MUST name and pin the substrate when the derivation is nontrivial, intended for interoperability, used as proof, or becomes a reusable predicate definition. If no current substrate supplies the proposed operator, return a missing-substrate blocker rather than improvising a universal constructor algebra.
A.6.RCD:4.3 - Select one of four dispositions
| Disposition | Test | Result | Stop |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Existing predicate | One current ClaimGraph already supplies the participant meanings, obtaining predicate, applicability, and claim family needed by the use. | State the readable affirmative, negative, or modal claim in a claim-bearing episteme under that predicate, retaining the source pattern only as a locator. Current case facts or constituting history supply its factual basis. If no needed predicate, applicability condition, or occurrence rule exists, return missing-governor; if the governor exists and the available case basis is sufficient to apply its positive test but that test fails, return factually unsupported; if a fact needed to decide the test is unavailable, return missing-information. State a negative only under an applicable non-obtaining criterion or complete closure basis whose facts are satisfied. | Stop. Do not derive a synonym predicate or duplicate relation kind. The relation obtains when its subject predicate is satisfied; an affirmative assertion reports that fact without creating it. Missing knowledge leaves the claim unresolved. Use A.6.REL when a named use consumes the occurrence’s identity. |
| 2. Local compound relation-bearing claim | A substrate-admitted composition of current base predicates closes this one receiving use, and no separately reusable definition or occurrence semantics is needed. | Put positive or negative compound claim content in one identified C.2.1 episteme. An information-sufficiency or reliance assessment stays with the evaluation or evidence pattern and uses the blocker boundary in section 0.1; it is not a third predicate value. | Stop. Introduce no relation kind, RelationSignature, or U.Relation occurrence. |
| 3. Reusable predicate semantics, with derived-kind continuation only when needed | A receiving use needs a stable definition, for example for a rule reference or repeated application. A rule limited to one subject is subject-bounded; a rule parameterized across subject instances is reusable across those subjects. | Publish one C.2.1 episteme with the branch-specific EntityOfConcern: the subject for a subject-bounded compound law, or the reusable predicate definition for cross-subject reuse. The latter may independently satisfy A.6.0 U.Signature membership. If a receiving use also needs stable relation-occurrence semantics, return a derived-kind candidate plus its proposed direct subject settlement and handle that candidate under E.24 and E.24.UK, and under A.11 when parsimony is current. | Stop at the selected definition unless occurrence semantics are named and the proposed settlement is supplied. A definition is not a kind. A.6.0 membership does not make it a RelationSignature; only an admitted relation kind opens that specialization. |
| 4. Primitive relation kind | Every accepted derivation loses one action-facing distinction, and the candidate has independent receiving uses plus its own obtaining, recurrence, applicability, and occurrence-identity laws. | Carry the candidate to A.11, E.24, and E.24.UK, and author a standalone direct subject pattern. | Stop or block if the failed derivation, lost distinction, independent use, direct pattern, or identity law is absent. A convenient name never passes this test. |
These are economy dispositions, not maturity stages. Later need can reopen a local claim or definition.
A.6.RCD:4.4 - Keep kinds, predicates, claims, and occurrences distinct
The admitted relation kind classifies occurrences; its direct predicate states their obtaining condition. The subject facts or constituting history determine whether the relation obtains. A claim-bearing episteme asserts affirmative, negative or rule-qualified modal content about that relation. Available evidence supports, refutes or leaves that assertion unresolved; lack of a deciding fact does not itself settle obtaining. Apply §0.1 to the unresolved claim, and use A.6.REL when the receiving use needs explicit occurrence identity.
