G.2 - Harvest and Synthesize SoTA for a CG-Frame
Type: Architectural (A) Status: Stable Normativity: Normative (unless marked informative)
Purpose. Provide a repeatable, auditable way to discover, triage, and synthesize state‑of‑the‑art (SoTA) across competing
Traditionlineages for CHR/CAL/LOG authoring and method selection in aCG‑Frame.Start here. Write the question the receiving CHR, CAL or selector work must answer. Before counting coverage, fix the source population and what counts as the same family. Distill the first source claims with their editions, evidence and limits, keeping competing lineages separate. The first useful result is a claim set that can answer part of that question and expose what is still missing. Use the manifest below when developing it into a conforming synthesis pack; a single-source fact lookup can return its source directly without creating such a pack. The primary output is a
SoTA Synthesis Pack@CG‑Framethat feeds:
- naming/publication (UTS),
- CHR authoring (G.3),
- CAL authoring (G.4),
- method/generator registries and dispatch (G.5).
Scope note. This pattern governs the harvesting + synthesis generator in Part G. Use G.10 to ship the pack and G.11 to orchestrate refresh.
Terminology (normative). The Tech token
Traditiondenotes a plural lineage with internally coherent commitments. Normative clauses may use the Plain term “tradition” only for that same meaning (1:1).
G.2:1 - Problem frame
A team extends FPF into a new CG‑Frame. The relevant literature is typically:
- plural (multiple
Traditionlineages with incompatible commitments), - source- and use-sensitive (results depend on the exact source and edition, claim region, EntityOfConcern, comparison basis, evidence, and receiving use),
- method‑heterogeneous (different evidence styles, operator sets, and validity regions),
- time-sensitive (new evidence or changed benchmarks and protocols can alter a claim’s applicability).
Downstream Part-G work in CHR, CAL, selection, shipping, and refresh depends on citation-ready claims that keep each exact CG-frame, source edition, claim region, EntityOfConcern, comparison basis, evidence anchor, and actual cross-source relation recoverable.
G.2:2 - Problem
How can we systematically assemble a SoTA view that is:
- pluralist but comparable (preserve plurality and establish the correspondence and comparison basis required for the intended use),
- evidence‑addressable (claims cite auditable evidence surfaces and anchors),
- actionable (supplies source-qualified claims and candidate inventories for G.3, G.4 and G.5),
- refreshable (the editions, policies and any applicable windows are pinned so RSCR/refresh can re‑audit and re‑run without semantic drift)?
G.2:3 - Forces
- Pluralism vs. consolidation. Consolidation is valuable, but unqualified fusion destroys meaning.
- Breadth vs. load‑bearing depth. Too broad becomes shallow; too deep misses rival lineages.
- Recency vs. stability. Freshness matters, yet durable “backbone” claims must be identified and kept visible.
- Pedagogy vs. rigour. Outputs must be teachable enough to support review, while remaining audit‑ready.
- Authoring vs. operations. This pattern governs authoring; use the applicable Work and decision patterns for operational runs and decisions.
G.2:4 - Solution
G.2:4.1 - G.Core linkage (normative)
Builds on: G.Core (Part‑G core invariants; citation/delegation hub)
GCoreLinkageManifest (normative).
(Canonical form, Nil‑elision, and Expansion rule are defined in G.Core.)
GCoreLinkageManifest := ⟨
CoreConformanceProfileIds := {
GCoreConformanceProfileId.PartG.AuthoringBase,
GCoreConformanceProfileId.PartG.UTSWhenPublicIdsMinted
},
RSCRTriggerSetIds := {GCoreTriggerSetId.SoTAHarvestSynthesis},
CorePinSetIds := {GCorePinSetId.PartG.CrossingVisibilityPins}, // expands only for actual channel/receiving-use conditions under G.Core:4.2.3
CorePinsRequired := {
// Scope pins (G.2‑specific)
CGFrameId, // identifies the exact CG-frame, which is the declared framing episteme; its cited ClaimGraph keeps source and edition, claim regions, EntityOfConcern, comparison basis, and intended use recoverable
Tradition[],
entityOfConcern := ⟨GroundingHolon, ReferencePlane⟩,
SoTA_SetId,
SoTAPaletteDescriptionId,
// Evidence / provenance pins (G.2‑specific)
CorpusLedgerId,
FlowRecordId,
EvidenceAnchorRef[],
EvidenceGraphId?,
// Crossing / synthesis pins (delta beyond CorePinSetIds; only when used)
GammaEpistSynthId[]?,
// Edition / policy pins (only when used)
HarvestPolicyRef?, // required when a coverage judgement is made
CoverageJudgementRef?, // the pack judgement, required for a relied-on coverage result
DistanceDefRef.edition?,
InclusionCriteriaId?,
ScreeningRubricId?
},
DefaultsConsumed := ∅,
TriggerAliasMapRef := ∅
⟩
(RSCR payload pins: ClaimSheetId[], SoTA_SetId, SoTAPaletteDescriptionId, BridgeMatrixId?, GammaEpistSynthId[]?, UTSRowId[]?, DistanceDefRef.edition?, HarvestPolicyRef?, InclusionCriteriaId?, ScreeningRubricId?, PathId/PathSliceId? when path‑citable evidence or a stable freshness window is pinned.)
Pattern‑local default. G.2 defines this coverage threshold outside the Part‑G-wide DefaultId set.
FamilyCoverageFloorK := 3 (unless explicitly overridden by HarvestPolicyRef and recorded in FlowRecord). This threshold supplies no counted population or same-family rule; those must be explicit before a coverage judgement. An undefined basis is unassessable, not a measured failure. Whenever coverage is judged, HarvestPolicyRef is required even when k uses this fallback; its applicability, receiving question, counted population/scope, grouping and same-family equivalence must be fixed before counting. An override changes k, not the unit or the independent pluralism duties.
