HCD.5:4.3 - Compare Method Fit and Evidence
For each serious candidate, record:
| Selection position | Required content |
|---|---|
| target contribution | The human action or judgement intended to change and its role in later Work. |
| proposed mechanism | How the Method is expected to change that target, what source or prior observation supports the expectation, and any plausible alternative explanation that matters. |
| task and learner fit | Starting performance, prior knowledge, task complexity, similarity, support dependence, and the differences from serious alternatives that matter to this selection. |
| proposed form of practice | The minimally sufficient explanation, demonstration, practice, feedback, correction, plan, coaching, or support change; identify a qualified professional description when local design would be unsafe or under-specified. |
| provider and access need | Competence, time, data, tools, AI, environment, supervision, permission, privacy, and peak-load conditions required for the Method. |
| burden and risk | Learner and provider effort, displaced Work, error exposure, overload, autonomy, fatigue, clinical or safety risk, and the cost of another attempt or probe. |
| evidence plan | Use existing observations when sufficient. Select further observation only for a question that can change the choice or qualify a needed claim; retain the relevant help, conditions and inference limits. A design hypothesis can guide an attainable next action without a separate causal study. |
| alternatives and stop | Any surviving alternatives or rejected candidates with reasons, conditions for stopping or returning, and the smallest change that would justify reconsidering the selection. |
Compare the intended contribution and full enactment effort on the same basis for each candidate. A richly specified Method does not defeat an unnamed alternative; make only the smallest alternative description needed to expose a decision-bearing difference. Preserve source limits instead of transporting one average effect, hours threshold, cue, sequence, or professional arrangement to a different task and population.