RMP.1:4 - Solution
Start with the question, or the material that could help formulate it. Use §4.0 when the distinction still needs to be developed. Look for a sufficient answer in existing material and apply the four membership conditions if a knowledge question remains. Give the result in the current exchange or work product. Use a ResearchQuestionBrief for an inquiry that meets all four conditions.
RMP.1:4.0 - Develop the question from available material
Use this branch when an observation, passage or other material is available but the claim or contrast that matters is still unclear. Examine what the material can reveal before judging the value or research status of the proposed inquiry.
Take a record, passage, attempted operation or observation. Recover what occurred or was asserted, how the material was obtained and the interpretation being used. Work through a consequence. You might contrast a case, change an assumption, or inspect a definition or intermediate operation whose contribution is unclear. For a reported count, establish what was counted before interpreting a change in the total. FPF B.5:4.1.2 gives the general method. Use valid operations and evidence from the relevant field.
Use the difference you find to state a candidate question, what its answer could add and what remains open. A limited exploration can be worthwhile before its exact discovery is known when accessible material and an identifiable operation could reveal a useful distinction. Use C.11.DUA to compare that attainable gain with the full burden. Use an adequate existing answer and respect competence, access and resources. If another contribution is needed, show the material and where interpretation stops. Establish whether it can be obtained and continue with the questions the current material supports.
Return a question that remains open to §4.1 and the membership conditions in §4.2. A new distinction may instead support a sufficient source answer, an ordinary professional result or a precise gap. Give that answer. A better historical explanation, a narrowed claim or a newly expressible question can be useful even if no intervention changes.
RMP.1:4.1 - Pattern-Use Unfolding
- Establish who needs what answer and for what use. Use §4.0 if the claim or distinction still needs to be developed. Identify the question, model, body of evidence or explanation that could change. The researcher may be its user. If another inquiry or an action depends on the answer, state that connection. For an action requiring permission or a decision, identify its holder and basis when known. If that authority is missing or unclear, state the limit on the action.
- Find what existing material can answer. Use an applicable source answer directly. Otherwise follow §4.3 to locate relevant passages and establish their meaning, conditions and consequences for the question. Compare alternatives when their differences could change the answer or the need for a study.
- Finish with a sufficient source answer. If the material answers the question for the intended use, give the answer, sources and limits and stop. Continue to the membership test when a knowledge question remains.
- Specify the possible change in knowledge. Identify the claim or corpus contribution that could be retained, narrowed, rejected, qualified or added. State the phenomenon, case, population or corpus, relevant relation or contrast, constraints and smallest useful answer. A topic or collection plan can supply a starting point for forming this question.
- Apply the four conditions independently. Establish the unresolved question, the whole inquiry’s non-routine knowledge task under genuine uncertainty, an inspectable path from question to evidence and criticism, and a bounded communicable contribution. The inquiry may use routine constituent actions or a justified supplied protocol. All four conditions must hold. Compare the inquiry with the nearest relevant ordinary use and identify what distinguishes them.
- Identify the criticism, adequate answer and conditions for stopping. State the error or rival a useful answer must be able to expose. Specify the evidence needed for this use, which result would defeat or narrow the claim and what the inquiry leaves outside. Also state when the work can finish with uncertainty, refusal or a missing input, for example if further work lacks value or permission. Retain the unmet evidence condition in that result.
- Return one exact disposition.
- give the sufficient existing source answer and its limits.
- give the ordinary professional result if available, or identify the work and who can supply it.
- identify the source or professional result whose absence blocks a needed decision about research and the condition for reconsideration.
- when the four conditions pass, give a ResearchQuestionBrief for the contribution still needed. Use RMP.2 for an open design choice.
- Keep later decisions with their holders. The brief explains the knowledge question, its relevance and its criteria. A study design, authorization to act or later receiving decision each requires its own grounds.
RMP.1:4.2 - Four-Condition Research-Membership Test
Apply the test to the inquiry and the knowledge it aims to return. Running an assay, recruiting a participant or executing a specified analysis can be routine within research. The second condition concerns the knowledge task of the whole inquiry. Performers can use a design and interpretation criteria that are already justified.