Counted-family basis. The HarvestPolicy defines which candidates enter the counted population and when two entries represent the same family for this receiving question. Count equivalence classes under that rule. Repeated cards, aliases and source references for one family add zero. A combined method/generator population needs one receiving purpose and an overlap rule: a generator that is also a method is not counted twice unless the policy deliberately defines separate role-qualified units and justifies that interpretation. Freeze this basis before inspecting the count; changing it to turn a failure into three is not a repair of coverage.
The pack’s coverage judgement carries the policy/edition, counted units, deduplication basis, count, k and pass/fail result, or the exact missing basis when unassessable. Give this existing pack component a local CoverageJudgementRef for citation. Evaluate lineage and materially distinct entry plurality separately. Cards and downstream consumers cite this same judgement instead of choosing their own unit. Compare counts across packs only when their bases match, or after an explicitly justified common-basis recount.
G.2:4.2 - Kit: SoTA Synthesis Pack@CG‑Frame (surface governed by this pattern)
A conforming G.2 publication produces a notation‑independent pack whose internal organisation is free, but whose exported named components and views are stable and citable:
Each named component is addressable via a stable pack‑local identifier (e.g., CorpusLedgerId, ClaimSheetId, FlowRecordId) for citation and RSCR scoping. If any component is minted/evolved as a public id, it is published and cited via UTSRowId[] per CC‑GCORE‑UTS‑1 (delegation).
-
SoTA_Set@CG‑Frame(export view; “M2 output” consumed downstream) A read‑optimised view of the harvested candidate set for downstream generators and selectors. Constraint (normative):SoTA_Set@CG‑FrameMUST be reconstructible from pack components by id. Its coverage result cites the pack’sCoverageJudgementRef, including its fixed HarvestPolicy basis; the export view does not redefine family membership. -
G.2a CorpusLedgerLedger of candidate sources. Each row names the exact source and edition, claim region used, triage status (for example, include, park, or retire), evidence locator, and rationale for this CG-frame and receiving use. -
G.2b ClaimSheets[Tradition]Typed Claim Sheets perTradition, each with:- exact source and edition, claim region, effective ReferenceScheme where meaning matters, EntityOfConcern, and comparison basis for the stated use,
- explicit evidence anchors/citations (A.10 and/or EvidenceGraph refs when available),
- the currentness basis relevant to the claim’s use, including any applicable freshness window and risk/trust cues (cite
B.3when using trust/decay claims).
-
G.2c OperatorAndObjectInventoryInventory of candidate CHR terms (characteristics, scales and coordinates) and CAL operators or flows for downstream authoring. Cite the governing artefact and typing grounds for an entry already established as lawful. Mark the other candidates as stubs. -
G.2d BridgeMatrixA citable alignment/divergence surface acrossTradition×Tradition, with explicit losses and row scopes. If any row asserts substitution or fusion across sources or acrossTraditionrecords, the pack MUST attach aGammaEpistSynthIdrecord (alias:G.2‑F) perG.2:Ext.GammaEpistSynthesis(no silent fusion). -
G.2e MicroExamplesWorked micro-examples for load-bearing claims. Each names the exact source and edition, claim region, EntityOfConcern, comparison basis, and intended use; cites its evidence carrier or A.10 evidence-provenance path; and annotates the assurance contributions selected for that claim and use underB.3/B.3.3. When evidence-lane tags are used, cite their declared regime;C.2.2:4.6defines the KD-CALTA,VA, andLAlanes. The example card is only a publication form for those claims. -
G.2f UTSProposalsDraft Name Cards + Minimal Definitional Sheets (MDS) + alias proposals (incl. concept‑set linkage where applicable), with the required publication pins. -
G.2g entityOfConcern MapMap from key terms/claims/public ids toGroundingHolon,ReferencePlane, and minimal reference cues for later CHR/CAL authoring. -
G.2h PRISMA Flow RecordA screening/eligibility trail for how sources entered the pack (method‑profile is allowed; see Extensions). (Name is historical; the artefact remains notation‑independent.) The pack coverage judgement and its policy basis are recoverable here, separately from the lineage and material-entry pluralism results. -
G.2i SoSIndicatorFamiliesIndicator families as variants (windows/constraints/assumptions) with explicit Acceptance branches per variant (branch ids/labels only; threshold semantics belong to CAL governing definitions). -
G.2j MethodFamilyCardsCandidate method families with a shared signature and a plurality of implementations, each with validity regions, cost/complexity notes, and known failure modes. When the pack targets downstream registry/dispatch, MethodFamily cards SHOULD include the declared refs and pinsG.5needs (eligibility predicate refs, assurance profile cues, and the pack ids that justify the family). -
G.2k GeneratorFamilyCards(if applicable) Candidate generator families for environment/task generation with declared validity regions and transfer hooks. -
G.2l Annexes(optional; governing-definition-cited; see Extensions) For example: QD/NQD annexes, discipline‑specific indicator annexes, interop forms.
SoTAPaletteDescription (export view; required downstream)
Its pack-local SoTAPaletteDescriptionId identifies the view that binds these components.
- the
SoTA_Set@CG‑Frameview, ClaimSheetId[],OperatorAndObjectInventory,BridgeMatrixId?,SoSIndicatorFamilies(with variant/branch structure),MethodFamilyCards/GeneratorFamilyCards?,MicroExamples,UTSProposals,- and the
entityOfConcern Mapfor citation and later CHR/CAL authoring.
G.3/G.4/G.5 use this export view to find and cite the pack components.
Editorial template: 1‑page “SoTA Sheet” per Tradition (informative).
A one-page ClaimSheets[Tradition] template can collect the scope, claims, evidence anchors, validity region, failure modes, any applicable freshness window, cross‑Tradition reuse notes and pointers to micro‑examples.
