Skin

The monster of the week format is put to good use in this episode as the shapeshifter furthers the brothers' melodrama AND works as a potent thematic metaphor, in this case domestic violence being the result of socialization of men. The writing is crisp and the show does a good job of ringing out the scares from the premise. Best of all, Dean-well "Dean"-expressing resentment towards Sam is very much needed to make the characters seem more like brothers ; this is an early example of that key dynamic of the show.

Apart from that the episode contains one of the goriest, viscerally horrifying scenes of the series in the first seen transformation of the shifter. They never bothered to go as extensive as the sequence here ever again but the scene is so effective that even 15 years later you still get the creeps in the shapeshifter episodes.

Good stuff.

I did enjoy this one, even though the idea of a shapeshifter isn't very original. It was Still a fun episode.

I have to commend the visual effects here. I thought the transformation "shedding" scene was great, grotesque and unsettling body horror. Also the piles of festering goop. I watch a lot of these types of shows and I felt grossed out by it. This gives the episode more points.

Seeing Dean shirtless definitely doesn't hurt either.

Okay so this episode starts out with a man convicted of murder and he's friends with Dean and Sam. The boys investigate and they run into a Skinwalker (a shape shifting man) who senselessly assaults and kills people for no reason. It morphs into Dean and starts wreaking havoc! I thought this episode was rather strange (this and Phantom Traveler). The Shape Shifter doesn't have a true story or background, I mean: where on earth did this thing come from? The being says it was born with the ability but that's it? Hmm...this is what makes it confusing because most of the other episodes of the show (except this one and Phantom Traveler) explain where the things come from and why they are what they are.

6 out of 10

"Skin," the sixth episode of Supernatural's first season, created by Eric Kripke and directed by Robert Duncan McNeill, is a gripping installment that delves into themes of identity and deception through the lens of a shapeshifter. This episode effectively explores the complexities within Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean Winchester's (Jensen Ackles) relationship while introducing a terrifying monster-of-the-week narrative.

The narrative begins with Zach Warren, one of Sam's college friends, being accused of murdering his girlfriend. As Sam investigates this crime to clear Zach's name, he discovers that they are dealing with a shapeshifter capable of assuming human forms perfectly. The shifter targets Rebecca Waring, another friend from Sam's past at Stanford University. The brothers soon realize that this entity can mimic anyone it desires-most disturbingly when it takes on Dean's appearance to torment both Rebecca and Sam.

Robert Duncan McNeill's direction skillfully captures both tension and emotional depth throughout the episode. The cinematography enhances suspenseful moments-such as when characters confront their doubles in dark environments-while also highlighting comedic elements like Dean's reactions to being impersonated by the shifter. However, some critics argue that certain plot points feel rushed or confusing due to time jumps in the narrative.

Jensen Ackles shines as Dean Winchester in this episode by portraying not only his usual bravado but also vulnerability as he grapples with being impersonated by an evil doppelganger. Jared Padalecki delivers strong performances as Sam confronts his past while supporting both their investigation into supernatural forces at play.

Thematically, "Skin" explores themes of identity-highlighted through both physical transformations via shape-shifting and emotional shifts within characters-and brotherly love-emphasized by Dean's unwavering support for Sam despite misunderstandings caused by their doppelgangers. It introduces complex dynamics between humans who struggle with trust issues due to external manipulation.

"Skin" is notable for its exploration of psychological tension through physical transformation-a metaphor for internal conflicts faced by characters throughout Supernatural. This theme resonates deeply across various episodes where identity crises are central plot points-a testament to how effectively this series intertwines horror tropes with deeper character analysis over its fifteen-season run.

Geez! I am really trying to get into this show. The plot is intriguing but so far with S1 E6, I am losing endurance. This show is so cliche and predictable. Running from town to town with funds from who knows how? Showing up 400 miles later no worse for wear. Same predictable co-star opposite, small frame eye candy doll in distress. And the brothers, posing as this or that to unwitting authorities, too dense and naive to crosscheck their story. Hello! These guys are too young for just about every impersonation! You ask too much of the viewer with "temporary suspension of disbelief" Designed for the "mind on hold" viewers curious about the paranormal.