Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:10:10 UTC

PSDA.5 - Generate Decision Alternatives

Type: Method pattern body Status: Stable

Primary working result: a finite candidate set for the inquiry. Identify the alternatives, the material distinctions among them and the grounds and unresolved conditions for their intended use. If only one direction or none is supported, give that result and its basis.

PSDA.5:1 - Problem frame

Use this when an inquiry has clarified what matters but the proposed decision still contains only the incumbent, a sponsor’s preferred project, or two labels such as “buy or build”. Also use it when a request for development advice names a course, provider, reorganization, or AI tool before the possible directions have been constructed.

Identify what action could address each material formulation or concern. Where a useful alternative is missing, vary the mechanism, arrangement, timing, combination or commitment. Describe each resulting candidate in enough detail for its intended comparison. Name any material gap that remains.

A candidate describes a possible intervention or commitment. Establish feasibility, permission, performance and benefit to the extent required for the intended use. Where candidates address different formulations, retain their different consequences in the comparison.

Use an adequate existing set directly for comparison or an authorized choice. Use the relevant domain practice if it already answers the alternative-generation question. A development-advice task needs a recipient or chooser for the subject concerned. For a population with neither, distinguish a researcher’s authorized intervention from advice to the population.

PSDA.5:2 - Problem

An apparently open choice can be closed before analysis begins. A list of pump models omits deployment arrangements; a list of training courses omits changing the Work that prevents capability expression; a list of AI models omits the tool, data, or operating configuration responsible for the failure.

Unrestricted ideation can repeat the same intervention under hundreds of names, depend on unsupported capacities or combine benefits that cannot coexist. Check the distinguishing consequence and the conditions for using each candidate. A workshop can identify a promising idea while its feasibility remains open.

PSDA.5:3 - Forces

ForceTension
Breadth and relevanceA different mechanism may expose a better direction, while an unbounded search consumes the decision horizon.
Plural formulationsAlternatives should address material interpretations without pretending that every interpretation seeks the same result.
Imagination and qualificationA proposal may be worth investigating before feasibility is known, while unsupported proposals cannot be presented as ready commitments.
Combination and interactionHybrid or staged directions can preserve options, while shared resources, incompatibilities, and delay can remove their apparent advantage.
Generation and choiceEarly preference helps identify concerns but can suppress candidates before their consequences are known.

PSDA.5:4 - Solution

Construct or complete the alternatives the question needs. Give each one enough content for its intended use. Distinguish a missing qualification from an established reason for exclusion. Return the bounded set or the particular alternative that remains missing.

PSDA.5:4.1 - Recover the receiving question and useful inputs

Identify the subject, question, horizon and any current arrangement. Establish applicable protections and resource limits. For advice or a proposed commitment, identify the recipient and the holder of the relevant decision or resource right where the task depends on them. Name any missing purpose or authority that limits what can be returned.

Use PSDA.1 where different formulations suggest different actions. Use a PSDA.3 model account where it distinguishes mechanisms or exposes a missing consequence. A PSDA.13 result may contribute an agreed observation or a contested claim that affects candidate construction.

Use a qualified direct result where it supplies the needed premise. If a premise is missing, stale or incompatible with the subject and horizon, identify the specific limit on the candidate.

PSDA.5:4.2 - Vary the decision-changing contents

Clarify the desired consequence, why it matters and what else could produce it. If early advocacy could anchor a group, have participants first generate ideas independently. Use relevant differences or objections to complete a candidate or construct a materially different one.

Consider changing the mechanism, obtaining arrangement, scale, timing, resource allocation or commitment. Other possibilities include combining compatible actions, retaining the present arrangement, declining a change or obtaining information before committing. Use the prompts that expose a material alternative.

When the known menu supplies no way to obtain a material desired consequence, use PSDA.6:4.2 to distinguish that end from the initially proposed means. Where their relationships need construction, use the backward branch of PSDA.8:4.2.1: trace necessary conditions and possible sufficient routes, propose a combination of means, and test that whole combination forward under the same assumptions. Return the resulting alternative here with its conditions and open transitions. An incompatible combination prompts another construction or a revised formulation; it does not prove that the desired result is impossible. Reuse an adequate direct construction without building another network.

Describe the baseline for “no new action”. It may include authorized maintenance, contractual duties, continuing costs, deterioration or exposure.