G.2:4.3 - Harvester loop (conceptual choreography; pattern-governed)
Apply the following operations to the declared source population. A conforming pack satisfies its declared gates. When the available basis does not satisfy them, return the supported bounded result and the unmet condition; repeat a search or repair only when an attainable contribution justifies it.
-
Declare scope and plurality. Identify the exact CG-frame (the declared framing episteme), the initial
Traditionset, each intended claim region and EntityOfConcern, the comparison basis, and the receiving use. Record the cited CG-frame and source editions and evidence anchors in the pack pins rather than hiding them in a generic context field. Before counting, fix the HarvestPolicy’s receiving question, counted population, grouping and same-family equivalence, including overlap handling for a combined population. -
Discover and triage sources (ledger‑first). Populate
CorpusLedgervia:- adding seed sources,
- expansion via citation chaining and keyword family exploration,
- pruning using load‑bearing relevance tests tied to the declared CG‑Frame scope.
-
Distill claims per
Tradition. For eachTradition, author a Claim Sheet that preserves internal commitments and cites evidence anchors. Do not fuse cross‑Traditionclaims at this stage. -
Inventory operators/objects for downstream authoring. Identify candidate measurement terms and operators for downstream CHR/CAL authoring. Mark proposals as stubs. Cite an already governed CHR/CAL artefact and its grounds when reusing it. The inventory does not decide legality or set acceptance thresholds.
-
Build alignment/divergence surfaces. Where reuse across
Traditionis desired, record the obtaining correspondence and its exact basis inBridgeMatrix: F.9 for sense correspondence, C.3.3 for kind correspondence, or the direct rule for a plane relation, as actually used. State preserved distinctions and losses for the receiving question. Consolidation requires explicit alignment proof. Add bundle or gate anchors only for an independently applicable E.18 flow crossing or A.21 gate, underCC‑GCORE‑CROSS‑1. -
(Alias: G.2‑F) Construct a needed synthesis and record asserted fusion/substitution. Use B.1.3:4.4 to construct a joint conclusion from the source claims when the receiving question needs one. Recover their support and conflict relations, shared dependencies, subject and applicability before composing. A qualified synthesis with separately stated support can suffice when no common numerical model is justified.
If a
G.2pack publication asserts fusion or substitution across sources or acrossTraditionrecords (beyond mere “parallel divergent claims”), it MUST emitGammaEpistSynthIdrecords perG.2:Ext.GammaEpistSynthesis(provenance union + explicit object alignment refs + assurance tuple refs), and it MUST applyCC‑GCORE‑PEN‑1to its loss assessment and any numerical assurance penalty. -
Publish teachable micro‑groundings. Attach worked micro-examples that explain the load-bearing claim and a consequential variation in its conditions. Keep them within the claim’s supported scope. Each retains the source and edition, claim region, EntityOfConcern, comparison basis, intended use and evidence carrier or A.10 evidence-provenance path.
-
Apply gates and record repairs. Apply the fixed HarvestPolicy basis and count its distinct units before comparing coverage with
FamilyCoverageFloorK(and apply any optional diversity-by-distance gate under its own basis). Missing count semantics returns an unassessable result and the exact missing basis. If a defined gate fails:- record the failed criterion, count and basis in
FlowRecord, with the relevant corpus entries recoverable; - identify a missing relevant lineage, venue or source region that could change the result, and judge whether the available search or repair is worth undertaking for the receiving use;
- if it is, perform the search or repair and recount under the declared policy. Record what was done and the new result in
FlowRecord, citing any affectedCorpusLedgerentries. Pin the new references for any justified change to the policy or criteria and keep the earlier judgement with its original basis; - otherwise return the scoped claims and failed or incomplete pack judgement, its receiving-use limit and any precise remaining inquiry. Preserve the failed gate rather than treating the partial result as a conforming pack.
For example, an exhausted bounded population containing two method families fails a declared
k=3method-only gate. A further report about either family does not change that count. A known unexamined source region may justify another search; without one, the count and coverage failure can be the completed bounded answer. Missing population or equivalence rules instead leave the count judgement unassessable. - record the failed criterion, count and basis in
-
Emit hand‑off manifests and export views. Produce explicit manifests to:
so that downstream work can cite pack components by id rather than re‑authoring them. Each relied-on coverage result carries the same
CoverageJudgementRefand its policy basis; a downstream method-selection use cannot treat a combined method/generator count as a method-only count. The pack MUST also exportSoTA_Set@CG‑FrameandSoTAPaletteDescriptionas the default downstream consumption surfaces (ids pinned).
G.2:4.4 - Interfaces (minimal I/O Standard)
| Interface | Consumes | Produces |
|---|---|---|
| G.2-1 Harvest | exact CG-frame (the declared framing episteme) identified by CGFrameId, initial Tradition[], source edition and claim-region boundary, EntityOfConcern, comparison basis, receiving use, HarvestPolicyRef whenever coverage is judged | SoTA Synthesis Pack@CG-Frame (G.2a-G.2l) |
| G.2‑2 Extend | existing Pack + new sources/anchors + the applicable policy pins, updated if the policy changed | updated Pack + RSCR‑relevant trigger emissions (canonical kinds) |
| G.2‑3 HandOff | Pack | CHR‑handoff (to G.3), CAL‑handoff (to G.4), Registry‑handoff (to G.5) |
Note: Orchestration of re‑runs is governed by G.11; this pattern only defines what a conforming (re)harvest produces and what pins it must expose.
G.2:4.5 - Extensions (pattern‑scoped; non‑core)
Extensions are pattern‑scoped annexes. They do not introduce Part‑G‑wide norms; they declare the additional pins required when those semantics are active and cite the corresponding governing patterns.