| Object | What it is | What it is not |
|---|---|---|
| admitted direct relation kind | the admitted classificatory distinction over its possible obtaining occurrences | not the direct predicate, one case result, an assertion, or an occurrence |
| direct obtaining predicate | the declared test for named participant meanings under its applicability conditions | not proof that the test is satisfied in this case and not an occurrence |
| direct relation-bearing assertion | one C.2.1 episteme whose claim family states affirmative, negative, or rule-qualified modal content about the predicate for named participants | not the world-side obtaining result and not an information-sufficiency or reliance disposition |
| obtaining direct relation occurrence | one world-side relation occurrence for which current case facts or constituting history satisfy the direct predicate; its direct identity rule exists even when no named use needs an explicit designator | not created by the assertion, evidence, a representation, or an identifier |
| local compound relation-bearing claim | claim content in one C.2.1 episteme, asserting or denying satisfaction of a substrate-admitted compound predicate | not a relation kind and not a relation occurrence |
| subject-bounded compound-law episteme | one C.2.1 episteme whose EntityOfConcern is the promise-content edition, subject structure, decision occurrence, or other subject to which the rule is explicitly limited | not a predicate definition reusable across subject instances, not a RelationSignature, and not a classifier of relation occurrences |
| reusable predicate-definition episteme | one C.2.1 episteme whose EntityOfConcern is the reusable predicate definition itself and whose claims define its parameterized semantics across subject instances | may satisfy A.6.0 U.Signature membership, but is not a RelationSignature before relation-kind admission and does not classify relation occurrences |
| admitted derived relation kind | a classificatory distinction over relation occurrences, with obtaining defined through admitted base relations | not the definition episteme; it needs its own direct subject settlement and identity rule |
| admitted primitive relation kind | a classificatory distinction whose needed action-facing semantics cannot be preserved by accepted derivation | not a reward for a familiar word or notation |
| claim or derivation representation | formula tokens, trees, query paths, graph elements, tables or diagrams interpreted under the selected scheme; C.29 applies when a separate mathematical representation or transfer question remains | the presence of a representation alone is neither satisfaction, obtaining, admission nor occurrence identity; its content may express the claim and grounds |
| designator or typed reference | a name or reference associated with an already settled definition episteme, relation kind, or individuated occurrence | not one token that silently creates or identifies all three |
A.6.RCD:4.5 - Settle a reusable predicate definition
When a receiving use needs a stable rule definition, establish its intended reuse boundary before publishing it.
- One subject. If every use asks about the same promise-content edition, subject structure, decision occurrence, or other subject, identify a subject-bounded compound-law episteme whose
EntityOfConcernis that subject. State plainly that the rule may be reused only for claims about that subject; a familiar formula does not make it portable to another subject. - Across subject instances. If the same parameterized rule is intended to apply across independently identified subject instances, identify one reusable predicate-definition episteme whose
EntityOfConcernis the predicate definition itself. If its claim graph supplies the subject and value range, Vocabulary, Laws, and Applicability required by A.6.0, the already identified episteme may satisfyU.Signaturemembership without relation-kind admission. It remains a predicate-definition declaration, not aRelationSignatureor a classifier of occurrences.
In either branch, the definition content states:
- parameter and participant meanings;
- the base-relation claims and the pattern content or declarations that define their predicates and obtaining laws;
- the derivation rule under the selected substrate;
- claim polarity and applicability, with any scope or time arguments the rule consumes;
- base-definition and substrate dependencies plus their editions when current;
- justification of the derived rule and its applicability, with cases where needed to expose a deciding condition;
- the admissible claim use, plus a restriction on occurrence or ontology inference only when F.19’s independent-ground, plausible-reader and consequence test warrants it.
If neither the subject nor the reusable predicate definition is the EntityOfConcern, keep the needed results as local compound claims. Do not manufacture a union concern or alternate opportunistically between the rule and a nearby domain subject.
A.6.RCD:4.5a - Reusable rule-content predicates stop before relation-kind admission
RuleContentBasisFindingDefinition@R7 is the disposition-3 declaration for two repeated cross-subject predicate semantics: derivedUsingRuleContent(dependentContent, baseContent) and evaluatedAgainstRuleContent(dependentContent, baseContent). Its EntityOfConcern is that reusable predicate definition. Its SubjectKind and RangedValueKind are both NonemptyClaimContent under C.2.1:4.1.2; satisfaction of either predicate is asserted in a C.2.1 episteme, so no separate result kind is introduced. The declaration may satisfy ordinary A.6.0 U.Signature membership. It is not a RelationSignature, relation kind, relation occurrence, registry, or claim that every definition or constraint was actually used.
Use the first predicate only when an identified derivation claim names the nonempty base subgraph as a formal premise under a declared inference rule or application producing the dependent content. Use the second only when an identified criterion-selection claim selects that base for a bounded evaluation claim concerning the dependent content. The dependent and base values are predicate parameters, not A.6.5 SlotSpecs. Assertions of these predicates remain ordinary C.2.1 epistemes; consultation, influence, provenance, evidence, evaluation Work, and later sufficiency remain separate.
Reuse the lightest sufficient branch. A subject-local assertion that names its defining or constraining ClaimGraph and closes the use stops at disposition 1 or 2. Use the R7 definition when its parameterized rule-content semantics answer the receiving question; there need not already be several observed applications. Open a basis analysis only for a named comparison, replay, conflict or reliance use. Stop at predicate-definition content unless a receiving use needs an obtaining occurrence as a participant, comparison object or otherwise identified relation.
