AU where Athena decides Erich is a failed experiment, so, using whatever means the writer prefers, she restrains Erichthonios and non-cons him into impregnating her a second time (since obviously Lahabrea isn’t up to the task)

Bonus points for Erich being absolutely terrified by the idea that it might work and trying to hold back his orgasm for as long as possible but Athena forcing it out of of him anyway.

The real reason Hythlodaeus got so sick of the Shark Concept Craze is that someone’s dumb shark was Horny and forced itself on him.

I’d rather see him annoyed and frustrated rather than overtly traumatized – it’s a recognized hazard of the job, perhaps – but otherwise, go wild.

I’d love to see Athena commanding the memory!Erich to have sex and Erich complying.

(I’d love love love it if she also forced Lahabrea to watch, but that’s completely optional and maybe another prompt altogether?)

Oh no!! The Crystal Tower has decided it’s a problem that the last bearer of the Allagan royal bloodline hasn’t shown any inclination to pass it on, so after making some alterations to G’raha’s biology, it forces m!WOL to knock him up!

[…]

What if Athena latched on to a different desire of Themis’ to control him?

Listen…

I want to see how the Uyagir do sex. Are they prudish about it, thinking they don’t deserve to feel pleasure, and feeling ashamed if they come? Do they use chastity belts?

How do the other tribes view this? I’m thinking maybe noncon with forced orgasms; or taunting about how worthless they are, barely even fit to serve as sex slaves; that kind of thing.

(Bonus: How do their views compare to Ishgardian views on sex? If “member of a specific Xaela tribe!WOL” doesn’t count as a named WOL, I’d be interested in any gender WOL/Aymeric, m!WOL/Haurchefant, or hell, pick any Uyagiri and any Ishgardian NPC and it would probably be great.)

Two options: either G’raha gets fucked by the Xande clone during the original Crystal Tower raid and taken prisoner, OR, G’raha fantasizes (at any point in his life) about being Xande’s sexpet back in ancient Allag. G’raha feels a lot of shame over kinking on this as hard as he does but comes the hardest when Xande (either the real one or the one in his head) is simultaneously mocking him for being a stupid animal with no thought in his head other than cock, and praising him for knowing his place.

[…]

valens making alfonse suck on the barrel of a loaded gun and then fucking his ass with the gun, that is all. would be extra hot (pun not intended) if valens shoots [the air/a wall/maybe alfonse himself somewhere non-essential] to prove it’s loaded and then making alfonse suck on the still-hot gun and alfonse being in pain from how hot it is and also noting the taste of gunpowder

[…]

It’s always been so funny to me that a great and powerful sorcerer of eld… would choose to shoot the Crystal Exarch at the climax of ShB. I think about this every day. Anyway, time to make it horny.

Emet-Selch, while holding him captive, makes the Exarch blow his pistol while Emet monologues at him. Maybe it escalates to Emet-Selch fucking him with it. I’m not looking for snuff, but teasing the implication that the safety is off and what they’re doing could kill or seriously injure the Exarch in a way that’s both horrific and horrifically degrading is… fun.

Set in the Garlemald section of early game-ish Endwalker. Jullus really, really resents the twins and the Warrior of Light for playing good Samaritans and offering the Garleans help in their darkest hour, to no doubt make demands of them later. He takes it out on the twins while they’re collared. If this is a straight-up noncon situation, maybe he starts out on just one of the twins but threatens to involve the other if the first steps out of line. Bonus points for knife or gun kink.

Bad end for Eden’s Promise: Anamorphosis. The Warrior of Darkness and their allies are incapacitated, and are powerless to do anything but watch while Ryne gets fucked raw by the daddy issues monster. She starts out genuinely frightened and unwilling, but gets the resistance fucked out of her eventually, and by the end of the encounter, she’s a fucked-out, quivering mess.

[…]

someone is being mind-controlled by somebody else. (Doesn’t really matter who bc I am not picky, but I’d really prefer them to both be male or NB)

The person being controlled obviously doesn’t like this situation so they attempt to regain control over their body in any way they can. But their controller is more powerful and is easily able to overcome them. As punishment, their controller forces them to perform sexual acts.

Bonus points for….forcing them to engage with a stranger who performs bdsm as a punishment on them…

what it says.

doesn’t matter who it is or multiple others at the same time.

Lyon treats xxx like how he’d tame a beast.

can be dom/sub play or an actual prisoner he caught.

can use actual beasts to ‘help’ during ‘taming’.

absolutely anything goes.

Listen… Aymeric has the prettiest deep blue eyes and I need him to weep. Doesn’t matter if it’s fully consensual, dubcon or noncon, if he’s happy, if he’s sad, because it hurts or because it’s just that good, I don’t care. Ruin that man, anon. Make him cry. Sustain me on pretty-boy tears.

Theomocent (the Harry Potter looking Catholic schoolboy in the Scholasticate quests) has that pure, earnest, holier-than-thou attitude that just gets right under your skin. The popular/higher class kids decide to put him in his place, and the bullying escalates.

[…]

during the In From The Cold cutscene right at the moment Zenos takes the Wol’s body away he subsequently leaves his own body behind unconscious(?) the Wol decides they’re angry and want revenge and his body is RIGHT THERE asahi be like oh ok you’re doing this now i’ll be over there byeee or he an stay and provide commentary go crazy

Emmanellain being a rakish little flirt has to get him into trouble one of these days. It doesn’t matter if his flirting isn’t very successful, some proper Ishgardian man has got to take offense to the Fortemps boy sniffing around the women of his family, and decide to take matters into his own hands. By which I mean, fucking that boy until he’s squealing apologies and promises to never go near the woman in question again.

Canonically, Emmanellain is interested in Laniaitte de Haillenarte, so Count Baurendouin would be perfect for this… or if the fill is set pre-canon, maybe Chlodebaimt before his death? It doesn’t need to be any canon NPC though, you can straight-up just make someone up. OP isn’t picky, as long as Emmanellain gets dominated thoroughly.

A sin-eater hunts down, captures, and ultimately consumes a terrified humanoid, transforming them into a sin-eater as well. The gender of both the victim and the sin-eater are up to the writer, how humanoid the sin-eater, whether or not it can speak, etc, although OP would prefer a genuinely monstrous sin-eater that is perhaps only capable of mimicking human speech… maybe the last words of its previous victims?

Bonus points if the writer includes some kind of brainwashing where the previously fearful human slowly becomes worshipful and rapturous in a psychological horror kind of way. Doesn’t have to include any sex at all, but if the writer wants, they can sprinkle in some dubcon or noncon at their leisure.

I’m not picky about the exact situation; I’m just sad this doesn’t actually exist yet.

Possible prompts:

• What appears to be perfectly consensual sex, but Lahabrea keeps pushing Urianger’s boundaries and eventually outright ignores him asking to stop
• What appears to be perfectly consensual sex but Secret Triple Agent Urianger knows it’s really Lahabrea but he can’t let on that he knows because then Thancred would know that he knew
• Just some good old-fashioned captivity-and-noncon

Or whatever! Up to you. No preference for WOL race/gender/class if they appear.