G.2:4.5.1 - GPatternExtension: GammaEpistSynthesis
PatternScopeId: G.2:Ext.GammaEpistSynthesis
GPatternExtensionId: GammaEpistSynthesis
GPatternExtensionKind: GeneratorSpecific
GoverningPatternId: G.2
Uses: {G.Core, B.3, F.9, G.6} (penalty routing + trust/decay cues + bridges/CL + evidence path citation when used)
⊑/⊑⁺: ∅
RequiredPins/EditionPins/PolicyPins (minimum):
GammaEpistSynthId[](pack‑local ids of synthesis records; emitted iff fusion/substitution is asserted)EvidenceAnchorRef[](provenance union; evidence carriers cited by A.10 evidence-provenance paths)BridgeMatrixIdand the applicable correspondence references when a sense, kind or plane relation is used; includeBridgeCardId[]for an F.9 semantic bridgeCL/CL^planeandΦ/Ψ/Φ_plane policy-idswhen required by the cited crossing or actually used loss model (semantics and penalties →R_effremain governed by the cited definitions)PathId/PathSliceId?(only when citing viaG.6)
RSCRTriggerKindIds: {RSCRTriggerKindId.EvidenceSurfaceEdit, RSCRTriggerKindId.CrossingBundleEdit, RSCRTriggerKindId.ReferencePlaneEdit, RSCRTriggerKindId.PenaltyPolicyEdit, RSCRTriggerKindId.PolicyPinChange, RSCRTriggerKindId.EditionPinChange}
Synthesis and its record (normative):
- For each asserted fusion/substitution, the auditable synthesis record identified by
GammaEpistSynthIdbinds: (i) provenance union, (ii) explicit object alignment refs, and (iii) assurance tuple refs underC.2.2:4.1, each tied to its exact assessed claim. A B.1.3Γ_epist^synthapplication and its returned episteme remain separate from this record. - This extension cites the
Γ‑fold,Φ, and penalty rules throughG.Coreand exposes the pins needed for replay. When B.3/C.2.2 supplies no justified common numerical score or loss calculation, retain the separate support, actual mapping limitations and bounded assurance conclusion; a synthesis record does not supply the missing model.
G.2:4.5.2 - GPatternExtension: HarvestProtocols
PatternScopeId: G.2:Ext.HarvestProtocols
GPatternExtensionId: HarvestProtocols
GPatternExtensionKind: MethodSpecific
GoverningPatternId: G.2
Uses: {B.3, A.10} (for freshness/decay and provenance anchors, when protocol requires them explicitly)
⊑/⊑⁺: ∅
RequiredPins/EditionPins/PolicyPins (minimum):
HarvestPolicyRef(declares the chosen protocol family and its parameters)FlowRecordId(protocol‑specific profile id or rubric id may be attached here)InclusionCriteriaId/ScreeningRubricId(ids only; semantics remain local to the protocol family)
RSCRTriggerKindIds: {RSCRTriggerKindId.PolicyPinChange, RSCRTriggerKindId.EditionPinChange, RSCRTriggerKindId.FreshnessOrDecayEvent}
Notes (extension discipline):
- This extension binds a declared protocol profile to the pack’s
FlowRecordwithout redefining evidence semantics.
G.2:4.5.3 - GPatternExtension: DHCAlignmentHooks
PatternScopeId: G.2:Ext.DHCAlignmentHooks
GPatternExtensionId: DHCAlignmentHooks
GPatternExtensionKind: DisciplineSpecific
GoverningPatternId: C.21 (DHC semantics)
Uses: {C.21, G.6, G.7} (DHC series + evidence path citations + bridge/CL regimes when alignment density is claimed)
⊑/⊑⁺: ∅
RequiredPins/EditionPins/PolicyPins (minimum):
DHCMethodRef.editionWindowRef?(if the DHC series is windowed)- exact F.17
SchemeSenseCellrefs used by the DHC comparison set (useSenseCellAddressRefwhere a durable address is needed; citeUTSRowId[]only for independently public ids) UTSRowId[]?(only if a cited cell or series id is independently minted or evolved as a public id)PathId[]/PathSliceId[](when alignment summaries cite evidence paths via G.6)
RSCRTriggerKindIds: {RSCRTriggerKindId.EditionPinChange, RSCRTriggerKindId.EvidenceSurfaceEdit, RSCRTriggerKindId.TelemetryDelta}
Notes (extension discipline):
- If DHC alignment summaries are emitted, this extension ensures the DHC method edition and the cited evidence paths are visible.
- AlignmentDensity uses C.21’s Unit
obtaining_relations/100_compared_cells: fix the exact compared F.17 cell set and count the exact obtaining directed F.9 relations, retaining each relation’s orientation and admitted-use qualifier. Keep observed loss in its evidence account. A CL calibration label does not include or exclude a relation by itself. Any independently justified receiving-use filter must name its own policy and resulting population; it is not a C.21 CL threshold. - For example, three obtaining directed relations in a fixed set of 100 compared cells give a density of 3 in that Unit. Changing a CL label while relation truth, population and admitted-use qualifier remain fixed leaves the density 3. A fourth calibration row labelled CL=2 with no obtaining relation adds nothing. If a use condition actually changes which relations qualify, restate that changed population before comparing densities.
G.2:4.5.4 - GPatternExtension: NQDAnnex
PatternScopeId: G.2:Ext.NQDAnnex
GPatternExtensionId: NQDAnnex
GPatternExtensionKind: MethodSpecific
GoverningPatternId: C.18 (NQD-CAL semantics). C.19 governs explore/exploit logging when used.
Uses: {C.18, C.19}
⊑/⊑⁺: ∅
RequiredPins/EditionPins/PolicyPins (minimum):
DescriptorMapRef.editionDistanceDefRef.editionInsertionPolicyRef(policy‑id/ref)EmitterPolicyRef(policy‑id/ref)TaskSignatureRef?(when QD mode is trait‑gated)
RSCRTriggerKindIds: {RSCRTriggerKindId.EditionPinChange, RSCRTriggerKindId.PolicyPinChange, RSCRTriggerKindId.TelemetryDelta, RSCRTriggerKindId.FreshnessOrDecayEvent}
Notes (extension discipline):
- This extension only pins the required references for replayability; it does not redefine QD semantics, dominance, or acceptance rules.
