Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 21:55:20 UTC

A.11 - Ontological Parsimony

Type: Kernel parsimony and admission discipline pattern Status: Stable Normativity: Normative unless a section is marked informative

A.11:0 - Use This When

Use this pattern when FPF work proposes a new U-kind, core relation, dependent durable value, or public structural name and the question is whether existing ontology can express the claim without the proposed durable ontology addition.

Typical moments:

  • a new U-kind seems useful after E.24.UK recovers the candidate object;
  • a proposed root kind may be a dependent value, slot, relation, record, publication form, lens, local frame, or C.3 U.Kind;
  • two candidates overlap strongly;
  • a name is convenient but the ontology may already be expressible through existing patterns.

EntityOfConcern. The parsimony claim for one candidate ontology addition.

First useful move. Recover the candidate with E.24.UK or the subject pattern, then find the best current FPF expression for the receiving claim or use.

In this pattern, an existing governed expression is an expression whose use is defined by an applicable pattern. It can identify an admitted kind or dependent value, slot, relation, record, publication form, lens or local frame, or state a claim governed by the applicable pattern.

What goes wrong if missed. FPF grows duplicate kinds for claims already carried by governed expressions. Later patterns then argue over words instead of recovering the EntityOfConcern, relation or slot, and admissible claim.

What this buys. A small ontology can express rich project situations: A.11 either identifies the existing governed expression that carries the claim or supplies a positive parsimony finding, with a boundary, for the candidate’s complete admission test.

Not this pattern when. The question is only a local display name, publication title, naming taste, or ordinary glossary cleanup. Use the relevant Part F naming pattern unless the name is being asked to carry durable ontology.

A.11:1 - Problem Frame

FPF needs enough primitives to be useful, but every new primitive creates learning cost, bridge cost, and future repair cost. Ontological parsimony is not anti-growth. It tests whether composition, reuse, dependent-value settlement, and subject patterns can express the action-facing claim without material loss. A positive parsimony finding is necessary for the proposed addition; it does not complete its admission.

When source or draft wording proposes a candidate durable value in U.* form, treat that as a proposal requiring an admission decision. Apply A.11 after E.24.UK recovers the governed object and before naming patterns choose a public label.

For a relation-kind candidate, first apply A.6.P. If the participants are exact but no current direct relation expresses the named receiving claim, apply A.6.RCD. Stop when it returns an existing predicate, a local compound claim, or subject-bounded or reusable predicate-definition content. A derived relation-kind candidate continues only when a named use needs stable occurrence semantics and supplies its proposed settlement; an irreducible primitive relation-kind candidate continues only under A.6.RCD disposition 4.

A.11:1.0 - Problem

A useful project word, slot-position label, publication form, diagram element, mathematical lens, or repeated source term can start acting like a durable FPF kind before the governed object and subject pattern are recovered. The problem is to decide whether the candidate preserves an action-facing distinction that the best existing governed expression cannot carry, or should remain that expression or a local name.

A.11:1.1 - Forces

ForceTension
Expressive reach vs. kind inflationFPF must name durable objects clearly, but each extra root kind increases learning, checking, and bridge cost.
Local usefulness vs. universal burdenA local project name may be helpful in one context, while a U-kind becomes a cross-corpus obligation.
Composition vs. material lossExisting slots, relations, and patterns often express the claim, but some candidates preserve a distinction that composition would hide.
Reader clarity vs. ontology compactnessA plain label can help users, but a convenient label must not conceal a relation, slot position, publication form, or mathematical lens.
Growth vs. reopenabilityFPF needs new primitives when problems demand them, but admitted values need reopen conditions when overlap or fuzziness appears.

A.11:2 - Solution

Use four gates to establish the parsimony finding for the proposed ontology addition. Apply every gate to the same candidate, receiving claim or use, and facts. Find the best existing expression first; then state the material loss, overlap discriminator, newly admissible claim or action, and nearest excluded case for that same use. A positive finding continues the complete admission test under E.24/E.24.UK or the candidate’s subject-kind governor; it is not that admission result or project-side permission.

