Tru's brother Harrison is mistakenly killed by a woman's jealous ex-husband. When Tru attempts to save him, Jack makes his intentions known by saying that he will make sure that Harrison dies or someone else will take his place by the end of the day.
Tru lives her more exhausting experience when every time the day repeats, a different person dies and asks her for help again. She must discover the true reason she was required the first time to finally see a different day.
It's Christmas Eve and a woman who's been dead for months asks Tru for help at the university. Since the woman can't be saved from death, Jack and Tru forget their rivalry and collaborate to find out what she wants from her.
In order to stop Tru from trying to save people, Jack frames Tru for the murder of a psychologist who is about to expose one of his patients for the murder of the patient's girlfriend, Grace.
On the same day, two corpses ask for Tru's help. However, the day only rewinds for the second one. Tru enlists Harrison's help to try to save both of the people.
When Tru's father comes to town to celebrate his birthday, Tru discovers the identity of her mother's murderer. Jack Harper is hired on as a new employee at the morgue.
Tru discovers that her mysterious new coworker, Jack Harper, has the same ability as Tru to relive days. However, she soon discovers that Jack doesn't share the same belief as Tru of trying to save everyone who asks for help.
Tru's asked for help when the lights had been turned off at her birthday party in the morgue, and she doesn't know who's the one who has died. So when the day repeats, she has to know who's the one in danger.