G.2:4.5.5 - GPatternExtension: InteropForms
PatternScopeId: G.2:Ext.InteropForms
GPatternExtensionId: InteropForms
GPatternExtensionKind: InteropSpecific
GoverningPatternId: G.13
Uses: {G.13}
⊑/⊑⁺: ∅
RequiredPins/EditionPins/PolicyPins (minimum):
ExternalIndexRef.editionClaimMapperRef.editionMappingPolicyRef(policy‑id/ref)UTSRowId[](for published external ids/aliases where relevant)
RSCRTriggerKindIds: {RSCRTriggerKindId.EditionPinChange, RSCRTriggerKindId.PolicyPinChange, RSCRTriggerKindId.TokenizationOrNameChange, RSCRTriggerKindId.EvidenceSurfaceEdit}
Notes (extension discipline):
- Interop affects only representation and citation routes; it must not introduce alternate legality gates or acceptance semantics.
G.2:4.6 - Palette first
SoTAPaletteDescription is the base, plurality-preserving palette. Keep it recoverable while displaying a derived front, archive or shortlist. A derived view declares its own comparison, retention or choice semantics; it does not replace the base palette or silently remove its members.
When the palette’s members are traditions, TraditionPalette is the reader-facing name for that same palette declaration. For methods, hypotheses or other members, use SoTAPaletteDescription or Palette + SubjectKind.
A TraditionFront is derived under a declared Q. A TraditionArchive is derived under a declared reachability or coverage rule. Pin each view’s governing basis separately; neither view renames Tradition or changes the base palette’s meaning.
Use richer geometry or atlas language when the comparison or retention question needs it to explain the derivation. Keep that interpretation separate from the palette’s default meaning.
G.2:4.7 - Optional atlas interpretation of a declared palette
Use TraditionAtlasView only when the reader needs several derived views or interpretive qualifiers together to understand a grouping, omission risk or comparison boundary. Otherwise use the palette and its declared front, archive or shortlist, or the thinner DeclaredSubstrateInterpretiveView. A naming-only question belongs to F.18.
TraditionAtlasView specializes DeclaredSubstrateAtlasView under A.19.DECLARED-SUBSTRATE-INTERPRETIVE-VIEW and retains that declaration by value: the base palette, active source set or result, TypedSetViews when several declared views are combined, the space/map references and interpretive qualifiers actually used, and the connections needed to answer the inspection question. Cite SearchSpaceRef or OutcomeSpaceRef for the corresponding declared spaces. Add SpaceMetricRef, TransitionRelationRef and BridgeDistortionNote only for the comparison, reachability, transition or cross-scale claim that needs them. An OutcomeMapRef identifies a mapping from the stated result into an outcome/effect space; it does not turn the palette or result into that space. Their formal claims retain their own governing definitions.
If the interpretation changes the base source-to-outcome relation or its distortion, reopen the substrate declaration. Different atlas views may use different spaces, metrics, relations or mathematical traditions; one view does not settle those choices for every other view.
G.2:5 - Archetypal Grounding (System / Episteme)
| Template element | U.System illustration | U.Episteme illustration |
|---|---|---|
| Tell | A safety engineering team needs to choose a control stack across robust-control, learning-based, and formal-verification lineages. It identifies the exact CG-frame (the declared framing episteme), vehicle and operating-envelope EntityOfConcern, source editions, claim regions, test or comparison basis, evidence anchors, and intended decision use. | A research group synthesizes SoTA on decision quality across named causal, evidential, bounded-rationality, and active-inference lineages, keeping each source edition, local claim, evidence norm, comparison basis, and intended research use explicit. |
| Show (failure) | The team merges source-local terms, treats incompatible test protocols and populations as comparable, and collapses partially ordered trade-offs into one unqualified score. A later safety review cannot recover which source, claim region, basis, or evidence supported the choice. | The group publishes one “best” metric and retrofits definitions to it. Conflicting claims cannot be traced because source editions, evidence anchors, comparison bases, and any actual cross-source relation were never made explicit. |
| Show (repair) | Keep parallel Claim Sheets with exact sources, editions, claim regions, EntitiesOfConcern, comparison bases, and evidence. Cite an F.9 Bridge and loss only for an actual relation. Authors of CHR, CAL, and selection methods can then use the citable claims without attributing authority to a card. | Preserve plural claims, represent indicators as families or variants, and expose freshness and evidence. Any justified alignment names its exact cells and obtaining relation; the card or matrix merely represents that result. |
G.2:5.1 - Count one pack under a declared basis
The following four hypothetical entries extend the control-stack example in §5. They illustrate how to count coverage under two different policies.
| Entry and distinct claim region | Lineage | Declared family unit |
|---|---|---|
| e1: robust controller’s operating-envelope claim | robust control | method M-R |
| e2: that family’s distinct disturbance-rejection claim | robust control | method M-R |
| e3: learned controller’s adaptation claim | learning-based control | method M-L |
| e4: scenario generator’s counterexample-generation claim | formal verification | generator G-S |
For the question “which control-method families can be selected?”, policy P-method counts method families only and equates entries exactly when they name the same declared method-family unit. The classes are {e1,e2} and {e3}: count 2, below k=3. Additional cards for e1 or citations for M-R leave the count at 2.
For the different question “which method and scenario-generator families can support building and evaluating this control stack?”, policy P-combined includes the three declared units M-R, M-L and G-S. Its overlap rule merges repeated references to one unit; these three units are stipulated distinct and G-S is not also M-R or M-L. Count 3 meets k=3 for that receiving purpose. This is not a passing method-only judgement and cannot be substituted after P-method fails. If one generator also qualified as a counted method, the overlap rule would have to resolve it before the count.