A.6.RCD:4.6 - Prepare derived or primitive relation-kind admission only with occurrence semantics
When a named use consumes occurrence semantics, A.6.RCD yields a relation-kind candidate and the settlement material needed for admission: a derived-kind candidate plus its proposed direct subject settlement, or a primitive-kind candidate plus its candidate standalone subject pattern. Apply the admission predicates defined in E.24 and E.24.UK, and the parsimony predicate in A.11 when that question is current. Neither a proposed settlement nor a candidate pattern locator admits the kind. For a candidate that is admitted, the resulting direct subject settlement states:
- the classified relation occurrences and participant meanings;
- the obtaining predicate and applicability;
- for a derived kind, the derivation law and base-definition dependencies;
- a direct occurrence-identity rule for identification and reidentification, including repeated occurrences when possible;
- recurrence, cessation, and continuation conditions when those distinctions matter;
- at least one named receiving use that consumes occurrence semantics;
- the standalone subject pattern.
An admitted relation kind never has identity intentionally absent. Ordinary use can omit explicit individuation, occurrence records, and designators because no named use consumes them; the direct identity rule still exists.
A pure converse preserves one base occurrence only when the direct subject ontology explicitly says that inverse wording concerns the same occurrence. Restriction, projection, composition, closure, aggregation, and hidden intermediates require an explicit identity decision. Their syntax does not decide whether the derived occurrence inherits one base identity, is constituted as a composite occurrence, or has a new direct identity rule. If no truthful rule is available, remain at local-claim or predicate-definition level.
Before relation-kind admission, authors MAY ask A.6.0 whether a reusable predicate-definition episteme satisfies ordinary U.Signature membership. That declaration’s EntityOfConcern is the predicate definition, not a candidate relation kind, and the result neither classifies occurrences nor admits a kind.
Authors MAY publish under A.6.0 a RelationSignature whose EntityOfConcern is a relation kind only after that kind is admitted. The RelationSignature declares reusable SlotSpecs and restates the direct laws; it does not admit the kind or make an occurrence obtain.
A.6.RCD:4.7 - Separate recognition from assurance
Recognition branch for ordinary receiving use. Ask only:
- What receiving claim or action is blocked?
- Who or what are the participants, and under which meanings?
- Does one current direct predicate already state the needed affirmative, negative, or rule-qualified modal claim?
- If not, what smallest substrate-admitted compound claim answers it?
- Which of the four dispositions lets the receiving use proceed now?
The ordinary branch can stop at a readable direct claim or one readable compound claim. It does not require a named substrate document, predicate-definition publication, new relation kind, signature, explicit occurrence, or designator when the receiving use consumes none of them.
Negative direct-claim case. A staffing check asks whether Robot_7 is assigned as InspectorSystemRole for Cell_3 during Interval_T under the declared CellInspectorAssignment species of U.SystemRoleAssignment. The species is the relation kind, not an assignment occurrence. A.2.1 and the species definition supply participant meanings and the positive predicate for the holder, cell and interval; taxonomy and reference scheme are not participants. When an applicable non-assignment criterion or complete closure basis is satisfied, a C.2.1 episteme can state the negative and disposition 1 closes the check without individuating an obtaining assignment. An absent direct predicate, applicability condition or required occurrence rule yields missing-governor; sufficient case facts that fail the positive test yield factually unsupported; an unavailable deciding fact yields missing-information. Neither a failed positive test nor a blocker supplies negative polarity by itself.
Check a compound claim or proposed definition. DPF and FPF authors verify the applicable grounds below when authoring a compound claim, reusable predicate definition, or relation-kind admission candidate, including a durable local compound claim that stops at disposition 2:
- exact base patterns, definitions, editions, and applicability;
- selected substrate and constructor semantics;
- the derivation’s validity and receiving-use result, with positive or discriminating cases when needed to settle a consequential condition;
- one truthful definition
EntityOfConcernwhen reusable semantics are published; - dependency and currentness conditions;
- direct occurrence-identity and recurrence rules for every admitted relation kind;
- the representation conventions needed to recover the derivation, with C.29 only for a separate mathematical representation or transfer question;
- naming only after the definition episteme, kind, or occurrence is settled;
- A.10 when evidence reliance is claimed, B.3 for an assurance claim, A.21 for a gate result, and C.11 or the direct decision pattern for a decision result.
Passing the assurance branch does not make evidence constitutive of relation obtaining. It makes the derivation and admission decision replayable for the declared use.
A.6.RCD:4.8 - Stop and return
Stop at the first disposition that closes the named receiving use. Use this pattern when:
- a relied-on base relation or predicate definition changes;
- the selected substrate edition or constructor semantics changes;
- applicability, polarity, participant meaning, scope, time, or hidden-intermediate policy changes;
- the derivation becomes unreadable, computationally unsuitable, or unable to interoperate for the declared use;
- a receiving use begins to need one stable definition or explicit occurrence identity;
- a purported primitive gains an accepted lossless derivation, or a derived kind loses a truthful identity rule.
G.11 supplies currentness, dependency closure, and scoped refresh when a relied-on base definition, substrate edition, or applicability settlement changes. Re-evaluate only affected claims and dependent kinds; do not rebuild a global relation registry.