GateTest questionPass condition
CompositionWhat is the best existing governed expression for this receiving claim or use?Pass only when that expression loses a stated claim, boundary, or admissible use.
Non-redundancyHow far does the candidate overlap an existing governed value or relation, and what discriminates the remainder?Pass only when the bounded remainder changes an admissible claim for the same use.
Action-facing contributionWhich claim or action becomes admissible because this addition exists?Pass only when that contribution reaches the named use rather than supplying naming comfort or source prestige.
BoundaryWhat is the one-sentence inclusion test, and which nearest case is excluded?Pass only when both cases can be distinguished from stated facts without private author intent.

The questions can be answered as an ordinary comparison. The following view may help retain or communicate the result. If an E.24-family decision is current, put or reference the parsimony evidence there and resolve this view back to that decision, preserving every required E.24:4.0a value. The view is not a second independently editable admission decision; a local wording or existing-expression answer need not create one.

ParsimonyAdmissionRecord:
  Candidate: candidate examined by this parsimony inquiry
  RecoveredGovernedObject:
  E24FamilySettlementDecisionRef: E.24:4.0a shared decision when one is current
  ReceivingClaimOrUse:
  CurrentFactsRef:
  ExistingExpressionAttempt: best existing governed expression for that claim or use
  MaterialLossIfComposed: lost claim, boundary, or admissible use
  OverlapWithExistingValues: extent plus discriminator
  ActionFacingContribution: newly admissible claim or action
  BoundaryTest: inclusion test plus nearest excluded case
  Disposition: parsimony finding and continuation; cite the separate admission result when current

Possible continuations of the parsimony finding:

  • retain as a root U-kind only with the corresponding complete admission result;
  • retain as a dependent durable value only with its complete root-coupled settlement: same-individual dependence keeps the root individual’s identity and adds a stable membership condition implying root-kind membership for that same individual; identity dependence identifies a distinct individual through a governed relation to a named root individual and all additional discriminators;
  • retain as a local C.3 kind or typed claim under its rule;
  • express through an existing governed expression;
  • keep as source wording or a local name;
  • for a relation-kind candidate, stop at the A.6.RCD existing-predicate, local-compound, subject-bounded-law, or reusable-predicate-definition result; none of these stops admits a relation kind;
  • continue a derived relation-kind candidate only with the required stable occurrence semantics, named receiving use, and proposed settlement; or
  • continue an irreducible primitive relation-kind candidate only when A.6.RCD disposition 4 passes: every accepted derivation loses the action-facing distinction, and independent receiving uses and obtaining, recurrence, applicability, and occurrence-identity laws are supplied.

These are continuation alternatives, not a single admission-result vocabulary. A U-kind decision uses E.24.UK:4.1–4.2: root, same-individual-dependent, identity-dependent, reuse, local-kind, or reject. Only the first three are positive admissions after the complete test; the remaining three are non-admission exits.

A.11:2.1 - Archetypal Grounding - Maintenance

Candidate claimParsimony resultWhy
CoolingPump as a new root U-kindFirst recover the project claim that distinguishes role classification, function, capability, component relation, or another governed expression. If that claim identifies an admitted U.System in a local cooling-circulator role, use the C.3 classification; otherwise return the missing discriminator. Add an assignment occurrence, capability, Method, or Work only when its predicate is current.The useful result follows the grounded project claim; the noun alone neither selects the role reading nor creates a universal kind.
Actuator or another transformer-like nounRecover the governed object and predicate needed by the candidate use; keep an ordinary functional or other subject claim with its rule. Use A.3 for a grounded acting-side claim and A.3.4 to identify any independently claimed actual change. An asserted Work needs the complete A.13 core and independent A.15.1 admission, with F.6 only when precise attribution is needed. If the facts do not select the predicate, return the missing discriminator. A new durable value needs the parsimony finding and complete E.24.UK admission.Neither the noun nor an identified change supplies an acting System, assignment, or Work. Those claims need their own facts.
Provenance-chain wordingUse A.10 for one source-to-use account and bounded reliance. Open G.6 when the use needs path identity, slicing, citation, or local refresh through already established objects and relations. Continue a new durable-value proposal only if the evidence or provenance patterns cannot express the needed claim without material loss; complete admission remains separately required.Parsimony tries subject patterns before minting a kernel addition; a chain label does not itself require an addressable path.
SmallPart or similar vague size classReject or keep local.The boundary depends on private scale expectations unless a measurement or classification pattern supplies a crisp rule.

