The Redhead and the Cowboy

Gosh. I don't have the energy to chart the history of the western. But this fits into an interesting pocket. Many westerns — including ones celebrated at the time — seem mighty dreary to me. But this one moves along.

It is basically a chase, a sort of detective story. It features a cowboy in noir mode with the redheaded saloon gal in her noir role, superimposed on her western role.

Nearly everyone we see is pretending to be something they are not and several key reversals happen. Of course our noir everyman, played by Ford, is pure and open. Dogs and little girls sense this.

It is in black and white, shot in Utah following the pattern. It has Indians, renegade soldiers, a stupid sheriff, a big finale complete with jumping into a runaway wagon. Until then, we have noir, but it switches to a western ending. Honest cowpoke, gets feisty redhead.

Ted's Evaluation -- 3 of 3: Worth watching.

For a modest western, The Redhead & The Cowboy manages to rise above its station (so to speak) and become something much better : part character study (and an excellent one at that), part mystery, it's maybe a bit too densely plotted for the kind of film it is, and yet it rises above its slightly sluggish pace, especially early on, and once its story gains a head of steam one wants very much to know what the late radio commentator Paul Harvey used to call "the rest of the story", which is to say the payoff.

Set in the Far West during the American Civil War, the film's story is indeed connected to that bloody conflict, mostly tangentially or inferentially; and yet it's there all the same, and all the time. One can never forget that there's a war "back east"; and the loyalties of the sympathies of many of the characters in the movie factor in its final outcome. Yet's easy for the viewer to forget such issues, and what drives the film. Gold figures into the narrative, as does, more prominently the guilt or innocence of its main character, well played by Glenn Ford.

As its story develops, the film begins to feel more like a western as it moves forward; as bit by bit there are more action scenes, more vistas; and also more twists and turns in the story itself. By its (roughly speaking) third and final act, while there are still unanswered questions, and some uncertainty as to who the good guy really is,--though casting helps in this--the movie is clearly heading toward what's starting to feel like a slam-bang ending. Western fans should be satisfied by the way the movie ends, even as the resolution is, alas, bittersweet.

Solid work all-round from director Leslie Fenton and such gifted players as not only Glenn Ford, Rhonda Fleming, Morris Ankrum, Alan Reed and, in a pivotal role, Edmond O'Brien, who's first rate and manages to stay very much in character for the entire length of the film. For me, his playing is smooth and low key for the kind of actor O'Brien was; and he gives the best and most memorable performance in the film.

I'm not a fan of Glenn Ford or Edmond O'Brien so this film passed the time without any wow factor, although I give credit to O'Brien as he upped his game in this film so that I actually liked him. For the first time ever! Ford is still a gormless monkey, though.

This film is about confederate spy Rhonda Fleming (Candace) trying to get a message through to her army whilst in the middle of Unionist territory. There are loads of double twists in this film and "who-is-who-and-what-are-they-doing" threads towards the end when it can get a bit confusing. Everyone looks the same and could be in the same army. They could have made things a bit easier.

We needed a female bar-room song - I know the film is not a western, but a bar-room song was missing. Also, we could have had better use made of the Navajo Indians. Where were the Indians? Alan Reed pops up towards the end as a conniving Colonel but plays his role as a comic cartoon character. He later found his calling as the voice of Fred Flintstone - a comic cartoon character! Perfect for him but he didn't belong in this film.

The answer to the question is 11.

Call me crazy, but shouldn't The Redhead and the Cowboy have been made in Technicolor? How are we supposed to know Rhonda Fleming has red hair? Alright, we've seen her in other movies, but I still maintain that this movie wasn't as effective in black and white. And speaking of other movies, I fully admit I suffer from "Humphrey-Bogart-It is" with her: the first movie I saw her in left an unchangeable impression. No matter how many movies where she plays a bad girl, I'll always think of her as Princess Sandy. Mark Twain made me loyal to her sweetness. She's so beautiful; it's a shame Hollywood made her a villain a lot of the time. In this movie, she plays a Confederate spy who plays men as easily as she looks at them and takes everything she can get. But, what about Princess Sandy! Can't she be a good girl deep down?

Glenn Ford plays her latest mark. He's a stranger in a small western town, and when he follows a flirtatious Rhonda into the back room of a saloon (hoping to get lucky, let's face it), he winds up alone with a corpse. Edmond O'Brien and other witnesses think Glenn is a murderer, and they chase him out of town - but Glenn is chasing Rhonda to clear his name. She's the only one who knows he's innocent. Unless Edmond believes him, or else why would he help him with his narrow escape? There are some twists and turns to this movie, but it's not the best Confederate western I've seen. I like The Texans far better. Or if you want Glenn Ford's comic timing, check him out in Advance to the Rear.

Glenn Ford is a living legend who seemed born to the saddle. On display in this film (once again) is his strong, yet amiable cowboy screen persona. Rhonda Fleming is well cast here and the storyline is interesting but not overly complicated. Pacing and script development are well done.

While this is not Ford's best western, it does show why he was so successful in the saddle. He presents a strong presence in the film, without taking himself too seriously.

It was great to see Alan Reed as the Condererate Colonel. ( Reed was the longtime voice of Fred Flintstone !!)