| “This rhythm is central, so it is the attractor.” | Identify the representation and meaning of centrality. A dynamical attractor needs appropriate transition and stability grounds. Consider reconstruction, performance, selection, branching or drift where plausible. |
| “The style is popular, so it will persist.” | Name population, sampling basis, reproduction relations, horizon, and evidence of continued reproduction. If changing a pressure would distinguish the forecasts, identify what could be observed and use suitable earlier observations where available. |
| “The creator caused the culture.” | Identify evidence of creation, publication, recognition, copying, transformation, selection or retention. Attribute a contribution at the scope the causal evidence supports. |
| “COIN explains style evolution.” | Keep COIN as one bounded sensorimotor-context hypothesis and preserve relevant capability, interference, partner, teaching, selection and population rivals. Choose additional tests by their actual contribution and whole cost. |
| “The model predicts 72%.” | Identify the variables, population, horizon, calibration and evidence that give 72% its meaning, and the question it answers. Use a qualitative forecast when the evidence supports only that. |
| “We have many scenarios.” | Give the supported mechanisms, distinct implications, evidence and remaining uncertainty. Include a practical response when required. An empirical update uses an observation actually obtained. |
| “Publishing the forecast will make it true.” | Treat the forecast’s influence as a possible cause. Identify evidence of exposure, any later change and the connection between the two. |
| “Our intervention selects the future.” | Keep project choice separate from distributed cultural recognition, selection, transmission, retention, and loss. |