For a staged direction, describe the first action, the later choice, evidence that could inform it and any delay or irreversible consequences. Establish the feasibility, consent, safety and recovery conditions needed for a claim about reversibility. A small initial commitment can have lasting effects.

PSDA.5:4.3 - Turn labels into sufficiently complete candidates

Give the material change from the baseline, affected subjects, intended result, enabling conditions and substantial burdens for each candidate. Identify the evidence and any unresolved premise the next use needs.

Use C.38 when several whole ways aim at the same receiving result and their descriptions still hide different burdens. When they aim at different results, preserve that difference in the comparison.

A combination is a distinct candidate where interactions can change its consequences. Check the needed resources, dependencies, sequencing and compatibility of assumptions. For example, each branch may require the same qualified crew at the same time. A provider advertisement, course title or benchmark may suggest a candidate. Its fit for the holder needs evidence for that use.

PSDA.5:4.4 - Distinguish exploration from a live commitment option

Keep a promising proposal available for inquiry and identify the conditions for commitment. For example, it may be ready for a bounded comparison, require a stated qualification, or be excluded by an applicable constraint.

Use an adequate specialist result where it exists. If a consequential feasibility, allocation, transfer or security premise remains open, identify the affected candidate. Seek an outside contribution through A.15.9 if its attainable use warrants the full acquisition burden under C.11.DUA. A gap in one branch can leave the others available.

Use C.17 to characterize a claim about novelty, diversity or usefulness. Use C.18 for open-ended generation or stewardship of an archive or front. Use C.19 for a live-pool policy question. Seek each contribution where the task needs it. The decision holder chooses among alternatives on the applicable grounds.

PSDA.5:4.5 - Challenge coverage and stop proportionately

Check whether a favoured formulation, a familiar technology or a powerful participant’s concern has obscured another material mechanism, baseline, combination or staged probe. Merge names for the same action and conditions. Retain differences that change consequences, eligibility or the grounds for use.

Stop when the candidates or stated gaps cover the material differences for the requested comparison, each candidate is intelligible and protected-condition exclusions are clear. Continue searching where an attainable additional alternative would warrant the effort.

If only one lawful direction remains, report its conditions and the grounds for its unique eligibility. Give the reasons for excluding other directions if any were considered. If none remains, distinguish a missing qualification, an infeasible requirement and a reason to reopen the formulation.

PSDA.5:4.6 - Return the set without making the choice

Return the subject, question, horizon and candidate descriptions. Include their material differences, supported conditions, any gap or exclusion and its grounds. Identify a change that would affect the set where it matters to later use. Choose a form the recipient can use to recover these distinctions.

PSDA.8 can use the set in a consequence comparison with the appropriate value, evidence and scope basis. Use the result for ranking or recommendation when that work is requested. A choice belongs to its authorized holder. A later programme, work plan, enacted intervention or achieved effect each requires its own grounds.

PSDA.5:5 - Archetypal Grounding

PSDA.5:5.1 - Flood-pump alternatives beyond a purchase contest

In this illustrative case, the board needs a pre-season return for the next flood season. The inquiry distinguishes nominal capacity, deployment reliability, unequal service, and downstream consequences. The model account says that nominal permanent and mobile capacity can meet the assumed inflow when the stated units are operating, but mobile arrival under road loss is not yet supported. Reachable assistance remains a separate service concern.

The inquiry turns those premises into three candidate descriptions and one unfinished proposal for staging:

CandidateDifferent action being consideredPresent use and gap
N — continue the present arrangementContinue authorized operations and maintenance without a new capacity commitment.Compare with the ongoing service and costs under N. Its adequacy remains a separate question.
F — fixed-capacity changeAdd fixed capacity with the necessary operating, staffing, and support arrangement.A proposed whole change; direct engineering and service results must qualify its consequences.
M — mobile-reserve arrangementObtain mobile capacity together with its transport, deployment, staffing, and access arrangement.Retained for inquiry; the road-loss deployment premise prevents an unconditional commitment claim.
S — unfinished staged proposalThe proposal would preserve a later capacity choice informed by an access or service inquiry, but its first intervention has not been specified.Keep the construction question open: what should change first, and how would that permit the later choice? Specify that intervention and qualify its temporary provision, resource overlap, delay and recovery before comparing S as a distinct direction. Adding the benefits of F and M does not answer these questions.