For example, a justified protocol may specify how new data will challenge a disputed effect and how to recognize compatible, discrepant or inconclusive results. Until suitable evidence arrives, the relation remains disputed. In a quality-control case, a new measurement under an accepted rule may instead give a batch verdict. The first condition concerns a gap in current knowledge within the intended use. The second concerns examining or developing that knowledge. An unknown ordinary case value does not by itself supply either.
| Condition | Passing question | Does not pass | Reopen cue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unresolved relative to a qualified frame and use | Could an answer or criticism change support for retaining, revising, rejecting, narrowing or adding a particular contribution to knowledge? | The question is new to this performer, or a qualified current source already answers it for the use. | A source gap, serious rival, material limit or changed use makes the contribution uncertain again. |
| Non-routine knowledge task of the whole inquiry under genuine uncertainty | Does the inquiry need to establish, criticize or develop a claim, explanation or applicability relation whose support remains open? | The accepted relation supplies an ordinary case result. The next measured value, verdict, schedule or execution remains to be observed. | A disputed explanation, validity or transfer relation needs examination. A suitable procedure may already exist. |
| Systematic and open to criticism | Can a critic trace the question to the sources, premises, intended moves, performed work, evidence, deviations, limits and conclusions relevant to the claim? | Stored records or repeated measurements leave a consequential link uninspectable. | The materials can now support a trace and a claim that criticism could narrow or defeat. |
| Bounded communicable knowledge contribution | Can a suitable critic examine the intended claim or corpus finding, its scope and limits? Who can use that result? | The sole intended result is an immediate control action, acceptance, compliance token, recognition, private belief or an unspecified increase in knowledge. | A bounded change in knowledge can be identified separately from an action or recognition. |
Use these four questions to establish membership. An experiment, review, laboratory, surprising graph or affiliation may suggest where to look. A qualifying inquiry can reuse an established design and criticism criterion. Use RMP.2 if selection remains open or RMP.6 for a replication or other credibility question with a compatible existing claim and basis.
RMP.1:4.3 - Answer from Existing Sources before Starting a Study
If a supplied answer fits the question, sources and conditions, use it. Otherwise use this route to establish what the sources answer and which part, if any, still needs investigation.
RMP.1:4.3.1 - Find and interpret the relevant material
- State the needed answer. Explain the difficulty using the terms of the work and identify which understanding, claim, inquiry or action the answer could improve. If the distinction is not yet expressible, develop it from available material through §4.0. Use the available texts and search tools. Account for time or specialist input when they affect what can be resolved. Clarify an ambiguity that would send the inquiry in a different direction.
- Locate passages that can answer it. Use the available texts, their contents and their terminology. Search the words of the question and useful alternatives. Follow a passage to definitions, conditions, examples or cited evidence when they change the interpretation. Use F.1 to find or select sources by what they contribute. One adequate identified source can answer the question.
- Resolve difficulties in the reading. If the search misses expected material, try a different expression or source. Read enough of the surrounding passage to establish its meaning. F.0.1 can help with a consequential expression. If the passage concerns a different population, setting or use, identify the difference. Use another suitable source when available or report the limit. Give the corrected interpretation.
- Return what the sources support. Give the answer with the passages, editions, uncertainties and omissions that affect its use. A.10 connects evidence and provenance to particular claims. Finish when the answer is sufficient. An existing explanation may contain the whole result. Record further search details when the question requires reproducing or diagnosing the search.
A missing text, unknown edition or unresolved applicability limits conclusions that rely on it. Preserve what can be answered and identify the source or competence needed for the remaining question. Further search is useful when what it might establish for the answer or its use justifies the cost. A remaining gap can stand as the result.
RMP.1:4.3.2 - Compare alternatives when their difference matters
Use this branch when existing sources offer materially different answers, or when the receiver needs the best-known current answer. Begin with the working question and the criteria that matter for its use.
Use F.1 to select sources that bear on the answer. For a best-known current answer, use F.1:4.2.1 and E.8:11 to compare serious alternatives, relevant failures and application effort. Date and adoption history can help identify sources. Prefer an approach on the grounds that matter to the present question.
