Episode list

'Buffy' star Alyson Hannigan becomes the new host. Magicians looking to fool the boys this time: Shawn Farquhar returns to try and fool them again by (mind) reading from a book he gives to Alyson, comedian magician Michael Kent does a trick with (dis)appearing bottles and glass cups, Vegas magician Nathan Burton makes a "security guard" run down a toilet and turns his wife into a poster, Nathan Coe Marsh makes an object randomly picked by Alyson appear inside a small glass jar, and finally Penn and Teller teach the audience how to find love through cards, but not everyone gets it.

Magicians looking to fool them this time: sword swallowing magician Brett Loudermilk does a trick that's hard to swallow for Alyson, Dan Harlan does a card guessing trick with his animated stickmen, illusionist Ryan Joyce makes his assistant disappear leaving her silhouette behind, comedian magician Kyle Eschen makes lentil appear out of thin air, and finally Penn, Teller and Jesse Eisenberg, who promotes his new movie about magic, try to outdo one another at a card guessing trick for Alyson.

Magicians looking to fool them this time: Robert Ramirez gives Alyson a puppy and does a prediction trick while playing tic-tac-toe with Teller, Dominik Krzanowski risks losing his hands along with Penn's watch during a Houdini-esque escape trick, comedian magician Joel Ward plays some tennis with Alyson and makes her ring disappear, Mahdi Gilbert, who had to learn how to do card tricks without using hands, does his own special hands-off trick with the three hosts, and finally Penn and Teller show us how a trick where Teller plays a disembodied rocket man works.

Comedy duo David Blatter and Leeman Parker do a rope trick, Jibrizy Taylor does a slight of mouth trick, escape artist Rick Maisel sets himself on the spin cycle, Felix Bodden does a card trick with two jacks, and Penn plays with fire.

Magicians looking to fool them this time: Alex Ramon makes a pesky lie detecting iPad disappear, showman Greg Frewin performs an epic version of Houdini's straitjacket trick while three villainesses try to knife him, Vinny Grosso bares it all for his tasty card guessing trick with Carrot Top, Arthur Trace freezes time to do his "eggcellent" vanishing trick for Alyson, and finally Penn teaches Alyson a card guessing trick using live rats and Teller's head.

Magicians looking to fool them this time: edgy illusionist Elliot Zimet boxes up a girl, Paul Gertner blows everyone's mind by making his cards talk, comedian and mentalist Matthew Disero guesses the colors of four audience members' underwear, Lithuanian magician Rokas Bernatonis charms Alyson while doing an X-Ray card guessing trick with her, and finally Penn and Teller do a gory snakelicious trick which was responsible for the most complaints NBC had ever received from viewers when they did it 30 years before on Tony Danza/Laurie Anderson (1986).

Magicians looking to fool them this time: Russian-born Vitaly Beckman does a card guessing trick by showing Alyson his photo album, Simon Coronel does a trick using poker chips, Mac King returns hungry as ever with a fish trick which disgusts Alyson, Kevin Viner does a mentalist trick with a random audience member and a plastic wall clock, and finally Penn juggles dangerously by playing with broken liquor bottles.

Magicians looking to fool them this time: teen magician Matthew Laslo does a card trick with a t-shirt cannon, comedian Rob Zabrecky performs a creepy mentalist trick with four audience members, David Garrard shows us how the girl in the box trick is done with the help of a special guest dear to Penn's heart, mentalist Wayne Hoffman has fun with the boys and makes a membership card for an audience member, and finally Teller just can't shut up with his salute to recycling which costs him a bunny.

Magicians looking to fool them this time: Xavier Mortimer returns to skip rope midair, Fielding West pretend-plays rough with his bird friend, Caleb Wiles instructs Alyson on how to do a fooler's card trick for the boys, Ken Hall (aka the Magic Maniac) entertains with magical anagrams of the boys' names, and finally, in honor of Houdini, Penn and Teller and their escape artist friends, the Pilobolus dance troupe, unleash their inner sadomasochists.

Magicians looking to fool them this time: Timon Krause messes with Alyson's mind by guessing her hand five times in a row, Kyle Marlett does a tea-card trick with Penn and Alyson, Jeff and Tessa Evason do an impressive mentalist trick, Anthony S. Riniti (AKA: Chef Anton) plays pool with Alyson, and finally Penn and Teller do tricks with a doorway metal detector and pull a special guest out of thin air.

Magicians looking to fool them this time: Christopher Tracy and Jim Leach pull a reverse Penn and Teller while doing card tricks for the boys, Neil Croswell does a dress swap trick, Ben Young does a numbers trick with Alyson's help using Penn's iPhone, Henok Negash does a mentalist trick, and finally Penn does a grizzly trick with bear traps.

Magicians looking to fool Penn and Teller this time: Joseph Reohm pulls drinking glasses out of thin air, Brent Braun does a card-finding trick, Chris Rose offers Teller and Alyson a chance to win some cash by repeating everything he does with a glass of milk, a cookie and a nail, Charles Bach plays a guessing game with balloons, and finally Penn rips into some newspaper headlines with Teller.

Magicians looking to fool them on the season finale: Anthony Asimov plays with cards and nuts, Angela Funovits shows us what's in the box, Ivan Amodei clumps audience members, Vince Charming puzzles us, and finally Penn & Teller do a skit where they try to fool themselves.