A.6.RCD:7 - Conformance Checklist
- Blocked use. The claim, check, decision, or continuation under repair is named.
- Participants first. Referents and relation-participant meanings are recovered before constructor or notation choice.
- Direct-predicate stop.
A.6.Precovers the current subject predicate before compound derivation begins. If that predicate can state the needed affirmative, negative, or rule-qualified modal claim, use it and stop. If no needed predicate, applicability condition, or occurrence rule exists, returnmissing-governor; if the governor exists and the available case basis is sufficient to apply its positive test but that test fails, returnfactually unsupported; if a fact needed to decide the test is unavailable, returnmissing-information. A negative additionally needs an applicable non-obtaining criterion or complete closure basis and facts that satisfy it. - Base. Every base predicate names the pattern content or declaration that defines it and its obtaining law. The current case separately supplies the relevant facts or constituting history; an assertion or representation does not turn that rule into an obtaining occurrence.
- Substrate authority. Every used constructor has semantics in the selected substrate; nontrivial, interoperable, proof-bearing, or reusable derivation pins the substrate and edition.
- Derivation and use. The selected constructor and base claims support the result required by the receiving use. Existing proof or verification may suffice; positive or discriminating cases are added where needed to establish or explain a consequential condition.
- Lightest disposition. Exactly one of the four dispositions closes the current use; later branches are not opened by habit.
- Claim polarity and occurrence boundary. Direct and compound assertions may be affirmative, negative, or rule-qualified modal claims. The subject predicate defines the test, current case facts or constituting history determine its satisfaction, and the assertion states the result without creating an occurrence. The three blocker phrases in section 0.1 remain distinct and are not predicate values. Use A.6.REL only when a satisfied affirmative case has an occurrence whose identity a named use consumes.
- Definition identity and reuse boundary. A subject-bounded compound-law episteme names the subject as its
EntityOfConcernand states that reuse does not travel to another subject. A reusable predicate-definition episteme names the reusable predicate definition as itsEntityOfConcern. Both state applicability and visible base dependencies. - Definition/signature boundary. A reusable predicate-definition episteme may satisfy ordinary A.6.0
U.Signaturemembership before relation-kind admission. It is not aRelationSignature, does not classify relation occurrences, and does not make one obtain. - Derived-kind candidate and admission. When a named use needs stable occurrence semantics, the A.6.RCD application records a derived-kind candidate plus a proposed direct subject settlement covering derivation and dependencies, obtaining, applicability, recurrence where current, and a direct occurrence-identity rule. Apply the admission predicates defined in
E.24andE.24.UK, and the parsimony predicate inA.11when current. Neither the proposal nor aSubjectPatternLocatoradmits the kind. Only an admitted relation kind proceeds to an A.6.0RelationSignature; ordinaryU.Signaturemembership of a predicate-definition episteme is independent of that branch. - Primitive-kind settlement. A primitive candidate records the failed derivation, action-facing loss, independent uses, own obtaining and identity laws, and standalone direct pattern before A.11/E.24/E.24.UK admission can pass.
- Identity never absent. Explicit individuation can be omitted from ordinary use; an admitted relation kind’s identity rule cannot.
- Representation boundary. Formula, query, graph, tree, path, diagram, row, and name remain representations or designators connected to independently recovered content.
- Neighboring claims. Apply A.10 when the evidence source-to-use account is implicit or must remain replayable, B.3 for assurance, A.21 for gates, A.15 for work, C.11 or the decision pattern for decisions, E.24.PUB for publication availability and identity, E.17 when a reader-facing form is needed, F.18 for naming, and G.11 for currentness.
- Stop or return. The result states the current stop and the dependency or use change that would reopen it.