Combat Obscura

Patchwork footage of fighting the Taliban and trying to win villagers' hearts and minds. Principally unfocused.

Screenplay...................................... 3 / 10 Interviews........................................ 3 Visuals................................................ 6 Sound................................................... 7 Editing................................................ 4 Timeless Utility................................. 5 Total.................................................... 28 / 60 ~= 4.7 (rounded to 6) Verdict................................................. Passable for a general audience.

It shows true segments of wartime experience and also what young people who we send to war sometime act like. However, the negative is what naysayers key on. Fact is, what sometimes is said and done in that situation doesn't translate well to the civilian world out of context. The language, horseplay, and interaction with civilians and the enemy are all by products of war. It is harsh, ugly and dark. Our Marines are just trying to survive in an impossible situation not of their own making. It is what it is.

I know for certain that this is not the realities of war, but a cinematic Hollywood adaptation to the world, but nonetheless the film provides an insight. I'm very grateful for the reality in which the film provides As for my comments on how the USA military is... I'll keep that to myself.

WOW!! This was bad. There was more video of the ground than anything else. The movie is incoherent with no particular point. For Mike's next movie I willstart a go fund me to hire him a sound engineer. The sound goes from 0 to 10 and up and down the entire 70 minutes. I had to constantly adjust he volume as I watched. It really is a bad movie. It the point is o show snapshots of war there are better movies of random soldiers from Iraq and Afghanistan on YouTube. Generally movies have a story to tell. This movie is very disjointed with no flow, nothing to follow. Mike doesn't even engage us with his unit. I give this a hard pass.

Many people who are rating this, came into expecting a well directed, produced, and polished movie. This is not that, it was not meant to be that. This is the true accounts and events of these corpsmen. This is meant to display there day to day life, not all the stuff everyone says about the military and marine corps. At the end of the day this is a job, and this shows us the job that they have on deployment. It also shows us joe they deal with war, and how they act. This gives incredible insight to what actually happens and is experienced on deployment. The military is not full of perfect men, as one point it was talked about during this film. It captures the faults and the seemingly unwarranted behavior they display. This was recorded by a corpsman and so of course he's not going to know how to create and capture every thing like a paid cameraman. This is a great documentary of reality.