Black Beauty

Sure there might be mistakes in a film, but just watch a fim for the film's sake! I thought it was very thought provoking and beautifully filmed. Well acted by both people and horses. Quite a tear-jerker. Very recommended viewing!

So I was scared to see this. But gave in. Black Beauty was one of my favorites growing up. Not 100% upset with it but I got weird Flicka vibes. Was like Black Beauty meets Flicka.

So its 2020, let's take the boy out and put in a chick. Let's make the stallion a mare. Let's take them out of London and put in the wild west. Let's make him/her sorry, a mustang and not a carriage horse. Seriously? This is sickening. Call the horse something else. Why would you change all of this and it has nothing to do with the book or the other films. 1994 one is the ultimate best, the cartoon from 78 is good but good luck finding it. Like the new Magnificent 7 or the new upcoming Wild Bunch, this is another i refuse to watch. Hollywood sinks to a new all time low.

This story makes no sense in parts, poor writing. The original was 1000 x better and the book was better still. At least they knew something about horses the people who made the original. It's just laziness & sloppiness. Everything is so dumber down now in movies. It's supposed to be geared towards horse people yet any decent horse person can see flaws in any scene. Very poor writing, directing & producing. That horse definitely is not a thorobred, colic isn't caused by or have anything to do with the lungs. How do these people get to make movies. Most movies are horribly written now. I didn't go to film school but I can make a better movie than 95% of stuff that comes out now. Where are they getting these people from?

I want to start by saying that when it was all said and done, I did end up enjoying the movie. Now on to my critique... Black Beauty was one of my absolute favorite novels when I was a young girl, and I've always loved the 90's movie adaptation. There were A LOT more changes in this new version than I was expecting, and I was not a big fan - especially with the mustang angle. I feel like they did too much to try to modernize the story and to also try to stay close to the novel, it seemed kind of cluttered. I'm a sap for any heart warming story that involves animals, though, so again I did end up enjoying it. But I think it probably would have better if they would have tried to make it more of its own film.