Her Cardboard Lover

Firstly, I cannot believe that Norma Shearer is 40 in this film. She looks absolutely incredible and doesn't look a day over 30! Besides being beautiful, Norma Shearer was fantastic in this film! She was brilliantly funny and sophisticated. I once read that Norma Shearer couldn't act (I don't recall who this person is who claimed that), but this person is wrong. Norma can act, and it was definitely proved in this film. Luck was on Norma's side because she ended her acting career with this amusing film.

And Robert Taylor -- what a gag! I love his acting and he's just so adorable! He was fabulous in this film! I won't give anything away, but the definite high point in the film (as well as Robert Taylor's funniest scene) happens in the middle of the movie and deals with a 'sleepy' Taylor...

With such a little -- but talented cast -- this movie is fantastically funny and has hilarious moments and wonderful acting. I cannot rave enough about Norma & Taylor -- just see the film yourself!!

This is the second attempt to bring Jacques Deval's play to the screen. The first one was a vehicle for Marion Davies and Nils Asther, directed by Robert Z. Leonard. This new version bears George Cukor's signature as the director. The film is interesting for two reasons: it marked the last time its star, Norma Shearer, appeared on a film, and it also has Robert Taylor doing comedy, something he wasn't seen in often.

"Her Cardboard Lover" is a sophisticated comedy that capitalizes on the strength of its stars. The screen play by Valerie Wyngate has some ups and downs in it that even the great Cukor wasn't able to solve. First, there is a marked age difference between the stars, not because Ms. Shearer looks older, on the contrary, she is in excellent form, but Mr. Taylor appears to be much younger.

The film has some good moments for everyone. The best thing Mr. Cukor was able to do was to give the suave George Sanders the part of Tony Barling, the playboy who comes back to claim the love of Consuelo Croyden. They have parted in a bad way, but there's still something between the former lovers. By hiring Terry Trindale as the "fake" lover, in order to make Tony Barling jealous, a new dynamic enters into play.

There are two extraordinary sequences toward the end of the film. The first one is the fight between Tony and Terry in the hotel's pantry when dishes, vases, and all kinds of porcelain gets smashed against walls. The second one is in the court that is presided by judge Sam, brilliantly portrayed by Chill Wills. The acting is first rate by this marvelous cast. In minor roles Frank McHugh and Elizabeth Patterson shine.

The film is a light comedy that is a delight to watch.

Norma Shearer, in her last film, is a wealthy woman desperate to stay away from her on-again/off-again boyfriend (George Sanders) in "Her Cardboard Lover.

To do this, she has Robert Taylor, a songwriter who's crazy about her, work off his gambling debt by pretending to be her boyfriend.

A nice dramatic role would have been better for Shearer's final performance. But like Garbo, she went out with a comedy, and one that bombed at that, also like Garbo.

One wonders what MGM was thinking. The dilemma seems to have been finding vehicles for these older stars as the world - and they - were changing.

The film was made in 1942, and though it is a delightful comedy, it really has the look and feel of the '30s to it. There are some wonderful scenes - one where Taylor threatens to jump over a balcony and a dandy fight scene at the end. But in spots, it seems a little tired.

Norma Shearer wears gorgeous clothes and is over-dramatic, which is what the part called for. Robert Taylor does a fine job, and George Sanders was wasted.

One of the comments said that Shearer was too old for the role - yet the actors seem properly matched and this writer, anyway, had no idea of Shearer's age.

In the end, though, it wasn't a fitting way for her to go out. The role hearkens back to a much earlier time. Perhaps, in the end, that's what she wanted.

As others have said, this was Norma Shearer's last film. I have no idea if she intended it to be, at the time, but it was, and she retired. Norma was, I think, 39 in this movie.

Shearer didn't appear in many comedies. The Women (1939), also directed by George Cukor, was fantastic, and a big hit. She was the lead, but her part was more serious, and she wasn't required to do the comedic heavy lifting (that was left mostly to co-star Rosalind Russell and the supporting cast).