Four claim regions remain four material entries. The example independently has three lineages, so its two-lineage and three-material-entry pluralism duties pass under the stated facts in both policies. With no counted-family basis, family coverage is unassessable even though that pluralism result remains available. A justified k=2 override for P-method changes its threshold result while leaving its count at 2 and those independent duties unchanged.
G.1 M2 and the G.3–G.5 consumers cite the chosen pack judgement with its purpose and policy; they do not reconstruct a more convenient count from the cards.
G.2:6 - Bias-Annotation (informative)
-
Selection bias. Any harvesting protocol can over‑represent certain venues, languages, or evidence styles. Mitigation: pluralism floor + explicit
CorpusLedger+ explicit protocol pins. -
Consolidation bias. Pressure to “merge” lineages can erase incompatible commitments. Mitigation: keep Claim Sheets disjoint by default; require explicit alignment proof for fusion; preserve loss notes.
-
Recency bias. Overweighting newest papers can hide durable backbone results; underweighting them misses SoTA drift. Mitigation: state the search date and use-relevant currentness basis; make changes to relied-on sources or applicable windows RSCR-relevant.
-
Didactic bias. Micro‑examples can steer interpretation toward familiar domains. Mitigation: show the operation and a consequential variation within the claim’s supported scope, with explicit source anchors; add a different substrate only when the claim and its grounds cover that transfer.
G.2:7 - Conformance Checklist (normative) — CC‑G2
| ConformanceId | Requirement | Purpose / Notes |
|---|---|---|
| CC‑G2‑CoreRef | A conforming G.2 artefact MUST satisfy the effective core obligations declared by the GCoreLinkageManifest in G.2:4.1 (per G.Core Expansion rule). | Keeps core invariants governed by G.Core. |
| CC-G2-Pluralism-1 | A conforming pack MUST include at least two Tradition lineages and at least three materially distinct entries, each identified by its source edition and claim region, with its EntityOfConcern, evidence norm, and comparison limits visible. | Prevents a single lineage or one renamed source cut from masquerading as synthesis. |
| CC‑G2‑Ledger‑1 | A conforming pack MUST include G.2a CorpusLedger with inclusion/triage status and explicit rationale hooks per entry. | Makes discovery/triage auditable. |
| CC‑G2‑FlowRecord‑1 | A conforming pack MUST include G.2h FlowRecord that traces identification → screening → eligibility → included at a minimum granularity sufficient to reproduce the corpus boundary. | Prevents “mystery inclusion” and supports refresh. |
| CC-G2-ClaimSheets-1 | For each included Tradition, the pack MUST include a Claim Sheet identified by ClaimSheetId that names exact sources and editions, claim regions, effective schemes where meaning matters, EntitiesOfConcern, comparison bases, evidence anchors, freshness notes, and intended use; it MUST NOT fuse cross-Tradition claims by default. | Keeps plurality and provenance explicit without a Context container. |
| CC‑G2‑Palette‑1 | A conforming pack MUST export SoTA_Set@CG‑Frame and SoTAPaletteDescription as citable views (via SoTA_SetId, SoTAPaletteDescriptionId) and ensure both are reconstructible from pack components by id (no hidden extra structure). | Prevents downstream scraping of prose; keeps “M2 output” explicit. |
| CC‑G2‑Palette‑2 | If the pack exports one derived tradition view such as TraditionFront or TraditionArchive, it MUST keep SoTAPaletteDescription explicit as the default base palette, keep that derivation recoverable, and cite the declared Q or reachability/coverage rule that disciplined that view. Derived tradition views MUST NOT silently replace the palette’s default meaning. | Keeps non-default tradition views recoverable without redefining palette-first semantics. |
| CC‑G2‑AtlasInterpretation‑1 | If the pack exports TraditionAtlasView, it MUST satisfy §4.7 and the cited A.19 interpretive-view declaration by value, including the connections needed to answer the inspection question. | Keeps atlas use conditional and its interpretation recoverable. |
| CC‑G2‑entityOfConcernMap‑1 | A conforming pack MUST include G.2g entityOfConcern Map, mapping (at minimum) each load‑bearing claim family and each minted/evolved public id to entityOfConcern := ⟨GroundingHolon, ReferencePlane⟩, and citing the relevant ClaimSheetId and evidence anchors (A.10 and/or G.6 paths when used). | Keeps plane/holon boundaries explicit and citable. |
| CC‑G2‑Alignment‑1 | Cross‑Tradition consolidation SHALL present either disjoint parallel claims with explicit divergence or an explicitly justified alignment proof. Reuse MUST cite the exact basis for every sense, kind or plane relation actually used and disclose its preservation and losses. Bundle/gate anchors MUST be supplied when an E.18 flow crossing or A.21 gate independently requires them, per CC‑GCORE‑CROSS‑1. | A kind correspondence alone requires neither an F.9 sense Bridge nor a flow-crossing bundle. |
| CC‑G2‑GammaSynth‑1 | If the pack asserts fusion or substitution across sources or across Tradition records (not merely “parallel divergent claims”), it MUST emit GammaEpistSynthId records satisfying G.2:Ext.GammaEpistSynthesis (provenance union + explicit alignment refs + assurance tuple refs). | Keeps the synthesis record (alias: G.2‑F) citable under its governing definitions. |
| CC‑G2‑Inventory‑1 | A conforming pack MUST include G.2c OperatorAndObjectInventory, sufficient for downstream CHR/CAL authoring to begin without re‑harvesting terms. | Ensures the pack is actionable. |
