Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:10:10 UTC

B.4:4.4 - Connect neighbouring cycles without collapsing them

The Canonical Reasoning Cycle (B.5) can supply reasoning Work within Observe and Refine. The B.5.1 development states and B.4 phases coordinate, but they are not a one-to-one implementation: a finding may reopen Exploration or Shaping, evidence use can support Evidence, and renewed use can enter or return to Operation.

When a preserve-worthy cue needs publication while its interpretation remains open, A.16.1 supplies a PreArticulationCuePack. Use B.4.1 after stabilization when a recipient needs possible continuations or a route choice made explicit. Its routed result can return to Refine or enter another subject pattern when that pattern’s entry conditions hold.

Keep the account proportional. A local answer can identify the current subject, observed basis, what occurred, the supported identity conclusion or open question, and the next use or contribution still needed. A sufficient answer need not complete another phase. Expand to a complete cycle trace when a relying decision, assurance case, audit or later replay needs it; retain missing phases as missing.

Didactic Note: four practical questions

  1. Operate: What subject is operating or being used now?
  2. Observe: What has use shown, and who made the observation or interpretation when that matters?
  3. Refine: What change is being considered, and would it continue or replace the subject?
  4. Deploy: How was the selected change made available, and what separately established fact now supports the next use?

The gain is a readable connection from an observed basis to a change and back to use, preserving the subject’s identity, the activities and results, and their grounds.