Worked case: retain a local classification. A maintenance inventory needs to select the installed pumps whose specified function is coolant circulation in Loop-L. The stated project facts admit P-17 as a U.System and establish that it is an installed pump with that function. P-18 is also an installed pump, but its specified function is fuel supply. The project already has a C.3.2 declaration of the local kind CoolingPumpInLoopL whose membership rule is the inventory selection condition; its classification admits P-17 and excludes P-18.

The proposal is to add a root U.CoolingPumpInLoopL with the same membership rule. The four gates give one result. Composition already expresses the selection without loss; the proposed extension coincides with the local kind; the new root admits no additional claim or maintenance action; and the P-18 boundary is already supplied by the local rule. Retain that local classification. If the proposal is carried into an E.24.UK decision, record local-kind through the existing C.3.2 declaration. If later work needs a claim the local classification cannot express, reopen that loss and the applicable admission test; the useful project label remains available in the meantime.

A retained addition also needs a reopen condition. Reconsider the parsimony finding and admission under its governing rule when usage collapses, overlap is discovered, an existing expression becomes adequate, the boundary becomes fuzzy, or the name hides the underlying claim. A scheduled review is useful only when it helps detect such a change.

A.11:4 - Bias-Annotation

A.11 corrects kind-inflation bias. A useful word, field name, record label, or diagram element can start behaving like a universal kind because it appears often, feels important, or has prestige in a source tradition. The repair is ontological: recover the governed object and try the best existing governed expression before admitting a new durable value.

It also corrects false-parsimony bias. A compact ontology is not achieved by refusing every new value. If composition hides a reviewable distinction or blocks an action-facing claim, a positive parsimony finding supports continuing the candidate’s admission test and states its boundary, overlap, and reopen condition.

A.11:3 - Conformance Checklist

CheckRequirement
CC-A11-1The candidate’s governed object is recovered before parsimony is judged.
CC-A11-2If the candidate uses U.* force, E.24.UK is applied before F.5, F.8, or F.18 naming.
CC-A11-3The best existing governed expression is attempted by value. For a relation-kind candidate this includes the A.6.P / A.6.RCD disposition. A representation may supply evidence. A derived relation-kind candidate requires its justified stable occurrence semantics, receiving use, and settlement; only a primitive candidate requires A.6.RCD disposition 4’s irreducibility test. Admission remains the complete governing result.
CC-A11-4Material loss is stated as a lost claim, lost distinction, lost boundary, or lost admissible use, not as naming discomfort.
CC-A11-5Strong overlap lowers or rejects the candidate unless the difference changes claims.
CC-A11-6The parsimony finding identifies the applicable section 2 continuation and, for a relation-kind candidate, the A.6.RCD result. Any U-kind admission cites the complete E.24.UK result rather than treating a continuation as admission.

