Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:30:10 UTC

HCD.5:4.3 - Compare Method Fit and Evidence

For each serious candidate, record:

Selection positionRequired content
target contributionThe human action or judgement intended to change and its role in later Work.
proposed mechanismHow the Method is expected to change that target, what source or prior observation supports the expectation, and any plausible alternative explanation that matters.
task and learner fitStarting performance, prior knowledge, task complexity, similarity, support dependence, and the differences from serious alternatives that matter to this selection.
proposed form of practiceThe minimally sufficient explanation, demonstration, practice, feedback, correction, plan, coaching, or support change; identify a qualified professional description when local design would be unsafe or under-specified.
provider and access needCompetence, time, data, tools, AI, environment, supervision, permission, privacy, and peak-load conditions required for the Method.
burden and riskLearner and provider effort, displaced Work, error exposure, overload, autonomy, fatigue, clinical or safety risk, and the cost of another attempt or probe.
evidence planUse existing observations when sufficient. Select further observation only for a question that can change the choice or qualify a needed claim; retain the relevant help, conditions and inference limits. A design hypothesis can guide an attainable next action without a separate causal study.
alternatives and stopAny surviving alternatives or rejected candidates with reasons, conditions for stopping or returning, and the smallest change that would justify reconsidering the selection.

Compare the intended contribution and full enactment effort on the same basis for each candidate. A richly specified Method does not defeat an unnamed alternative; make only the smallest alternative description needed to expose a decision-bearing difference. Preserve source limits instead of transporting one average effect, hours threshold, cue, sequence, or professional arrangement to a different task and population.