The property-protection and reachable-assistance concerns remain distinct. They lead the team to ask whether each whole arrangement serves both; they do not establish an approved priority between them. No candidate is dropped because its proponent dissents from the majority.

Return N, F and M within their stated limits. For S, retain the question about the first intervention. A commitment-ready M needs its access premise. S still needs its first intervention to be specified and qualified. The bounded set already supports the comparisons for which the inputs are sufficient.

A further construction round. Suppose the recipient now asks for a pumping arrangement that can be deployed on the isolated side when the bridge is closed. PSDA.6 separates that end from the proposed means “deliver the reserve unit by road”. Working backward through PSDA.8:4.2.1 gives another route: put a unit, a competent crew and their required supplies on that side before closure. The first combination borrows the crew of an existing fixed station. Testing it forward exposes an incompatible condition: operating both arrangements during the flood needs that same crew at both sites. This candidate cannot claim both services.

The team constructs L: pre-position a leased unit and supplies at a suitable local site, with a separately available crew and an agreed local activation arrangement. For this teaching continuation, assume that the responsible specialists have established site suitability, equipment and crew availability, the relevant operating permissions, and provision for the named flood duration; the cost fits the stated comparison budget. With those premises, the forward trace no longer depends on the bridge or double-allocates the fixed-station crew. L is a new comparison-ready alternative for the specified deployment result. Its cost, capacity, service distribution and other material consequences still need comparison; investment selection and demonstrated deployment each need their own grounds. If the separate crew cannot be obtained, retain that exact gap or reopen the service formulation instead of silently restoring the double allocation.

PSDA.5:5.2 - A ninety-day development-direction question

An advisory team is asked which direction a service organization should consider for a ninety-day reliability horizon. “Train, outsource, or use AI” is not yet a set of comparable directions. The adviser resolves the labels into internal development with covered service duties, a qualified provider arrangement, and a mixed human–tool arrangement with specified oversight and fallback. A bounded mixed-arrangement probe is a separate candidate when its information and operating consequences differ from deployment.

For the internal branch, establish what the available human evidence supports about transfer to the representative work. For the provider, establish interface and security fit. For the mixed arrangement, qualify reliability in the operating configuration. A missing allocation result can limit the comparison. Report the comparisons that remain supported and the missing allocation premise that limits a ranking.

For advice about one person, the same move generates directions only from qualified human and target-Work premises. For an AI arrangement, it distinguishes parameter, data, scaffold, tool, code, and environment changes only where the case makes those objects live. Use evidence for the mechanism and subject underlying the particular direction.

PSDA.5:5.3 - Cheap non-use

A recipient already has two complete, qualified ways of obtaining the same repair result and asks which to choose. Use the existing set and the applicable comparison or C.11 choice guidance. Another brainstorming exercise adds no candidate-changing result.

PSDA.5:6 - Bias-Annotation

Scope: alternatives for bounded decision inquiries. Lenses: Prag tests useful differences; Onto/Epist separates proposed arrangements from facts; Arch exposes combinations and dependencies; Gov preserves protected conditions and later authority; Did replaces label lists with intelligible candidates.

Incumbency, sponsor anchoring, technology availability, and novelty bias can each shrink or distort the set. Challenge the omitted mechanism and baseline, not merely the number of ideas. Counter the opposite bias toward endless variety by asking which attainable candidate could change the comparison or the grounds for it.

PSDA.5:7 - Conformance Checklist

  • The receiving question, holder or subject, current arrangement and horizon are recoverable; the recipient and separate choice boundary are stated where that use requires them.
  • Any formulation, model or inquiry result used contributes to a candidate, its conditions or its grounds.
  • Distinct alternatives have a material difference in action, conditions, consequences or use.
  • The baseline includes applicable ongoing obligations and consequences.
  • Combinations and staged directions expose interactions, delay, and unresolved enabling conditions.
  • Supported, proposed, and unknown premises remain distinguishable.
  • Material gaps and exclusions are identified with their grounds.
  • The stopping point is justified for the requested use and attainable further search.
  • The return distinguishes the set or identified gap from a later selection, commitment, implementation or benefit.

