A.11:8 - SoTA-Echoing
Receiving use and reuse. Two historical ontology-engineering contributions supply comparison methods. Noy and McGuinness, Ontology Development 101 (2001), §3, use competency questions to specify the intended application and test whether an ontology supplies enough information, and recommend considering existing ontologies for reuse. Shimizu, Hirt and Hitzler, MODL: A Modular Ontology Design Library (2019), §§3.2–3.3, develop reusable, adaptable modules whose competency questions identify the intended answers. A.11 applies this comparison to the receiving claim or use and the best existing FPF expression.
Construction and identity. Florio and Linnebo, Introduction to Constructional Ontology (2024), §§1 and 3, distinguish constructors, inputs and constructional processes, and show how construction choices bear on identity: a set has its particular elements, while the same sum can have different decompositions. Borgo and Righetti, Towards Applied Constructional Ontology (2025), §§3–5, explore reconstructions of BFO, DOLCE and UFO with explicit choices about dependence, parthood, inherence and participation. Their exploratory comparison helps expose which construction and relation account a candidate uses.
FPF synthesis. Recovering a candidate’s construction and identity establishes what the proposed addition concerns. A.11 then asks whether a new durable kind changes admissible claims, boundaries or work-facing use. Its four gates combine material loss, non-redundancy, action-facing contribution and a boundary for the same candidate, use and facts. The complete E.24.UK admission decides the proposed U-kind’s disposition and root or dependent form.