All Things

The episode isn't brilliant but it isn't trash either. We get to see that Scully is far from flawless. If you're confronted with your past, you're forced to make peace with it and deal with your present life and choices. If all you want is the brainless entertainment you will hate this episode. I don't blame Gillian Anderson for wanting to give Scully's character more depth. We know Scully; the scientist, her morales, her loyalties and her religion. Now we get a peek at Scully; the woman.

Like the above poster, this is far from my favorite episode - either when it aired or watching it again all these years later. Parts of it are way too touchy-feely and smack of pop psychology, and the slo-mo effects are little gimmicky. At times, it feels like a music video (though a nicely done one) with bits of drama and narrative thrown in.

But seeing it again, I appreciate that it gives us a different glimpse of Scully. Like many females, I loved Scully's intelligence and determination throughout the series, but in this episode, it was nice to see her passion too, even if it also means she might not be perfect in her choices. Finally, she gets to respond to impulses that aren't governed by logic or science! Preceding X-Files writers (Glen Morgan and James Wong, especially) were instrumental in making Scully her own person, independent of Mulder, but leave it to Gillian Anderson herself to force the question of Scully's life outside of the X-Files.

The seventeenth episode of The X-Files' seventh season, "All Things," stands out as a deeply introspective and spiritually driven narrative, marking Gillian Anderson's directorial debut. In this unique departure from the series' typical formula, the episode focuses on Agent Dana Scully's personal journey and exploration of fate, love, and self-awareness. The plot revolves around Scully's chance encounter with Dr. Daniel Waterston, a former mentor and romantic interest, who is now gravely ill. As Scully faces unresolved emotions and questions the choices she has made throughout her life, the episode delves into themes of destiny and interconnectedness.

Anderson's direction demonstrates a keen sense of visual storytelling, employing symbolic imagery and dream-like sequences to convey Scully's inner turmoil. The use of soft lighting and fluid camera movements creates an ethereal atmosphere that complements the episode's introspective tone. One of the standout sequences is a montage accompanied by a hauntingly beautiful musical score, illustrating Scully's reflection on pivotal moments in her life. This artistic approach, though ambitious, may feel too abstract for viewers accustomed to the show's more straightforward narrative style.

The script, also penned by Anderson, takes a contemplative approach, focusing heavily on character development rather than external conflict. This narrative shift allows for a rare exploration of Scully's emotional landscape, which has often been overshadowed by the series' paranormal investigations. Anderson delivers a nuanced and heartfelt performance, capturing Scully's vulnerability and strength as she grapples with existential questions. However, the episode's pacing can be uneven, with certain scenes lingering longer than necessary, potentially diminishing the overall impact.

One of the episode's strengths is its thematic exploration of synchronicity and spirituality. Scully's encounters with symbols and moments of serendipity suggest a universe guided by unseen forces. Anderson skillfully integrates these elements without becoming overly didactic, inviting viewers to ponder the mysteries of fate and choice. The absence of Mulder for much of the episode, while initially jarring, allows Scully's journey to take center stage, emphasizing her autonomy and growth.

"All Things" is a bold and introspective entry in The X-Files canon, showcasing Gillian Anderson's talents both in front of and behind the camera. While its abstract narrative and slower pacing may not appeal to all viewers, it stands as a thoughtful meditation on love, loss, and self-discovery. Anderson's creative vision and exploration of Scully's character add depth to the series, making this episode a memorable and meaningful departure from the show's usual structure.

An episode written by Gillian Anderson, in which she plays herself rather than Scully, which barely features Mulder, which is about a long lost love interest we have never heard of. This isn't even an episode of the X-Files, it's just some some hospital soap opera.

This guy we are supposed to care about means nothing to us, and the writing is all over the place. It was very difficult to follow and all a bit pointless.

The Taoism/Buddhism connection was also completely out of character considering Scully's strong history of Christianity in the show. Again, it was added because Gillian Anderson was interested in it. I think it's an interesting topic and I'm sure the writers could have come up with a real plot for it but it had no place in this episode, which itself has no bearing on the wider show. Just immediately forgotten as the silliness it is. Season 7 really is where The X-Files jumped the shark repeatedly.

The one saving grace of this episode is that it's better than the comedy/musical episode that David Duchovny directs two episodes later.

there is this moment in the episode when you see such tenderness and longing in Scully -- a memory of a great love and loss... it is when she learns he has been in DC for all this time... i found it so incredibly tender... it so perfectly captured that moment we all have when we remember what was and what might have been... i am still blown away when i see the way she bends forward and touches his hand... the rest of the episode is a blur, just back fill. but that scene to me is priceless and makes this whole episode so utterly great... when you look at the first season (which would mean Scully had just ended the relationship a couple years before), she is young and driven and professional -- it's hard to imagine that she felt such passion and pathos... i wonder if she could only show it with the passage of time and realization of where she is at now...