A.11:5 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them

  • Slot label becomes kind. A system-role designation, transformation-participant label, source-maintenance position, carrier position, or boundary slot is renamed as if the label created a new universal kind; recover the admitted System, local system-role kind or direct relation, any separately obtaining assignment, and Work only when each is current.
  • Publication form becomes ontology. The appearance of a card, record, view, dashboard, figure, or report title does not establish a new durable kind or make a depicted relation obtain. Recover what the claim selects: claim-bearing content, a publication form, a carrier, or another subject. Use C.2.1/E.24.PUB when that distinction changes the claim; a form can be a legitimate subject, and a view-episteme remains distinct from its carrier.
  • Mathematical lens becomes object. A graph, tuple, algebra, metric, coordinate, or threshold does not establish a new durable kind by mathematical appearance. Recover its object and predicate. Use C.29 when a question about choosing, transferring, or relying on a mathematical representation remains unresolved; identify the represented subject, correspondence, and preservation/loss boundary needed for that question. An ordinary threshold, measurement, formal declaration, or other governed claim stays with its subject rule.
  • Local project name becomes kernel vocabulary. A useful project label is promoted to durable FPF vocabulary before composition and pattern expression are tried.
  • Overlap is ignored. A candidate is admitted even though an existing pattern already carries the same claim with clearer boundaries.
  • Parsimony as refusal. A new value is rejected because “fewer kinds is better” even though existing composition loses a distinction users need to claim, compare, repair, stop, or rely on.

A.11:6 - Consequences

ConsequenceBenefitCost or boundary
Smaller durable vocabularyReusing adequate expressions reduces the number of U-kinds that readers must learn and relate across domains.The comparison must show the best existing expression by value. Keep it recoverable when later use depends on it.
Better U-kind admissionsComplete admission requires the parsimony evidence: material loss, non-redundancy, action-facing contribution, boundary test, and reopen condition; these do not replace the other admission conditions.Some attractive names remain local or dependent even when they are common in source traditions.
Clearer neighboring-pattern useReaders know when to use E.24.UK, A.8, C.3, Part F naming, or a subject pattern.The pattern supplies the parsimony finding; the governing admission test decides admission and Part F chooses the public name.

A.11:7 - Rationale

Ontological parsimony preserves FPF’s ability to handle many domains without turning every local distinction into a root object. The pattern follows the same discipline used by E.24.UK: recover the governed object first, then decide whether a new durable value is needed. Using an existing governed expression is a successful result, not a failure to mint a kind.

The practical criterion is not abstract minimalism. A candidate earns a positive parsimony finding only when users gain a claim, comparison, repair, stop condition, reliance condition, or boundary they cannot recover by composition without material loss. Admission still requires its complete governing test. That keeps parsimony tied to FPF’s work-facing purpose rather than to a taste for small vocabularies.

A.11:8 - SoTA-Echoing

Receiving use and reuse. Two historical ontology-engineering contributions supply comparison methods. Noy and McGuinness, Ontology Development 101 (2001), §3, use competency questions to specify the intended application and test whether an ontology supplies enough information, and recommend considering existing ontologies for reuse. Shimizu, Hirt and Hitzler, MODL: A Modular Ontology Design Library (2019), §§3.2–3.3, develop reusable, adaptable modules whose competency questions identify the intended answers. A.11 applies this comparison to the receiving claim or use and the best existing FPF expression.

Construction and identity. Florio and Linnebo, Introduction to Constructional Ontology (2024), §§1 and 3, distinguish constructors, inputs and constructional processes, and show how construction choices bear on identity: a set has its particular elements, while the same sum can have different decompositions. Borgo and Righetti, Towards Applied Constructional Ontology (2025), §§3–5, explore reconstructions of BFO, DOLCE and UFO with explicit choices about dependence, parthood, inherence and participation. Their exploratory comparison helps expose which construction and relation account a candidate uses.

FPF synthesis. Recovering a candidate’s construction and identity establishes what the proposed addition concerns. A.11 then asks whether a new durable kind changes admissible claims, boundaries or work-facing use. Its four gates combine material loss, non-redundancy, action-facing contribution and a boundary for the same candidate, use and facts. The complete E.24.UK admission decides the proposed U-kind’s disposition and root or dependent form.

A.11:9 - Relations

  • Builds on: E.24.UK, A.6.P, A.6.RCD, A.8, C.3, F.8, F.18, and subject patterns.
  • Coordinates with: E.24.CD for candidate detection and E.24.PUB when a publication form or structural name created the admission claim.
  • Does not replace: universal-core testing in A.8, typed claim quantification in C.3, or naming discipline in Part F.

A.11:End

Referenced in the corpus

35 literal mentions in other sections. Read their context to establish the relation.