User reviews

Absolute chilling episode, just dark, bleak and emotionally draining. When Jimmy and Larry are conversing in the machine room, the tone goes from a sort of casual back and forth, to incredibly dark and twisted, the rain starts coming down. Just fantastically done.... The narration by the female victim was heartbreaking and also so well done, reminiscent of Lovely Bones. The payoff of finding the bike was needed, the episode was so dark, some kind of positive was absolutely crucial. NIN at the end was profound, I feel like the series had been working up to it and it really hit home.

Spectacular episode.

That was a one of the best episode I've ever watched in TV.

Paul Walter Hauser and Taron Egerton were fantastic. Just give to the Emmy nomination for 2023 them already.

This has to be one of the best single episodes i've ever seen of any show.

Compelling and incredibly intense.

If you're not gut punched watching this episode then you need to check your pulse....cos you might not have one!

Fantastic episode. Very emotional storytelling with acting masterclasses from Taron Egerton and Paul Walter Hauser. Will be gutted when this is over and it deserves a bigger audience than Apple TV can give it. Surely awards will come beckoning for the 2 leads.

Brilliant television - first class and one of the best episodes of any series I've seen.

-

A great episode.. James try to hide his feelings while Larry talking.. He wants to punch him so bad.. but Instead he just sit there and listening to a horrible story to help himself. The soundtrack, and the rain made the story more terrifying.

First of all, the show does their best to try and explain jimmy's cognitive ability in this episode. I was a little confused until I realized how smart Jimmy is when he is meeting with the psychologist. Then the series got even better. This episode is surely hard to watch emotionally.

It is one of his best performances as a young upcoming actor.

First off I'd like to say the acting in this series is obviously phenomenal and Edgartan is a rising star but PWH takes this character and role of a dark twisted child murderer to another level. This episode he mesmerizes while speaking of a murder so well that you are hanging onto every horrific word he says. Just must see television. This series is as good as any that I've seen. I'll put it up there with the first season ofTrue Detective.!!! YES, it's THAT Good. Unbelievably believable character and one of the best serial killer depictions I've ever seen.. phenomenal episode !!!

This episode broke me. The character of Jessica will remain with you for a long time even after you complete the series.. Nothing like you can anticipate at the beginning.. writing is just top notch!!

The way i, u, Taron Egerton and the whole cast of this series lived through these emotions, just like the man himself James Keene and yet Larry Hall didn't feel a thing and not just that he was happy and smiling makes you thank god a thousand times you were born healthy in the head.

Paul Hauser did an excellent job and he deserves an Emmy nomination, the way i hated every second of him on the big screen tells what a great actor he is in such a hard difficult role to play.

Its true that Ray Liotta and Sepideh Moafi doesn't appear as much on the screen but hell they take the whole thing to themselves, especially Sepideh she's an amazing actress!

This episode was as chilling as "Memories of Murder". It was extremely sad and touching. Only a few crime mysteries have had this effect when it came to 'seriel-killer' storytelling. Acting is top notch. It's more sad and depressing when we watch it as entertainment but something like this had really happened. Ha, atleast it's educational to be cautious on the strangers you may meet. Impactful episode..

This episode apitmised the quality work form the crew and writers. Forget the actors, this is a work of ART. The attention to detail, which the actors might know about when filming, is astounding. Gotta give it 10, can't wait! For the next episode.