Recover the assumptions, conditions and support for each proposed answer. For a claimed improvement, compare the earlier limitation with what the new approach repairs and what it leaves open. Consult the earlier source if the comparison depends on it. Historical influence and evidence that the current approach works answer different questions. State trade-offs where alternatives improve different characteristics or identify what would distinguish them.
Give the conclusion of the comparison and its consequences for the answer, applicability, remaining research question or stopping point. Use RMP.7 if a new corpus conclusion needs appraisal and synthesis. F.0.2 serves conceptual synthesis for framework authoring. G.2 serves a broader, repeatedly refreshed SoTA collection under its declared CG-Frame. A sufficient comparison can finish here.
RMP.1:4.4 - Nearest Non-Members and Exact Returns
| Nearest non-member | Exact return | Reopen RMP.1 only when |
|---|---|---|
| Routine engineering qualification, verification or validation against supplied criteria | Give the test or qualification result for the engineering or assurance use. If a choice follows, its designated authority makes it. | Relevant sources leave a mechanism, validity, transfer or evidential relation open. A suitable examination may already exist or need construction. |
| Monitoring or measurement under established variables, thresholds and response rules | Use the observation or current-state finding in Operations or the domain monitoring practice. | A question about an unexplained pattern, rival causes, an invalid measure or transfer changes what the inquiry must establish. |
| Troubleshooting, incident response or fault isolation to restore an operating result | Give the supported diagnosis or restoration finding under the engineering, service or operations method. | A separate question about the episode, its mechanism or the suitability of the recovery method remains open and meets the four conditions. |
| Audit, compliance, programme evaluation or product acceptance under given criteria and authority | Give the required verdict, evaluation or acceptance result under the practice responsible for it. | The question now concerns the validity of the criteria, a causal explanation, transfer or another unsettled knowledge claim. |
| source retrieval, currentness checking, or bounded cross-source comparison sufficient for the use | Return the answer and the source, applicability and comparison limits needed by its receiver, using §4.3. | A material source gap or a new question changes what that answer can establish. |
| Ordinary application of a qualified professional Method | Use that method to produce the domain result, use a supplied result or seek the contribution from a qualified provider. | An unresolved question about fit, the underlying claim or a new case meets the four conditions. Use the corresponding Core Methods for Method identity, qualification, fit, trial, worth or variants, and A.3.1.MI for introduction. |
For adjacent work or a missing result, preserve the question, the usable material, the result needed and any condition for reopening the inquiry. Identify a supplier or responsible authority where the next work actually needs one. Give an adequate supplied answer to its user and finish.
RMP.1:4.5 - Record the Result
For an inquiry that passes the four conditions, include the following information in the ResearchQuestionBrief.
| Result position | Required content |
|---|---|
| receiver and use | Who needs the answer and what knowledge or practical use it serves. If the inquiry informs a decision, state that decision, any authority or permission already established and any gap that limits its use. |
| intended episteme change | Exact claim or corpus contribution that could be retained, narrowed, rejected, qualified, or added. |
| bounded question | Answerable question with phenomenon, unit, case, population or corpus, relation or contrast, constraints, and effective horizon where material. |
| qualified current frame | The source answer prepared through §4.3 or supplied for the same use, with its source editions, relevant alternatives, omissions and applicability limits. |
| membership account | Explain how each of the four conditions holds and how the inquiry differs from the nearest relevant ordinary use. State the knowledge task of the whole inquiry, including any routine actions or justified design it can reuse. |
| criticism demand | Principal error, rival, invalid source use, dependence, bias, missing context, or unsupported transfer that a defensible answer must expose. |
| constraints and professional results | Applicable domain criteria, measurement, instrument, safety, ethics, rights, confidentiality, access, resources or authority. Identify what is available and any missing condition the work depends on. |
| answer condition | What the evidence must establish for an adequate answer to the bounded question, including applicable uncertainty and scope. |
| work-stop and reopen conditions | When the present work can finish with an adequate answer, a refusal, retained uncertainty or a missing input. Identify any unmet evidence condition and what could reopen the inquiry. |
| source and result limits | What the supplied sources establish, the limits that matter to the use and which missing contribution cannot be inferred from them. |
| continuation | The brief and frame for an open RMP.2 choice, or other supplied inputs for the contribution needed. State separately any design selection, protocol, authorization or receiving decision already in place. |
If a supplied result answers the current question, give the answer with the source, scope and limits the user needs. The current exchange or existing work product may carry the complete result. Finish there.