| CC‑G2‑Inventory‑2 | G.2c OperatorAndObjectInventory entries MUST NOT embed acceptance thresholds or decide legality locally. An entry may cite a governed CHR/CAL artefact with the grounds required by CC‑G2‑MeasurementLawful‑1. If an entry is not a citation of an already governed CHR/CAL artefact, it MUST be explicitly marked as stub (typing/lawfulness TBD) and MUST NOT be used as if lawful. Legality/threshold semantics are governed by G.3 for CHR and G.4 for CAL via explicit ids/pins. | Prevents “shadow CHR/CAL” and preserves lawfulness discipline without redefining it locally. |
| CC‑G2‑MeasurementLawful‑1 | If any inventory entry is presented as non‑stub (i.e., already lawful/typed), the pack MUST cite the governing lawfulness discipline (e.g., A.17–A.19/C.16 as applicable) and provide the minimal evidence anchors needed to justify that typing claim. | Prevents “quietly lawful” measurement claims inside the harvester pack. |
| CC-G2-MicroExamples-1 | For every load-bearing claim family, a conforming pack includes worked grounding that lets the reader obtain its result and handle a consequential change of conditions within the supported scope. Each example names the source and edition, claim region, EntityOfConcern, comparison basis and intended use; cites its evidence carrier or A.10 provenance path; and states the assurance contributions actually selected under B.3/B.3.3. | Preserve the grounding needed to understand and adapt the claimed contribution. |
| CC‑G2‑UTS‑1 | If the pack proposes or evolves any public ids, it MUST publish UTS proposals (Name Cards + MDS where applicable) and cite them via UTSRowId[], satisfying CC‑GCORE‑UTS‑1 (delegation). | Keeps naming and evolution disciplined. |
| CC‑G2‑Families‑1 | SoS indicators and candidate evaluation constructs SHALL be represented as families/variants (windows/constraints/assumptions) with explicit Acceptance branch structure per variant (branch ids/labels only), not as single unqualified scalars; any scalar summary MAY be included only as report‑only unless explicitly promoted by governing patterns. (Set-return discipline is delegated to CC‑GCORE‑SET‑1.) | Prevents covert scalarization and keeps acceptance governed by downstream patterns. |
| CC‑G2‑HandOff‑1 | A conforming pack MUST emit hand‑off manifests to G.3, G.4, and G.5 that cite pack components by id and identify which families/operators are intended for downstream formalisation or registry entry. | Prevents downstream re‑authoring and drift. |
| CC‑G2‑CoverageGate‑1 | The pack MUST declare FamilyCoverageFloorK and enforce it as a harvesting gate. It MUST either (i) specify k in HarvestPolicyRef, or (ii) use the pattern‑local default rule governed by CC‑G2‑CoverageGate‑1. Default threshold (pattern-local): k=3. In both threshold branches, HarvestPolicyRef MUST fix the receiving question, population/scope, grouping, same-family equivalence and overlap rule before counting. The pack judgement cites that basis, its distinct units and result; all consumers reuse it. Missing basis returns unassessable. Duplicate references add zero, and a threshold override changes neither the units nor the independent duties in CC-G2-Pluralism-1. If the defined gate fails, record the criterion, count and basis in FlowRecord. When an identified relevant source region or operation can make a worthwhile contribution, repeat the search or repair and record that iteration and its result in FlowRecord. Otherwise return the bounded supported claims, failed/incomplete pack judgement and exact remaining inquiry under :4.3. A selected exploration policy is pinned. | Makes the coverage judgement and its receiving-use limit explicit. |
| CC‑G2‑DistanceGate‑1 | If a diversity‑by‑distance gate is used, the pack MUST pin DistanceDefRef.edition and the declared threshold (δ), and treat edits as RSCR‑relevant per CC‑GCORE‑TRIG‑* (delegation). If no such gate is used, the pack SHALL explicitly state that it is not used. | Avoids implicit distance defaults and improves refreshability. |
| CC‑G2‑RSCR‑1 | A conforming pack MUST emit canonical RSCRTriggerKindId causes (not free text) for edits to evidence surfaces, name/tokenization surfaces (e.g., UTS proposals/aliases), crossings, planes, edition pins, and harvesting policy pins (HarvestPolicyRef), per CC‑GCORE‑TRIG‑1…TRIG‑4 (delegation). | Keeps refresh reason codes stable and typed. |
| CC‑G2‑Ext‑GammaEpist‑1 | If G.2:Ext.GammaEpistSynthesis is used (i.e., any fusion/substitution is asserted), the pack SHALL expose the required pins listed in that extension and SHALL NOT redefine Γ‑fold/Φ/penalty semantics locally (cite governing definitions by delegation). | Keeps synthesis auditable without creating shadow specs. |
| CC‑G2‑Ext‑HarvestProtocols‑1 | If G.2:Ext.HarvestProtocols is used, the pack SHALL expose the required pins/criteria ids listed in that extension and SHALL NOT redefine evidence/quality semantics outside the declared protocol profile. | Keeps protocol variation explicit and separately citable. |
| CC-G2-Ext-DHC-1 | If G.2:Ext.DHCAlignmentHooks is used, expose the DHC method edition, exact compared F.17 cell population, counted obtaining directed F.9 relation refs with their orientation and admitted-use qualifiers, evidence paths, and C.21 Unit obtaining_relations/100_compared_cells. CL labels alone neither change that population nor impose a counting threshold. Cite any separate receiving-use policy under its own authority. | Keeps the quantity identical to the C.21/G.7 definition. |
| CC‑G2‑Ext‑NQD‑1 | If G.2:Ext.NQDAnnex is used, the pack SHALL expose the required pins/editions/policies listed in that extension and SHALL NOT redefine QD semantics locally. | Keeps QD/OEE extension pins replayable and non‑shadowing. |
| CC‑G2‑Ext‑Interop‑1 | If G.2:Ext.InteropForms is used, the pack SHALL expose the required interop pins and SHALL NOT introduce alternative legality/acceptance semantics. | Prevents “foreign gate” shadowing. |
G.2:8 - Common Anti‑Patterns and How to Avoid Them
-
AP‑G2‑1: “One true SoTA score.” Avoid: selecting a single unqualified scalar metric as “the” SoTA. Do instead: represent evaluation constructs as families/variants; keep partial orders set‑returning (delegated).
