B.4:4.3 - Keep the four phase claims distinct
These phases distinguish questions and results, not necessarily disjoint clock intervals. Operation and observation can overlap. Identify the activities and result dependencies needed for the transition; qualify particular Work claims under B.4:4.2.
| Phase | Question | Output and boundary |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Operate | How is the current subject operating or being used? | Name the current use or operation and any records that exist. Monitoring may occur, but a record does not establish an observation, comparison, or change. |
| 2. Observe | What do records, measurements, testimony, or other evidence show for the use? | Identify the observation, comparison or interpretation and who carried it out when that matters. State the observed basis, finding, hypothesis or unclear cue under the result or evidence rule, including what remains unresolved. A sufficient observation result can finish the question before a change is selected. |
| 3. Refine | What change, if any, does the receiving use need, and what identity relation would it have? | Develop or select a candidate change when needed. Establish the grounds required for its intended use, reusing applicable results and performing any needed revision or tests. State a continuity, successor, substitution, refinement or edition relation only when its endpoints exist and its conditions obtain; otherwise retain the identity question or intended treatment. A selected candidate does not establish availability for renewed use. |
| 4. Deploy | How was the selected change made available for use? | Identify the deployment activity and what it established—for example, a changed or produced entity, publication, configuration, release or availability—under the rule for that fact. Acceptance, admission and later use remain separate claims. |
State transition conditions:
- Operate -> Observe: a named cue, question, monitoring result, or review need requires interpretation.
- Observe -> Refine: the remaining question requires considering a change, and an observed basis or routed cue supports forming that change question.
- Refine -> Deploy: one candidate is selected, the conditions required for that deployment are met, and its subject-specific identity question or intended treatment is explicit. State an obtaining continuity, successor, substitution, refinement, or edition relation here only when both endpoints exist; otherwise keep the question open until the change or production has occurred.
- Deploy -> Operate: renewed operation or use begins; availability does not close this transition.
Evidence is not a fifth phase. Evidence relations warrant the observed basis, candidate choice, transition, or renewed-use claim when a receiver relies on them. Evidence can be produced or used during several phases without duplicating those phases.