I guess what I'm trying to say is that Norma didn't particularly have the light touch necessary for this type of sophisticated comedy. It's the sort of thing Claudette Colbert could have done in her sleep - and she would have made it seem better than it actually was.

It's a trifle about a woman hiring a good-looking man (Robert Taylor) as a secretary - but really it's to give the impression of being her lover, in order to make her boyfriend (George Sanders) jealous. Taylor's character already has a crush on her when he's hired.

Shearer is good enough, but the role seems to expose not only some of her acting weaknesses but also some of the qualities that made her a little hard to take as a personality. She was always able to rise to the occasion in difficult material - having triumphed in Romeo And Juliet (1936) (another occasion where she was directed by Cukor), and Strange Interlude (1932), as Eugene O'Neill's complex heroine, Nina Leeds. But as a film personality required to just "play herself" in this piece of fluff, she tends to come off as both strained, and, at times, strange.

Robert Taylor wasn't known for his comedic abilities, either, but the times he was cast in comedies he actually did very well. He's funny, here - but there's not a lot of chemistry between him Miss Shearer. And unfortunately he was almost a decade younger- and looks it. (George Sanders was also younger than Norma by a few years.)

Shearer and Taylor had been paired previously in the drama, Escape. They weren't a totally effective screen couple, but then Taylor seemed do do better opposite actresses who could display more vulnerability - such as Margaret Sullavan, Katharine Hepburn, and maybe especially, Vivien Leigh. (Strangely enough, Shearer's final acting role was in a 1951 radio adaptation of Waterloo Bridge - Taylor's one film with Leigh.)

Finally, director George Cukor is simply off his game, in this one. It didn't happen very often, but it was obvious when it did. Not that the script is up to the level of The Philadelphia Story, Holiday, or anything remotely that good. The story is really extremely light and a little dumb, and probably required some very expert, elegant, comedy stars to make you forget that fact. Which Shearer, Taylor, and Sanders were not, unfortunately.

Bosley Crowther of the New York Times put it on his 10 Worst list for the year, and it was a box office bomb. Norma Shearer turned down Mrs. Miniver to make it - paving the way for Greer Garson to take her place as First Lady of MGM.

This version was so bad that Norma Shearer retired from the screen. I actually liked the quirky 1931 version with Irene Purcell in the same role, but it had the same effect on her career, and would be the last film in which she ever performed, though she was primarily a stage actress. Only the silent 1928 version with Marion Davies did not destroy the career of the leading lady.

Anyways, back to this version. In it Norma Shearer hires a lovestruck Robert Taylor (sporting a Bela Lugosi Dracula haircut with a point down the middle) to protect her from herself. Norma plays a Palm Beach vacationer hopelessly in love with a womanizer, played by, who else, George Sanders. Shearer hates that she can't control her desires for Sanders. Since Taylor owes her a gambling debt, he can pay it off by being Norma's secretary. His job doesn't involve typing. He's there to keep her away from Sanders, a job he performs too well, practically keeping her hostage in her own room. The chemistry between Shearer and Taylor is okay. But not as charged as her scenes with Sanders. You get the sense the two of them could have a happy open marriage. Shearer excels at playing liberated women (A Free Soul), (Private Lives). Norma wouldn't lose sleep over a philandering husband, as she would have her own trove of lovers. Of course, this is not Pre-Code Hollywood, which was something that worked in the favor of the 1931 version - "The Passionate Plumber".

I give Taylor credit for playing against type. Some of the comedic tropes for keeping Norma and George separated are funny, and some come across as creepy. This film has gorgeous sets, Harry Stradling's rich B&W photography, the elegant atmosphere, and of course Norma Shearer. But still, it just feels like the story is playing out in the wrong era.

Norma Shearer retired after this film. Apparently, during its making, someone said she had "jiggling grandma arms", and that was enough to have her hang it up at age 40. Although she still looked mighty fine to me.