-
AP‑G2‑2: Fusion without explicit alignment proof. Avoid: merging rival
Traditionclaims into one statement “by common sense.” Do instead: preserve parallel Claim Sheets; if consolidation is required, publish explicit alignment proof or keep a divergence record. -
AP‑G2‑3: Hidden protocol drift. Avoid: changing the harvesting protocol (inclusion criteria, windowing, screening rubric) without pins. Do instead: pin harvesting policy/profile ids and treat changes as RSCR‑relevant.
-
AP‑G2‑4: Unanchored pedagogy. Avoid: micro‑examples without carriers (they become folklore). Do instead: bind micro‑examples to A.10 anchors and declare
entityOfConcern. -
AP‑G2‑5: Atlas by default. Avoid: writing as if every tradition comparison or NQD/OEE note needs
TraditionAtlasView, or as if atlas wording renames the palette itself. Do instead: keep the base palette and derived front, archive, or shortlist explicit; use atlas form only when several declared views or interpretive qualifiers must be held together, and prefer thinnerDeclaredSubstrateInterpretiveViewwhen that is enough.
G.2:9 - Consequences
- Positive: Downstream CHR/CAL/dispatch work becomes faster and less ambiguous because the pack is citable and structured.
- Positive: Plural claims remain available, with the correspondences and comparison basis needed for any joint use.
- Positive: Refresh becomes tractable because pins and typed causes exist.
- Negative: Adds authoring overhead (ledger, flow record, micro‑examples, explicit pins).
- Negative: Requires governance discipline to prevent the pack from becoming an uncontrolled “everything bucket”.
G.2:10 - Rationale
Source-qualified claims let CHR/CAL authors and G.5 selectors reuse a comparison basis without re-harvesting it. Separate Claim Sheets preserve lineage commitments; justified mappings and support relations permit a qualified joint conclusion. The pack keeps these grounds citable for reuse and refresh.
G.2:11 - SoTA-Echoing — keep a reusable synthesis current without restarting it
Practice question. How should several downstream authors reuse a synthesis when new sources can change a consequential, unsettled comparison? The selected line keeps a question-bound source ledger, separable claims and explicit update causes; a living protocol is chosen when continuing evidence surveillance is worth its cost. A serious alternative is a well-reported static review with an explicit search date and a separately commissioned update. That alternative is sufficient for a stable question or a one-time decision and avoids maintaining a continuing review service.
The Cochrane Handbook v6.3 (2022), Chapter 22, §§22.2.3–4 supplies this earlier conditional living-review line and its resource trade-off: priority, uncertainty and likely new evidence can justify frequent updates, while additional searching needs resources. Adapt this conditional choice in HarvestProtocols; declare the search/update policy rather than treating every G.2 pack as perpetually living. The clinical-review guidance does not establish coverage or evidence adequacy for an arbitrary engineering CG-frame.
The PRISMA 2020 reporting guidance supplies a shared reporting basis for the static-review comparator. Its explanation of study selection distinguishes records, reports and included studies. Adapt the distinction to CorpusLedger, FlowRecord and the declared family units in §4.3: multiple source entries can concern one counted family. Reject treating a publication count or a completed flow diagram as proof of adequate family coverage. G.2’s k threshold, lineage duties and FPF alignment rules remain local decisions, not PRISMA requirements.
The 2024 PRISMA-LSR extension supplies the more specific reporting line for an actually selected living protocol: justify that mode, identify the version’s trigger and changes, and plan when to retire it. Adapt that distinction to the policy pins, change causes and downstream handoffs in §4.3 and G.2-2 Extend; G.11 governs refresh orchestration. Source reporting guidance does not supply an automatic update schedule or establish that a newly added claim is sound.
In the control-stack case (§5.1), if e1’s operating-envelope claim is revised, locate the changed source and claim in the ledger. Use the family card and handoff manifests to identify M-R and its affected consumers, then re-examine the claim and the comparisons that depend on it. The new report does not add a family. The method-only count remains 2 until a distinct method-family unit within the declared population is found. A static review can also be updated correctly, but each separate consumer must recover the changed basis unless a shared update is published. For the same new source and receiving question, the selected pack reuses existing screening and claim relations; its added maintenance burden is justified only while repeated shared use and consequential change make that work useful.
Reopen the choice of protocol when the evidence rate, decision importance, uncertainty or maintenance resources change; retire living surveillance when its reason no longer holds. Reopen an individual synthesis when a new source changes a relied-on claim, coverage judgement or alignment. A source with a new date but no relevant content change does not by itself warrant reconstructing every downstream conclusion.
G.2:12 - Relations
-
Builds on:
G.Core(core invariants, typed RSCR causes, Default Governing Definition Index)E.8(pattern template discipline)E.10(lexical/ontological rules; strict distinction; kind‑suffix discipline)E.19(conformance discipline)A.10(evidence-provenance paths and cited source/carrier anchors)A.19.DECLARED-SUBSTRATE-INTERPRETIVE-VIEW(generic interpretive-view and atlas discipline whenTraditionAtlasViewis used)A.6.P(space/view/publication precision restoration when palette/support claims collapse)B.3(trust, freshness/decay as cited governing patterns)F.9(bridges and CL as cited governing patterns)F.17(UTS publication discipline; via delegation)G.0(CG‑Spec legality gate; cited when legality surfaces are referenced)G.6(EvidenceGraph / path citation surfaces when used)
-
Used by:
G.1(generator chassis consumes harvested SoTA sets)G.3(CHR authoring consumes operator/object inventory and claim sheets)G.4(CAL authoring consumes operator stubs, acceptance branch scaffolding)G.5(registry/dispatch consumes MethodFamily/GeneratorFamily cards)G.10(shipping cites the pack as payload)G.11(refresh orchestration can re‑invoke harvest via typed causes)
-
Relates to: