Episode: "Threshold"
Series: Star Trek: Voyager
Season 2, Episode 15
Original Air Date: January 29, 1996
Tom Paris breaks Warp 10, the Trek-canon-imposed absolute speed limit. Boy are the folks back home going to be impressed. If Voyager ever makes it. Surely, this solves all of our heroes' problems and they can get back to the Alpha Quadrant lickety-split. Except, of course, there's a hitch. For unclear reasons, the phenomenon causes Paris to de-evolve into a lizard-like creature. By means even more unclear, he causes Janeway to undergo the same. The two mate and reproduce with shocking speed. Of course, the Doctor comes up with a miracle cure and all is made right. But the idea of using Warp 10 magic to get home is scrapped.
"Threshold" is
Voyager's most notorious episode, a popular choice as the series's worst. I'm more of the opinion it's so bad it's good. I'd say just in Season 2 so far,
"Twisted" is worse. Don't get me wrong, "Threshold" is a mess. But the de-evolution contrivance is so absurd that it makes for unmissable comedy.
Lower Decks poked fun, of course, and the result is hilarious.
In their book Star Trek 101, Terry J. Erdmann and Paula M. Block created the Spock's Brain Award to give to the worst episode of each Star Trek series to that point. I suppose it's a good time to see how their choices compare with mine.
The original series -
The Animated Series -
The Next Generation -
Deep Space Nine -
Theirs: "Profit and Lace"
Mine: Haven't gotten to the end yet in this watch-through - haven't even gotten to Season 6's "Profit and Lace." But I'd say the worst to this point (mid-Season 4) is
"Storyteller."
Voyager -
Theirs: "Threshold"
Mine: Also haven't gotten to the end but "Threshold" won't be my choice. So far, "Twisted" gets my vote for worst.
A few observations...
Erdmann and Block do not like de-evolution. Both TNG's "Genesis" and Voyager's "Threshold" embrace that idea.
For both TAS and DS9, even the worst episodes have their selling points. In TAS's "The Practical Joker," the ship computer plays pranks on the crew, including creating a shirt for the Captain that reads "Kirk is a jerk" on the back. I want that shirt! "The Lorelei Signal" is nothing to write home about but it does feature Scotty singing a Welsh ballad from the Captain's chair. I'll listen to that anytime. I do not mean to imply that TAS is a great series. It's not. But it's fairly even in terms of quality. I appreciate that.
DS9's "Storyteller" is more hokey than bad. And it marks the beginning of the Julien/Miles bromance, a meaningful thread overall. For Deep Space Nine, it definitely is a sign of quality. Even the worst are still pretty good. The best are awesome.
Amazingly, for as notoriously terrible as "Threshold" is, the episode won an Emmy for Outstanding Makeup, beating out DS9's otherwise far superior
"The Visitor."
Acting Notes
Mirron E. Willis played the role of Rettik, the traitor Michael Jonas's Kazon contact. Willis was born June 12, 1965. "Threshold" is his last of three Trek appearances. His films include
Universal Soldier,
Independence Day and
Fracture. Beyond Trek, he has made recurring appearances on
Tarzan: The Epic Adventures and
ER plus guest appearances on
Cheers,
Seinfeld and
Monk.