MDPE.20:5 - Recognition and Assurance
A complete forecast or historical assessment answers the questions relevant to its use.
- What practice, population, place, period, horizon and question does the forecast concern?
- What structures and representations underlie the observations at the time in question, and what do they lose?
- Which mechanisms support the serious trajectories, including drift or absence of a stable attractor when plausible?
- Which distinguishing implications make the serious trajectories different, and what available basis or possible observation could narrow or defeat them?
- Which observations, models or qualified estimates support the forecast? For an empirical update, which obtained observation changed or preserved which conclusion and within what limits?
- Which developments does the evidence support, weaken or leave unresolved? What changed relative to an earlier forecast, if one is being compared?
- When a response is wanted, which preparation, intervention or stop follows under the conditions? What could alter it?
Check the distinctions that matter to the claim.
- Identify whether the claim concerns an individual change, a population distribution, prevalence, retention or loss.
- prototype, centrality, cluster, reconstruction bias, lineage, increasing frequency, and dynamics attractor remain different claims;
- Establish the relation between the relevant practice, its representation, the forecast, observed events, any decision or intervention and its possible effects.
- Give conditions and distinguishing implications for the serious trajectories. Retain warranted rivals when available observations do not settle them.
- an empirical update cites the observation actually obtained, its direct Method or source, evidence basis, source-to-claim relation, population, setting, uncertainty and transfer limit;
- Identify which trajectories and, when applicable, which decisions the evidence warrants. Qualified retention, a preparation common to several futures, a stop or an inconclusive result can complete the question.
- Identify the music or dance performers, material, structures, methods and setting, and any recognition task or probe that matters to the forecast.
- expert estimates show basis, uncertainty, and update condition;
- Use publications, standards, curricula, media or platform measures for what they document. For a claim about how common performance was, examine the relevant performances and sampling basis. For continued reproduction, examine the activity across the period.
- For a proposed intervention, identify decision authority, permission, affected participants and systems, and who bears any displaced work.
- Give a numerical probability only with a model and evidence adequate to that claim.