PSDA.5:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them

Anti-patternRepair
Score the sponsor’s option against “do nothing”.Recover a real baseline and a materially different mechanism or explain why none is live.
Treat buy, provider, AI, and internal as peer kinds.Describe the proposed whole arrangements and their receiving results.
Exclude a proposal because feasibility is unknown.Keep the inquiry candidate separate from commitment eligibility and name the missing result.
Add component benefits to justify a hybrid.Qualify the combined configuration and its interactions.
Treat novelty or archive membership as selection.Use the characterization or archive result only for its stated function.
Generate forever because the set is not exhaustive.Stop at the bounded comparison need and retain a specific reopen condition.

PSDA.5:9 - Consequences

The recipient gets a bounded set of candidates or an explanation of a missing direction. Constructing and qualifying additional candidates costs effort. Concentrate it on omitted differences that matter to the comparison or its use.

PSDA.5:10 - Rationale

Differences in a formulation matter to choice when they change the available actions, conditions or consequences. An alternative can be worth investigating while its feasibility or authorization remains open.

PSDA.5:11 - SoTA-Echoing

Practice questionBest-known lineSerious alternative or defaultDefect overcome and pattern mutationSource roles and limitsReopen condition
How can an engagement escape the incumbent without producing a decorative idea list?Use objectives and materially different mechanisms to guide alternative construction.Unstructured group brainstorming is cheap; a supplied option menu is cheaper still.Adapt: :4.1–:4.3 add concern-led prompts and independent generation where anchoring matters. The deliberate cost is a short construction pass before comparison; an adequate existing set takes the cheap exit.Borgonovo et al.’s 2026 decision-analysis review, especially its value-focused-thinking discussion, is a current synthesis candidate. Keeney’s 2012 value-focused brainstorming supplies the specific objective-led and individual-before-group procedure. Its policy example is not universal effectiveness evidence.Reopen if a simpler elicitation gives the same material breadth or the objectives themselves suppress a live formulation.
When is a staged alternative genuinely different?Preserve options only through explicit dependencies, observations, and feasible later changes.Compare only fixed end-state projects, or label an underspecified pilot “adaptive”.Adapt: :4.2–:4.4 require a specified and qualified first commitment, later question, and delay or lock-in consequence. The unfinished S example shows why a staging label is insufficient. Additional description is justified only when timing changes the comparison.The 2019 DAPP chapter is the best-known-line candidate for pathway dependencies and failure conditions; its water-policy applications do not supply PSDA’s local thresholds, authority, or universal sequence.Reopen when monitoring, lead time, or reversibility makes the staged direction infeasible or no longer distinct.
Does a novelty result already supply the alternatives?Keep characterization, generation stewardship, and local choice separate.Read a novelty profile or archive as a ready option set.Adopt: :4.4 uses C.17 for characterization and C.18 for generation stewardship; :4.6 retains the PSDA candidate result. This avoids reconstructing machinery when ordinary candidate descriptions suffice.Current C.17 characterizes bounded novelty or use; C.18 governs generation, archive, and front stewardship; C.38 forms same-result ways. Their exact boundaries defeat the broader reading, but none supplies holder feasibility.Reopen only if a direct contribution or the receiving candidate question changes.

PSDA.5:12 - Relations

  • PSDA.1 supplies formulation differences for candidate formation, not selected actions. PSDA.3 supplies discriminating model claims, not the obtaining conditions they represent. PSDA.13 supplies shared and contested inquiry claims only where they change the set; dissent remains explicit.
  • PSDA.6:4.2 distinguishes desired ends from proposed means. When a missing alternative requires a new means combination, PSDA.8:4.2.1 supplies backward construction and its forward test; return the candidate and its conditions to :4.3. PSDA.8 may then consume the set for the named consequence comparison. Generation does not select.
  • C.17, C.18, C.19, and C.38 supply characterization, generation stewardship, live-pool policy, and same-result construction only under their own use conditions.
  • A.15.9 supplies bounded use of an outside-practice result and selection of a worthwhile further request. Direct holder and domain practices supply feasibility, mechanisms, protected conditions, and evidence.
  • Use C.11 for a later local choice over an adequate option set. Use an applicable source to establish a missing premise or return the specific gap.

PSDA.5:End

Referenced in the corpus

42 literal mentions in other sections. Read their context to establish the relation.