For later reliance or another use, retain the source, scope, date or uncertainty that affects application of the answer. Use an adequate existing explanation and add a missing condition when the new use needs it.
For a non-research result or a research-boundary hold, identify the applicable relations in this table using the existing material or a short return.
| Return position | Required content |
|---|---|
| current question | The question as raised, or what the material allows you to clarify about it. Preserve the use that prompted it. |
| disposition basis | Supplied-answer sufficiency, nearest non-member, or named missing/stale source or owner result. |
| available material | Exact current results and limits worth carrying to the receiver or owner. |
| return target and expected result | What input or result is needed and who can supply it, if known. State any unresolved source or permission that limits further work. |
| effect and retry | What stops now, what can continue, and the condition that would reopen RMP.1. |
RMP.1:4.6 - Frascati Criteria Mutated for This Boundary
The OECD Frascati criteria provide a cross-sector comparison for research and development statistics. RMP.1 adapts them to inquiry that can be criticized on its evidence regardless of the performer’s institutional affiliation.
| Frascati criterion | RMP.1 use |
|---|---|
| novel | Adapt. Determine what remains unresolved in the relevant knowledge and use. Personal unfamiliarity is insufficient. The contribution need not claim patent novelty, publication priority or a global first. |
| creative | Adapt. Assess the non-routine task of the inquiry as a whole. It may construct or criticize an unsettled claim, explanation or applicability relation using a fully supplied design. The status of the particular procedure does not settle that of the inquiry. |
| uncertain | Specify. The defensible answer or route remains unsettled. Uncertainty about the schedule, process variability or execution risk can exist under fully accepted knowledge. |
| systematic | Adopt. Make the connection from question to result inspectable, including sources, premises, intended and performed actions, evidence, deviations, limits and stopping conditions relevant to that use. |
| transferable or reproducible | Adapt. Return a bounded contribution and enough evidence for a critic to examine or reuse the reasoning. The conditions for generalization, recurrence or replication with new data depend on the historical, qualitative, field, citizen or other inquiry. |
RMP.1:4.7 - First-Hour Qualification Card
If the question or useful distinction remains unclear, use §4.0 on the available material. Start the card with prompts 1–3. When prompt 3 gives a sufficient answer, return it under §4.5 and finish. Use prompts 4–8 when a question about research membership remains. Add a short statement or row where the necessary grounds are missing.
- Who needs the answer, and for what use? If a later decision or permission is at issue, what authority has been established and what, if anything, remains open?
- What do the available sources answer? Use §4.3 if the answer still needs to be recovered or compared. Retain the sources and limits that matter here.
- Does that source answer resolve the receiving question? If yes, return it with the sources and limits needed for this use, and stop here.
- What exact episteme could change, and what phenomenon, unit, case, corpus, relation, or contrast bounds it?
- Why is the question unresolved relative to the frame rather than merely unfamiliar?
- What knowledge claim or explanation must the whole inquiry establish, criticize or develop, beyond an ordinary case result under an accepted rule? What remains uncertain, and which suitable design or criticism choices can already be reused?
- How could a critic inspect and defeat or narrow the claim?
- What evidence would make the answer adequate? Separately, when can the current work finish with uncertainty or refusal, and what could reopen it?
If a missing source or professional result prevents a decision the current branch still needs, state the hold and what it affects. When the work belongs to another practice, give its supported result or identify the contribution needed. A sufficient answer finishes the corresponding branch.
RMP.1:4.8 - What Changes in Practice
A practitioner can start with a record whose significance is unclear and develop the question from its contents. Use a source answer or an ordinary measurement or acceptance result where it suffices. If an unresolved knowledge question remains, identify how the inquiry could change its support. A justified ready protocol can examine a disputed claim. When design selection is open, RMP.2 receives the bounded question and its criticism requirement. A specific supply gap can also be the current result.